Showing posts with label caste. Show all posts
Showing posts with label caste. Show all posts

Friday, 19 March 2021

The discordant notes of caste lines in the classical arts

 At a recent webinar organized by the UCLA Center for India and South Asia, scholars and artists laid bare the seldom-discussed problem of caste in the performing arts of South India.

In the early 1900s when legendary musicologist, Pandit V.N. Bhatkhande, reached the south of India as part of his epic sojourn through the country to consolidate music systems, he was disappointed.


In accounts of these tours recorded in his travelogue, Majha Dakshinecha Pravaas (My Musical Journey in Southern India), and in some of his letters and lectures, he expressed his dissatisfaction not only with what he described as “this yaiyy yaiyy style of singing” but also with the fact that south of India did not quite turn out to be the land of untouched Shastric music that he was seeking. It was instead a colourful amalgam that included folk, Islamic and Christian musical styles too. The ardent, anti-Muslim Sanskritist in him was not pleased.


Bhatkhande was not alone in his conception and more than a hundred years after his not-so-pleasant discovery, this narrative of the ‘pure South’ continues to drive the scholarship and public consumption of its classical arts. According to Davesh Soneji, Associate Professor, Department of South Asia Studies, University of Pennsylvania, this notion has resulted in the erasure of a rich tradition of Tamil Muslim and Christian music and many other art forms practised by non-Brahmin or Hindu artist communities.


The concretisation of the present-day notion of 'Carnatic music' came about when English-speaking upper castes colluded with colonial powers to define a narrow idea of India and its complex social matrix. Photo: Louise Patterton/Unsplash, (CC BY-SA)



Examining the arduous in the arts

At a webinar titled ‘The Arduous Arts: Caste, History, and the Politics of “Classical” Dance and Music in South India’, organised by the University of California, Los Angeles, on January 11, Soneji and others examined these and related issues that rarely get discussed.


With conversations about equity gaining prominence, said Professor Anna Morcom, Mohindar Brar Sambhi Chair of Indian Music, UCLA Department of Music, “now seemed the right time to run this panel, because of the momentum of BLM which is causing more discussion and reflection about class amongst South Asian scholars internationally and in India… The debates on caste are becoming more open and heated especially in the world of south Indian classical dance… (and) it is imperative that these debates are grounded in evidence-based research… I was really keen to present a panel on caste with a highly authoritative lineup of leading scholars, performers, and activists,” she said.


The aesthetic erasure of non-Brahmin art

The theme of erasure – a natural corollary of hegemony – resonated persistently throughout its 3.5-hour duration. T M Krishna, singer and activist who has persistently talked about this issue, raised the question of ‘aesthetic erasure’, a process by which [musical] sounds that do not conform to the classical Carnatic style are deemed plebian and thus undeserving of recognition. It begs the question of what indeed is “classical” and who decides its parameters.


The concretisation of the present-day notion of “Carnatic music” came about in the 1920s and 30s when the English-speaking upper castes colluded with colonial powers to define a narrow idea of India and its complex social matrix. With the criminalisation, marginalisation, and invisibilisation of several castes and artist communities, their contributions to the performing arts scene were also forgotten or lost. Carnatic music came to be understood in a most narrow, Brahminical sense with strict codes of performance.


The codification and obsession with ‘purity’ in the classical arts in the early 20th century was also something of a defensive reaction, according to Dr Stephen Hughes, cultural anthropologist and currently, Film Officer and Film Festival Director at the Royal Anthropological Institute. Purists stood guard as it were against the new, popular forms of music emerging in that period. The ‘mechanization of music’ with the invention of the harmonium, the gramophone, broadcasting and later, film music was the threat from which ‘classical music’ had to be shielded.


What, indeed, is ‘classical’ music?

This begs the question: What is or was ‘classical’ music? Amanda Weidman, Associate Professor of Anthropology at Bryn Mawr College and a socio-cultural anthropologist noted that labelling certain kinds of music as ‘classical’ “is itself a move of power; a way of assigning music to imagined scenes of creation, of performance and reception, to regimes of taste and sensitivities.”


The term, in Weidman’s opinion, is universalising and homogenising in a way that makes canonised knowledge seem like it exists outside of time. Even today, scholars and musicians turn to Shastric texts rather than oral histories or lived traditions to draw from and assert authority over art forms such as Carnatic music and Bharatanatyam dance.


A preponderance on these ‘eternal’ canons means that the real, socio-cultural histories and contexts in which they were constructed are ignored. Posing three questions can help understand the way caste hegemony functions in codifying the ‘classical’ art forms: what repertoire is canonised?; how is theory created?; and how are genres defined? The answers will almost always point to communities traditionally in-charge of knowledge creation and management, such as Brahmins.


In professor Yoshitaka Terada’s words, “some narratives are cherished and furthered, while some others are suppressed and forgotten”. These selective ideas presented as truths entrenches caste hegemony in the arts. But it would serve one well to be reminded of the definition of truth as given by anthropologist, Ana Maria Alonso: “Truth is an unmediated reality created by discursive strategies.”


However, voices are beginning to be raised against such selective truths and hegemonic histories as scholars, performers and activists are beginning to challenge the predominant narratives in the classical arts. Danseuse and scholar Yashoda Thakore proudly proclaimed her Kalavanthulu or Devadasi lineage and asserts that her ancestors were far more valuable cultural contributors than they are believed to be to be today. In addition to challenging stereotypes, she is also challenging male dominance in dance pedagogy.


Nrithya Pillai, a dancer and an activist, also belongs to the hereditary community of devadasi dancers but her claims run somewhat contrary to Thakore’s in her rejection of the label. While Pillai wants acknowledgement and honour for both, herself, and her notable musically talented ancestors, she wants it without the burden of associations that the Devadasi and Bahujan communities come with. She believes that the term ‘Devadasi’ is as casteist as it is colonial and one that Brahmins want to keep upholding to continue the skewed, exclusivist narrative. The need of the hour, according to her, is “foregrounding the invented nature of 20th century history of Bharatanatyam and replace it with actual, social histories.”


These prevalent histories that Pillai refers to are those that are laden with cultural nationalism. Professor Hari Krishnan, Chair and Professor of Dance at Wesleyan University and also the artistic director of Toronto based company, inDANCE, urged Pillai in taking the voices of the traditionally dispossessed communities seriously.


Krishnan stressed on the need for empathy, kindness, and generosity while creating and claiming these changes, for there can be no art without harmony.


It was a conversation much needed and the presence of practitioners and experts lent an extra dimension to the issue, which is bound to be talked about more in the years to come.


Author: Urmi Chanda is a culturalist who writes independently on Indian history, culture and religion. She is currently pursuing a doctorate in interfaith studies and is associated with non-profit work pertaining to conflict resolution and peace studies.


(Source: The Wire)

Friday, 26 February 2021

PhD entry in IITs tougher for students from marginalised communities

 Despite official policy, OBC, SC and ST applicants less likely to gain admission as compared to those from General Categories

Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribe applicants are half as likely to get selected for a Ph.D. programme at leading IITs in the country as aspirants from the General Category (GC) are.


Data collated from a series of RTI applications, including from The Hindu, on the number of applicants versus the number of those admitted to Ph.D. programmes in the five older IITs has indicated that the acceptance rate is skewed against students from the SC, ST, and Other Backward Classes (OBC) communities.


The acceptance rate, which refers to the number of students selected for every 100 students who applied, stood at 4% for students from historically privileged castes (General Category). It falls to 2.7% for OBC students and further down to just 2.16% for SCs and 2.2% for STs.




Policy ignored

This finding comes against the backdrop of the Education Ministry’s data submitted to Parliament last year showing the failure of the IITs to fill Ph.D. seats as per reservation.


It showed that of the total admissions made by all IITs from 2015 to 2019, only 2.1% went to STs and 9.1% to SCs. The government’s reservation policy mandates allocation of 7.5% seats for students from the STs and 15% from SCs.


Similarly, 23.2% seats went to applicants from the OBCs against the 27% mandated by reservation. Remaining 65.6%, or roughly two-thirds of all the seats, went to GC applicants.


The IITs have often cited the lack of applicants from the marginalised communities for the situation. However, the RTI data reveals quite the opposite.


Five-year period

The RTI query data covered 3,279 Ph.D. admissions made from among 95,445 applicants in the five-year period from 2015 to 2019 in the four popular departments of civil (CE), electrical (EE), computer science (CSE), and mechanical (ME) engineering departments in the IITs of Madras, Bombay, Delhi, Kanpur, and Kharagpur.


These five IITs accounted for nearly 60% of all Ph.D. admissions made by all 23 IITs. Within these five IITs, the four departments included in the analysis accounted for roughly 25% of all the admissions made in around 80 different departments offering Ph.D.s.


The trend of acceptance rate being significantly higher for GC students is more pronounced in the Delhi, Madras, Bombay and Kanpur IITs. Though the skewed acceptance rate was observed in IIT Kharagpur also, it did marginally better.


In absolute numbers, only 238 of the 11,019 SC applicants and 40 of the 1,809 ST applicants got selected, according to the RTI data.


The disparity is more visible when the proportion of each category of applicants was compared with their proportion among those who gained admission.


The percentage of GC students among those admitted was always higher than their percentage among those applied. However, the converse was true for OBC, SC and ST candidates. Their percentages among those admitted was always lower than their respective percentages among applicants.


For instance, in IIT Delhi, while 63.3% of all applicants were from GC, they accounted for 76.3% among those admitted. In contrast, the percentage of OBC, SC and ST candidates dropped from 22.9%, 11.9% and 1.9% in the application stage to 17%, 6% and 0.7%, respectively, in the admission stage.


Few of the specific instances where the skewed admission rate was striking included the January 2019 admission cycle in EEE in IIT Delhi. Of the 195 SC applicants, only three were selected (acceptance rate of 1.5%) while none were selected from the 30 ST applicants. In contrast, 50 students were selected from the 1,071 GC applicants (4.7%).


In the July 2016 admission cycle in EEE in IIT Kanpur, 29 candidates were selected from 396 GC applicants (7.3%) while not a single one of the 46 SC applicants made it.


Bucking the trend

Interestingly, data from IIT Guwahati painted a different picture, countering the explanations for the disparity in other IITs.


According to data on 456 admissions and 13,033 applicants provided by IIT Guwahati, the acceptance rates for students from marginalised communities were roughly similar or even higher than GC students.


While the acceptance rate for GC candidates was 3.3%, it was 4% for OBCs, 3.4% for SCs, and 4.9% for STs.


While IIT Guwahati also failed to fulfil the reservation-mandated allocation of seats, it was the only major IIT that came closest to the desired numbers. The percentage of OBC, SC and ST candidates among those admitted were respectively 21%, 12.3% and 5.5%.


‘Selection bias’

Responding to the data, Professor and Chair in the Department of Anthropology at Harvard University Ajantha Subramanian said it was far more likely that the failure to fill the reserved seats was due to selection bias.


Professor Subramanian, who has written on the workings of upper caste privileges in the IITs in her book The Caste of Merit, told The Hindu, “There has been long-standing opposition among IIT administrators and faculty to reservations, which they see as a form of unjust government intervention in their meritocratic institutions.”


Arguing that the data showed the pyramidal structure of Indian education in which exclusion increased as one moved through advancing degrees, Professor Subramanian said the argument of “merit” was often used as an alibi for continuing social exclusion.


“A truly just admissions policy must directly address the vastly different circumstances from which students come so that so-called ‘merit’ is recognised as the by-product of unfair structural advantages and not simply as innate talent,” she said.


The recent report of an Education Ministry-constituted committee, which included administrators from a few IITs, has faced criticism for recommending the abolition of reservation in faculty recruitment.


Sukhdeo Thorat, Professor Emeritus, Jawaharlal Nehru University, and former Chairman of University Grants Commission, who previously headed a committee to look into caste-based discrimination at the All India Institute of Medical Sciences, said the data highlighted the need for a further detailed study on the issue.


He stressed the need for increased transparency in the admission process and the presence of OBC, SC and ST members on the selection panels.


ChintaBar, a student collective in IIT Madras, has said the acceptance rate must ideally be higher for students from reserved categories with different cut-off marks for them.


Pointing out that the number of applicants from reserved categories was many times higher than the reserved seats, it urged the IITs to follow reservation in letter and spirit.


The Hindu reached out to the six IITs for their comment. IIT Delhi and IIT Kharagpur did not respond to repeated queries.


The other IITs ruled out the possibility of any bias in the selection process, and said the admissions were conducted in a fair manner. Confirming that the reservation policies were followed in all seats funded by the Education Minstry and different cut-off marks were followed for reserved category students, they said efforts were being made to fill seats as per reservation.


IIT Guwahati did not directly answer a question on reasons for the acceptance rate being uniform. The institute, however, said it was working towards admission policies to ensure all seats under reserved categories were filled.


Students from the Scheduled Caste (SC) and Scheduled Tribe (ST) communities have significantly poor representation and acceptance rate in Ph.D programmes at the Indian Institute of Technology (IIT) Madras, analysis of data obtained through the Right to Information (RTI) Act revealed.


The analysis was based on data provided by IIT Madras regarding 2,195 admissions made from 54,462 applicants in the five-year period from 2015 to 2019.


The data showed that SC students numbered only 7.6% and STs were just 1.2%. The reservation policy requires that 15% of seats be allocated to SCs and 7.5% to STs.


Moreover, the data showed a significant difference in the acceptance rate, which refers to the number of students admitted for every 100 applicants. While General Category (GC) students, which in the case of the IITs predominantly refers to those from historically privileged communities, had an acceptance rate of 4.4%, it was 2.9% for SCs and 2.7% for STs.


Only 167 of the 5,855 SC applicants and 27 of the 991 ST applicants were selected.


Interestingly, the institution had filled the reservation-mandated seats for Other Backward Classes (OBCs), thanks to nine of the 16 departments that managed to fill the seats. . 29.8% of the seats went to OBC candidates against the 27% of minimum allocation to be done as per reservation norms. The remaining 61.6% seats went to the GC category.


Though IIT Madras had admitted 3,874 Ph.D. scholars from 2015 to 2019 according to the data submitted by the Ministry of Education in the Parliament last year, it provided community-wise data on applications and admissions for only 2,195 admissions (57% of the total).


Despite appeals through RTI, a few of the 16 research departments in IIT Madras did not give data for some semesters. For the Mathematics Department, the administration said it had data for only one semester.


It can be noted, however, that the RTI data followed a fairly similar pattern to that of the data submitted to the Parliament in terms of seat allocation. Of the 3,874 admissions, 64.4% went to the GCs, 27.9% to OBCs, and only 6.4% to SCs and 1.3% to STs.


The RTI data threw light on how the difference in acceptance rate was more pronounced in some departments.


For instance, in Aerospace Engineering (AE), the acceptance rate was 6.6% for GCs and only 1.7% for SCs. In absolute numbers, only five of the 292 SC applicants were selected. In contrast, 100 applicants were selected from the 1,520 GC candidates.


A stark difference in acceptance rate was also observed in Applied Mechanics, Electrical Engineering, Humanities and Social Sciences, and Management Studies, between GC and SC applicants.


The Department of Computer Science and Engineering had one of the highest number of applicants from SC and ST categories. From the 755 SC applicants, only four were selected and from 136 ST applicants, none were selected. 


While the overall acceptance rate was lower in the department, it was lower still for SC and ST applicants.


Engineering Design and Mechanical Engineering were among the exceptions, with similar acceptance rates for all categories. While most departments had poor acceptance rates for STs, departments like Physics, Metallurgical and Materials Engineering, and Ocean Engineering, had better acceptance rates for SCs. Consequently, they came closer to filling seats as per the reservation rules.


Ruling out the possibility that the difference in acceptance rate was due to selection bias, Bhaskar Ramamurthi, Director, IIT Madras, said that the institution in fact adopted a strategy of calling a high percentage of SC and ST applicants for interview.


He said that an internal analysis of the past three years of data showed that SC and ST candidates were roughly 10% and 1.7% of the total applicants to the institution. He said that while 32% of applicants were called for an interview overall, the rate was 65% for SC and ST candidates.


“Only 25 to 30% of those from SC/ST categories who are called attended the interview,” he said. While the percentage selected among those interviewed was 24% overall, it was 16% for the reserved categories. “The acceptance rate for SC/ST is therefore not lower given that the calling rate is double,” he said.


On how the institution filled the seats reserved for OBC with the acceptance rate being better, he said, “We do not know why, but are happy that this is so.”


RTI data for 2015-2019 reveals poor acceptance rate for students from marginalised communities, with 25 of 26 departments not filling OBC, SC quotas either.


None of the 26 departments in IIT Bombay managed to fill seats reserved for Scheduled Tribe students in Ph.D. programmes between 2015 to 2019, according to data obtained through Right to Information queries.


The data obtained by the Ambedkar Periyar Phule Study Circle, a student collective in IIT Bombay, showed that 25 of the 26 departments failed to fill Other Backward Classes (OBC) and Scheduled Castes (SC) quota as well. Eleven of the 26 departments did not admit a single student under ST category in the period under question.


Of the 2,874 admissions for which data was provided by the institution, 71.6 % went to General Category (GC) students, which in terms of IITs predominantly constituted students from historically privileged communities; 19.2 % went to OBCs, 7.5 % to SCs and 1.6 % to STs. Reservation policy demands a minimum allocation of 27% to OBCs, 15% to SCs and 7.5% to STs.




Skewed entry

In 13 of the 26 departments, more than 75% of the seats went to students under GC.


The data showed the acceptance rate, which refers to the number of students selected for every 100 applicants, to be lower for students from reserved categories than those from GC. While the acceptance rate was 3.8% for GC, it was 3.1% for OBCs and STs and 2.5% for SCs.


In 16 of the 26 departments, this skew in acceptance rate was more pronounced with SC and ST students having acceptance rates at half or lower those for GC applicants.


For instance, Electrical Engineering (EE) and Mechanical Engineering (ME) departments had the highest number of ST applicants. While two of the 148 ST applicants got selected in EE with an acceptance rate of 1.4%, the acceptance rate was 3.8% for GC. In ME, not a single ST candidate from 110 applicants got selected whereas 168 students were selected from 4,590 applicants under GC with an acceptance rate of 3.7%.


In the Energy Sciences and Engineering department, only 5 of the 610 SC applicants got selected with an acceptance rate of 0.8%. In contrast 82 from 3,902 GC applicants got selected with an acceptance rate of 2.1%.


Computer Science was one of the few departments that recorded dismal acceptance rates across OBC, SC and ST categories. Only five from 797 OBC applicants, four from 495 SC applicants and one from 78 ST applicants were selected with an acceptance rate of 0.6%, 0.8% and 1.3% respectively. In contrast 69 applicants from 2,997 GC applicants were selected with an acceptance rate of 2.3%.


The Centre for Studies in Resource Engineering (CSRE) and SJM School of Management (SJMSM) were the two departments that did not admit a single student from among SC and ST applicants. The two departments together selected 74 students from among 1,780 applicants under GC. However, none were selected from 313 SC and ST applicants.


Environment Science and Engineering (ESE) and Centre for Policy Studies were the only departments to fill seats reserved for OBC and SC students. ESE and Humanities and Social Sciences (HSS) came closer to filling seats reserved for STs. HSS also had marginally better acceptance rate for OBC, SC and ST applicants.


Interview

The data also indicated that more students from marginalised communities were rejected at the interview stage.

A comparison of the proportion of students from different categories showed that their proportion remained fairly the same at the application stage and the interview stage. Overall, around 12% of applicants got rejected; the remaining 88% made it to the interview stage.


However, among those selected post the interviews, while the percentage of GC increased to 71.6%, the proportion of students from all other categories went down.


GC candidates accounted for 64.8%, OBCs 22.2%, SCs 11.1% and STs 1.9% in both application and interview stages. However, among those selected post the interviews, while the percentage of GC increased to 71.6%, the proportion of students from all other categories went down.


‘Fair selection’

In response to queries on the data, the IIT Bombay administration said that the selection process was fair and transparent.


“Lower cut-offs and extra efforts are made to take candidates as per reservation categories to fill the seats,” a spokesperson for the Institute said.


On the acceptance rate being different, the spokesperson said, “IITs have very high expectations of our student input, which is needed to carry out research towards a Ph.D.”


“While we do get sufficient candidates in certain departments, in some other departments, students of the required calibre tend to take up industry jobs rather than join for a Ph.D which has extra uncertainties and lower income levels during Ph.D and in some areas even post Ph.D. It is possible that the family background and economic level may have an impact on such candidates applying for a Ph.D. This requires a proper socio-economic study,” the spokesperson added.


(Source: The Hindu)

Thursday, 29 October 2020

In another India, Hindus and Muslims do marry without changing their faith

There has always existed a world in India beyond the imagination of fanatics, where religion is not one’s primary identity

I have lived through the #TanishqAd... my Muslim mother-in-law gifted me a mangalsutra and even godhbharai.”

Architect Rachna Lanewala, who tweeted this at the height of the Tanishq ad controversy last fortnight, is not the only woman to have “lived through” the experience depicted in the jewellery advertisement. Almost half a century ago, writer Saryu Rizvi’s parents would accompany each other to their respective shrines, be it the temple to get their new car blessed, or to the Karbala Maidan during Muharram.


There has always existed a world in India beyond the imagination of fanatics, where religion is not one’s primary identity, and a Hindu can marry a Muslim without either of them changing their faith. So, while in 1972, Saryu’s parents, hailing from Kanpur and Dehradun, could only consider getting married in Delhi, the question of conversion never came up.


Illustration for representative purpose.   | Photo Credit: R. Rajesh


Fully supportive

Neither did it come up in 1999 when Aasif Lanewala married his collegemate Rachna, whose parents, having migrated to Delhi after Partition, had warned her never to marry a Muslim. More than a thousand attended their Mumbai reception.

In 2012, journalist Mustafa Plumber, ignoring murmurs from the men in his family, declared that he wasn’t planning to convert his colleague Prachi Pinglay when they got married. After his younger brother’s nikaah, it was Prachi, guided by Mustafa’s mother, who performed the rituals expected of the eldest bahu (daughter-in-law).


The timeline from Saryu’s parents, who didn’t inform their families about their civil marriage right away, to Mustafa and Prachi, whose wedding was attended by both families, has not been a linear one.


Religious conversions happen even today, but far often than not, it is more a formality to please the families and not some “jihadi trap” as portrayed by the radical fringe. Thus Veena’s (name changed) conversion only meant a change in her official name. Straight after her wedding, her husband accompanied her to Tirupati for a long-desired pilgrimage.


Elopements too continue to take place in this world. In 1996, Vidya and Shoaib (names changed) fled to Vadodara after a secret wedding at the Registrar’s. Both belonged to joint families that had their own businesses. To their surprise, Shoaib’s parents called them back and hosted a grand dinner after a nikaah (marriage ceremony). Vidya’s uncle too, who had objected the most, became fully supportive.


Though Shoaib, despite having grown up in a Muslim locality, happily participated in Diwali pujas with his Marwari in-laws, Vidya took her new religion seriously — until she got drawn to meditation two years ago. Nobody had forced her to do namaaz and nobody objected when she stopped.


Secular upbringing

Contrary to popular belief, these Hindu-Muslim marriages are not restricted to the well-to-do. Masood Akhtar, who till recently lived in a slum, still wakes up to nightmares of the time he was beaten up by the police and put behind bars during the 1992-93 Mumbai riots. But he refused to let the trauma tarnish the secular upbringing he had had. As a boy, he would often accompany his father to his workshop to distribute Diwali sweets to his Hindu workers. When Masood informed his family that his Hindu fiancee’s name must remain unchanged after the nikaah, only his father supported him. Today, his joint family consults his wife Rama Shyam on everything. And every Durga Puja, Masood, Rama and their son go pandal-hopping.


The best part of this world is not the conservatives it manages to convert along the way, but the children born of such unions. Saryu fondly recalls her mother reading the Ramayana while the local maulana who had come to meet her waited patiently. “Accha, baaji paath padh rahi hai (Let sister finish reciting the Ramayana),” he would say. Her father named her after the U.P. river sacred to Hindus.


Aasif still regrets not being allowed to say ‘Indian’ in the religion column of his son’s birth certificate. When the child was four, he was asked by someone in Aasif’s hometown Dahod whether he was Hindu or Muslim. The cricket-crazy boy simply said, “I’m a Mumbai Indian”.


Mustafa finds that his two-year-old son has taken over what used to be his task on Diwali day — ringing the bell while Prachi performs Lakshmi puja. Sometimes, the toddler stands next to him when Mustafa performs the namaaz. “Let him find his own path,” say the parents.


Going forward, it is these children who will prove to be immune to the vitriol spewed by bigots.


(Source: The Hindu)

Wednesday, 2 October 2019

Over 1.2 lakh students in Kerala leave caste and religion columns blank during admission

As many as 1,24,144 students who secured admission to classes 1 to 12 in schools during the 2017-18 academic year in the state have left the caste and religion columns blank.

On Wednesday, Kerala state Education Minister Prof C Ravindranath, informed the legislative assembly of figures that show how the new generation is leaving the religion or caste columns blank during admission in school or college.

According to an article by Mirror Now, Prof Ravindranath stressed on how the number of students enrolling in schools and colleges in Kerala leaving their religion or caste column blank is increasing with every academic year.

Students who left caste and religion column
As many as 1,24,144 students who secured admission to classes 1 to 12 in schools during the 2017-18 academic year in the State have left the caste and religion columns blank.

"In the latest academic year at least 124, 144 students between class and 1 and 12 stated they had no religion or caste. Every year their numbers are growing," said the education minister while appreciating the positive change in the minds of India's young.

Meanwhile, education department officials admit that they had no contribution towards driving this positive change since there is nothing that they can do if the parents of a child say that they follow no religion.

Students who filled caste and religion form
However, all students who have secured admission to Vocational Higher Secondary Education (VHSE) courses in the State during 2017-18 have filled the caste and religion columns.

(Source: India Today)

Thursday, 21 February 2019

Tamil Nadu woman becomes first Indian to get 'no caste, no religion' certificate

Sneha Parthibaraja, a 35-year-old lawyer from Vellore became the first woman to get an official 'no religion, no caste' certificate.

The caste system may have been legally abolished in 1950, but if you live in India, the box for you to fill in 'caste' and 'religion' is still present in a lot of forms. Some of these boxes on forms are also compulsory, and you do not always have the option of leaving them empty.

The closest option you get is 'Choose not to say' or 'Other' as an answer to these boxes.

A woman from Tamil Nadu, however, can now choose to not answer these on any forms as she officially has 'no caste, no religion.'


On February 5th, Sneha Parthibaraja, a 35-year-old lawyer from Vellore became the first person in the country to win the right to not have any caste or religion associated with her identity after a 9-year-old court battle.

Sneha was brought up in a family which neither believed in any caste nor religion. All her certificates, including birth and school certificates, have nil or are blank against the “caste” and “religion” columns. “They mention me as an Indian,” she told The Hindu.

Sneha mentions that with every form that she filled, the mandated enclosure of community certificate made her realize she had to get an identity 'that was sans caste and religion.'

Parthibaraja began her fight in 2010 but all her attempts remained futile, as officials usually turned down on the basis of there being no precedent in the country.

Finally, in 2017 Sneha submitted her last application and explained her stand to officials. She said that she didn't want to avail any government schemes or restrictions, and hence, her request should be granted.

On February 5th, Sub-Collector, Tirupattur, B. Priyanka Pankajam finally decided to give her the ‘no caste, no religion’ identity certificate. “Though we found no precedent, we decided to go ahead and certify her as it will not affect anybody or take away another person’s opportunity,” she said.

Kamal Hassan and others congratulated her on Twitter for finally having no caste or religion attached to her identity.





(Source: News18) 

Wednesday, 23 January 2019

Confessions of a Karnataka voter: Don’t blame us for the MLAs we never voted for

We cast our votes for caste, religion, money and muscle power. We voted for the party symbol and not the person who is seeking our vote to represent us, writes Srinivas Alavilli on The News Minute. Read on: 

Voters of Karnataka are feeling angry, cheated and stricken with guilt after days of #ResortPolitics #MLAsBrawl #OperationLotus playing out in national media. The collective feeling can be summed up in one word: shame.

But I think there is nothing here to be shameful of. Absolutely nothing. Because we never elected these MLAs that are now on sale and being ferried state to state, resort to resort, in the first place. Contrary to popular perception, we did not vote for them. Don’t get me wrong, we did cast our vote but not for any of these ‘elected representatives’.

We cast our votes for caste, religion, money and muscle power. We voted for the party symbol and not the person who is seeking our vote to represent us. We voted for some big national leader who might lead the state or country, not the person whose name is actually on the ballot.


We voted for some party that is supposed to represent the best interests of “our caste". How can any other caste get dominant position in our politics? That would hurt our future so instead of evaluating the merits of various candidates, we ensured the remarks “India votes caste” holds good even in 2018.

We voted for a party that will take care of “our religion” and makes sure the “other religion” doesn’t get political power. Never mind what the Constitution says, we made elections about spreading religious hatred.

We happily voted for criminals and money bags who we very well know didn’t make their fortunes legitimately because we are too focused on getting our party in power. We avoided even looking at the face of an actual candidate leave alone his or her track record, skills and capabilities to be a legislator in the state Assembly. We were eager to support even a lamp post that got the ‘ticket’ never mind deserving candidates that are independents or from small parties trying to change the system.

We pressed the button next to names who we won’t ever invite home for tea or trust with our children for five minutes because we believed these names have been “selected” by party and they are “winnable”. We played along.

We never voted for these people in the first place.

So why should we feel ashamed?

The great leaders of our party and caste will “take care” of the situation. Soon.

Life will be back to normal, we will vote again for the same MLAs that are currently in resorts throwing stuff at each other, negotiating their price to defect, seeking positions of power where there is scope to make a killing. Who cares if they didn’t make any positive difference as legislators.That stuff is not nearly as important as our loyalties to the caste, religion and party!

Thursday, 10 January 2019

In India, it’s OK to hate reserved quotas – until it benefits your community

The Cabinet has announced 10 per cent reservation for economically backward upper-castes: a transparently populist move from a BJP government gearing up for election year. But it has also turned a demographic that has been traditionally critical of reservation policies into supporters of the same overnight, writes Dushyant Shekhawat on Arre. Read on: 

When I was a teenager seeking admission to Mumbai’s colleges, the one word on everyone’s lips was “quota”. Xaviers College had a Catholic quota, Jai Hind had a Sindhi quota, and almost every institute had a sports quota. And then there was me, an average student with average marks, ineligible for special treatment of any kind – except my privilege – praying that my name would make it onto one of the accepted lists. Luckily for me, my grades were good enough to get me into the college I wanted to attend, but I remember wishing I could have had the safety net of a quota to rely on during the waiting period.

Yesterday, far too late to quell my admission anxiety, the Cabinet announced 10 per cent reservation in government jobs and educational institutes for the economically backward from the upper-castes, who have traditionally been excluded from India’s many reservation programmes across the country. Apart from being a transparently populist move from a BJP government gearing up for election year, the announcement has also had the effect of turning a demographic that has been traditionally critical of reservation policies into supporters of the same overnight.

Since India came into being, upper castes have been spectators as the Schedule Castes and Tribes, followed by OBCs, became beneficiaries of reservation policies. The resentment at being left out from the affirmative action programmes sometimes boiled over in the form of protests, like those against the Mandal Commission in 1990, and the student protests that took place in 2006, or more recently, the Patidar, Jat, and Maratha agitations across the country. Perhaps the seeds for yesterday’s announcement were sown during those protests; in 2006, the BJP and their student wing ABVP were in support of reservation, but wanted it to be extended to the poor among upper-castes as well.

Not only does this move have no precedent, it probably won’t be passed in the Rajya Sabha, where the BJP doesn’t enjoy a majority.

Illustration: Akshita Monga

The Cabinet’s decision was met with a round of support from BJP faithful online, with the hashtag #SaavarnoKoSammaan trending on Twitter, as the BJP’s traditional vote bank lapped up the latest PR stunt. And yes, despite all the furore the announcement has created, at this point it remains just a publicity stunt. Not only does this move have no precedent, it probably won’t be passed in the Rajya Sabha, where the BJP doesn’t enjoy a majority.

It is also likely that the Supreme Court will strike down any proposition to create 10 per cent reservation for upper-castes, since such a move would mean more than 50 per cent of the seats in government institutions are blocked on the basis of reservations. Crossing the 50 per cent limit would require an amendment to the Constitution, as well as completely reimagining the concept of reservations and how they’re implemented in the Indian context.


According to the father of the Indian Constitution BR Ambedkar, reservations were a measure to be used only for “communities which have not had so far representation in the State.” By this definition, the upper-castes currently in a position to benefit from the Cabinet’s latest reservation proposal would be ineligible due to having been adequately represented in state bodies and institutions. Also, in 1992, in the landmark Indira Sawhney, Etc VS Union of India and Other, Etc case, wherein the Supreme Court analysed the legality of quotas and the concept of backwardness in detail, the court stated that “a backward class cannot be determined only and exclusively with reference to economic criterion. It may be a consideration or basis along with and in addition to social backwardness, but it can never be the sole criterion.” If the Supreme Court is to follow its own precedent, it will have to reject the Modi government’s latest proposal as unconstitutional.

The real irony here is that the predominantly right-wing supporters of the BJP have often been vocal critics of reservation in the past.

Even though these might not seem like the best conditions to announce such a radical reservation programme, there was no better time than now for the Modi government to take this decision. Promising jobs to upper-castes via reservation is an act of magician-level misdirection, that detracts attention from the fact that this government’s record of providing employment – a crucial plank for the BJP’s 2014 campaign – has been unsatisfactory. So badly has that affected the electorate, that unemployment played a key role in the party’s defeat in Rajasthan, Chhattisgarh, and Madhya Pradesh state assembly elections last month. As political commentator Dhruv Rathee pointed out, “10 per cent of zero is still zero.”

Despite these obvious shortcomings, the BJP’s upper-caste Hindu voter base has celebrated the announcement of the reservations for upper-castes like a victory in the 2019 Lok Sabha election. The real irony here is that the predominantly right-wing supporters of the BJP have often been vocal critics of reservation in the past. When particular communities have agitated for reservations in their name, for example, the Patidar agitation in Gujarat or Maratha agitation in Maharashtra, both BJP-ruled states, arguments were made against reservation being a political stunt to undermine the government and thwart meritocracy. In 2015, at the height of the Patidar protests, RSS chief Mohan Bhagwat weighed in on the issue, saying that India’s reservation policy needed a review.

It is unclear if Bhagwat meant an arbitrary announcement that brings yet another group of citizens under the already expansive umbrella of India’s reservation quotas, but that appears to be how his ideological disciples in the government have chosen to implement his words. The BJP’s recent defeat in the state assembly elections is sure to have set alarm bells ringing, and it has been reported that the RSS feels like the BJP is losing its appeal to its core demographic, upper-caste Hindus. This move might be a last-ditch effort to lure back disenchanted supporters.

We view reservations as an unfair practice, right up until it becomes fair in our favour.

As the debate over whether these reservations can even be effectively implemented rages on, it will be amusing to watch previous critics of reservation defend the policy just because it can suddenly benefit them.

Which takes me back to the time I was seeking admission to college. The students eligible for any of the multitudinous quotas were gleeful about the inherent advantage they possessed, while the have-nots grumbled about having the deck stacked against them. I’d be hard pressed to come up with a better analogy for India’s relationship with the reservation system on a national level – we view it as an unfair practice, right up until it becomes fair in our favour. After which it is taken as something completely routine, and praiseworthy even. The debate over the Cabinet’s latest decision regarding reservations is just another example of the same attitude.

Monday, 7 January 2019

Remembering Vaikom satyagraha in the light of Sabarimala

Congress party’s stand on the Sabarimala issue is but one sign of how far it has fallen in recent times. The once brave party of the freedom struggle is now represented by self-seeking cowards, writes Ramachandra Guha. Read on: 

In the last week of January 1924—fully 95 years ago—two radicals in Kerala formed an ‘Anti-Untouchability Committee’. They were TK Madhavan, a journalist and a follower of the great Shri Narayana Guru; and KP Kesava Menon, a Congressman and a follower of Mahatma Gandhi. In the months and years to follow, this Committee and its members were in the vanguard of an epic struggle for social equality, that is worth recalling for its own intrinsic interest, and for the light it might shed on the ongoing controversy over the entry of women of a certain age into the Sabarimala shrine.

Dalits and women are the two groups that Hindu society has historically discriminated against. Down the centuries, they were treated as less-than-equal in everyday social life, and as less-than-equal under the law as well. This essay relates to yet a third area of discrimination; that of religious custom and practice. In Sabarimala today, women are treated as less-than-equal in the eyes of god. Back in the 1920s, Dalits were also treated as less-than-equal in the eyes of god. The entry of women of a certain age in Sabarimala, now, and the entry of Dalits in Hindu shrines, then, was regarded as ‘polluting’. The struggle of Dalits in Kerala to achieve equal rights in the temples of the 1920s is therefore of compelling relevance to the struggles of women to achieve equal rights in the temples of today.

The first target of the Anti-Untouchability Committee formed in 1924 was a famous Siva shrine in the town of Vaikom, where worship was restricted to upper-castes alone. Lower castes and Dalits were denied entry not merely to the temple, but also to its surroundings. In February 1924, the Committee held a public meeting in Vaikom, where it was decided that the rule barring the temple roads to low castes would be defied by a group of satyagrahis. March 30 was fixed as the date when this defiance would take place.

On March 30, 1924, volunteers arrived in Vaikom from different parts of Travancore. Some came from Malabar, the Malayalam-speaking district of the Madras Presidency. The atmosphere in the satyagrahis’ camp was, one chronicler wrote, ‘charged with the austere serenity of Gandhian idealism and the burning odour of nationalist sentiment.’ Mahatma Gandhi had sent a message to the satyagrahis; after this was read out, three men—a Pulaya (a caste then considered not just ‘untouchable’, but also ‘unapproachable’), an Ezhava, and a Nair—were garlanded, before marching hand-in-hand towards the prohibited road. When they were stopped by the police, the satyagrahis refused to turn back, but squatted on the road. A further batch of three men from different castes then came forward to break the law. The six protesters were arrested and taken off to court—one apologised, but the others stayed firm, and were sentenced to six months in prison.


A week later there was a fresh round of rule-breaking in Vaikom. This time both TK Madhavan and KP Kesava Menon courted arrest. More volunteers came forward to take their place. The authorities now changed their tactics, in part because the jails of Travancore were not large enough to house many more protesters. Now they had a large barricade erected across the road and placed a police guard next to it.

Meanwhile, the roads to the temple remained barred to the lower castes. The satyagrahis now changed their tactics too, by sitting outside the barricade and refusing to eat or drink. This part of India is always hot and humid—and these men were unaccustomed to fasting anyway. Several fainted, and were rushed to hospital.

Mahatma Gandhi had been in close touch with the satyagrahis of Vaikom, and, in a long, reflective, article in Young India, he took up the larger meaning of their struggle. He had been criticised for suggesting that while the satyagraha continued, the organisers should simultaneously send petitions and deputations to the authorities. In advocating an approach of determined incrementalism, Gandhi remarked that ‘in Travancore, the satyagrahis are not attacking a whole system. … They are fighting sacerdotal prejudice...Satyagrahis would, therefore, be deviating from their path if they did not try to court junction with the authorities and cultivate public support by means of deputations, meetings, etc. Direct action does not always preclude other consistent methods. Nor is petitioning, etc., in every case a sign of weakness on the part of a satyagrahi. Indeed, he is no satyagrahi who is not humble.’

In the third week of May 1924, a group of activists from Vaikom arrived to meet Gandhi, who was then in Mumbai. When asked what their future course of struggle might be, Gandhi suggested that the caste Hindus who supported reform should march peacefully from Vaikom to the state capital, Trivandrum. He advised them to ask the Ruler for an audience, and persuade him to act to remove the restrictions imposed by the temple authorities. Gandhi told the deputation that ‘the caste Hindus comprising the procession must be prepared to suffer the inconveniences incidental to a slow march on foot. They must camp in places away from villages and towns and make their own arrangements for food.’

Back in Vaikom, after the local leaders, Madhavan and Kesava Menon, had been arrested, reinforcements came in from the Tamil country. Among the new volunteers was EV Ramasamy (later known as ‘Periyar’), an activist with a deep antipathy to the caste system. Ramasamy threw himself into the struggle, being arrested twice. His commitment earned him the appellation Vaikom virar, the valiant hero of Vaikom.

In the second week of February 1925, the matter went up to the Travancore Legislative Council. Its members voted by the narrowest of margins (22 to 21) against the entry of lower castes to the temple road. A satyagrahi from Vaikom now urged Gandhi to visit the town. If they did not have his sustenance and support, he said, the movement would wane, and perhaps die out altogether.

In March, Gandhi decided to visit Vaikom. He reached there on the 11th of the month, having stopped in and spoken at Cochin (the state’s largest city) en route. In Vaikom he found the volunteers squatting in front of the barricades put up to guard the temple’s four entrances. Each batch was stationed for six hours, its members spinning or singing.

Addressing the satyagrahis, Gandhi asked them ‘to forget the political aspect of the programme. … We are endeavouring to rid Hinduism of its greatest blot. The prejudice we have to fight against is an age-old prejudice. … The end is to get all such roads throughout Travancore to be opened up to the [lowest castes]….’

Gandhi, meanwhile, also sought an audience with the high-caste Namboodiri Brahmins who were most bitterly opposed to granting the Ezhavas and Pulayas the right to walk on the roads outside the temple.

The conversation between Gandhi and the Namboodiri orthodoxy in Vaikom was recorded for posterity by Mahadev Desai. When asked why they treated the low castes so harshly, the leader of the Namboodiris—named Indanturuttil—said placidly that the Ezhavas and Pulayas were merely ‘reaping the reward of their karma.’ It was for their (bad) behaviour in their past life that they had been relegated to the bottom of the pile in this one.

Gandhi told Indanturuttil Namboodiri that their conduct was a form of ‘Dyerism’—as shocking, and as brutal, as the actions of General Dyer in Jallianwala Bagh. The Brahmin said, in justification, that the practice he and his caste men followed had been started by Adi Sankara, the eighth century preacher from Kerala who had helped create a sense of unity among Hindus. Gandhi asked that if indeed this was an ancient custom, why was it not practiced elsewhere in India? To this the Namboodiri answered: ‘Surely untouchability is there in every part of India. We carry untouchability a little further. That’s all.’

Gandhi discussed the caste question with the most reactionary elements in Malayali society, as well as with the most progressive. On March 12, 1925, Gandhi met Narayana Guru, in the Guru’s math in Varkala. In Gandhi’s version of the meeting, when the Guru told him ‘religion was one’, he respectfully disagreed; in his view, ‘so long as there are different human heads, so long will there be different religions, but the secret of a true religious life is to tolerate one another’s religion.’

To make his point more effectively, Gandhi used a homely metaphor. The two men were sitting in an open courtyard under a mango tree. Gandhi told Narayana Guru that ‘no two leaves of this very tree, under whose shadow we are sitting, are alike, though they spring from the same root, but, even as the leaves live together in perfect harmony and present to us a beautiful whole, so must we, divided humanity present to the outsider looking upon us as a beautiful whole.’

The version told by the Guru’s biographers uses the same metaphor, but with a crucial twist. Here, Gandhi plucked two leaves from the tree, and, pointing to their different textures, sizes and shapes, said they illustrated the variety of humanity, and hence of their religious affiliations. In response, the Guru bit into the stem of one leaf, and then the other, and asked Gandhi to do the same. He would find that the juice of the two stems tasted exactly the same. In the same manner, men may appear to differ in size or skin colour or caste identity, but in essence they were the same. Hence Narayana Guru’s slogan, ‘One Caste, One God, One Humanity’.

A poem attributed to Narayana Guru beautifully conveys his egalitarian and universalist philosophy. It reads well enough in English, and must surely be even more evocative in its native Malayalam. Here are a few lines:

One of kind, one of faith, and one of God is man
Of one womb, of one form, difference herein none
Within a species, is it not, that offspring truly bred?
The community of man thus viewed to a single caste belongs
Of the human species is even a Brahmin born,
And the Outcaste too.

Despite their different theological positions, Gandhi was greatly impressed by Narayana Guru, and by the manifest influence he had on the self-esteem of the Ezhavas. In a public meeting held in the state capital, Trivandrum, he said it ‘hurt his sense of religion, humanity and nationalism’, that someone like Narayana Guru could not enter the prohibited roads in Vaikom. Gandhi believed that ‘blind orthodoxy could not stand the fierce light of local public criticism provided it was sympathetic, non-violent and humble. There were only 60 thousand Brahmins, compared to eight lakh non-Brahmins and 17 lakh untouchables in [the state], and while he was gratified by their educational advancement, he felt they should not be refused the rights of common humanity.’

It took another decade for these rights to be recognised. In the second week of November 1936, the Travancore Darbar announced that all temples in the state were henceforth to be open to all Hindus, regardless of caste. This was the final fruit of the Vaikom satyagraha begun by the followers of Narayana Guru, and later supported by Gandhi. Gandhi made a public announcement congratulating the Travancore Darbar, for allowing the oppressed and excluded in Travancore to ‘feel the glow of freedom and real oneness’ with other Hindus.

The discrimination against Dalits and women practiced by upper-caste patriarchs has been, as Gandhi put it, ‘the greatest blot on Hinduism.’ The Vaikom Satyagraha was in this regard a crucial milestone in the struggle of Dalits to achieve equality in the eyes of god. The Sabarimala struggle is centred on the right to equality in the eyes of god for women. Both movements have challenged what Gandhi called ‘sacerdotal prejudice’, whereby orthodox and closed-minded priests denied morality and justice in the name of custom and tradition. Back in the 1920s, the state and public institutions—the Travancore Durbar and the local courts, in this case—were on the side of the inequality and oppression sanctioned by sacerdotal prejudice. Now, the Kerala government and the Supreme Court have both weighed in strongly on the side of equality and justice. Sadly, however, powerful elements in politics and society in Kerala today support the irrational, manifestly unConstitutional restrictions sought to be imposed by the temple authorities in Sabarimala on women devotees.

That the BJP led by Amit Shah would seek to polarise and divide Kerala on this issue should not surprise us. That they should encourage violence and intimidation by young men seeking to maintain patriarchal hierarchies is entirely in character. The BJP will do anything to garner votes and win elections. Far more surprising, and altogether more distressing, is the reaction of the Congress party, which claims to be heir to the legacy and mantle of Mahatma Gandhi. Let me remind them that, at the same year as the Vaikom struggle was gathering momentum, 1924-5, Gandhi convinced his party colleagues that their next president must be a female. Thus, in 1925, Sarojini Naidu was chosen president of the Indian National Congress, this at a time when no major (or possibly even minor) political party in the west had women in leadership positions. A few years later, the Motilal Nehru Report emphatically stated that in free India, ‘Men and women shall have equal rights as citizens’, this at a time when in many western countries, women did not even have the right to vote.

The Congress has evidently regressed a great deal since those days. Those great heroes of Vaikom, TK Madhavan and KP Kesava Menon, would have been absolutely appalled by the argument of Congress MPs that because ‘popular sentiment’ is allegedly against the entry of women of a certain age into Sabarimala, thinking citizens should capitulate in the face of reaction. Back in the 1920s, perhaps well over 90% of upper-caste Hindus were against the entry of Dalits into the Siva shrine in Vaikom. That did not deter the reformers, who struggled on for their cause. Now, even though (as the Women’s Wall across Kerala on January 1 showed) popular opinion is more evenly divided, the Congress party chooses to take fright in the face of the mob, and side with the bigots. This, tragically, is but one sign of how far the Congress has fallen in recent times. The once brave party of the freedom struggle is now represented by self-seeking cowards.

[The historical sections of this essay draw on my recent book, Gandhi: The Years That Changed the World (Allen Lane). Two excellent monographic studies of the Vaikom Satyagraha are TK Ravindran, Eight Furlongs of Freedom (New Delhi: Light and Life Publishers, 1980), and Mary Elizabeth King, Gandhian Nonviolent Struggle and Untouchability in India: The 1924-25 Vykom Satyagraha and the Mechanisms of Change (New Delhi: Oxford University Press, 2015).]

(Source: TNM)