Showing posts with label mathematics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label mathematics. Show all posts

Friday, 10 December 2021

Why kids should use their fingers in Math class

Evidence from brain science suggests that far from being “babyish,” the technique is essential for mathematical achievement.

A few weeks ago I (Jo Boaler) was working in my Stanford office when the silence of the room was interrupted by a phone call. A mother called me to report that her 5-year-old daughter had come home from school crying because her teacher had not allowed her to count on her fingers. This is not an isolated event—schools across the country regularly ban finger use in classrooms or communicate to students that they are babyish. This is despite a compelling and rather surprising branch of neuroscience that shows the importance of an area of our brain that “sees” fingers, well beyond the time and age that people use their fingers to count.


In a study published last year, the researchers Ilaria Berteletti and James R. Booth analyzed a specific region of our brain that is dedicated to the perception and representation of fingers known as the somatosensory finger area. 


Philippe Lissac / Godong / Corbis


Remarkably, brain researchers know that we “see” a representation of our fingers in our brains, even when we do not use fingers in a calculation. The researchers found that when 8-to-13-year-olds were given complex subtraction problems, the somatosensory finger area lit up, even though the students did not use their fingers. This finger-representation area was, according to their study, also engaged to a greater extent with more complex problems that involved higher numbers and more manipulation. Other researchers have found that the better students’ knowledge of their fingers was in the first grade, the higher they scored on number comparison and estimation in the second grade. Even university students’ finger perception predicted their calculation scores. (Researchers assess whether children have a good awareness of their fingers by touching the finger of a student—without the student seeing which finger is touched—and asking them to identify which finger it is.)


Evidence from both behavioral and neuroscience studies shows that when people receive training on ways to perceive and represent their own fingers, they get better at doing so, which leads to higher mathematics achievement. The tasks we have developed for use in schools and homes (see below) are based on the training programs researchers use to improve finger-perception quality. Researchers found that when 6-year-olds improved the quality of their finger representation, they improved in arithmetic knowledge, particularly skills such as counting and number ordering. In fact, the quality of the 6-year-old’s finger representation was a better predictor of future performance on math tests than their scores on tests of cognitive processing.


Many teachers have been led to believe that finger use is useless and something to be abandoned as quickly as possible.


Neuroscientists often debate why finger knowledge predicts math achievement, but they clearly agree on one thing: That knowledge is critical. As Brian Butterworth, a leading researcher in this area, has written, if students aren’t learning about numbers through thinking about their fingers, numbers “will never have a normal representation in the brain.”


One of the recommendations of the neuroscientists conducting these important studies is that schools focus on finger discrimination—not only on number counting via their fingers but also on helping students distinguish between those fingers. Still, schools typically pay little if any attention to finger discrimination, and to our knowledge, no published curriculum encourages this kind of mathematical work. Instead, thanks largely to school districts and the media, many teachers have been led to believe that finger use is useless and something to be abandoned as quickly as possible. Kumon, for example, an after-school tutoring program used by thousands of families in dozens of countries, tells parents that finger-counting is a “no no” and that those who see their children doing so should report them to the instructor.


Stopping students from using their fingers when they count could, according to the new brain research, be akin to halting their mathematical development. Fingers are probably one of our most useful visual aids, and the finger area of our brain is used well into adulthood. The need for and importance of finger perception could even be the reason that pianists, and other musicians, often display higher mathematical understanding than people who don’t learn a musical instrument.


Teachers should celebrate and encourage finger use among younger learners and enable learners of any age to strengthen this brain capacity through finger counting and use. They can do so by engaging students in a range of classroom and home activities, such as:


Give the students colored dots on their fingers and ask them to touch the corresponding piano keys:


youcubed.org


youcubed.org



Give the students colored dots on their fingers and ask them to follow the lines on increasingly difficult mazes:


(The full set of activities is given here.)


The finger research is part of a larger group of studies on cognition and the brain showing the importance of visual engagement with math. Our brains are made up of “distributed networks,” and when we handle knowledge, different areas of the brain communicate with each other. When we work on math, in particular, brain activity is distributed among many different networks, which include areas within the ventral and dorsal pathways, both of which are visual. Neuroimaging has shown that even when people work on a number calculation, such as 12 x 25, with symbolic digits (12 and 25) our mathematical thinking is grounded in visual processing.


A striking example of the importance of visual mathematics comes from a study showing that after four 15-minute sessions of playing a game with a number line, differences in knowledge between students from low-income backgrounds and those from middle-income backgrounds were eliminated.


Number-line representation of number quantity has been shown to be particularly important for the development of numerical knowledge, and students’ learning of number lines is believed to be a precursor of children’s academic success.


Visual math is powerful for all learners. A few years ago Howard Gardner proposed a theory of multiple intelligences, suggesting that people have different approaches to learning, such as those that are visual, kinesthetic, or logical. This idea helpfully expanded people’s thinking about intelligence and competence, but was often used in unfortunate ways in schools, leading to the labeling of students as particular type of learners who were then taught in different ways. But people who are not strong visual thinkers probably need visual thinking more than anyone. Everyone uses visual pathways when we work on math. The problem is it has been presented, for decades, as a subject of numbers and symbols, ignoring the potential of visual math for transforming students’ math experiences and developing important brain pathways.


It is hardly surprising that students so often feel that math is inaccessible and uninteresting when they are plunged into a world of abstraction and numbers in classrooms. Students are made to memorize math facts, and plough through worksheets of numbers, with few visual or creative representations of math, often because of policy directives and faulty curriculum guides. The Common Core standards for kindergarten through eighth grade pay more attention to visual work than many previous sets of learning benchmarks, but their high-school content commits teachers to numerical and abstract thinking. And where the Common Core does encourage visual work, it’s usually encouraged as a prelude to the development of abstract ideas rather than a tool for seeing and extending mathematical ideas and strengthening important brain networks.


To engage students in productive visual thinking, they should be asked, at regular intervals, how they see mathematical ideas, and to draw what they see. They can be given activities with visual questions and they can be asked to provide visual solutions to questions. When the youcubed team (a center at Stanford) created a free set of visual and open mathematics lessons for grades three through nine last summer, which invited students to appreciate the beauty in mathematics, they were downloaded 250,000 times by teachers and used in every state across the U.S. Ninety-eight percent of teachers said they would like more of the activities, and 89 percent of students reported that the visual activities enhanced their learning of mathematics. Meanwhile, 94 percent of students said they had learned to “keep going even when work is hard and I make mistakes.” Such activities not only offer deep engagement, new understandings, and visual-brain activity, but they show students that mathematics can be an open and beautiful subject, rather than a fixed, closed, and impenetrable subject.


Some scholars note that it will be those who have developed visual thinking who will be “at the top of the class” in the world’s new high-tech workplace that increasingly draws upon visualization technologies and techniques, in business, technology, art, and science. Work on mathematics draws from different areas of the brain and students need to be strong with visuals, numbers, symbols and words—but schools are not encouraging this broad development in mathematics now. This is not because of a lack of research knowledge on the best ways to teach and learn mathematics, it is because that knowledge has not been communicated in accessible forms to teachers. Research on the brain is often among the most impenetrable for a lay audience but the knowledge that is being produced by neuroscientists, if communicated well, may be the spark that finally ignites productive change in mathematics classrooms and homes across the country.


(Source: The Atlantic)

Wednesday, 24 March 2021

Math, Physics not mandatory in Class 12 to qualify for engineering course: AICTE

 The AICTE has given a list of 14 subjects from which students of Class 12 need to pass three subjects to be eligible for BE, BTech courses.

The All India Council for Technical Education (AICTE), the statutory body for technical education, has revised the eligibility criteria for Class 12 students aspiring to pursue engineering courses. According to the Approval Process Handbook 2021-22, subjects such as Mathematics and Physics will not be mandatory, but optional, to get admission to undergraduate programmes such as Bachelor of Engineering (BE) and Bachelor of Technology (BTech).


Currently, passing Mathematics and Physics in Class 12 is mandatory for admission to engineering courses. This has been relaxed, in order to bring in students from diverse backgrounds, said AICTE. The technical regulator has given a list of 14 subjects — Physics, Mathematics, Chemistry, Computer Science, Electronics, Information Technology, Biology, Informatics Practices, Biotechnology, technical vocational subject, Engineering Graphics, Business Studies and Entrepreneurship. Students need to pass any three subjects from the list in Class 12 or 10+2.




Students who pass any three subjects from the list, with a minimum of 45% marks in the Class 12 board examination will be eligible for engineering courses. Currently, students are admitted to engineering courses based on their scores in entrance exams as well as their Class 12 scores in Physics and Mathematics.


Some educational experts have concerns, as Physics and Mathematics are subjects that are critical to understanding the concepts of engineering. And Class 12 lessons in these subjects provide an important foundation. They feel students that have studied Physics and Mathematics will have a better grasp of the field when pursuing further education, compared to candidates who do not have basic knowledge of the subjects.


The AICTE has, however, said that the universities will offer appropriate bridge courses, in subjects including Mathematics, Physics, and Engineering Drawing, among others, to help students from diverse subject backgrounds to achieve the desired learning outcome of the programme, reported Outlook India.


According to the Times of India, Mathematics runs up to the fifth semester in AICTE's model curriculum for almost all engineering programmes. Anil D Sahasrabudhe, the Chairman of AICTE, told the newspaper that the choice of three mandatory courses for engineering courses has been expanded. He said that a student without Mathematics will be required to do a lot of courses on the subject. According to the AICTE Chairman, the new regulation will be in line with the National Education Policy (NEP) and in the new education system of 5+3+3+4, which will not have arts, science and commerce streams.


AICTE vice-chairman MP Poonia told Outlook that the exam syllabus of Joint Entrance Examination (JEE) — the entrance exam for admission to undergraduate engineering courses at technical institutions such as the Indian Institutes of Technology (IITs) and National Institutes of Technology (NITs) — may change in the future. 


(Source: TNM)

Tuesday, 9 March 2021

Scientists find great works of literature are ‘fractals’

 According to scientists at the Institute for Nuclear Physics in Poland, works of great literature have a mathematical structure in common: They’re fractals.

Researchers studied over 100 works of literature, including Finnegan’s Wake, was well as texts by Dickens, Shakespeare, Dumas, Thomas Mann, Umberto Eco, Samuel Beckett, Henry James and many more. What they discovered was shocking: mathematical consistency, even that they were structured like fractals.


Via the Guardian:

“‘All of the examined works showed self-similarity in terms of organisation of the lengths of sentences. Some were more expressive – here The Ambassadors by Henry James stood out – others to far less of an extreme, as in the case of the French 17th-century romance Artamene ou le Grand Cyrus. However, correlations were evident, and therefore these texts were the construction of a fractal’ said Dr Paweł Oświęcimka from the Institute of Nuclear Physics of the Polish Academy of Sciences, one of the authors of the new paper Quantifying Origin and Character of Long-range Correlations in Narrative Texts.”



The most complex work studied was Joyce’s Finnegan’s Wake, the legendary and notorious final novel by the Irish writer that has baffled and fascinated readers and literary scholars for nearly a century, and which has often been seen as a kind of mirror or even prophesy of the breakdown in consciousness humanity underwent in the 20th century. (Parts of the book seem to predict, among other things, the invention of television; the quark particle was named after one of Joyce’s phrases, “three quarks for Muster Mark.”) Finnegan’s Wake was found to be a complex “multifractal,” or fractal of fractals, far surpassing any other studied work in mathematical complexity.


Again from the Guardian:

“The absolute record in terms of multifractality turned out to be Finnegans Wake by James Joyce. The results of our analysis of this text are virtually indistinguishable from ideal, purely mathematical multifractals,” said Professor Stanisław Drożdż, another author of the paper, which has just been published in the computer science journal Information Sciences.”


Other, albeit less complex, works that the researchers found multifractal structure in were A Heartbreaking Work of Staggering Genius by Dave Eggers, Hopscotch by Julio Cortazar, The USA Trilogy by John Dos Passos, Virginia Woolf’s The Waves, Roberto Bolano’s 2666 and, of course, James Joyce’s Ulysses. 


Perhaps satisfyingly, Ayn Rand did not rank. (But then, neither did Proust.)


According to the researchers, this suggests that stream-of-consciousness writers actually “discovered” fractals and multifractals long before scientists did.


The writer and consciousness researcher Robert Anton Wilson, who spent much of his adult life looking for ways to enhance and “de-linearize” his consciousness—exploring psychedelics, general semantics, Aleister Crowley, Buckminster Fuller, G. I. Gurdjieff and many other avenues of weirdness—was long obsessed with Finnegan’s Wake as a kind of ultimate statement of non-linear, quantum thinking.


Here’s Wilson interviewed on Finnegan’s Wake, via Maybe Logic:

Yes, FW is what I call ‘The Good Book,’ and I’m only half joking.  To me it’s not only the greatest novel ever written, it’s the greatest poem ever written, the greatest detective story ever written, and the most entertaining work in all literature, and as William York Tindall of Columbia says, it’s the funniest and dirtiest book in the world.   People are intimidated by it.  If the publishers just had the sense to put on the cover, ‘the funniest and dirtiest book in the world – Tindall, Columbia,’ it would sell a lot better, and people would make the effort to decipher it.


Below, Robert Anton Wilson reads from Finnegan’s Wake.




(Source: UltraCulture)


Thursday, 1 October 2020

Physicists prove time travel is 'mathematically possible'

 Australian scientists say they have ‘squared the numbers’ of the grandfather paradox

Scientists in Australia claim to have proved that time travel is theoretically possible after solving a logical paradox.


Physicists from the University of Queensland used mathematical modelling to reconcile Einstein’s theory of general relativity with classical dynamics. The clash between these two systems is behind a famous flaw with time travel, known as the grandfather paradox.


Einstein’s theory allows for the possibility of a person using a time loop to travel back in time in order to kill their grandfather. 


However, classical dynamics dictates that the sequence of events following the grandfather’s death would culminate in the time traveller not existing in the first place. 




“As physicists, we want to understand the universe’s most basic, underlying laws and for years I’ve puzzled on how the science of dynamics can square with Einstein’s predictions,” said Germain Tobar, who led the research. “Is time travel mathematically possible?”


For their calculations, Mr Tobar and Dr Costa used the coronavirus pandemic as a model for working out whether the two theories could co-exist.


They imagined a time traveller attempting to go back and prevent patient zero from being infected with Covid-19.


Einstein’s theory allows for the possibility of time travel but the science of dynamics would mean that the fundamental sequence of events could not be interfered with.


This is because if the time traveller succeeded in preventing the virus from spreading, then it would eliminate their initial motivation for them to travel back in time.


“In the coronavirus patient zero example, you might try and stop patient zero from becoming infected, but in doing so you would catch the virus and become patient zero, or someone else would,” Mr Tobar said.


"No matter what you did, the salient events would just recalibrate around you. This would mean that - no matter your actions - the pandemic would occur, giving your younger self the motivation to go back and stop it. Try as you might to create a paradox, the events will always adjust themselves to avoid any inconsistency.


“The range of mathematical processes we discovered show that time travel with free will is logically possible in our universe without any paradox.”


University of Queensland physicist Dr Fabio Costa, who supervised the research, added: “The maths checks out - and the results are the stuff of science fiction."


A paper detailing the research was published in the journal Classical and Quantum Gravity.


(Source: The Independent)

Monday, 6 January 2020

7 signs a child will be incredibly successful

Life not quite going to plan? Just shift the blame onto the shoulders of your childhood self.

Science has pinned down the childhood behaviours that predict success in later life - whether that means educational attainment, finding a more prestigious job and a higher income. Obviously, though, success is subjective.

No study investigated the traits that might lead to the adulthood ability to scoff a pizza in record time. So, if that's your definition of success, you can rest easy if your childhood doesn't quite match up to these behaviours. 
Picture: Getty Images / Kevin Winter / Staff


Here's what the researchers found that children with extremely bright futures get up to. Spoiler: Do your homework. 

1. They have good reading and writing skills
New research published in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology analysed data from 346,660 US high school students in 1960.

After checking back with participants 11 and 50 years later, lead author Marion Spengler and her co-authors found that having fewer problems with reading and writing was significantly associated with greater educational attainment, finding a more prestigious job and a higher income. 

2. They are interested in school  
Spengler's research found that attentiveness when it comes to school is also a predictor of success. 

She said in a press release:

Our research found that specific behaviours in high school have long-lasting effects for one's later life.

3. They're a responsible student
Spengler's team concluded that being a responsible student - for example, attending school, doing your homework and taking exams seriously - suggests that your adult life will likely be pretty fruitful. 

4. They do chores
Julie Lythcott-Haims, former Dean of Freshmen at Stanford University and author of 'How to Raise an Adult' , doesn't seem like a bad person to take parenting advice off.

She told Business Insider: 

If kids aren't doing the dishes, it means someone else is doing that for them,
And so they're absolved of not only the work, but of learning that work has to be done and that each one of us must contribute for the of the whole.

She based this claim on an 80-year-old study called the Harvard Grant Study, which found the biggest predictor of a person's success is whether they did chores as a child. 

5. They're taught maths early on 
A 2007 meta-analysis of 35,000 preschoolers across the US, Canada and England found that developing maths skills early on can add up to a huge advantage. 

Northwestern University researcher and co-author of the study Greg Duncan said in a press release: 

The paramount importance of early math skills — of beginning school with a knowledge of numbers, number order, and other rudimentary math concepts — is one of the puzzles coming out of the study.

Mastery of early math skills predicts not only future math achievement, it also predicts future reading achievement.

6. They defy their parents 
If your kids are rebellious, grit your teeth through the pain because you might actually be getting something right. 

A study published in Developmental Psychology tracked the income and education levels of kids who attended Luxembourg schools in the 1960s. 

Those who were willing to resist authority and defy their parents tended to stay in school longer and were more likely to go into further education.

7. They are gritty
Yeah, not like that. 

University of Pennsylvania psychologist Angela Duckworth uncovered a personality trait powerfully correlated with success - and, for some reason, she called it grit. 

Basically, it means you stick with your goals, particularly long-term ones, and don't give up. 


(Source: Independent)

Saturday, 23 November 2019

Bad at maths in school? You might be a genius

If you were one of those unfortunate students who dreaded fractions and whose nightmares were filled with trigonometry, we have some good news for you. 

You might actually be a genius in disguise.

Having 'a natural talent' for maths is a myth. 
In fact, Elsbeth Stern, a professor at the Zurich Technical University, argues in a paper that maths is a fundamental human ability.

Stern wrote:

In the case of mathematics it is entirely plausible that nature has equipped human beings with intuitive number knowledge and sensitivity for magnitude.

Stern argues that bad maths grades usually stem from ineffective maths teaching - however, this assumption shifts when it comes to learning abilities such as dyscalculia.
Maths puzzles can be tough sometimes iStock/Imgorthand

She went on to lament that the education system may be failing those who would otherwise excel with numbers, adding:

A serious lack of conceptual understanding remains, as even the most intelligent students often cannot transfer the insights they should have gained to problems that differ from those dealt with in the classroom.

Hard work is more important than genetics 
Children who have had maths introduced to them from a younger age are bound to do better on initial school tests.

Meanwhile, kids who haven't benefited from being taught maths from a young age might assume that they just don't have the brain for maths, lose confidence and fall at the first hurdle.

Believing you are bad at maths can, therefore, become a self-fulfilling prophecy. But research backs the idea that hard work, not natural ability, is more important.

A study measuring maths achievement in 3,520 students over five years concluded:

It's not how smart students are but how motivated they are and how they study that determines their growth in math achievement.

So, you may actually be an undiscovered mathematical genius after all.

(Source: Independent)

Monday, 21 October 2019

10-yr-old student earns praise after refusing to answer ‘offensive’ math problem about girls’ weight

In a picture of the answer shared online by the proud parent, Rhythm encircle the question and wrote "what!!!!" adding that, "This is offensive. Sorry I won't right [write] this it's rood [rude]."

A fourth-grade student from Utah is winning hearts online after she refused to solve an ‘offensive’ maths problem that asked students to compare girls’ weights. Her answer on the worksheet refusing to solve the sum stating her reason and a note to her teacher explaining her concern are going viral.
Rhythm Pacheco is winning hearts online after standing up for things she strongly believes in.

Rhythm Pacheco, a Grant Elementary School in Murray, recently was given a homework where a question involving body-weight of girls made her uncomfortable as she thought it was very rude. The problem read, “The table to the right shows the weight of three Grade 4 students. How much heavier is Isabel than the lightest student?”

In a picture of the answer shared online by the proud parent, Rhythm encircle the question and wrote “what!!!!” adding that, “This is offensive. Sorry I won’t right [write] this it’s rood [rude].”


The 10-year-old also went ahead and wrote a note to her teacher explaining why she couldn’t answer the question. “Dear Mrs. Shaw, I don’t want to be rude, but I don’t think that math problem was very nice because that’s judging people’s weight. Also, the reason I did not do the sentence is cause I just don’t think that’s nice. -Love Rhythm”


Speaking to Today, her mother Naomi said, “Rhythm’s dad and I were extremely proud of Rhythm for listening to her gut instincts and standing up for what is right. Rhythm’s teacher was so responsive and handled the situation with such care. She told her she understands how she would be upset about this and that she didn’t have to write out the answer.”

People on social media praised the little girl for “standing up for the things she believed in”, while a few others lashed out at the publishers who curated the assignments.

“I was shocked… I was shocked, honestly,” Naomi told Fox News about the homework question. “I feel like it’s such an irresponsible way to teach children how to do math,” Naomi said.


\After the girl went viral and it raised concerned among many parents online about the kind of questions through which children learn these days, Eureka Math, the company that provides core educational materials to the girl’s school district, released a statement regarding the questionable math problem.

“User feedback is a vital part of our culture; we are grateful to receive constructive feedback from students, teachers, and parents alike,” said the statement. “We apologize for any discomfort of offense caused by the question. Please know that we will replace this question in all future reprints, and suggest that teachers supply students with an appropriate replacement question in the interim.”

(Source: The Indian Express)

Tuesday, 30 July 2019

The aesthetic beauty of math

In 1939, as the buildup to war in Europe intensified, a brilliant French mathematician named André Weil made a plan to emigrate to the U.S. He was thirty-three and didn’t want to serve in the army; his life’s purpose was math, he felt, not soldiering. His escape turned out to be more difficult than he anticipated, in part because, as he would write in his memoir, “the Americans, who so warmly welcome those who do not need them, are much less hospitable to those who happen to be at their mercy”—as we’ve gone on to prove repeatedly since then.

He was vacationing in Finland when the war broke out, and he tried to lay low in Helsinki but was arrested and returned to France, where he sat in jail during the spring of 1940, awaiting trial for desertion. While there, he took some consolation from the fact that jail allowed him to work undisturbed, as well as to read novels and write letters, in particular letters to his sister, Simone Weil, who was also remarkably talented, a philosopher and spiritual thinker.

Though her brother’s incarceration infuriated her, Simone saw an opportunity. His work in advanced mathematics was to her, as it would be to most of us, esoteric. Since you have some spare time on your hands, she wrote to him, why don’t you explain to me exactly what it is you do?

There wouldn’t be any point, he replied. Trying to explain my work to a non-mathematician, he wrote, would be like trying to explain a symphony to someone who can’t hear. Later he would rely on another metaphor, calling math “art in a hard material.”


Mathematics is an artistic endeavor, his words suggest. Yet Simone was skeptical. What kind of art? What is the material? Even poets have language, but your work seems to rely on sheer abstraction, she wrote her brother.

That math is an art, that one of its signature qualities is its beauty—these are ideas that continue to be articulated by mathematicians, even as non-mathematicians may wonder, as Simone did, what that could possibly mean. I myself become wary when a mathematician or scientist speaks about the beauty of her discipline, since it can seem vague and high-handed, if not wrong.

In the same year that André Weil spent months in jail, British mathematician G. H. Hardy penned what is perhaps still the most eloquent attempt to give non-mathematicians a sense of math’s aesthetic appeal, in the form of a book-length essay called A Mathematician’s Apology. As with the letters between the Weil siblings, it was the war that occasioned and shaped Hardy’s book, prompting him to argue that math has an intrinsic value unrelated to any military uses. His Apology is a stylish work and a wistful one. Hardy, then in his sixties, felt that he was past his prime and that writing about mathematics—as opposed to doing mathematics—was symptomatic of his decline.

“A mathematician, like a painter or a poet, is a maker of patterns,” he wrote. “If his patterns are more permanent than theirs, it is because they are made with ideas.” Hardy went on to characterize what makes a mathematical idea worthy: a certain generality, a certain depth, unexpectedness combined with inevitability and economy.

My own pursuit of math ended in college, but this rings as true to me, and it could just as readily apply to a great poem. Elegant is a word often used to commend a good mathematical proof. It is a construction that can seem like a kind of magic trick without sleight of hand, in which nothing has been hidden, each step building up another layer of a black hat that turns out to contain, in the end, a rabbit.

Philosophers can argue whether beauty is the property of an object or lies in our perceptions of it; Hardy would have it both ways. The best mathematics is eternal, he maintained, and like the best literature, it will “continue to cause intense emotional satisfaction to thousands of people after thousands of years.” Recent research in neuroscience has lent support to this idea of “emotional satisfaction.” A few years ago, a neurobiologist in London, Semir Zeki, performed fMRI scans of mathematicians while they contemplated equations they’d rated as beautiful, and the region of their brains that lit up has been associated in other studies with perceptions of visual and musical beauty. (Contemplating equations they found less inspiring, on the other hand, did not activate that part of the mathematicians’ brains.) In the brain, a mathematician’s affective response to math is similar to, or maybe the same as, the way in which we respond to beauty in the arts.

And there’s another sense in which math could be considered beautiful. In addition to the aesthetic appeal of a particular equation or a proof, there’s a kind of cumulative marvelousness to math, to its landscape of ideas. Here is an elaborate model world, in which the more you explore, the more fantastic it gets. “ ‘Imaginary’ universes are so much more beautiful than this stupidly constructed ‘real’ one,” Hardy wrote.

As for the Weils, Simone wouldn’t let her brother off the hook. After he told her he couldn’t explain his work, she urged him, in her next missive, to just please try. The letter he finally wrote, in which he did attempt to present his area of study to her, is still cited by mathematicians—not for its breakneck review of the history of number theory, which gave Simone headaches, but for its description of the process of mathematical discovery. Progress in mathematics, he wrote to her, is often made by working out analogies between one subject area and another. “Nothing is more fecund than these slightly adulterous relationships” between analogous theories, he wrote; “nothing gives greater pleasure to the connoisseur.”

It’s worth noting that Simone didn’t doubt the value of mathematics, but she suspected that in the hands of her brother and his contemporaries, mathematical research had grown too abstract. For her, ancient Greek geometry was the epitome of mathematical thinking and of a piece with other ancient Greek achievements. In that culture, she believed, art and math and science were all bridges between the human and the divine, beauty a means of access to grace. Mathematics, she would write, “is first, before all, a sort of mystical poem composed by God himself.”

Eventually Simone and André both made it to America. André would enjoy a long and illustrious career, while Simone would travel back across the ocean, to England, where she would die in 1943 after an illness left her unable to eat. In a memoir, published in 1992, André would remember a vacation in the mountains his family took when he and Simone were young: “My sister had this vacation in mind when she later wrote that contemplating a mountain landscape had once and for all impressed the notion of purity upon her soul,” he wrote. “I was left with a totally different impression. Seeing the shafts of sunlight criss-cross in the distance at sundown gave me the idea of composing on several planes simultaneously.”

As with the mountains, so with mathematics—the beauty of the discipline, to her, resided in its mystical connection to the divine, while to him it lay in the marvel of its connections, its adulterous relationships. Pressed to say why we deem something beautiful, we might all come up with something different. The very idea of beauty might slip away as we try to articulate it, and yet we would still know it was there.

(Source: The Paris Review)

Wednesday, 20 March 2019

For the first time, mathematics' most prestigious prize has been awarded to a woman

Karen Uhlenbeck, a mathematician and professor at the University of Texas, has been awarded this year's Abel Prize, a mathematics prize modeled after the Nobels. It's the first time the prize has gone to a woman.

The Abel Prize is awarded by the King of Norway to mathematicians who have greatly influenced their field, and includes a cash award of 6 million Norwegian kroner (about $700,000). The first prize was awarded in 2003.

Uhlenbeck, 76, is known for her work with partial differential equations. However, her decades-long career spans multiple disciplines, including physics, geometry and quantum theory.


"Uhlenbeck's research has led to revolutionary advances at the intersection of mathematics and physics," Paul Goldbart, dean of the University of Texas' College of Natural Sciences said in a release. "Her pioneering insights have applications across a range of fascinating subjects, from string theory, which may help explain the nature of reality, to the geometry of space-time."

One of Uhlenbeck's most famous contributions was her theories of predictive mathematics inspired by soap bubbles. The thin, curved surface area of a soap bubble is an example of a "minimal surface," a surface that forms itself into a shape that takes up the least amount of area. Examining how these surfaces behave can help researchers better understand a wide amount of phenomena across a wide array of scientific studies.

"Her theories have revolutionized our understanding of minimal surfaces, such as those formed by soap bubbles, and more general minimization problems in higher dimensions," Hans Munthe-Kaas, chair of the Abel Committee said in a release.

(Source: CNN)

Thursday, 8 November 2018

This simple puzzle is exposing how bad everyone is at maths

Maths isn't everyone's strong suit, but we'd all like to think we can literally count a bunch of shapes, right?

It's not exactly trigonometry, but this maths problem has been bewildering people online after it was tweeted by journalist Jitesh Pillai.
It starts off easy: there's one big triangle, right? And then three definite triangles at the top. With it so far.

But then you notice that you can also make bigger triangles. And smaller triangles too. Suddenly all you see is triangles downwards, upwards, and sideways, and you no longer know what a triangle actually is, who you are or, more importantly, why humans are still allowed the internet.


Here's proof this puzzle messes with your brain: Even the consistently calm and collected world of Twitter is in meltdown.

Everyone got a different answer and no one showed their working. For example, this person somehow saw just 1 triangle.
While this person, oddly, saw 2.
Meanwhile, this person saw 3.

Am I the only one that sees 3 triangles or ... https://t.co/mu7pVJRPRe — nisaa reed (@nisaareed) April 10, 2018

Another saw 4.

ITS 4 YALL ARE DUMB DUMB STUPUD HEADS https://t.co/VeDRpDKfzg — WOODCHIP BUT YOU CAN CALL ME CHIP FOR SHORT (@dadtrash) April 10, 2018

This user spotted 5.
And this person, 6.
7. ...8. And 9.
Can you guess what's coming next? 10.
The answer is 11, clearly.
While this person think it's 12.
Nope, it's obviously 13.

It's actually 14, depending when you ask. i saw this tweet when i was taking a shower and it infuriates me BC MY NUMBER CHANGES EVERYTIME I COUNT (i see 14 rn ?) https://t.co/WZ0JhBvrc3 — *alm voice* can't we all be oomfs (@seaboundshrine) April 10, 2018

15. No questions asked.

16? um, 16 ? what ? https://t.co/etWvdhiRXP — 🌹lelli🌹 (@illelligal) April 10, 2018

17 and now everything hurts. I could only get 17 before I got a headache https://t.co/qwd1efih4p — ندوي (@na_alhashmii) April 10, 2018

No wait, it's 18.
You get 19 if you include "triangles" too, whatever that means.

We've reached the 20s. '

Update: 21. https://t.co/j075wzu135 — Ya Gurl Mady ✨💕🥑🍑👩🏻💅🏼 (@mady134) April 10, 2018

People are just fantasising up triangles at this point.
It turns out the answer is actually 18.

Probably. If anything is even real anymore.

18 pic.twitter.com/iNwwyZlA9Z — Neeraj✍️ (@Iam_Ineffable) April 9, 2018

(Source: The Independent)

Sunday, 21 October 2018

Astrology is hard, even if it’s fake

There’s an exam, and it involves math. In fact, there are many exams.

On the morning of the International Society for Astrological Research’s Certification of Astrological Proficiency (ISAR CAP) exam, which was held at a Marriott in Chicago on a balmy morning in May, the cosmic weather boded well. The moon was in Sagittarius, the most erudite of the signs, and the communication planet Mercury had just entered quick-witted Gemini. There had been a dramatic full moon the night before, but the handful of astrologers who’d signed up to take the test didn’t seem too shaken by it. They were, after all, professionals — or at least, hoping to be, having undergone years of intense preparations for this six-hour “metaphysical SAT,” as one called it. Though technically open book, the ISAR CAP has a reputation for being one of the most grueling exams in the astrological field.

Yes. In 2018 there are multiple rigorous exams that assess one’s ability to read the stars.

And yes, it may seem strange to apply extremely technical standards to this abstract spiritual practice, but doing so isn’t without precedent. Astrology has existed, in some form, since at least ancient Babylonian times and was long considered a completely logical means of making sense of the world. It wasn’t until rationalism became all the rage in the 19th century that astrology was relegated to the realm of the mystical and absurd.

Today, it’s mostly considered the province of women’s magazines and Instagram memes, at best a harmless fiction and at worst a pernicious pseudoscience. But for a rising number of students and specialists, the practice is extremely serious, if admittedly unscientific.

The uptick in astrology’s popularity has been attributed to a rise in unconventional spirituality, a playful brand of post-recession nihilism (in which it doesn’t even matter if “astrology is fake,” as the meme goes) and, of course, the internet. (Alternatively, it could be that everyone born from November 1983 to November 1995 has Pluto in Scorpio, which draws them to occult practices and magical thinking.)

There are also more ways than ever to become well-versed in astrology. Star charts can be quickly generated online and delivered by apps, emails and the like, and astrologers can speak to thousands of students using social media. It beats the old-fashioned way: Pre-internet, generating a star chart required a number of byzantine conversions and calculations and at least two separate esoteric reference books.

In other words, to do it by hand, it takes an expert.

For example, in order to calculate a person’s natal chart, which is used to assess personality, psychological patterns and life path, one must first identify the precise placements of planets within the sky at the time of someone’s birth, relative to the exact location at which their birth occurred. That information is then cross-referenced with the 12 astrological houses — fixed, conceptual divisions of the celestial sphere, each of which rules a specific area of life (e.g. the subconscious mind, marriage and partnerships) — and the 12 zodiac signs, which are in constant motion through the houses and correspond to the sky as it appears from the earth, our terrestrial home.

A full astrological natal chart reading accounts for all these variables, as well as the exact angles each celestial body makes to others in the sky, and yields personalized results. This part is as objectively “real” as any other time-related conception of Earth: It involves applying unchanging mathematical formulas to finite historical data. It’s the next part — the interpretation of those results — that plunges astrologers into the realm of what they might call inference or intuition, and what nonbelievers might call memorized random associations.

Interpretation is one of many skills that the ISAR CAP tests. It includes an essay portion and about 600 multiple-choice, true-false and short-answer questions, which cover chart calculations, the history of astrology, basic astronomy as applied to astrology and forecasting skills. Sample questions include: What is the Sun’s greatest distance from the celestial equator? What is the harmonic of a quintile aspect, and how many degrees is it? And how often are Mercury and Venus trine? (Trick question! A trine is a 120-degree angle between two planets, which never occurs between Mercury and Venus!)

“Since astrology tends to be something people perceive as mystical and magical, maybe a bit made-up, I just really thought that having a certification would show due diligence,” said Debbie Stapleton, a hairstylist with bangs and ornate beaded earrings. An industrious Capricorn, she had traveled from Canada to take the test.

Getting certified, Ms. Stapleton said, “would give me the professional confidence moving forward that I’d been evaluated by the elders in my community, by my peers, and that there are these standards.”

This year’s exam was held during the United Astrology Conference (UAC), a major astrological networking event that has been hosted once every four or six years since 1986. (It remains unclear who, exactly, decides when it will be quadrennial or sextannual, or how they do so.) The conference in May was the best attended in history, attracting around 1,500 astrologers, who spent the week attending panels with names like “How to Work With the Moon,” “Eclipses: Portals of Destiny” and “The Astrology of a New Vision of Capitalism.”

The astrologers were there to share research and meet luminaries in the field. Possibly also to purchase crystals and psychedelic caftans at the pop-up marketplace, yes, but many said they were deeply invested in establishing astrology as a legitimate profession. Astrological certification is a crucial part of this last goal; throughout the weekend, a handful of people compared it to passing the bar or getting accredited as a therapist.

“It’s good that we have this standard of learning — very, very good,” said Shelley Ackerman, the official spokesperson for UAC and a diplomatic Libra. “Not that it guarantees absolute perfection in the field, but it certainly does eliminate and address a lot of mishaps that could have happened if you don’t have the training.”

“We can say things that can inspire people,” Ms. Stapleton said, “but if we’re not careful, we can say things that frighten and damage and alienate people.” (ISAR expressly forbids members from making predictions that are scary or extreme, such as prophesies about deaths or other calamities, even when they can clearly see them on someone’s chart.)

ISAR’s isn’t the only astrological certification exam in existence — there are other metaphysical organizations with certification programs of their own, most notably the National Center for Geocosmic Research (NCGR). But the ISAR CAP stands out in the astrological community for its strong emphasis on how to properly counsel clients. In addition to the bafflingly rigorous exam (446 questions longer than the nonmetaphysical SAT), students must also complete a two-and-a-half-day counseling skills training and an ethics course, which culminates in a second test. (It is, thankfully, much shorter.)

“The bottom line is astrology is not for the impatient or faint of heart,” Ms. Ackerman said. “You have got to love puzzles, math, myth, and the complexity of life. You can’t be in a rush and be a good astrologer.”

“It is not for morons,” she said.

(Source: NYT)

Monday, 11 June 2018

Numerical imagination of Ancient India

The conception of astronomical numbers by mathematicians in India made them stand well above the rest, writes Abhijit Adhikari in Pragyata. Read on: 

 Introduction
The mathematical achievements of ancient India have largely remained hidden, but thanks to the internet age are coming to the surface in recent times. Many books have been written about the advanced mathematics, including trigonometry and calculus discovered in India which reached Europe in the Middle Ages through the Arabs. Here, I want to go into an even more basic mathematical idea which turns out to be one of the biggest leaps of imagination also. This is the ancient Indian numeric system.

Other Civilizations
The most basic indicator of the mathematical abilities and imagination of any civilization is the numeric system used by them and the largest number which they have arrived at. The following are some of the numbers used by ancient civilizations.

The largest number having any representation in ancient China was 10,000. That's it.

Chinese wrote Ten Thousand as:

Similarly, the largest named number for the ancient Greeks was a Myriad, which was 10,000. To be fair, Archimedes did write a paper calculating the number of sand grains in the universe and therefore did imagine numbers as large as 1063, but that knowledge remained unused and quickly forgotten.

Even the Romans, Persians and Egyptians never went beyond One Million.
Roman one million:

Persian one million - میلیون
Egyptians wrote one million this way:

Of course, Arabs received all knowledge from India, so they should not even be counted. Compared to the above numbers from other civilizations, ancient India went far ahead.

Some of the largest numbers are referred to and defined in the Valmiki Ramayan. Valmiki defines these numbers while describing the size of Sri Ram's army in the Yuddha Kanda, (६-२८-३३)

शतम् शतसहस्राणाम् कोटिमाहुर्मनीषिणः || शतम् कोटिसहस्राणाम् शङ्कुरित्यभिधीयते |

"Wise men call a Shata Shata Sahastra as a Koti. A Shata Sahastra Koti is reckoned as a Shanku."

Shata is a hundred and Sahastra is a thousand. So a Koti is 10,000,000 (10 Million) and Hundred Thousand Koti is a Trillion. These days, what we call as "one lakh crore" for lack of proper terminology, actually had a name in ancient times - a "Shanku"!

So One Shanku (1012) is basically One Trillion.


Valmiki goes further to define even larger numbers:

शतम् शङ्कुसहस्राणाम् महाशङ्कुरिति स्मृतः || महाशङ्क्य्सहस्राणाम् शतम् वृन्दमिहोच्यते |
शतम् नृन्दसहस्राणाम् महावृन्दमिति स्मृतम् || महावृन्दसहस्राणाम् शतम् पद्ममिहोच्यते |
शतम् पद्मसहस्राणाम् महापद्ममिति स्मृतम् || महापद्मसहस्राणाम् शतम् खर्वमिहोच्यते |
शतम् खर्वसहस्राणाम् महाखर्वमिति स्मृतम् || महाखर्वसहस्राणाम् समुद्रमभिधीयते |
शतम् समुद्रसाहस्रमोघ इत्यभिधीयते || शतमोघसहस्राणाम् महौघ इति विश्रुतः |

Using Shatam Sahastram (same as Laksha) as Hundred Thousand for easy understanding:

Hundred Thousand Shanku = Maha Shanku =  1017

Hundred Thousand Maha Shanku = Vrinda =  1022
Hundred Thousand Vrinda = Maha Vrinda =  1027
Hundred Thousand Mahavrinda = Padma =  1032
Hundred Thousand Padma = Mahapadma =  1037
Hundred Thousand MahaPadma = Kharva =  1042
Hundred Thousand Kharva = Maha Kharva =  1047
Hundred Thousand MahaKharva = Samudra =  1052
Hundred Thousand Samudra = Augha =  1057
Hundred Thousand Aughas = Maha Augha =  1062

How big is Maha Augha?
Does anyone know what 1062 is called in the modern metric system? Probably not, because no one uses numbers as large as these, except scientists working at the astronomical scale (counting stars and galaxies) or atomic scale while measuring the number of atoms in the universe.

Yes, that's how big this number is.

So, considering that there are 1023 stars and estimated 1080 atoms in the known universe, that's the scale we are talking about. This is far far ahead of any civilization in all of earth's history, that came up with a numeric system.

Even Further
Later on, the Buddhist monks went even further. The Lalitavistara Sutra (a Mahayana Buddhist work) recounts a contest which included writing, arithmetic, wrestling and archery. In it the Buddha was pitted against the great mathematician Arjuna and showed off his numerical skills by citing the names of the powers of ten, up to 1 'tallakshana', which equals 1053, but then going on to explain that this is just one of a series of counting systems that can be expanded geometrically. The last number at which he arrived at after going through nine successive counting systems was 10421, that is, a 1 followed by 421 zeros! But he did not stop there, he actually named all the numbers up to that, with 10421 being called as "dhvajagranishamani (ध्वजाग्रनिशमनी)". That is astounding!

Very small numbers
I can bet many people have no idea that ancient Indians were interested in very small numbers also, especially when defining the concept of Time.

How small? 
Well, त्रुति (Truti) was equal to "0.031 µs (micro second)" = 3.1 x 10-8

रेणु (Renu) = 60 Truti = 0.86 µs = 8.6 x 10-7

लव (Lava) = 60 Renu = 0.11 ms = 1.1 x 10-4
लीक्षक (Leekshak) = 60 Lava = 6.696 ms = 6.696 x 10-3

And so on. I am sure it must come as a surprise to many people that in ancient India we had names for numbers that went to negative powers of ten also!

Infinity
After naming bewilderingly large numbers, it would have been surprising if ancient Indians did not come up with a shloka or two to define Infinity.


Om poornam-adah poornam-idah poorna-aat poornam-udachyate,
Poorna-asya poornam-aadaaya poornam-evaa vashishyate


That is whole, This is whole, From the whole comes the whole. Even if the whole is taken away from whole, still the wholeness remains.

Yes. That is the exact definition of Infinity, that many of us use in our daily prayers!

Where are we now?
So, forget about using any of these numbers in our daily lives, the mind boggles just at the thought of the mathematical imagination of our forefathers. Remember, Ramayan and Lalita-Vistara were religious scriptures, so it is an ode to the mathematical genius of ancient Indians, that they found it very normal to define huge mathematical numbers even in our religious texts.

Maybe, in those days being good in mathematics was just commonplace.

Compared to this, how does it sound now, when we hear people using simple terms like "lakh crore" and "crore core" being used in modern India when our own ancestors were way smarter than us in using larger numbers?

References / Footnotes
• http://www.valmikiramayan.net/utf8/yuddha/sarga28/yuddha_28_frame.htm

• https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indian_numbering_system

• https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Sand_Reckoner

• https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_large_numbers

• https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hindu_units_of_time

• https://archive.org/details/TheFlowerOrnamentScriptureATranslationOfTheAvatamsakaSutraByThomasClearypdfdtyxxytd

• http://www.storyofmathematics.com/

• http://www-groups.dcs.st-and.ac.uk/history/HistTopics/Chinese_numerals.html

• http://www.universetoday.com/36302/atoms-in-the-universe/