Showing posts with label Supreme Court. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Supreme Court. Show all posts

Sunday, 23 January 2022

Daughters to inherit fathers’ self acquired, inherited properties, to get preference over others: SC

 In a significant verdict, the Supreme Court on Thursday said the daughters of a male Hindu, dying intestate, would be entitled to inherit the self-acquired and other properties obtained in the partition by the father and get preference over other collateral members of the family.

In a significant verdict, the Supreme Court on Thursday said the daughters of a male Hindu, dying intestate, would be entitled to inherit the self-acquired and other properties obtained in the partition by the father and get preference over other collateral members of the family.


The judgement, which came on an appeal against the Madras High Court verdict, dealt with the property rights of Hindu women and widows under the Hindu Succession Act.


“If a property of a male Hindu dying intestate (without a will) is a self-acquired property or obtained in the partition of a coparcenary or a family property, the same would devolve by inheritance and not by survivorship, and a daughter of such a male Hindu would be entitled to inherit such property in preference to other collaterals (such as sons/daughters of brothers of deceased father),” a bench of justices S Abdul Nazeer and Krishna Murari said.


The bench was dealing with the legal issue concerning the right of the daughter to inherit the self-acquired property of her father, in the absence of any other legal heir.


Justice Murari, writing the 51-page judgment for the bench, also dealt with the question of whether such property will devolve on to the daughter upon the death of her father, who died without a will, by inheritance or shall devolve on to “father’s brother’s son by survivorship”.


“Right of a widow or daughter to inherit the self-acquired property or share received in the partition of a coparcenary property of a Hindu male dying intestate is well recognized not only under the old customary Hindu Law but also by various judicial pronouncements...,” the verdict said.


Referring to the legal provision, it said the legislative intent was to remedy the limitation of a Hindu woman who could not claim an absolute interest in the properties inherited by her but only had a life interest in the estate so inherited.


“Section 14 (I) converted all limited estates owned by women into absolute estates and the succession of these properties in the absence of a will or testament would take place in consonance with Section 15 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956...,” it said.


If a female Hindu dies intestate without leaving any issue, then the property inherited by her from her father or mother would go to the heirs of her father whereas the property inherited from her husband or father-in-law would go to the heirs of the husband, it said.


“The basic aim of the legislature in enacting Section 15(2) (of the Hindu Succession Act) is to ensure that inherited property of a female Hindu dying issueless and intestate, goes back to the source,” it said.


Dealing with the facts of the case, the bench set aside the trial court and the high court’s findings dismissing the partition suit of the daughters.


The apex court said, “...since the property in question was admittedly the self-acquired property of a father despite the family being in a state of jointness upon his death intestate, his sole surviving daughter will inherit the same by inheritance and the property shall not devolve by survivorship.


“Thus, the impugned judgement and decree dated March 01, 1994, passed by the Trial Court and confirmed by the High Court vide judgment and order dated January 21, 2009, are not liable to be sustained and are hereby set aside,” it said. 


(Source: Republic World)

Tuesday, 13 August 2019

‘My family descended from Lord Ram’s son Kush’: BJP MP Diya Kumari

BJP lawmaker Diya Kumari, a member of the erstwhile Jaipur royal family, claimed on Sunday, 11 August, that her family has descended from Lord Ram's son Kush, days after the Supreme Court sought to know whether anyone from the 'Raghuvansha' was still residing in Ayodhya.

She said descendants of Lord Ram are all over the world and the dispute in Ayodhya should be resolved soon.

"Court has said where are the descendants of Lord Ram... Descendants of Lord Ram are all over the world, including our family who descended from his son Kush," Kumari, the MP from Rajsamand in Rajasthan, said.

She said that her comments were based on manuscripts, genealogy and documents available with the royal family.

Curious to know whether anyone from the 'Raghuvansha' (descendants of Lord Ram) was still residing in Ayodhya, the Supreme Court on Friday had put this query to 'Ram Lalla Virajman', the deity and one of the parties in the politically sensitive Ram Janmabhoomi-Babri Masjid land dispute case.

A five-judge Constitution bench headed by Chief Justice Ranjan Gogoi had asked the question to senior advocate K Parasaran, appearing for 'Ram Lalla Virajman', when he was arguing that the deity and the birth place both were "juristic" entities and hence, capable of holding properties and instituting lawsuits.

“We are just wondering if anyone from the ‘Raghuvansha’ dynasty is still living there (at Ayodhya),” the bench had said.
fbtw
"I have no information. We will try to find it out," Parasaran had responded.

Kumari said, "Everyone has faith in Lord Ram. It is our request that hearing in the Ram temple case should be expedited and the court give its verdict soon."

She said that if needed she will present documents proving links of her family to Kush in the court, but will not interfere in the Ayodhya case by taking a lead.

The law suit filed by the deity in the case has also made the birth place of Lord Ram as co-petitioner and has sought claim over the entire 2.77 acre of disputed land at Ayodhya where the structure was razed on 6 December, 1992.

Fourteen appeals have been filed in the apex court against the 2010 Allahabad High Court judgment, delivered in four civil suits, that the 2.77-acre land in Ayodhya be partitioned equally among the three parties -- the Sunni Waqf Board, the Nirmohi Akhara and Ram Lalla.

On 6 December, 1992, the Babri Masjid, constructed at the disputed site in the 16th century by Shia Muslim Mir Baqi, was demolished.

The Supreme Court is currently holding day-to-day hearing in the case.

(Source: The Quint)

Tuesday, 16 July 2019

Hindu wife can’t inherit muslim husband’s property, rules SC

If a Hindu woman enters into a matrimonial with a Muslim man without converting to Islam beforehand, the marriage would neither be “regular” nor “valid”, under the existing laws.  While the wife in such a case will be entitled to dower (mehr), she cannot inherit her husband’s property, the Supreme Court (SC) has ruled.

Under the Muslim law, a marriage is a civil contract which can be broken at the will of the parties concerned. Under the Islamic laws, there are three types of nikaah (marriage) ─ valid, irregular and void. A marriage that follows all the prerequisites set under the law is a legal or sahih marriage. An irregular marriage, known as a fasid marriage, takes place when the two parties fail to fulfil the prerequisite norms to make it valid. If a Muslim marries for the fourth time, for instance, it would be a fasid marriage. Similarly, if there are no witnesses to the ceremony, the marriage would be held irregular under the Islamic law. A marriage that involves taking the consent of either party forcefully is considered void. Children born out of such wedlock have no right in their father’s property.

(Shutterstock)

While giving its verdict in a case recently, the top court also ruled that children born out of such wedlock are legitimate, and are eligible to inherit the property of their fathers.

"The marriage of a Muslim man with an idolater (Hindu) or fire worshipper (Zoroastrians) is neither valid nor void, but is merely an irregular marriage ... the legal effect of this is that though the wife is entitled to get dower (mehr), she is not entitled to inherit the properties of the husband, in case of consummation of the marriage. The child born out of that marriage is legitimate, as is in the case of a valid marriage, and is entitled to inherit the property of the father," the SC ruled.

Mehr is the gift a Muslim husband promises to pay his bride at the time of marriage. There are no fixed rules on the Mehr amount, and it is fixed between the two parties after consultation.

The SC ruled is based on the fact that an irregular marriage is not unlawful in itself.

"A void marriage is one which is unlawful in itself, the prohibition against such a marriage being perpetual and absolute. An invalid marriage is described as one which is not unlawful in itself, but unlawful for something else  ... (like the absence of witnesses, etc.)," the SC said.

(Source: Proptiger)

Tuesday, 11 December 2018

Has the Indian media no shame?

Media people stoutly oppose any accountability, even by an independent regulator. They say they will do self-regulation, writes Justice Markandey Katju, former Judge, Supreme Court of India, in indica news. Read on: 

I was in a Thanksgiving party in an American city recently, and some people there said they had heard in the Indian media of an Indian industrialist’s daughter forthcoming wedding on 12th December in Mumbai. The media had reported how fabulous and mind blowing the wedding will be. It will be preceded by 2 days of festivities in Udaipur on 8th and 9th December where 200 chartered fights are expected to arrive.

After hearing all this for some time, and when I could stand it no longer, I said ” Isnt it the height of vulgarity to celebrate a wedding in such an extravagant manner when crores of Indian children do not get enough to eat? ”

I then mentioned that according to Global Hunger Index 21 percent Indian children are ‘wasted’ i.e. their weight is too low relative to their height, which indicates acute malnutrition, and in fact 47 percent Indian children are malnourished. I also mentioned about the 300,000 farmers suicides in India, the massive unemployment, almost total lack of proper healthcare and good education for the masses, etc.

This retort apparently upset many of those present, who quickly moved to another room. I was reminded of the Sanskrit adage ‘ Na Bruyat Satyam Apriyam ‘  ( Don’t speak an unpleasant truth ). Unfortunately, habits die hard.

So I found it disgusting when a large section of the Indian media highlighted the spectacular weddings of Priyanka Chopra with Nick Jonas, and of Deepika Padukone with Ranveer Singh, as if these were important issues in India.

I also find it disgusting when the media highlights the lives of Taimur, the son of Kareena Kapoor and Saif Ali Khan, and Aradhya, the granddaughter of Amitabh Bachchan.

Many years back a leading English journal published on its front page an article about female breast enlargement surgery, and how affordable it has become now, costing only Rs 1.50 lacs. I immediately wrote to the editor of that journal lodging a strong protest. I said that most Indian women were bravely toiling from morning till night running the household, feeding their families, and sometimes doing outdoor work in addition to earn a little money. It was a cruel insult to them to talk of breast enlargement.

The Roman Emperors used to say ” If you cannot give the people bread, give them circuses “, and Queen Marie Antoinette said, “If the people do not have bread give them cake.” The Indian state and the Indian media seem to follow these dicta. They try to divert public attention from the real issues facing the people, which are socio-economic, to entertainment like cricket, lives of film stars, babas, astrology, petty politics etc.

One would not have any objection to the media showing some entertainment, if it is not overdone. But when 90% of the Indian media’s coverage is devoted to entertainment ( and I include Indian politics in that category ) and very little to social issues like healthcare, malnourishment, education etc there is surely something wrong with the Indian media.

Some time back a Lakme Fashion Week in Mumbai was covered by 512 accredited journalists. The models wore cotton dresses, while the farmers who grew that cotton were committing suicide an hour’s flight away in Vidarbha. No one told that story except one or two journalists locally.

At one time we had great journalists like Raja Ram Mohan Roy who in his journals Miratul Akhbar and Sambad Kaumudi wrote against sati, child marriage, purdah etc, Ganesh Shankar Vidyarthi who through his newspaper ‘Pratap’ fought against oppression and was killed by a mob while opposing communalism, and Nikhil Chakraborty who highlighted the Bengal famine of 1943. Even today we have great journalists like P. Sainath who revealed the story of farmers suicides in rural India. But these are exceptions, and most Indian journalists of today appear to be sold out. The TRP driven electronic media are the worst culprits.

In England the Leveson Committee report castigated the ‘sensationalism’ and ‘recklessness’ in the British media, and recommended an independent regulator. Perhaps the same is needed in India too. No freedom can be absolute, and neither can freedom of the press.

No doubt there is freedom in a democracy, but there is also accountability. Lawyers are in a free profession, but if they commit professional misconduct their license can be suspended/cancelled by the Bar Council, and a doctor’s license can be suspended/cancelled by the Medical Council for medical misconduct. As a judge in the High Court and Supreme Court I could function independently, but I could be impeached by Parliament for taking bribes. So, everyone in society is accountable.

But media people stoutly oppose any accountability, even by an independent regulator. They say they will do self-regulation.

In my opinion self-regulation is an oxymoron. If there is to be self-regulation, why should it be for the media alone? Why have laws against theft, rape or murder? Let everyone regulate himself.

I regret to say so, but in my opinion most media persons, are totally superficial people having little knowledge of history, science, economics, literature, philosophy etc. but pretending to be great ‘intellectuals’ who can discourse on everything under the sun.

And of course, about their ethics the less said the better.

Tuesday, 16 October 2018

Kerala Muslim women forum to move SC seeking right to pray in mosques

NISA will not just seek permission for women to offer prayers in the mosques, but also fight for appointing them as ‘imams’.

Drawing inspiration from the Supreme Court verdict permitting women of all age groups into the Sabarimala temple, a Kerala-based Muslim women’s right group is gearing up to approach the apex court, demanding the entry of women in all mosques across the country.

NISA, a progressive women’s forum, will soon move the top court. The group will not just seek permission for women to offer prayers in the mosques, but also fight for appointing them as ‘imams’ (clerics).

The outfit, which has been campaigning for gender equality within Islam, also wants to curb the practices of polygamy and ‘nikah-halala’, a community law that allows a Muslim woman to remarry her former husband only after marrying another person and consummating the wedding with him.

Muslim women offering prayers at a Idgah on the Kozhikode beach. File   | Photo Credit: THE HINDU
NISA president V.P. Zuhra said that there were no records stating that the Holy Quran and Prophet Muhammad had opposed women entering mosques and offering prayers.

‘Sabarimala verdict historic’
She also hailed the top court verdict lifting the ban on the menstruating women from offering worship at the Sabarimala Lord Ayyappa Temple as “historic”.

“Like men, women also have the constitutional rights to offer worship according to their belief. So, like in Sabarimala, we want the entry of women in all mosques, cutting across denominations and establish their right to worship,” the activist said.

Ms. Zuhra said discussions were on with legal experts and a petition in this regard would be filed at the Supreme Court soon.

She said at present, women are allowed to offer prayers at mosques under Jamaat-e-Islami and Mujahid denominations, while they are barred from mosques under the predominant Sunni faction.

Even in the mosques where women are allowed, there are separate entrances and enclosures for worship for men and women, the NISA chief said.

“Our demand is to end this gender discrimination and allow Muslim women to pray in all mosques, cutting across denominations,” said Ms. Zuhra, one of the earliest petitioners against triple talaq in the apex court.

She urged the orthodox section in the community to explain who had asked them to impose such restrictions on women which amount to violation of constitutional rights.

“There is no such gender discrimination to offer worship in Mecca, the holy city. The faithful, both men and women, together circle the Kaaba. Then why are the restrictions imposed on us in our mosques?” she said.

The rights campaigner said there were records showing that Prophet Muhammad himself had allowed his wife in the mosque.

“There are several women scholars in the Muslim community. But they are not allowed to be Imams and lead prayers in mosques. This practice also should be changed,” she said.

NISA had approached the apex court recently, demanding equal property rights for Muslim women.

On September 28, a five-judge Constitution bench, headed by then Chief Justice Dipak Misra, lifted the ban on the entry of women of menstrual age into the shrine.

(Source: The Hindu)

Saturday, 29 September 2018

Why Justice Indu Malhotra, only woman on bench, dissented on Sabarimala

In a four-one verdict, the Supreme Court ended a centuries-old ban on women aged 10 to 50 from entering Kerala's Sabarimala Temple.

Justice Indu Malhotra, the only woman in the five-judge bench of the Supreme Court that ruled today that women of all ages must be allowed in Kerala's renowned Sabarimala temple, gave a dissenting judgment, disagreeing with her peers.

"The practice of age restriction on women entry to Sabrimala temple can't be treated as an essential religious practice," said the court in a majority four-one judgment, ending a ban on the entry of women between 10 and 50 years.

Justice Indu Malhotra, however, said that issues which have deep religious connotation should not be tinkered with to maintain secular atmosphere in the country.

"It is not for court to interfere in religious practices even if it appears discriminatory. Notions of rationality cannot be brought into matters of religion," she said.

Justice Indu Malhotra on Friday said religious customs
were protected by the constitution. (File)
She was of the view that it is not for courts to determine which religious practices are to be struck down except in issues of social evil like 'Sati'.

"An equality doctrine cannot override the fundamental right to worship under Article 25. Notions of rationality cannot be brought into matters of religion," Justice Malhotra said.

She added that the issue in this case not limited to Sabarimala only. It will have far reaching implications for other places of worships, she said.

Reacting to the dissenting view, senior lawyer Indira Jaising said, "While I disagree with Justice Indu Malhotra, she has an opinion which must be read, I am sad though that a dissent in Shabrimalai came from a woman judge."

For centuries, women of menstrual age were restricted from entering the temple as its presiding deity, Lord Ayyappa, is considered to be a celibate. A number of petitions had challenged the restrictions on the entry of women.

The head priest of Sabarimala, Kandaru Rajeevaru, said: "We are disappointed but accept the Supreme Court verdict on women entry."

(Source: NDTV)

Friday, 28 September 2018

Devotion not subject to gender discrimination, Sabarimala temple open for all: Supreme Court

Today's verdict is the latest in a recent series of landmark Supreme Court decisions, including the decriminalisation of gay sex and adultery.

The Supreme Court on Friday removed a ban that prevented women between 10 and 50 years of age from entering Kerala's Sabarimala temple -- the latest in a recent series of landmark decisions, including the decriminalisation of gay sex and adultery.

The Sabarimala shrine, located northeast of Pathanamthitta in a tiger reserve, is dedicated to the Hindu deity Ayyappan. Devotees consider Ayyappan to be an eternal celibate.

Chief Justice Dipak Misra and Justice AM Khanwilkar, who delivered one of four judgments, said devotion can't be subject to gender discrimination.

Justices Rohinton F Nariman and Dhananjaya Y Chandrachud concurred with Misra and Khanwilkar. Justice Indu Malhotra dissented.

Chandrachud said religion can't be used as a cover to deny women the right to worship, and that to treat women as the children of a lesser God was to blink at constitutional morality.

The Sabarimala shrine, located northeast of Pathanamthitta in a tiger reserve, is dedicated to the Hindu deity Ayyappan. (Photo: Facebook/SabarimalaOfficial)
Union Women and Child Development Minister Maneka Gandhi said the "wonderful" judgment "opens up the way forward for Hinduism to become even more inclusive and not a property of one caste or one sex."

Kandararu Rajeevaru, the head priest at Sabarimala, said the verdict was "disappointing" -- -- but that the 'Tantri [head priest] family' would accept it.

The Congress, currently an Opposition party in Kerala, said it welcomed the verdict.
JUSTICE INDU MALHOTRA DISSENTS
Justice Indu Malhotra, the lone woman on the bench, said it wasn't for courts to determine which religious practices should be struck down -- except in issues of social evil, like Sati.

Issues which have a deep religious connotation, she said, shouldn't be tinkered with to maintain a secular atmosphere in the country.

HISTORIC DECISIONS
In recent weeks, the Supreme Court has delivered a series of historic judgments. It partially struck down one colonial-era law and scrapped another to decriminalise sex between consenting adults of the same sex and adultery.

In another verdict, it said Aadhaar -- a biometric database on more than 122 crore Indians -- was valid, but imposed curbs.

(Source: India Today)

Should Sabarimala temple open its doors to women? The arguments heard in court

The court is hearing a petition to allow all women between the ages of 10 and 50 to enter the premises of Sabarimala temple.

A five-judge Constitution Bench led by Chief Justice of India Dipak Misra is set to deliver its verdict on Friday on a batch of petitions challenging restrictions on the entry of women between the ages of 10 and 50 inside Kerala’s Sabarimala temple. Following an eight-day hearing in July, the Supreme Court initially reserved its verdict on August 1.

The top court is hearing a PIL filed by the non-profit body Indian Lawyers Association seeking the entry of all women and girls to the temple dedicated to Lord Ayyappan. The temple bars girls and women of menstruating age – 10 to 50 – from entering its premises.

While it first came up for hearing in August 2006, over the years it has seen a number of judges in various combinations taking up the matter. With 24 respondents in the case, the issue of allowing women entry to the temple is one of religious freedom, gender equality and female autonomy.

To decide the merits of the case, the Constitution Bench will consider five questions framed by the top court. This includes whether the restrictions on women based on biological factors is discriminatory and as a result violates Articles 14 (right to equality), 15 (prohibition of discrimination), 17 (untouchability), and cannot be protected by “morality” based on Articles 25 (freedom to practice and propagation of religion), 26 (Freedom to manage religious affairs).

It will also look into whether the practice of excluding women constitutes an “essential religious practice” under Article 25; whether the devotees of the Ayyappa temple form a separate religious denomination, thereby being allowed to preserve its own practices and rituals among other questions.

TNM summarises the main arguments put forth by some of the key parties in the case.


Indian Young Lawyers Association
Represented by advocate Ravi Prakash Gupta, the non-profit body argued that the bar on entry of women in Sabarimala temple is not the essence of their religious affairs, observing that it is “neither a ritual nor a ceremony associated with Hindu religion”.

He also argued that the Sabarimala temple cannot claim the character of an independent religious denomination, pointing to the fact that it is managed by the Travancore Devaswom Board, which receives public funds. As a result, the temple cannot practice gender-based discrimination, as it violates Articles 14 and 15 of the Constitution.

Referring to the Shiroor Mutt case, Ravi points out that attributes of a “religious denomination” are five-fold: 1) Having its own property, 2) District Identity, 3) Having its own set of followers, 4) Distinct set of practises and beliefs, and 5) Its own hierarchy of administration without external control and interference.

Ravi also told the court that the Sabarimala temple could not claim that the restrictions on women is a customary tradition as there are records of women entering the temple during the control of the Travancore King, tweeted LiveLaw. He also submitted that the ban on entry was based on practical considerations rather than on tradition, noting that earlier women were reluctant to visit Sabarimala due to the physical hardship of climbing the hill and other risk factors. Gupta added that the oath of 41-day celibacy taken by Ayyappa devotees did not constitute an essential practice of Hinduism.

Happy to Bleed
Appearing for Happy to Bleed, senior advocate Indira Jaising equated the ban on entry of women to Sabarimala temple with the practice of untouchability.  “Prohibition of women entry is a form of untouchability. The sole basis of restriction is menstruation of women. To keep away menstruating women is a form of untouchability. Menstruating women are seen as polluted,” she argued before the Constitution Bench.

She also submitted before the Bench that the Constitution guaranteed the freedom to practice religion (Article 25), noting, “There is nothing in health, morality or public order to prevent a woman from offering worship in a public temple”.

Concluding her arguments on day 8, Indira Jaising told the court that restraining women from entering Sabarimala on the grounds that the deity is celibate was equivalent to stereotyping women as seductresses. She also argued that the deity as a legal person had limited rights, and could not claim the protection of life and personal liberty under Article 21 and freedom of conscience under Article 25.

People for Dharma and Chetana
Two women’s groups, People for Dharma and Chetana, have moved the court demanding women not be allowed into Sabarimala temple. Representing them, J Sai Deepak, a Delhi-based advocate, argued that Ayyappa in Sabarimala is a celibate and his individual rights should be protected under Article 25 of the Constitution. He argued the rule is not discriminatory for it is neither based on misogyny nor menstrual impurity, rather Ayyappa’s celibacy here is a fundamental character of the temple.

Kerala Government
The Kerala Government’s stance, which has flip-flopped over the years, declared its support for women entering the temple. Representing the LDF Government, senior advocate Jaideep Gupta submitted that constitutional provisions have to be broadly interpreted. He argued that the State’s right to make laws under Article 25 (2) (b) applies to religious aspects and not just social aspects, reported Bar and Bench. He added that the Sabarimala temple could not be considered a separate religious denomination and therefore could not claim rights as per Article 26.

Furthermore, he argued that Rule 3(b) of the Kerala Hindu Places of Worship (Authorisation of Entry) Rules could be read down to no longer exclude women. Submitting that the Constitution is reformist, Jaideep Gupta told the apex court, “If we go back to holy antiquity every time then there won’t be reform.”

Travancore Devaswom Board
Advocate Abhishek Manu Singhvi appeared for the Travancore Devaswom Board, which manages the affairs of the Sabarimala Temple. Pointing to the historical origin of the ban, he argued that the entry of women of menstruating age was antithetical to the celibate nature of the deity, reports Live Law.

Abhishek Manu Singhvi centred his argument on observance of the 41-day penance, which he said, was essential for the pilgrimage to Sabarimala. Dismissing the idea that that the ban on entry of women is discriminatory, he said it was not physiologically feasible for women to observe the 41-day penance.

Further justifying that “every religion is based on male chauvinism”, the counsel for the Board stated, “Prohibition is not because of male chauvinism. It is linked to the penance and character of the deity. Women accept the prohibition. It is not imposed on them,” reports The Hindu.

When CJI Dipak Misra questioned whether the ban is an essential part of religion, Abhishek defended the restrictions observing that it is the crux of Sabarimala. He went on to submit, “If a person has a belief, it is not for a secular judge to sit in judgment of that belief", adding, “It is not for me or you to say the practice is irrational. That is a belief held by all Ayyappa Swamis”.

Head Priest of Temple
The main argument of advocate V Giri, who represented the Thantri of Sabarimala temple, revolved around the ‘Naishthik Brahmacharya’ or the celibate nature of the deity.

“I don’t go to a temple to question the faith but to assert my faith. If I say I believe in the deity, then my belief will be in sync and not antagonistic to what is held as an essential religious practice,” Giri told the court, reported G Ananthakrishnan. The counsel for the Thantri added that celibate character of the deity cannot be wished away by devotees.

Pandalam Royal Family
The Pandalam Royal family, which managed the affairs of the Sabarimala temple before the Travancore Devaswom Board was constituted, also challenged the petitioner’s claim to remove the ban on women’s entry to the temple. K Radhakrishnan, the counsel for the family, raised doubts over the petitioner’s intentions. Suggesting that removal of the ban on women’s entry attacks Hindu beliefs and practices and attempts to demolish the temple’s glory, Radhakrishnan argued that the petitioner does not represent the ardent faith of the Ayyappa devotees, reports Live Law.

Radhakrishnan also argued that girls and women of menstruating age abstained from undertaking a pilgrimage to Sabarimala in reverence for the celibate nature of the deity. He further submitted that constitutional morality cannot trump morality of society and of religious institution. Furthermore, the family’s counsel the rights of the State as per Article 25(2) does not apply to religious institutions.

Respondents like the Nair Service Society, Ayyappan Seva Sangham, People for Dharma, NGO Chetna among others have also batted for the ban on the entry of women, urging the court to respect tradition.

All eyes will now be on the Constitution Bench on whether it will order the 1500-year-old Sabarimala temple to open its doors to women.

(Source: TNM)

Thursday, 27 September 2018

Adultery no longer a criminal offence in India

India's top court has ruled adultery is no longer a crime, striking down a 158-year-old colonial-era law which it said treated women as male property.

Previously any man who had sex with a married woman, without the permission of her husband, had committed a crime.

A petitioner had challenged the law saying it was arbitrary and discriminated against men and women.
Under the law the woman could not be punished as an abettor -
the man was considered to be a seducer
It is not clear how many men have been prosecuted under the law - there is no data available.

This is the second colonial-era law struck down by India's Supreme Court this month - it also overturned a 157-year-old law which effectively criminalised gay sex in India.

While reading out the judgement on adultery, Chief Justice Dipak Misra said that while it could be grounds for civil issues like divorce, "it cannot be a criminal offence".

Who challenged the law?
Last August, Joseph Shine, a 41-year-old Indian businessman living in Italy, petitioned the Supreme Court to strike down the law. He argued that it discriminated against men by only holding them liable for extra-marital relationships, while treating women like objects.

"Married women are not a special case for the purpose of prosecution for adultery. They are not in any way situated differently than men," his petition said.

The law, Mr Shine said, also "indirectly discriminates against women by holding an erroneous presumption that women are the property of men".

In his 45-page petition, Mr Shine liberally quotes from American poet Ralph Waldo Emerson, women rights activist Mary Wollstonecraft and former UN Secretary General Kofi Annan on gender equality and the rights of women.

However, India's ruling BJP government had opposed the petition, insisting that adultery should remain a criminal offence.

"Diluting adultery laws will impact the sanctity of marriages. Making adultery legal will hurt marriage bonds," a government counsel told the court, adding that "Indian ethos gives paramount importance to the institution and sanctity of marriage".

What did the adultery law say?
The law dictated that the woman could not be punished as an abettor. Instead, the man was considered to be a seducer.

It also did not allow women to file a complaint against an adulterous husband.

A man accused of adultery could be sent to a prison for a maximum of five years, made to pay a fine, or both.

And although there is no information on actual convictions under the law, Kaleeswaram Raj, a lawyer for the petitioner, said the adultery law was "often misused" by husbands during matrimonial disputes such as divorce, or civil cases relating to wives receiving maintenance.

"Men would often file criminal complaints against suspected or imagined men who they would allege were having affairs with their wives. These charges could never be proved, but ended up smearing the reputations of their estranged or divorced partners," he told the BBC.

Previous pleas were dismissed by the court in the interests of "stability of marriages"
Interestingly, Indian folklore and epics are full of stories about extra-marital love. Most love poems in Sanskrit, according to scholar J Moussaief Masson, are "about illicit love".

But Manusmriti, an ancient Hindu text, says: "If men persist in seeking intimate contact with other men's wives, the king should brand them with punishments that inspire terror and banish them".

What did the judges say?
All five Supreme Court judges hearing the case said the law was archaic, arbitrary and unconstitutional.

"Husband is not the master of wife. Women should be treated with equality along with men," Chief Justice Misra said.

Judge Rohinton Nariman said that "ancient notions of man being perpetrator and woman being victim no longer hold good".

Justice DY Chandrachud said the law "perpetuates subordinate status of women, denies dignity, sexual autonomy, is based on gender stereotypes".

He said the law sought to "control sexuality of woman (and) hits the autonomy and dignity of woman".

Critics have called the law "staggeringly sexist", "'crudely anti-woman'", and "'violative of the right to equality'".

"The legal system should not regulate whom one sleeps with," wrote Rashmi Kalia, who teaches law.

The main concern, according to the respected journal Economic and Political Weekly, is "not whether the expectations of fidelity in a marriage are right or wrong, or whether adultery denotes sexual freedom."

"It is whether the state can and should monitor a relationship between adults that is too complex, sensitive and individual for it to be capable of doing in a just manner," the journal wrote in a recent editorial.

Where else is adultery a criminal offence?

The latest challenge was made in view of the "changed social conditions"
Adultery is considered illegal in 21 American states, including New York, although surveys show that while most Americans disapprove of adultery, they don't think of it as a crime.

"The criminal statutes remain in force for largely symbolic reasons, and there isn't enough enforcement risk for anyone to incur the political costs of repealing them," Deborah Rhode, a a professor of law at Stanford University and the author of Adultery: Infidelity and the Law told the BBC.

Adultery is prohibited in Sharia or Islamic Law, so it is a criminal offence in Islamic countries such as Iran, Saudi Arabia, Afghanistan Pakistan, Bangladesh and Somalia.

Taiwan punishes adultery by up to a year in prison and it is also deemed a crime in Indonesia. In fact, Indonesia is drafting laws that prohibit all consensual sex outside the institution of marriage.

In 2015, South Korea's Supreme Court struck down a similar law where a man could be sent to prison for two years or less for adultery. The court said the law violated self-determination and privacy.

More than 60 countries around the world had done away with laws that made adultery a crime, according to Indian lawyer Kaleeswaram Raj.

In the UK, adultery is not a criminal offence and like many other countries, one of the main reasons given for divorce.

Couples cannot use adultery as a ground for divorce if they lived together as a couple for six months after the infidelity was known about.

Have there been previous challenges to the law?
In 1954, the law was first challenged by a petitioner asking why women cannot be punished for the offence, and that such "exemption was discriminatory".

Critics have called the law "violative of right to equality"
The Supreme Court rejected the plea.

Since then, the top court has rejected similar pleas, including the constitutional validity of the law, at least twice - 1985 and 1988.

"The stability of marriage is not an ideal to be scorned," a judge said in 1985.

A married woman had approached the court, demanding the right to file a complaint of adultery against her husband's unmarried lover. The court, rather patronisingly, described the plea as a "crusade by a woman against a woman".

It said the law was about punishing the "outsider" who "breaks into the matrimonial home" and "violates its sanctity".

Two different panels on law reforms in 1971 and 2003 recommended that women should also be prosecuted for the offence.

"The society abhors marital infidelity. Therefore there is no good reason for not meting out similar treatment to the wife who has sexual intercourse with a married man," the 2003 panel, led by a judge, said.

In 2011, the top court, hearing another plea, said the law was facing criticism for "showing a strong gender bias, it makes the position of a married woman almost as a property of her husband".

What has the reaction been to the latest ruling?
Many Indians were not even aware the law existed. However, after Thursday's ruling, people have been largely supportive of the verdict.

Others said the top court should now move to make marital rape a criminal offence:
But a few felt that the law should have been made gender neutral instead of being struck down:

(Source: BBC) 

SC upholds Aadhaar validity but says no need to link to bank accounts, mobile phones

The court has placed strict restrictions on the scope of the project while striking down contentious provisions of the Aadhaar Act.

The Supreme Court on Wednesday declared the Aadhaar programme and the Aadhaar Act 2016 to be constitutional, but placed strict limitations on the scope of the project while striking down several contentious provisions of the legislation including clauses that allowed sharing of data for national security purposes and the usage of the biometric authentication system by private corporations.

In a three-judge majority order, the court also read down the five-year rule for archival storage of transaction logs and also struck down any storage of metadata with regard to Aadhaar authentication.

Of the five judge-bench that delivered the verdict, three justices delivered separate opinions. Justice A.K. Sikri delivered the majority opinion, with Chief Justice Dipak Misra and Justice A.M. Khanwilkar concurring with him.

In his majority opinion, Justice Sikri noted that Aadhaar cannot be made mandatory and linked to bank accounts, mobile phone connections and a number of education schemes. In particular, the judge called out the changes to the Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA), which laid the foundation for mandatory Aadhaar-bank linking, as “unconstitutional” and noted that it did not satisfy the test of proportionality.

However, Section 139AA of the Income Tax Act has been upheld, which means that Aadhaar-linking will be required while filing income-tax returns.

Justice D.Y. Chandrachud and Justice Ashok Bhushan have written separate opinions, with the former having partially dissented on a number of points.

In a three-judge mjajority verdict, the SC has upheld Aadhaar but placed several limitations. Credit: The Wire

Which sections of the Aadhaar Act have been struck or read down?
While Justice Sikri noted that the purpose of the Aadhaar Act was “legitimate” and that a “balancing test had been satisfied as Aadhaar only collected minimal data”, he noted that several parts of the legislation needed to be struck and read down. They are:

Section 57: The clause states that “nothing contained in this Act shall prevent the use of Aadhaar number for establishing the identity of an individual for any purpose, whether by the State or any body corporate or person…” (emphasis added).

This provision has allowed an ecosystem of private players to use the biometric authentication system to provide identity-based services and applications. This has now been struck down

Section 33 (ii): This part of the legislation allowed disclosure of identity information and Aadhaar authentication data if “made in the interest of national security” and if done in pursuance of a “direction of an officer not below the rank of Joint Secretary”.

This has now been struck down. Sikri stated that the “joint secretary mechanism is “arbitrary” and would require a judicial warrant.

Section 47: This contentious provision noted that “no court should take cognisance of any offence punishable under the Act save on a complaint made by the Authority (UIDAI)”.

This has now been struck down, with Sikri stating that even individuals should be entitled to file complaints if they have a grievance.

Section 2 (d): This part noted that an Aadhaar “authentication record” would include the “record of the time of authentication, identity of the requesting entity and the respones provided by the Authority”.

The majority opinion has said this will be read down to not include metadata of transactions, which presumably includes all of the above.

Dismisses exclusion and money bill concerns
Two of the issues raised by petitioners revolved around welfare exclusion concerns and that the legislative process surrounding the Aadhaar Act was flawed as it was introduced a money bill in Parliament.

The majority judgement appears to have dismissed these concerns. In his opinion and summary of the judgement, Justice Sikri noted that the Aadhaar Act could have been passed as a money bill.

When it came to people being denied entitlements and rations because of Aadhaar-based technology, Justice Sikri noted that while it was “concerning”, throwing out the whole Act on this basis would be “throwing out the baby with the bathwater”.

“Unconstitutional”, says Justice Chandrachud’s dissenting opinion
In his partially dissenting opinion, Justice DY Chandrachud  has disagreed on a number of crucial issues. In the parts that he read out in cart, the judge noted that  that Aadhaar could not have been a money bill and that passing it as such was a “subterfuge”.

While the Aadhaar Act is legitimate, he said, it did not have “enough robust safeguards as to informed consent and individual rights such as opt-out”. As The Wirehas reported, the petitioners had stated that if Aadhaar is to be held voluntary, it would require an opt-out option for people who had already had signed up but now wanted to remove themselves from the programme.

On the core issue of whether the unique identification projected violated the fundamental right to privacy, Justice Chandrachud has disagreed to a great extent from the majority opinion. In remarks in open court, he noted that the project is “completely violative of privacy”.

“Constitutional guarantees cannot be subjected to probability algorithms and technological vicissitudes,” he said.

In sharp contrast to Justice Sikri and the majority opinion, which held that profiling is not possible as a result of the Aadhaar initiative, Justice Chandrachud noted that the not only have the government’s claims on security “not been convincing enough”, but have also fallen short of standards required to protect privacy and data protection.

Justice Ashok Bhushan goes down the middle
In the parts of his opinion that were read out in court, Justice Bhushan largely walked a middle-line between Justice Chandrachud’s sharply dissenting opinion and the majority opinion pronounced by Justice Sikri.

The judge noted that “implementation problems and shortcomings” do not make Section 7 (which mandates Aadhaar for India’s welfare system) as unconstitutional. “No material record to say that exclusion has increased post-Aadhaar,” Justice Bhushan noted.

On the issue of whether the Aadhaar project violates the right to privacy and the legitimacy of the Aadhaar Act as a money bill, Justice Bhushan has also split down the middle. While he believes that there is no “violation of privacy” as it passes the “three-fold-test” laid out in the 9-bench decision on privacy, he added that the “certification as a money bill” can be reviewed by the court.

‘Little relief to the poor’
In her initial reactions on the Aadhaar judgement, IIT-Delhi professor Reetika Khera, who has extensively studied the impact of the UID programme on welfare schemes, notes that it will provide “little relief to the poor”.

“The Aadhaar verdict is disappointing, but I am not dejected or defeated by today’s verdict,” Khera said in a statement.

“Disappointed because apart from striking down Section 57 of the Aadhaar Act the majority opinion provides little relief to the poor from Aadhaar (under Section 7), in terms of accessing essential entitlements. On this, it is disappointing that the judges who have signed the majority opinion have believed the government’s false assurances that nobody will be denied their entitlements due to Aadhaar. We know that the governments have been blatantly violating the Supreme Court’s orders since 2013, and in its present form, exclusion is built into the Aadhaar ecosystem,” she added.

(Source: The Wire)

Friday, 7 September 2018

Indian supreme court decriminalises homosexuality

Cheers from campaigners as colonial-era law is struck down after decades of uncertainty

India’s supreme court has decriminalised homosexual sex in a landmark judgment for gay rights.

A five-judge bench of the country’s highest court ruled on Thursday that a 160-year old law banning sex “against the order of nature” amounted to discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation and was unconstitutional.

“Criminalising carnal intercourse under section 377 Indian penal code is irrational, indefensible and manifestly arbitrary,” said the chief justice, Dipak Misra, in his ruling, part of a series of judgments that quoted from Oscar Wilde (“The love that dare not speak its name”), Leonard Cohen (“From the ashes of the gay / democracy is coming”), William Shakespeare (“What’s in a name? That which we call a rose by any other name would smell as sweet”), and the German philosopher Johann Wolfgang von Goethe (“I am what I am, so take me as I am”).

“Social exclusion, identity seclusion and isolation from the social mainstream are still the stark realities faced by individuals today,” Misra said, “and it is only when each and every individual is liberated from the shackles of such bondage … that we can call ourselves a truly free society.”

“History owes an apology to members of the community for the delay in ensuring their rights,” stated another judge on the bench, Indu Malhotra.

The announcement of the decision drew loud cheers from a crowd gathered on a lawn outside the supreme court. India has one of the world’s largest populations of gay people.

“It’s in our favour,” Smriti, 19, who did not give her last name, shouted as she embraced three others before they were mobbed by television cameras. They had seen a text message from a journalist inside the court quoting the judges. “That's when we knew they had lifted it,” she said. “It’s a positive. There’s so much work to be done, but it’s a great first step. We’re not criminals in our own country.”

Indian activists celebrate after the hearing. Photograph: Divyakant Solanki/EPA
Ritu Dalmia, one of the five LGBT Indians who put their name to a legal petition that succeeded on Thursday, said the verdict made her feel hopeful.

“I was turning into a cynical human being with very little belief in the system, but honestly, this has really shown once again that we are a functional democracy where freedom of choice, speech and rights still exist,” she said.

“Today is a historic day,” said Anand Grover, one of the lawyers who led the case, on the lawn outside the supreme court in central Delhi. “The future is for everybody to be included, to realise their fundamental rights of equality, privacy, dignity, etcetera. That is what the court has stated and given directions that this be made available and known to everybody.”

The decision appears to mark the end of a fraught path to legalising homosexuality in modern India. Early cases filed in 1994 and 2001 bounced back and forth for years between higher courts reluctant to rule on the issue.

A flag is held by an activist outside the supreme court. Photograph: Sajjad Hussain/AFP/Getty Images
In 2009, the Delhi high court quashed the cornerstone of section 377 of the Indian penal code, finding that applying its ban on “carnal intercourse against the order of nature” to consenting adults breached the rights to life, liberty and equality enshrined in the country’s constitution.

That decision was overturned four years later by the supreme court, which argued that the 1861 law that came to be associated with homosexual sex had been used so infrequently – fewer than 200 times, according to the judgment – and against such a “minuscule fraction” of the population that it could not be said to violate Indians’ constitutional rights.

Activists were blindsided by the decision and thousands of Indians grappled with a fundamental part of their identity being suddenly restored as a criminal offence, punishable by life imprisonment.

“That was such a ridiculous judgment,” said Anjali Gopalan, whose organisation, the Naz Foundation (India) Trust, filed the case that was decided in 2009 and then overturned in 2013. “How do you re-criminalise homosexuality? What were they thinking?”

Critics of the law say that although prosecutions under section 377 are rare, it is frequently used to blackmail gay and lesbian Indians and contributes to their marginalisation, while also inhibiting efforts to fight diseases such as HIV/Aids.

One LGBT group, the Humsafar Trust, said its crisis response team in Mumbai had attended to 18 cases in the past two years of gay men who were being blackmailed by the police or by people threatening to report them to authorities.

It said it had received at least 52 reports of LGBT Indians experiencing harassment or discrimination in the workplace who were unable to report it because of the ban on homosexuality.

Lawyers working to overturn the supreme court’s decision had a breakthrough in 2017. “What changed everything was last year’s privacy judgment,” said Gautam Bhatia, a Delhi-based lawyer and legal scholar. “In August 2017, the supreme court held there was a fundamental right to privacy, and as part of that, five judges said the 2013 decision was wrong.

“It was unprecedented. The judges commented on a completely unconnected case to say it was wrong. But once they said it, with the imprimatur of a full bench behind it, section 377 was gone, implicitly if not formally.”

When the petition was heard by the supreme court over four days in July, supporters were encouraged when India’s Hindu nationalist government, which had previously expressed support for section 377, chose not to file a submission opposing the gay activists, leaving the decision to “the wisdom of the court”.

Swami Agnivesh, a Hindu cleric who supported the abolition of section 377, said the Vedas, the scriptures that undergird many Hindu beliefs, contained nothing that barred same-sex relationships.

“According to the Vedas, all human beings constitute one family, irrespective of what country they belong to or their skin colour,” he said outside the supreme court. “If two adults decide to have according to their sexual orientation, to have a relationship in private, why should anyone have an objection?”

The decision legalises behaviour that many Indians say was accepted in their culture before the imposition of conservative Victorian mores during the British imperial era. The anti-sodomy law was imposed in the Indian colony as part of a raft of laws against public vice and immorality instituted across the British empire.

“I’m elated,” said Harish Iyer, a veteran gay activist and writer. “We have thrown out the British once again.”

But he cast forward to future battles for India’s LGBT community, including marriage, surrogacy, and basic acceptance in more conservative regions of the vast country. “This is the end of the beginning,” Iyer said. “It’s the beginning of many more battles we have to fight.”


Acceptance of homosexuality has slowly increased in India over the three decades, particularly in urban centres, reflected in and encouraged by the growing number of openly gay characters on television and in film.

Activists said changing conservative attitudes to homosexuality was the next challenge, especially outside major cities. “

The supreme court urged the government to “take all measures” to ensure the abolition of the ban on gay sex be publicised in the media, and called for training for police and government officials to eliminate the stigma that persists in what is still a deeply conservative country.

Manaka Guruswamy, one of the lawyers who argued the case, said the judgment was a “big moment for constitutional democracy”.

“Whoever you are, if you are rural or urban, in a small city or big city, or if you are here in the supreme court, the court is very clear: you are not alone, they stand with you,” she said.

(Source: The Guardian)

Sunday, 24 June 2018

The entire justice system here is run by black women

When LaDawn "LBJ" Jones walked into a meeting at work a couple of months ago, she was hit with a serious case of "black girl magic."

Jones, the city solicitor in South Fulton, Georgia, was meeting for the first time with the city's municipal court staff. As she entered the room, she realized she was looking at something she'd never before seen in her legal career.

Everyone in the room looked like her.

These women hold the reins of power in the municipal criminal justice system of South Fulton, Georgia. Foreground, from left, LaDawn Jones, Lakesiya Cofield, Viveca Famber Powell, interim Police Chief Sheila Rogers. Background, from left, clerk Kerry Stephens, Chief Judge Tiffany Carter Sellers, clerk Ramona Howard, clerk Tiffany Kinslow
"I walked into a very small conference room, and I noticed that it was all black women," Jones told CNN. "I kind of got that feeling of 'this is nice -- this is exciting.'"

South Fulton, an Atlanta suburb and one of Georgia's newest cities, has the distinction of being perhaps the first city in the nation to have its criminal justice system led entirely by black women:

  • Chief Judge Tiffany Carter Sellers
  • interim Police Chief Sheila Rogers
  • solicitor LaDawn "LBJ" Jones
  • public defender Viveca Famber Powell
  • court administrator Lakesiya Cofield
  • chief court clerk Ramona Howard
  • court clerk Tiffany Kinslow
  • court clerk Kerry Stephens


Many will hail this group as a definitive sign of progress in the tortured relationship between the justice system and black America.

But does having a judicial system led entirely by black women automatically guarantee a greater degree of justice for residents of this city of 95,000 people?

Chief Judge Tiffany Carter Sellers
They didn't plan this
The women are quick to point out that this wasn't some kind of grand diversity experiment by South Fulton, Georgia's fifth-largest city, whose population is almost 90% black.

"This was not something that was pre-planned or prescribed," said Chief Judge Tiffany Carter Sellers. "It came together very organically."

The city of South Fulton was incorporated in May 2017, and work soon began on putting together a municipal court system. The first step was to get a judge, and Sellers was selected by a panel of Superior Court judges to serve as the city's first chief jurist.

Jones, the city solicitor, and Powell, the city's public defender, were hired by the city attorney. Interim police chief Rogers was selected by South Fulton Mayor William Edwards and the city council (5 of 7 of whom also are black women).

Then Sellers hired Cofield, the court administrator, and then they worked together to hire everyone else.

Solicitor LaDawn "LBJ" Jones
By January 2018, South Fulton's municipal court was up and running
.
The women are all the first hires in those positions in the young city's history.

They were hired not because they were black women, Sellers said, but because of their experience and expertise in law enforcement and the courts -- and also, in many cases, their ties to the community. Many of them grew up in South Fulton.

They are becoming a source of pride
But the women understand that they don't look like what most people are used to seeing in the criminal justice department, and they're actually a source of pride and inspiration for many.

Powell shared a story about a man with a traffic ticket who brought his young daughter to court -- so she could see the women running it.

Public Defender Viveca Famber Powell
"He had heard about us in some kind of way, and he wanted his daughter to see this combination of black women handling business," Powell said. "He had a ticket and I wondered why he had his little girl with him. Most of the time, people do not bring school-aged children to court. He told me ... this is why he brought her."

And it's not just South Fulton residents who have taken notice of this unusual group. City officials have been hearing from people nationwide after a photograph of all eight black women -- looking regal in a courtroom -- appeared in the Atlanta Voice, an African-American community newspaper, and caught fire on social media.

Rogers, the police chief, said she's glad that black women and girls across the country are being inspired by the group.

Court Administrator Lakesiya Cofield
"I've seen a lot of posts in social media, and it's quite moving and I got chills," she said. "If people can connect with what we look like, and then go beyond to understand what we do and find out they can do it too, it's very inspiring."

One person asked Jones, "Where is this place in South Fulton? I want to move there," she laughed.
That made Jones, a native of the community, excited because in some ways that's the point of all this -- to let people know about the stature of South Fulton.

"Where I grew up, black excellence is the norm. I grew up with everyone being entrepreneurs (and) all my teachers and principals or my elected officials looked like me," she said. "But I realized that the other people who do not know what this area of excellence looks like, they needed to see it, to believe it."

They understand what it's like to fear the criminal justice system
So is justice really any different in South Fulton compared to the rest of the country, where it's mostly meted out by white men?

Clerk of Court Ramona Howard
Yes, the women say. Being both black and female means they see things a little bit differently. Being black means they have empathy for many of the defendants who end up in police custody or appear in the courtroom, and they understand the fear that the criminal justice system will be biased against them because of the color of their skin.

They also say that as women they are natural nurturers, so they care deeply about the citizens they meet and want to help them succeed in life.

Court Clerk Tiffany Kinslow
"We are wives, we are mothers, we are daughters, we are sisters, and we bring those experiences with us," Sellers said.

Rogers, the interim police chief, says that being black and a woman doesn't change the way she enforces the law. But she believes her empathic point of view and nurturing tendencies do influence how she treats people, and that trickles down through her 91-person department.

Court Clerk Kerry Stephens
"The respect is there," she said. "That same respect is what I expect of the South Fulton police department in their dealings with people (and) giving them an opportunity for a better way to live."

They administer justice a little differently
In Sellers' courtroom, all those good intentions are put into action, as South Fulton does a few things differently than other cities.

  • Its municipal court has a pretrial diversion program called "Second Chance South Fulton," which looks at people's records to see if they can be diverted from the criminal justice system and instead given resources, such as counseling, to keep them out of further trouble. Sellers, who was a trial attorney for over a decade, said she's never seen a pretrial diversion program at the municipal court level as strong as the one in South Fulton.
  • Under state law, defendants don't need to have an attorney present when they first go before a judge. In South Fulton, however, every defendant is given a public defender for their first appearance. "The law doesn't require that you get a lawyer for that. I think that's kind of silly," Sellers said. "I think we can do it better, so we do."
  • The city places extra emphasis on educating citizens about the law. "I think that we should be educating people that if you are driving with a suspended tag, your license will be suspended for six months if you are found guilty," Sellers said. "People don't know that, but it's a reality that happens every day. I'm very big on making sure that people really understand the law, understand the consequences of bad decisions." She added, "I think it's part of the woman thing that we do, where we nurture people ... to seek a life-changing, life-altering result."
(Source: CNN)

Thursday, 17 May 2018

When ‘Japanese only’ rules were OK, and other odd Supreme Court cases

Yes, reading about the court’s orotund rulings can be a tough slog, even for us professionals. But if you spend enough time sifting through the gravel pits of grandiloquent legalese you find the occasional gem, writes Colin P.A. Jones, a professor at Doshisha Law School in Kyoto, on the JT. Read on: 

Did that headline grab you? I hope so. Because we really need to clickbait more of our online readers. How else are we supposed to get them to digest and discuss an article about Japanese Supreme Court cases?

Yes, reading about the court’s orotund rulings can be a tough slog, even for us professionals. But if you spend enough time sifting through the gravel pits of grandiloquent legalese you find the occasional gem. Today’s column will introduce some quirky things Japan’s top court has decided (including the case in the shameless teaser headline).

The case of the cat corpse and the night soil
First, my personal favorite: In 1992 the court had to decide whether putting a dead cat painted red in a fire chief’s desk drawer and dog feces in his coat pocket, “thereby hindering his ability to receive reports from his subordinate officials or perform the duty to decide various matters scheduled in the morning on that day,” constituted “force” for purposes of banging up the joker who did it for the crime of “forcible obstruction of business.” Of course, it did: conviction upheld. Nice that they made that clear, though.

Stretching the letter of the law
Reading criminal cases makes you numb to the reliability with which Japanese courts find a way to arrive at a conviction or uphold one on appeal. Occasionally, though, a judge takes a stand for justice, the presumption of innocence and clarity of law.

This involves some effort. Supreme Court judgments are researched and initially drafted by subordinate research judges staffed to the court. Judges who want to write their own dissenting or concurring opinions, however, are on their own. Some former top jurists even report having their proposed separate opinions disdainfully returned by researchers, full of red-lining.

This is why it seems bizarre to see, in a case from Nov. 20, 2008, Judge Mutsuo Tahara writing an extended dissent from a judgment affirming the conviction of a man for the obscene act of “stalking a female customer at a shopping building and taking photographs of her buttocks in trousers with his cellular phone.” Available in all its glory on the court’s English website, his dissent includes a phrase rarely seen in Supreme Court jurisprudence: “I will examine the act of ‘looking at’ another person’s ‘buttocks,’ which precedes the act of taking a photograph of the same.”

Accepting that it “is true that the act of ‘looking at another person’s buttocks’ can be judged to be ‘obscene’ if it means ‘looking at’ the buttocks while putting one’s face close to them,” Takahara goes on to explain why simply taking bum snaps from a respectable distance does not constitute “obscenity.”

To be fair, police overreach through strained interpretation of the law is a problem everywhere. But it’s still odd to see this particular case being chosen as the place to draw that line.

In a similar vein, in 1978 the court took a stand against City Hall. A municipal authority had sought to shut down a “soapland” quasi-brothel by approving the construction of a playground nearby, which would then make operation of the soapland illegal (because … the children!). The court found this to be a tortious abuse of government power and the aggrieved plaintiff to be entitled to damages.

Abuse of power was also at issue in a 2002 case in which the court actually invalidated a village mayoral election. The incumbent mayor had used the powers of the office to prevent the town hall from issuing to a challenger a family registry extract, one of the documents required to apply to stand for election. Running unopposed, the incumbent won until the courts decided a do-over was required.

When doubt is unreasonable
A 2007 criminal case is sometimes cited for guidance as to what the “beyond a reasonable doubt” evidentiary standard for criminal convictions means. A man going through a messy divorce “made an explosive by connecting a considerable quantity of (chemicals) … with a detonating device consisting of an ignition heater, battery, etc., and putting it into a file case, and then putting this case into a nonstandard-size postal envelope.” He then mailed this to his mother-in-law.

Where justice rules?: The Supreme Court of Japan's gray exterior belies some of the quirky cases that have been heard within its walls. | VIA WIKIMEDIA COMMONS, CC BY-SA 3.0
The murder attempt failed and the man was caught and convicted. The Supreme Court’s opinion shows the fine level of detail Japanese courts (usually lower ones) feel necessary to put in their judgments. A week before the parcel was delivered, the man had “by using the computer situated at his residence, accessed and browsed internet websites that provide information on the methods for producing explosive substances … and methods for making detonating devices” and “purchased acetone and other chemicals … in the quantity that seems to have been used to produce the explosive.” There is also a long description of the stamps used, the color printer on which the address label had been printed, the postbox into which the package was dropped and so on. It almost reads as a manual on how not to send a letter bomb.

The appeal was grounded in the conviction being based only on circumstantial evidence, there having been no confession. Conceding the accused had in fact purchased the chemicals, his lawyer argued it had been used for other things. Also, it was possible that he didn’t purchase at least 10 of the 24 stamps used. And so forth.

The court wasn’t having it, declaring that the “beyond a reasonable doubt” standard did not mean that judges could not convict in the face of the possible existence of abstract alternatives or contrary facts.

He was asking for it, guv
The courts are more forgiving of police when they stray from the righteous path. In a 1997 case, the police had executed a search warrant on a residence and found illegal drugs. When presented with evidence of his guilt, the occupant said “Sonna aho na” (“That’s ridiculous”), which earned him a sound beating.

Considering whether the drugs should be excluded as evidence, the court acknowledged that “although the illegal acts by the police officials were committed at the scene of search, the violence occurred after the article of evidence was discovered and it was induced by the accused’s remarks.” Conviction upheld; apparently the beating was his fault too.

Guilty no matter what
A classic is the 1948 case where the court first ruled on the constitutionality of the death penalty. In a judgment containing the memorable phrase “the life of a single person is heavier than the Earth,” the court nonetheless upheld the appellant’s death sentence. At the time, the U.S. Occupation authorities were preparing to hang Hideki Tojo and other former Japanese leaders for war crimes, so any other conclusion would probably have been inconvenient.

A 1996 case affirmed a conviction for violating a proscription on the capture (hokaku) of birds using a bow and arrow (yumiya). The offender had used a “Western-style bow” (crossbow or yōkyūjū). As a former Dungeons & Dragons aficionada, I was disappointed by the lack of discussion into whether a crossbow was the same as a Japanese longbow. Instead, the court focused on whether you could still be guilty of “capturing” a bird if your arrow (I know, “bolt”) missed. Of course you could: conviction affirmed.

The court has been more discriminating when it comes to swords. Japan not only has famously stringent gun control, but tight sword control also. How tight? In a 1996 case, the court considered an appeal over a conviction for having a “cutting tool … for use at a traditional ritual of cutting food.” The court didn’t care that it was just a big cooking knife rather than a sword: conviction upheld.

Not all swords are created equal
The real discrimination came in the headline case, a 1990 case under the same law, which contains an exception allowing possession of swords (tōkenrui) that have cultural or artistic value and are registered with the authorities. The implementing regulations, however, only recognize Japanese swords (Nihontō) as eligible for registration.

The case was brought by someone seeking to register a Western saber. In a surprisingly long judgment (seven pages including a dissenting opinion) the Supreme Court declined to expand the exception to grubby Western swords. It explained that, after Japan’s defeat in World War II, Occupation authorities had sought to disarm the Japanese people completely. But the Japanese government had been able to wheedle an exception based on the aesthetic worth of Japanese swords, which are made using unique techniques that entitle them to special treatment as cultural artifacts in a way other swords are not. Two of the five judges dissented because the law itself clearly applied to all swords and the more restrictive implementing regulations should thus be invalid.

Forcing a confession
Finally, there is the only interesting civil case I have come across, a 2001 appellate judgment in a tort case brought by the developer of game software against a vendor of game-mod (modification) devices.

The software at issue was “a love simulation game in which the main character … becomes a student of a fictitious high school, selects his favorite schoolgirl from among the characters in the game and, with the aim of receiving a confession of love from this schoolgirl on the graduation day, steps up efforts through studying, incidents, events, etc., he experiences during three years, to develop his capabilities that deserve to receive a confession of love from his favorite schoolgirl. … The story is supposed to unfold based on the assumption that no schoolgirls appear until the values of the apparent parameters reach a certain level.”

The heinous game-mod devices ruined this wholesome game by making some schoolgirls appear prematurely and enabling players to skip straight to graduation and unfailingly reach “a level that is necessary to receive a confession of love from the player’s favorite schoolgirl.” Judgment for plaintiff upheld — without any creepy dissents. Who says there is no justice?