Showing posts with label adultery. Show all posts
Showing posts with label adultery. Show all posts

Saturday, 12 February 2022

An honest review of Shakun Batra’s ‘Gehraiyaan’

If ‘it’s complicated’ could have an entire movie to itself, we’d get Shakun Batra’s Gehraiyaan. It’s ‘Kapoor and Sons’ but about 40 layers deeper, and with numerous crisscrossing subplots that take you into the twisted lives of Alisha, Tia, Zain, and Karan. I am not complaining though and—as a viewer watching Deepika Padukone, Ananya Panday, Siddhant Chaturvedi, and Dhairya Karwa bring to life Batra’s layered writing—neither will you! 

All in all, Gehriaiyaan is a beautifully twisted, emotionally draining, and daringly dark take on human relationships. 


While there might be times you’ll want to rewind to catch up with the unfolding narrative, there’s a sense of mystery that will keep you hooked till the very end. 




The anchoring plotline

As shown in the several trailers up until now, Deepika’s ‘Alisha’ and Ananya’s ‘Tia’ are first cousins who grew up together. Several DVD footage-fuelled flashbacks of the two kids enjoying their summer home in Alibaug show us a fond childhood shared by the two. Yet, as the film begins, one can sense that the two central characters, now all grown up, have probably not met in years.


When they do reconnect, Tia is dating Zain (Siddhant Chaturvedi) and they have been together for nearly three years. Karan (Dhairya Karwa) and Alisha, although not as well-off as the other two, are not in a good space in their six-year-long relationship. As the story unfolds, one cannot deny the inevitable chemistry between Alisha and Zain. Herein begins the drama. 


What starts off as an escape from a loveless relationship soon turns into a twisted tale of family ties, sex-fuelled manipulation and even a jumpscare.


In the end, Gehraiyaan deals with several topics—from the fragility of human relationships to understanding the psychology of pathological liars, from mental health disorders to a sense of coming of age. There’s no denying you really need to rewind to catch up at some points.


The direction, cinematography, and screenplay

Batra’s screenplay—co-written by Ayesha Savitre, Sumit Roy, and Yash Sahai—is an ode to ageing Millennials and that quiet anxiety we’re all subconsciously dealing with. When Alisha said, “I feel stuck,” there’s no way in hell you did not feel that. This film is an embodiment of that clusterfuck feeling, with three characters bringing their own trauma to the table. 


A big part of Gehraiyaan’s effect is the subtle direction. Like the light hanging off the head when Alisha realizes she’s screamed at her dad a little too harshly or Tia’s confusion when she’s about to confront Zain—there’s realness in those moments. Kaushal Shah’s observant camera captures the undertones in their situations.


The dialogues are all superbly naturalistic as if you’re in the room with the actors. All points to the team for really thinking the small moments through—the characters react much as their situations demand and, for that, I am especially grateful!


The background score, composed by Kabeer Kapthalia and Savera Mehta, is rich and hauntingly melodious. By the end of it, you’ll not be able to imagine the film without it. They have a special power of making you feel things, I am not kidding! 


The performances

Deepika is a league of her own. Her performance is spectacular, to say the least. She carries the weight of the film and delivers a performance that cannot be easily matched. What do I even say about Ananya? I think our entire nation owes her an apology for dismissing her so quickly because, goddamn, can she act!


Dhairya's role is minimal but he plays the uninterested boyfriend role to its full capacity. Rajat Kapoor and Naseeruddin Shah too have their fair share of screen time and are always a pleasure to watch. 


It’s Siddhant Chaturvedi who is ambitious in his role as Zain. He is meant to play the suave rags-to-riches tycoon who feels no remorse for his manipulative ways, yet there are points in the film I wished someone more charming was playing the part. I missed Fawad Khan and the resilient energy he brought to our screens. 


In the end, does it even matter?

Batra really tries to outdo his last masterpiece. However, there are too many subplots and themes in the movie—perhaps trying to embody how human lives are inherently complicated. However, it would’ve been even better had the film been stretched into a three or four-part series, taking sufficient time to flesh out the details. Like the family structure that forms the core of all the dilemmas, more context for Alisha and Karan’s relationship, etc. 


At the end of it, it’s Deepika who is running the show with her hyper-real acting skills and her sidekick, the exceptional music! 


(Source: iDiva)

Thursday, 25 July 2019

Sahib Bibi Aur Ghulam took on adultery way before Supreme Court did

Abrar Alvi’s 1962 film Sahib Bibi Aur Ghulam made way for a fearless and gutsy Meena Kumari.

After 158 years, adultery is not a crime in India anymore. ‘Husband is not the master of wife’ the Supreme Court said while dumping the colonial-era law. Bollywood director Abrar Alvi dared to question this feudal notion of marriage over five decades ago in his black and white classic Sahib Bibi Aur Ghulam.

Based on Bimal Mitra’s Bengali novel Shaheb Bibi Golam, Alvi’s ‘much ahead of its time’ film is about ruins – a system, a haveli and a marriage. Every question that the film’s main protagonist, Meena Kumari, asks is a dart thrown at the institution of marriage, family, patriarchy and the zamindari system.

The film begins with the shot of a haveli in ruins. Wandering through the ruins in Calcutta, a middle-aged architect Bhootnath (played by Guru Dutt), recalls he had been here many years ago looking for work.

The haveli belongs to the Choudharys, a family of Bengali zamindars, where a younger Bhootnath began to observe the degenerating lifestyle of the elder and the younger zamindar. One evening, he gets to meet Chhoti Bahu (Meena Kumari), wife of the younger philandering zamindar Chhote Babu (Rehman) – the most stunning scene in the film (appearing at the 50th minute in complete disregard to commercial considerations).

His first glimpse is of her bejewelled feet. Beautifully lensed by the great V.K. Murthy, the scene opens with a PoV shot of Bhootnath who walks into the room looking at the chequered black and white floor. As he answers her questions, he looks up to see her face. From that majestic close-up of Kumari’s eyes, she holds the audience in what is remembered as one of the greatest performances ever put on Indian screens.

She lets him in on a secret, an intimate reality in her marriage, as well as the lives of the women in the haveli. “The days are for sleeping, but the nights here are for staying awake and keeping others’ awake.”

Hinting at the humiliating sadness that she carries within her – something she says men and most women will not understand — Chhoti Bahu asks him to bring her Mohini Sindoor (vermillion). She hopes it will bring her luck and strengthen her hold on her marriage and her husband.

In the song, Naa jao saiyaan, she boldly demands sexual fulfilment from her husband – an audacious demand for not only the women in the haveli, but also for Bollywood heroines of the time. Sexual expressions were reserved only for the vamp in the cinema until then. After all, we are told that the women in the haveli have only one activity to busy themselves with – buying jewellery.

In the middle of all this loss and longing, Bhootnath and Chhoti Bahu discover a form of an unconventional friendship. He is able to provide her with the kind of emotional intimacy which she seeks from her husband but doesn’t find. The film doesn’t name this relationship. But in the feudal haveli, even a platonic relationship is frowned upon.


The Chhoti Bahu tries everything – from the special sindoor to alcohol – to draw her husband’s wavering attention and to prevent him from going out every night. But the strength of her tragic character is only matched by the decadence of her husband, a symbol of the feudal society under the colonial rule. Into this unravelling world walks in Bhootnath, an educated middle-class youth.

Their unusual friendship comes to an abrupt end when they leave at dawn in a horse cart to visit a sadhu in the city. In her drunken drawl, she says to him nobody understands her the way he does. But the patriarch of the family sends his goons to attack them.

For a long time, it was speculated that the 1962 film was actually made by Dutt. The fact that it did have many of the legendary filmmaker’s stylistic flourishes have only kept the speculation alive. However, Dutt only produced this marvel, five years and two classics after Pyaasa.

In the end, Bhootnath finds the ‘ruins’ of Chhoti Bahu in more ways than one, rounding up the film’s circular tale.

Each actor in the film brought alive the turn-of-the-century clash between a feudal, patriarchal society and a new meritocratic order alive on screen. A star in her own right by then, Waheeda Rehman even took a secondary character just to be part of the film.

The timeless score by composer Hemant Kumar and lyrics by Shakeel Badayuni (both not the first choice) gave Alvi the sweep to create his edifice. The three Geeta Dutt songs – Na jao saiyaan, Koi door se awaaz, Piya aiso jiya me – remain as memorable as ever.


The character of Chhoti Bahu was seen as a gamble for Meena Kumari given that the traditional representation of an Indian woman up until that point was of a virginal woman. A woman who could drink herself to self-destruction? That was a complete no-no.

The subtle dismantling of that legacy by Alvi, who allowed his character in Sahib Bibi Aur Ghulam the space to breathe even in a bad marriage, remains the film’s greatest contribution to Hindi films.

(Source: The Print)

Thursday, 27 September 2018

Adultery no longer a criminal offence in India

India's top court has ruled adultery is no longer a crime, striking down a 158-year-old colonial-era law which it said treated women as male property.

Previously any man who had sex with a married woman, without the permission of her husband, had committed a crime.

A petitioner had challenged the law saying it was arbitrary and discriminated against men and women.
Under the law the woman could not be punished as an abettor -
the man was considered to be a seducer
It is not clear how many men have been prosecuted under the law - there is no data available.

This is the second colonial-era law struck down by India's Supreme Court this month - it also overturned a 157-year-old law which effectively criminalised gay sex in India.

While reading out the judgement on adultery, Chief Justice Dipak Misra said that while it could be grounds for civil issues like divorce, "it cannot be a criminal offence".

Who challenged the law?
Last August, Joseph Shine, a 41-year-old Indian businessman living in Italy, petitioned the Supreme Court to strike down the law. He argued that it discriminated against men by only holding them liable for extra-marital relationships, while treating women like objects.

"Married women are not a special case for the purpose of prosecution for adultery. They are not in any way situated differently than men," his petition said.

The law, Mr Shine said, also "indirectly discriminates against women by holding an erroneous presumption that women are the property of men".

In his 45-page petition, Mr Shine liberally quotes from American poet Ralph Waldo Emerson, women rights activist Mary Wollstonecraft and former UN Secretary General Kofi Annan on gender equality and the rights of women.

However, India's ruling BJP government had opposed the petition, insisting that adultery should remain a criminal offence.

"Diluting adultery laws will impact the sanctity of marriages. Making adultery legal will hurt marriage bonds," a government counsel told the court, adding that "Indian ethos gives paramount importance to the institution and sanctity of marriage".

What did the adultery law say?
The law dictated that the woman could not be punished as an abettor. Instead, the man was considered to be a seducer.

It also did not allow women to file a complaint against an adulterous husband.

A man accused of adultery could be sent to a prison for a maximum of five years, made to pay a fine, or both.

And although there is no information on actual convictions under the law, Kaleeswaram Raj, a lawyer for the petitioner, said the adultery law was "often misused" by husbands during matrimonial disputes such as divorce, or civil cases relating to wives receiving maintenance.

"Men would often file criminal complaints against suspected or imagined men who they would allege were having affairs with their wives. These charges could never be proved, but ended up smearing the reputations of their estranged or divorced partners," he told the BBC.

Previous pleas were dismissed by the court in the interests of "stability of marriages"
Interestingly, Indian folklore and epics are full of stories about extra-marital love. Most love poems in Sanskrit, according to scholar J Moussaief Masson, are "about illicit love".

But Manusmriti, an ancient Hindu text, says: "If men persist in seeking intimate contact with other men's wives, the king should brand them with punishments that inspire terror and banish them".

What did the judges say?
All five Supreme Court judges hearing the case said the law was archaic, arbitrary and unconstitutional.

"Husband is not the master of wife. Women should be treated with equality along with men," Chief Justice Misra said.

Judge Rohinton Nariman said that "ancient notions of man being perpetrator and woman being victim no longer hold good".

Justice DY Chandrachud said the law "perpetuates subordinate status of women, denies dignity, sexual autonomy, is based on gender stereotypes".

He said the law sought to "control sexuality of woman (and) hits the autonomy and dignity of woman".

Critics have called the law "staggeringly sexist", "'crudely anti-woman'", and "'violative of the right to equality'".

"The legal system should not regulate whom one sleeps with," wrote Rashmi Kalia, who teaches law.

The main concern, according to the respected journal Economic and Political Weekly, is "not whether the expectations of fidelity in a marriage are right or wrong, or whether adultery denotes sexual freedom."

"It is whether the state can and should monitor a relationship between adults that is too complex, sensitive and individual for it to be capable of doing in a just manner," the journal wrote in a recent editorial.

Where else is adultery a criminal offence?

The latest challenge was made in view of the "changed social conditions"
Adultery is considered illegal in 21 American states, including New York, although surveys show that while most Americans disapprove of adultery, they don't think of it as a crime.

"The criminal statutes remain in force for largely symbolic reasons, and there isn't enough enforcement risk for anyone to incur the political costs of repealing them," Deborah Rhode, a a professor of law at Stanford University and the author of Adultery: Infidelity and the Law told the BBC.

Adultery is prohibited in Sharia or Islamic Law, so it is a criminal offence in Islamic countries such as Iran, Saudi Arabia, Afghanistan Pakistan, Bangladesh and Somalia.

Taiwan punishes adultery by up to a year in prison and it is also deemed a crime in Indonesia. In fact, Indonesia is drafting laws that prohibit all consensual sex outside the institution of marriage.

In 2015, South Korea's Supreme Court struck down a similar law where a man could be sent to prison for two years or less for adultery. The court said the law violated self-determination and privacy.

More than 60 countries around the world had done away with laws that made adultery a crime, according to Indian lawyer Kaleeswaram Raj.

In the UK, adultery is not a criminal offence and like many other countries, one of the main reasons given for divorce.

Couples cannot use adultery as a ground for divorce if they lived together as a couple for six months after the infidelity was known about.

Have there been previous challenges to the law?
In 1954, the law was first challenged by a petitioner asking why women cannot be punished for the offence, and that such "exemption was discriminatory".

Critics have called the law "violative of right to equality"
The Supreme Court rejected the plea.

Since then, the top court has rejected similar pleas, including the constitutional validity of the law, at least twice - 1985 and 1988.

"The stability of marriage is not an ideal to be scorned," a judge said in 1985.

A married woman had approached the court, demanding the right to file a complaint of adultery against her husband's unmarried lover. The court, rather patronisingly, described the plea as a "crusade by a woman against a woman".

It said the law was about punishing the "outsider" who "breaks into the matrimonial home" and "violates its sanctity".

Two different panels on law reforms in 1971 and 2003 recommended that women should also be prosecuted for the offence.

"The society abhors marital infidelity. Therefore there is no good reason for not meting out similar treatment to the wife who has sexual intercourse with a married man," the 2003 panel, led by a judge, said.

In 2011, the top court, hearing another plea, said the law was facing criticism for "showing a strong gender bias, it makes the position of a married woman almost as a property of her husband".

What has the reaction been to the latest ruling?
Many Indians were not even aware the law existed. However, after Thursday's ruling, people have been largely supportive of the verdict.

Others said the top court should now move to make marital rape a criminal offence:
But a few felt that the law should have been made gender neutral instead of being struck down:

(Source: BBC) 

Monday, 11 December 2017

Why is only the man liable for adultery, asks Indian Supreme Court

The court said that Section 497 of the Indian Penal Code goes against gender neutrality and treats women like chattel.

The Supreme Court on Friday issued a notice to the Centre challenging the validity of Section 497 of the Indian Penal Code, which says that only a man is liable for adultery, Bar and Bench reported. The court has sought a reply from the Centre in four weeks.

A bench headed by Chief Justice of India Dipak Misra and Justices AM Khanwilkar and DY Chandrachud issued the notice after hearing a petition that questioned the section’s constitutionality. It asked why a married woman, who is equally liable for committing adultery with another married man, is not punished along with the man.

According to the section in the IPC, a man can be punished with up to five years in jail or a penalty or both if he has sexual intercourse with the wife of another person. However, the wife shall not be punishable as an abettor of the crime.


Observing that the section relieves the woman of any liability, the bench said, “Though the act is hypothetically capable of being committed by both the man and the woman, only one is liable for criminal offence.”

The court also said that the provision goes against gender neutrality and treats women like chattel. “It is perceivable from the language of the provision, the fulcrum of offence is destroyed once the consent of husband is obtained,” the court said. “Viewed from that scenario, the provision creates a dent on the independent identity of women.”

The Supreme Court had in 2011 said that the adultery law is biased against men. The provision reduces a married woman to a property of the husband, it had said. It also said that punishment is meted out to only the man, though the woman with whom he had consensual sex was an equal partner in the alleged crime.

(Source: Scroll)