Showing posts with label Bhagavad Gita. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Bhagavad Gita. Show all posts

Sunday, 6 February 2022

How a pioneering Greek scholar was robbed of the credit for translating Chanakya’s words in Sanskrit

Dimitrios Galanos, who was born in Athens in 1760, spent almost five decades in India and became the first Greek Indologist in the modern era. Galanos’s greatest lexicographical work was a Persian-Sanskrit-English-Greek dictionary. Sanskrit and Persian words were written in the Latin script and there was an accompanying English text with copious explanations. Although the dictionary was incomplete and missing some translated words, it was a pioneering attempt to help Greeks understand Sanskrit, writes Ajay Kamalakaran. Read on: 

In 1786, Dimitrios Galanos, a 26-year-old Greek teacher boarded a ship in Basra for Calcutta in search of a new life. A few months before, the young man who was formally educated in Ancient Greek, Latin, philosophy and music, had been galvanised by a chance encounter with a merchant in Constantinople. The merchant, one Madratzoglou, had extensive ties with the 200-strong Greek community that had settled in Bengal by the 1780s in places such as Narayanganj, Dhaka and Calcutta.


“Madratzoglou found him ideal for tutoring the children of the Greek merchants who had settled in Narayanganj (near Dhaka) and Calcutta and offered him a position as a teacher there,” wrote Dimitrios Vassiliadis, a noted Greek Indologist and Sanskrit and Hindi scholar, in 2020 for the Hellenic-Indian Society for Culture and Development. 


“Galanos, eager to expand his knowledge, gladly accepted Madratzoglou’s offer and prepared himself for his journey to the East; ‘…to carry the torch of the paternal education to the Greeks in India, and to send back from there to Hellas a few sparks of the ‘light of Asia’.’”


Spyridon Prosalentis/Wikimedia Commons [Public Domain]


After six months, Galanos reached India, a country where he would live for the next 47 years. Of this time, he spent a relatively brief six years as the teacher of the children and relatives of a wealthy merchant named Constantine Pandazy. But it was a time spent well.


The Greek scholar lived in a Bengal that was in the throes of the Hindu Revival Movement and came across Hindu reformers who were outward-looking and keen to interact with foreign scholars. This was also a period when European scholars developed a deep interest in Sanskrit and were moving to Calcutta because of the Royal Asiatic Society of Bengal. While working in Bengal, Galanos learned and mastered English, Hindustani, Persian and Sanskrit.


Some researchers studying Galanos’s life have suggested that he also got involved in business ventures and made a small fortune for himself. In a 1969 article for the Journal of the American Oriental Society, Siegfried Schulz, who taught languages at the Catholic University of America in Washington DC, wrote that Galanos left behind 75,000 to 80,000 gold francs when he passed away in 1833. “Having shrewdly invested his earnings (and possibly a generous gift from Pandazy as well), Dimitrios Galanos set out for Varanasi in 1793,” Schulz wrote.


Life in Varanasi

Not much is known about the life of Galanos in the Hindu holy city. So consumed was the scholar in translating texts from Sanskrit to Greek that he mostly kept aloof from other foreigners. He does, however, find a place in a book published in 1824-’25 titled Narrative of a Journey Through the Upper Provinces by Anglican Bishop Reginald Heber.


The British were initially suspicious about Galanos’s motives in living in Varanasi, according to Heber. But, after watching him for a long time, they came to the conclusion that there was nothing in his conduct to confirm their suspicions. “So few Europeans, however, who can help it, reside in India, that it seems strange that any man should prefer it as a residence, without some stronger motive than a fondness for Sanskrit literature, more particularly since he does not appear to meditate any work on the subject,” Heber wrote.


The Anglican bishop mentioned a special friendship that Galanos shared with a Russian trader who lived in Varanasi. “There is also a Russian here, who by a natural affinity lives much with the Greek,” Heber wrote. “He is, however, a trader, and has apparently moved in a much humbler rank of society than his friend.” The Russian, named Peter Federoff (Pyotr Fedorov), passed away in 1825 and was buried in Varanasi’s Chaukaghat cemetery. So close was their friendship that there was a Greek inscription from Galanos on Federoff’s tomb.


Besides his Russian friend, Galanos mainly chose to be in the company of learned Sanskrit scholars. “He has little intercourse with the English, but he is on very friendly terms with the principal Hindoo families,” Heber wrote. One of the Greek scholar’s closest Indian friends was a writer and an exceptionally learned man named Munshi Sital Singh, who helped Galanos with his Sanskrit. Sital Singh’s Persian work Silsilah-i-Jogiyan (Chain of Yogis) played an important role in the way the West understood Indian religious groups. It was under the Indian scholar’s guidance that Galanos embarked on a series of translations of Sanskrit texts to Greek.


Incredible legacy

In four decades in Varanasi, Galanos managed to translate 20 volumes of manuscripts. Unfortunately, none of his translated works were published in Greece when Galanos was alive, except The Aphorisms of Chanakya, which Greek captain Nikolaos Kephala, who carried the manuscript, published under his own name. Greek readers first came to know of Galanos after the plagiarised book was published since Kephala mentioned him in the acknowledgments as a most “erudite scholar of the Sanskrit dialect” who “assisted” him in translating the book.


The first volume of Galanos’s translations was posthumously published in Athens in 1845. It contained 330 verses from Bhartrhari’s Niti And Vairagya Satakas, 86 verses from Laughu Chanakya, and 98 verses from Panditaraja Jagannatha’s Bhaminivilasa.


The Greek scholar’s translation of the Bhagavad Gita was published in 1848. “It is the only occasion – in what is, apparently, his first completed translation – upon which Galanos names the Indian who helped him with the work: Kandaradasa,” Schulz wrote in his 1969 paper. “The note in the manuscript also records the exact date when he finished this study: November 12, 1802, in Kashi, the city of the Brahmans.”


Among his other notable translations were chapters from Devi Mahatmyam and Markandeya Purana.


Galanos’s greatest lexicographical work was a Persian-Sanskrit-English-Greek dictionary. Sanskrit and Persian words were written in the Latin script and there was an accompanying English text with copious explanations. Although the dictionary was incomplete and missing some translated words, it was a pioneering attempt to help Greeks understand Sanskrit.


Some Greek scholars are of the opinion that Galanos converted to Hinduism and was accepted as a Brahmin in Varanasi, but Greek Indologist Vassiliadis wrote that there is enough evidence to suggest that he retained his Christian faith. “Evidence that Galanos continued to retain his Christian faith throughout his life is found in his correspondence with Greek priests in Calcutta, and Greece,” Vassiliadis wrote. “Further, his last will starts out with the standard Christian formula, ‘In the Name of God. Amen’ and contains precise directions to be buried in a Christian cemetery.”


Galanos died at the age of 73 in Varanasi in May 1833. The city was in the midst of a cholera epidemic and the Greek scholar may have contracted the illness. He was buried in a churchyard in the city.


He willed a “moiety” of his fortune to his nephew Pandoleon Galanos, while leaving most of the rest to the Academy of Athens. In his will, Galanos wrote, “I hereby also give and bequeath to the principal Academy at Athens all my Sanskrit books, writings, translations and Memskey’s (Franciscus a Mesgnien Meninski) dictionary in all three volumes.” He also left some money for his teacher and servants and even set aside money to pay for his grave and tombstone in the churchyard.


It took almost four years for the manuscripts to reach Athens. “In Athens the manuscripts were bound into volumes with little attention to subject matter of sequence and incorporated into the library of the fledgling university,” Schulz wrote.


Munshi Sital Singh, who was the executor of Galanos’s will, composed a Persian quatrain as an epitaph for his Greek friend:

“Woe, a hundred times!
Demetrios Galanos has gone away from this world
To the eternal abodes.
Woe me! weeping and wailing have I said it.
I am out of myself.
Ah, he has gone away,
The Plato of this century!”


The Greek scholar’s long life in India was the first attempt to rekindle links that stretched back to the pre-Christian era. Concerted efforts have been made by academia in Greece and India to remember and celebrate the legacy of Galanos. In 2000, a Dimitrios Galanos Chair for Hellenic Studies was established at the Jawaharlal Nehru University in Delhi, while in 2016, the Athens Centre for Indian and Indo-Hellenic Studies was established to study India’s cultures, languages and traditions.


Ajay Kamalakaran is a writer and independent journalist, based in Mumbai. He is a Kalpalata Fellow for History & Heritage Writings for 2022.


(Source: Scroll)

Thursday, 12 October 2017

Hierarchy of rasa-s in Vyāsa’s Mahābhārata: Themes, forms and aesthetics

In the below article published on Indiafacts, Sreejit Datta writes about the aesthetic effects of the Mahābhārata with suitable examples drawn from the text. Read on: 

Is there a singular, supreme, overarching conclusion – superseding all others – which the composer(s)/compiler(s) of the ‘epic’ text of Mahābhārata (the one traditionally attributed to Vyāsa) had intended to deliver by composing/compiling it? In other words, does there exist a singular subtext of Vyāsa’s Mahābhārata? Is it ever possible to carry out a purely thematological analysis of this text in an attempt to answer the question above? How far can a familiarity with the myriad forms of storytelling and narrative techniques, imbibed with poetic excellence of the highest order, employed within this text help us find an answer to such a query?

In this context, it is also important to keep in mind that Vyāsa’s Mahābhārata has been treated by many influential Western scholars (e.g. by the American Sanskrit scholar and translator of the Bhagavad Gītā, Franklin Edgerton) (Edgerton 1944, 3-4) as a compendium of many texts (such as the Bhagavad Gītā and the Aṇu–Gītā) and subtexts which, over long stretches of time, have each assumed an independent existence and textual life in their own right.

Is then a hierarchical pattern, ostensibly on account of aesthetic/psychological/didactic/metaphysical/theological value, among the various rasa-s apparent in such a reading of the text, especially when one is reading this text in line with the poetic considerations put forward by Bharata and his successors, such as Ānandavardhana? With these questions in mind I wish to enquire about the aesthetic effects of the Mahābhārata in this paper with selected, suitable examples drawn from the text, from the perspective of the aesthetic needs presented to us by our times.

In the award citation dedicated to the great Marathi writer Vishnu Sakharam Khandekar for his Marathi novel Yayati (which has received a second life in the form of an abridged English translation by Y P Kulkarni under the title Yayati: A Classic Tale of Lust), the Sahitya Akademi, India’s national academy of letters, offered – as a sort of justification for their choice of the awardee for the year 1960 – the following words of praise:

“Artistic maturity and a high seriousness of purpose make this work a significant contribution to Marathi Literature.” (Khandekar 1978)

I wish to draw the reader’s attention specifically to the second reason cited by the Sahitya Akademi for their choice of the awardee in that year: “a high seriousness of purpose”. How could the Akademi be so sure of the existence of a so-called purpose of this literary work, let alone the high seriousness that the Akademi took to be its hallmark? Whoever, if anybody at all, dictated such a purpose of Yayati the Marathi novel?

Perhaps, the answer to such musings could be found in the introduction to the novel, penned by Khandekar himself. This introduction serves, at the same time, as Khandekar’s defense for the choice of Yayati’s tale out of so many others from the vast body of Vyāsa’s Mahābhārata, based on his inclinations and curiosities towards it since his childhood days on one hand, as well as a space within the text created by the writer with an aim to set the ‘serious’ tone of the ensuing narrative on the other. The second of these two is where the question of purpose comes into play. In Khandekar’s own words:

“I do not know if I would have written this novel, if in the decade 1942-51 I had not been witness to the happenings in the world and in the country – the strange spectacle of physical advancement and moral degeneration going hand in hand. If I had written it before 1942 it would have been a very different story. I would then have confined myself to Sharmishtha’s love affair.” (Khandekar 1978)

Khandekar further adds:

“The common man of today is groping like Yayati in the twilight of a world in which the old spiritual values have been swept away and new spiritual ones have yet to be discovered. Blind pursuit of pleasure is tending to be his religion.

In the case of the mythological Yayati, the idea of pleasure was limited to that with a woman. Not so today. The whole world, made more beautiful and prosperous by science, machine and culture is spread before us. The various instruments of pleasure tempt us at every step, all the time. Every moment passions are being moved and roused. This is leading to a degeneration of social values and corruption of the human mind. The loss is society’s which I feel very keenly about.” (Khandekar 1978)

Toward the end of this introduction, Khandekar urges the potential reader to keep in mind the fact that the principal characters in the novel – Kacha, Devyani, Sharmishtha or Yayati – are representative of certain values, virtues and vices each rather than just being a few mortals controlled by the diktats of fate.

I have used Khandekar’s Yayati as a pretext to my discussion on Vyāsa’s Mahābhārata in order to foreground the question of an alleged “purpose” of a text, which has been raised time and again by numerous critics, including Ānandavardhana and Abhinavagupta (Daniel H. H. Ingalls 1990) within the Indic traditions; in addition to the obvious reason that Khandekar’s Marathi novel draws its Stoff from the same Rohstoff as Vyāsa’s text does. I shall try to investigate if the content, form and the aesthetic considerations that went into the making of Vyāsa’s text are, in any way, correlated to such an alleged “purpose” of the text. But for that, we have to first comment on the existence of any such claim of a definite ‘purpose’ of this text, as is definitely the case with Khandekar’s novel.

To reiterate (and rephrase) the opening line of this exercise: Is there, and can there be, any one end or purpose which the composer(s)/compiler(s) of the ‘epic’ text under consideration had in mind while composing/compiling it? [I am using the word epic within quotation marks because I would not categorise Vyāsa’s Mahābhārata as an epic. Epic is a literary form, originating and mostly prevalent in European literary traditions and drawing on the classics from Greek, Latin and the modern European languages’ literary traditions, which always has one or more central ‘heroic’ figures; concerns itself mainly with their adventures/exploits; whereas Vyasa’s Mahābhārata has been categorised in the Indian literary tradition and several schools of philosophical thought as a Kāvya (a poetic work), Itihāsa (history) and a Śāstra (a didactic work).]


Coming back to my question; even if the answer to it is found to be in the affirmative, it can hardly be said that an analysis of the text based purely on thematological considerations can be attempted to come to such a definite conclusion that claims: this is the one and only purpose of this text; and “nānyaḥ panthā vidyate ayanāya” – there is no other alternative. The very fact that Vyāsa’s Mahābhārata has been considered, within Indian traditions, as both Kāvya and Śāstra testifies that it was not (and cannot sufficiently be) ascribed one single purpose. Doing so would smell of an imposition of a teleological design, historicism (of the Judeo-Christian kind) and positivism often found in Abrahamic religious literature and emic (i.e. insider’s) scholarship on the same, which has been the case so very often ever since Indology as an academic discipline started producing considerable scholarly output in Europe since early 19th century and later in North America. (Vishwa Adluri 2014)

But, to approach this problem from the perspective of literature and poetics, we are forced to consider both theme and form, as I have already indicated earlier in this exercise that thematology alone may not suffice to pave a path for us in this literary critical-analytical forest. This is especially the case with a Sanskrit text like Vyāsa’s Mahābhārata which, apart from being a narrative of certain events, has been elevated to the stature of a didactic text intended to teach the essence of dharma or dharma–śāstra. This we must never forget in any of our discussions regarding Vyāsa’s or somebody else’s Mahābhārata text; it is not simply meant to be a Kāvya or for that matter, Mahākāvya intended for the rasika who seeks kāvyāsvāda – poetic pleasure, indeed it is a self-proclaimed itihāsa and a śāstra. So much so that in the Ādi Parva, or the first book of Vyāsa’s Mahābhārata, Sauti Ugraśravā, the first narrator in the text, informs us that in the olden days the gods had weighed this tome, only to find out that it weighed more (owing to its depth and variety of content) than the four Vedas including the Upanishads taken together. (Bhandarkar Oriental Research Institute 2017)

A didactic text is sure to employ aesthetic techniques, which are capable of producing the desired effects in its audience/reader – as has been the case for such texts across different nations, religions and philosophical schools of thought. Ācārya Ānandavardhana’s Dhvanyāloka, coupled with the Locana or commentary by Ācārya Abhinavagupta on it, has some important observations to make in this regard. It categorically declares,

“Again, in the Mahabharata, which has the form of didactic work although it contains poetic beauty, the great sage, who was its author, by his furnishing a conclusion that dismays our hearts by the miserable end of the Vrisnis and the Pandavas, shows that the primary aim of his work has been to produce a disenchantment with the world and that he has intended his primary subject to be liberation (moksha) from worldly life and the rasa of peace. This has been partly revealed indeed by others in their commenting on the work. The most compassionate of sage (Bhisma) himself asserts the same when he seeks, by imparting the light of his pure knowledge, to rescue the world from the cruel illusion in which it is plunged.” (Daniel H. H. Ingalls 1990)

From these remarks we realize that Ācārya Ānandavardhana (and perhaps the commentator Ācārya Abhinavagupta too) links the human goal or varga named mokṣa with the śānta rasa as far as the interrelation between literary purpose and aesthetic-metaphysical effects is concerned. Now we may ask the following question: what makes the Ācārya-s have such firm conviction about the “ultimate” (or at least, “principal”) aim of Maharṣi Vyāsa in the Mahābhārata? To this the revered Ācārya-s have to say that Vyāsa in the Mahābhārata had furnished “a conclusion that dismays our hearts by the miserable end of the Vṛṣṇis and the Pāṇdavas…” To corroborate this theory, the Ācārya-s quote Bhīṣma from the Anuśāsana Parva as saying:

“The more the world’s affairs go wrong for us and lose their substance, the more the disenchantment with them grow, there is no doubt. (Mahābhārata 12.168.4)” (Daniel H. H. Ingalls 1990)

Keeping all this in mind, I proceed to raise the question whether there are references in the text that might contradict or problematize the theory propounded by the Dhvanyāloka /Locana. For this, I will first look for any such references, within the text, to the alleged purpose that it is believed to fulfil by the end of it. I will then use the premise put forward by the Dhvanyāloka/Lochana viz. the purpose of a text and the aesthetic considerations in it are highly positively correlated, to demonstrate a kind of ‘democracy’ of the varied purposes and the rasa-s employed (apparently to achieve those purposes) in the Mahābhārata of Vyāsa, such that no single purpose and consequently no single rasa has been bestowed the ultimate/principal role in the text.

Let us go directly into the text and try to know what the text itself has to say on this subject.

As the narrative (or itihāsa – which is one the appellations applied to the text by itself) draws toward its conclusion, in the final book, the Svargārohaṇa Parva, the primary narrator Sauti Ugraśrava reappears in the scene to inform the dvija-s (or twice born-s – those whose upanayana saṁskāra has been accomplished) residing in the āśrama of Maharṣi Śaunaka and partaking in his 12-year-long yajña, who were the primary listeners to his narration, about the fruits one may reap from the act of reading/listening to this ‘kathā’. This section of the final Parva is known as the Mahābhārata–Māhātmya. These fruits, as recounted by Sauti, are listed as follows, although the list that I have prepared here is not an exhaustive one:

Victory comes to them who have the Mahābhārata in their house.
As the rising sun destroys darkness, the act of listening to the Mahābhārata likewise purges the body, speech and mind of all sins.
Those who desire the paradise attain it as a result of listening to this history.
Those who desire victory attain it as a result of listening to the Mahābhārata.
A pregnant woman, if she listens to the Mahābhārata, gives birth to either a son or a daughter of many fortunes.
One who listens with full concentration to the whole of the Mahābhārata, which is comparable to the Veda-s, is liberated from the shackles of billions of sinful acts such as the killing of a Brahmin.
Brahmins and Kṣatriya-s who seek liberation, mokṣa, should listen to this itihāsa which is also known as Jaya.
(S)he who reads out each and every Parva of the Mahābhārata to listeners is freed from sins and attains the Brahma.
During a Śrāddha, if a yajamān (on whose behalf the Brahmins perform the sacrifices according to the Vedic rituals) reads out the Mahābhārata even in part to Brahmins, then her/his late ancestors are provided with ever-replenishing havi – i.e. food and drink for the departed soul.

Such variation of the fruits that the text claims can be reaped from the act of reading/listening to it, points out a relative balance of importance attached to the four varga-s, i.e. goals of the human life – dharma, artha, kāma and mokṣa, as we can clearly see that there is a prevalence of all sorts of desires (ranging from childbirth to victory to the eternal rest of one’s ancestors) and their fulfilment in the list mentioned above. If we look at another, and arguably the most famous, part of the text – the Bhagavad Gītā, we shall find enough references to this harmony of varied purposes, sought by different persons who are characterised by various guṇa-s or qualities. Needless to say, such an approach rules out the possibility of treating the Bhagavad Gītā as an interpolation into the body of the Mahābhārata as Edgerton et al have frequently done. In the Bhagavad Gītā, Bhagavāna Krishna declares:

“Ye yathā maṃ prapadyante tāṃstahaiva bhajāmyaham

Mama vartmānuvartante manuṣyāḥ pārtha sarvaśaḥ”

(In whatever way men approach Me, even so do I reward them; My path do men tread in all ways, O Arjuna!) (Bhagavad Gītā 4:11)

Even though the ultimate goal of the human soul may be the attaining of mokṣa, the text makes the Bhagavāna himself utter such words which suggest that people having different set of goals or different desires may attain the same through the act of reading/listening to the text – even the very act of reading the text of the Bhagavad Gītā has been described by the text as an act of worshipping, a sacrifice in itself.

“Adhyeṣyate cha ya imāṃ dharmyāṃ saṃvādamāvayoḥ

Jñānyajñena tenā ’hamiṣṭaḥ syāmiti me matiḥ”

(He who studies this sacred conversation worships Me by his intelligence) (Bhagavad Gītā 18:70)

Coming toward the conclusion, I would like to make the observation that the rasa-s that the Bhagavad Gītā employs in its literary-aesthetic body-complex are varied as well – karuṇa, vībhatsa, vīra – and even the bhakti rasa – a later day addition to the prescriptions of Bharata, Ānandavardhana and Abhinavagupta. We must also remember that the śānta rasa itself is a later-day addition to Bharata’s system of eight rasa-s expounded in the Nāṭyaśāstra. It has often been described as the ni–rasa or no-rasa at all, that pervades and transcends all the others; as such it may be described as being a derivative of all the eight rasa-s of the Nāṭyaśāstra.

Even if it is granted, if only for the sake of argument, that Vyāsa intended to produce the ultimate aesthetic effects on the reader made manifest by the śānta rasa without naming or mentioning it, then it may be contested by saying that irrespective of whether the śānta rasa may, or may not, have been the “ultimate” aesthetic objective of Vyāsa, he evidently had to use every other rasa in his arsenal to employ it in the final analysis and consequently create the effects which it is supposed to have the potential for.

So in this regard, there seems to be room for accommodating doubts; such that one cannot possibly emphasize the conjecture of the śānta rasa being the principal rasa producing a purportedly ultimate and singular aesthetic effect on the reader of the Mahābhārata. Clearly, the critic still cannot assert that, again to borrow the words of the Upanishads, “nānyaḥ panthā vidyate ayanāya” – there is no other way – as far as the domain of literary-aesthetic criticism in Sanskrit traditions is concerned.

Thursday, 5 October 2017

All you need to know about Bhagavad Gita

The day on which the Bhagavad Gita was revealed is celebrated as the Gita Jayanti festival. Vishal Agarwal looks into some interesting aspects of Bhagavad Gita, on Indiafacts. Read on: 

Gita Jayanti or the anniversary of the day on which the Bhagavad Gita was revealed is celebrated as the Gita Jayanti festival. This day is the 11th day of the waxing moon of the Mārgashīrṣha month of the Hindu calendar, and falls in the months of November-December of the Gregorian calendar. On this day, Hindus worship Krishna, perform Pujas, sing the Gita ārati, chant the entire Gita, or even perform a Yajna while chanting each verse of the Gita collectively.

Let us now look into some interesting aspects of Bhagavad Gita.

1. What does the name ‘Bhagavad Gita’ mean?
The title of this beloved Hindu scripture literally means “The Divine Song” or the “The Song of the Lord”. This holy book of Hindus presents an eternally relevant dialogue between a human representative (Arjuna) and the Supreme Being (as Krishna). The Bhagavad Gita is often referred to simply as the ‘Gita’ in short. Many other Gitas exist in the Hindu scriptural tradition, but when the word ‘Gita’ is used, it denotes our Bhagavad Gita, because of its pre-eminence over all the other Gita named scriptures.

The Gita is not a one sided monologue. In the Gita, Arjuna expresses many doubts, asks many questions, and Krishna does not force him to accept the answers that he gives to Arjuna. He merely asks Arjuna to think about the answers, and then act as he wishes, if they make sense to him.

Arjuna does not ask these questions just out of curiosity, or with arrogance or just to humor Krishna. He asks them because he is faced with a very difficult situation in his life, and he wants to know how he can take the right decision. He asks these questions with a lot of humility, love and with a genuine desire to know the truth.

Krishna answers all the questions of Arjuna. He does not put down Arjuna anytime. He talks to Arjuna as a loving and an understanding friend. He gives Arjuna not just ‘one right answer’. Instead, He offers Arjuna many different possible solutions with their pros and cons, but also says what his own preference is. Eventually, Arjuna agrees to Krishna’s preferred solution and wins the war of Dharma against Adharma.

Because of message of the Gita is relevant for all humanity in all times, Krishna is considered the teacher par excellence, and is termed as ‘Jagadguru’ or ‘Teacher of the World.’

Everyone can draw some good teaching from the Gita, whether we are believers or atheists, whether we are Hindus or non-Hindus, intelligent or stupid, rich or poor, man or woman. Its teachings can help you whether you are happy or sad, in need or not in need, in a desert or in a rain forest, in a crowd or alone, whether you are praised by others or hated, and whether you love others or hate them.

The Gita teaches us how to transform from an average human being to an extra-ordinary human being, and then become Divine. The Gita tells about the true nature of this Universe. It teaches us something even more important – and that is, who WE are. It teaches us about our relationship to Bhagavān and to the Universe. How we should live our daily lives, the correct attitude, and what is really important and what is not important in life.

2. Importance of the Bhagavad Gita in Hinduism:
The Bhagavad Gita has been considered one of the most important scriptures of Hindus for over 2000 years. The scripture is almost universally regarded by Hindus as the epitome of all the spiritual teachings of the Vedas and the Upanishads and is read by millions of Hindus for inspiration and solace to this day. Many Hindus memorize all of its 700 verses, or at least selected chapters and verses to draw upon their teachings and to teach others. Many Hindus believe that if you study and understand the Gita, then there is not much need to read the hundreds of other scriptures that we have.

The importance of the Bhagavad Gita is indicated in the Hindu tradition by several popular verses, one of which says that whosoever seeks recourse to Gita, Ganga, Gāyatrī and Govinda – the 4 Gs, is freed of the cycle of birth and death. Another verse states that all the Upanishads are cows, and Lord Krishna is the milkman who has extracted their teaching in the form of the milk of Bhagavad Gita.

3. Gita as a part of the Mahābhārata
The Mahabharata is the longest poem in the world and has approximately 100,000 verses. The Bhagavad Gita is a part of this much larger scripture – the Mahabharata. It forms chapters 23-40 in the Bhishma Parvan, which is the 6th of the 18 books of the Mahabharata. The Gita has 700 verses in the standard version. In fact, the Gita is located right at the center of the 100,000 verses of the Mahabharata, and is literally the heart of the Mahabharata.


The Mahabharata is a giant epic that describes the events leading to the great civil war in the Indian subcontinent. There were two sets of royal cousins – the righteous five Pāṇdavas and the unrighteous hundred Kauravas. Yudhishthira, the eldest Pāṇdava prince, should have inherited the kingdom of Hastinapura, which is around 50 miles east of Delhi. But his blind Uncle Dhritarashtra (the father of Kauravas), with his eldest evil and arrogant son Duryodhana wanted to rule instead. To prevent a conflict, the kingdom was divided into two parts. The original capital and eastern half was given to Duryodhana to rule. The western barren half around Delhi was named Indraprastha and was given to the Pāṇdavas to rule.

By dint of their hard work and under the guidance of Krishna, the Pāṇdavas became very prosperous and powerful. The jealous Duryodhana could not tolerate the happiness of Pāṇdavas. Through trickery, Duryodhana banished the Pāṇdavas into 13 years of exile and usurped their half of the kingdom as well. But when the Pāṇdavas came back to reclaim their kingdom after 13 years as per the original agreement, Duryodhana told Krishna that “I will not give even as much land to the Pāṇdavas as can stay on the tip of a needle.” Earlier, Duryodhana had even tried to kill the Pāṇdavas through several foul means.

The Pāṇdavas, encouraged by their mother Kunti and by Krishna, decided to fight the unrighteous Kauravas, who were led by Duryodhana. As preparations for the war began, all the kings and princes of the Indian subcontinent started joining one or the other of the two parties – that of the Pāṇdavas and the Kauravas. Bhagavān Krishna sided with the Pāṇdavas at the request of Arjuna, but the entire army of Krishna was handed over to Duryodhana upon latter’s request.

Almost 4 million soldiers gathered at the battlefield of Kurukshetra which is north of Delhi. When the two armies faced each other and before the fighting began, Arjuna asked Krishna to take him to a spot between the two armies. He wanted to see whom he will be fighting. When he saw that his cousins, dear Uncles, teachers and even some friends were in the opposite camp, he was suddenly filled with a mixture of guilt, fear, compassion and doubt. He asked Krishna as to how he can fight his own loved ones even though they were unrighteous, and had tried to kill him and his brothers in the past. Arjuna said that it would be perhaps better to just give everything to Duryodhana and retire to a forest as an ascetic. Torn between the desire to fight for justice, and just become an ascetic, he asked Krishna as to what would be the correct thing to do. This is when Bhagavān Krishna revealed to him the beautiful scripture of Bhagavad Gita.

Did You Know?
The civil war of Mahābhārata killed millions of people in Bhārata. Almost 2000 years later, in the early 7th century CE, a Chinese traveler named Hieun Tsang visited India. The Hindus showed him the site of the war, and the traveler recorded in his diary that he could still see bones scattered over the plain.

In Kurukshetra, there is a banyan tree that is said to mark the spot where the Gita is revealed. It is said that Krishna and Arjuna stood next to the tree, which became immortal by hearing the Divine words. Due to this, it has survived even today. Close to the tree is a pond called ‘Jyotisar’ (the pond of light). Hindus go even today on a pilgrimage to Jyotisar and to the holy tree.

4. Why was the Bhagavad Gita revealed on a battlefield? Why Krishna advises Arjuna to fight and not make peace? Is it a War-Mongering Book?
There is a very practical reason why the Gita was revealed in a battlefield. It is very easy to preach and sermonize while we are sitting on a couch in a million dollar mansion. But real life is much more difficult. In fact, the most difficult and stressful situation that we can come across is in a war, where we are not sure whether we will survive or not, and when we have to fight against someone whom we have loved. The fact that Krishna’s teaching worked and enlightened Arjuna to take the right decision means that the Gita should work for us in our less stressful, and easier real life situations as well. What is the use of revealing a scripture in a comfortable situation, which has no relationship to the challenges that we can face in our day to day lives?

Krishna and Pāṇdavas did try to stop the war and asked for just 5 villages. But Duryodhana went back on his word. In fact, he tried to imprison Krishna! Duryodhana also tried to kill the Pāṇdavas many times through foul means. The message of the war of Mahabharata is that sometimes war is in fact a necessary evil. Just for the sake of peace, we should not stop fighting for our rights because the evil and unrighteous people will not let us live and prosper even if we try to ignore them. As an example, the world tried to ignore Hitler till he started threatening all the countries around Germany. And then, the world had no choice but to fight and defeat him.

The Gita is not a war-mongering book. In fact, Krishna tells Arjuna that he should not fight a war for selfish reasons. Instead, he should fight a war only so for a higher purpose, and for justice. When we fight wars and compete against others for selfish reasons, we also have to reap the fruit of the paapam involved in wars and competition. But when we fight and compete for a higher purpose in life in a detached manner, then it results in the purification of mind and Bhagavān grants us Moksha.


5. Arjuna as the Student of God
In many ways, Arjuna was an Average-Joe, like all of us. He had some bad habits, and some good habits. But he had a very good heart. Most people would not have the moral hesitation to fight a war or compete for their rights even if that means causing pain to others. But Arjuna was a very sensitive person. Krishna realized that Arjuna would be an ideal person to reveal the Gita. Thanks to Arjuna, and thanks to Veda Vyasa, who recorded it, we received the teachings of Bhagavad Gita from God.

Arjuna was an ideal student for many reasons:


  • Arjuna chose God above worldly power and riches: Before the war, Arjuna as well as Duryodhana went to Krishna to get Him on their side. Krishna announced that He will not lift any weapon and will not fight. But still, the two could choose between Him and his mighty army. Duryodhana immediately asked for the army of Krishna. But Arjuna said – “My Lord, it has been my desire that I should make you my charioteer. I do not need any army.” So, Arjuna chose Bhagavān to guide him as his charioteer and did not care for the mighty army. Most of us foolishly choose worldly attractions over Bhagavān. Life is all about choices. More often than not, we behave like Duryodhana and think that our success lies in choosing wealth, power and popularity even at the expense of compromising with honesty and justice. But those of us who are like Arjuna will always chose Dharma over all these worldly temptations. The war that Arjuna fought resulted in a victory for his side even though his army was much smaller than Duryodhana’s. In the battle of life too, the genuinely truthful, honest, loving, and compassionate achieve great success (in the next life if not now) than those who just care for power, money and fame.

  • Arjuna was as persistent and hard working. Once, all the Pāṇdava and Kauravas complained that their Guru favored Arjuna too much. Drona decided to test all of them. He sent Arjuna for an errand. As soon as he left, Drona started teaching the other princes how to take aim at the exact leaf and shoot it successfully with an arrow and bow. Then, all of them left that site even before Arjuna returned. When Arjuna returned to that spot, he found a lot of split leaves and immediately realized that he must have missed that important lesson. So in his free time, he started target practicing using the leaves as his target. In this way, Arjuna soon made up for the missed lesson. When the princes learned how Arjuna worked hard to make up for the missed lesson, they realized why their teacher used to treat Arjuna as his favorite student.

  • Arjuna was very attentive and focused: Once, Guru Drona asked all the Kauravas and Pāṇdavas to shoot the eye of a mock bird on a tree with a bow and arrow. He asked them as to what they could see while taking aim. Everyone said – “I can see the trees, you, the leaves and the bird.” But Arjuna said – “Guru-ji. I can see only the eye of the bird.” Not surprisingly, Arjuna turned out to be the best archer.

  • Not addicted to Eating or to Sleeping: Once while Bheema, the glutton brother, was eating, the lamp blew out and it became dark. Bheema was of course still able to eat. So Arjuna thought – “If Bheema can eat in the dark, should I not be able to aim and hit my target in the dark, if the target makes a sound?” He immediately stopped eating and started practicing archery skills in the dark. But this was a difficult skill to master. So Arjuna even cut on his sleep time to practice even more. In the course of time, Arjuna learned to shoot in the dark by following the sound of his target! In fact, one of Arjuna’s names was ‘Gudākesha’, which has several meanings, one of which is “He who has mastered sleep.”

  • Arjuna was willing to leave his family for learning: When the Pāṇdavas had to live several years in the forest due to Duryodhana’s trickery, Arjuna decided to use his time constructively and learn some new skills, and the science and art of using more advanced weapons. So he left his family for a year to go to learn weaponry from Bhagavān Shiva after an arduous journey away from his family.

  • Arjuna was very humble, sincere and was willing to acknowledge his faults and learn from them. In fact, Arjuna confessed to Krishna, “Overcome by faint-heartedness, confused about my duty (Dharma), I ask you: Please tell me that which is truly better for me. I am your student. Please teach me, who has taken refuge in you.” Gita 2.7

  • Arjuna was very respectful to his teacher and followed his instructions. Drona had been humiliated by King Drupada. When the princes ended their education, Drona asked for a tuition fee – capturing Drupada alive and bringing him to Drona. Arjuna followed his Guru’s request and did what his Guru wanted, risking his own life.


6. Dating of the Bhagavad Gita
The Gita was revealed on the first day of the 18 day long Mahābhārata war at Kurukshetra. There is a lot of controversy as to when the war happened. From a traditional Hindu perspective, the dating of Bhagavad Gita does not matter because unlike Abrahamic religions (Islam, Christianity and Judaism) that are based on historical events, Hindu Dharma is based on eternal principles. These principles are not dependent on any historical connection and can be discovered by anyone at any time, they can be experienced by any one or revealed again to any person any time in human history. Yet, some dates have been suggested by the Hindu tradition as well as by modern scholars. They are:

  • 32nd BCE.
  • 24th BCE
  • 15th BCE
  • 10th BCE


However, as some scholars argue, this does not mean that the Gita in its current state was finalized right around the war. The Mahābhārata itself was written and expanded after the war. Scholars disagree as to whether the Gita was included originally in the Mahābhārata or whether it was added on later. Or whether the Gita was a shorter scripture in the beginning and then expanded to the current form. Scholars have again proposed several different dates for when the Gita was written down in its present form. These dates vary from 32nd Cent BCE to 2nd cent CE!

For our purposes, we will assume that the Gita was revealed around 15th cent. BCE because archaeologists have dated the remains of Dwārakā (the capital of Krishna) to around that time. In reality, all these discussions are futile and we cannot fix the date of Gita with the given lack of evidence. Nor can we prove decisively whether the Gita was a shorter book that was expanded later. All these debates simply do not matter to someone who merely wants to understand the overall message of the Gita. Therefore, we shall just assume, for convenience, that the Gita was completed in its present form (with very few if any changes) shortly after the Mahābhārata War.

Some factors that lead the present author towards this conclusion regarding the date of the Gita are:


  • A Buddhist manuscript dated to 150 AD (‘Spitzer manuscript’) from Turfan (Sinkiang, China) says that the Buddha (6th BCE) had studied the Mahabharata.

  • Panini in Pakistan (6th BCE) mentions Krishna as the teacher of Arjuna.

  • Krishna and other characters of the Mahabharata are mentioned in much more ancient scriptures of Hindus and Buddhists like the Jatakas, Chhandogya Upanishad and Nirukta.

  • Quotations from the Gita are found in ancient scriptures like Nirukta (chapter 14) and Baudhayana Grihya Parishesha Sutra.


7. Translations and Explanations of the Gita
The Gita is the second most translated scripture in the world, after the Bible. There are more than 700 commentaries and translations of the Bhagavad Gita. There are more than 225 commentaries on the Gita in Sanskrit alone.

The oldest surviving translation of the Gita is in Javanese, an Indonesian language. This translation covers less than 100 verses and is more than 1000 years old. Alberuni too wrote an Arabic translation of portions of the Gita in the 11th cent. CE.

Literally dozens of Hindu scholars and saints wrote their own commentaries and explanations on the Bhagavad Gita in the last 1500 years or more. Most of them are in Sanskrit. The oldest commentary that survives is that of Adi Shankaracharya (~700 AD) and tries to show that the scripture teaches the philosophy of Advaita Vedanta. However, it is clear from this commentary that there existed several ancient commentaries on the Gita but none of these have survived today.

Shankaracharya is closely followed in time by Bhatta Bhaskara, who interprets the Gita according to the school of Bhedābheda Vedanta. Other prominent Sanskrit commentaries on the Gita are by Ramanujacharya (following Vishishtadvaita Vedanta), Madhvacharya (following Dvaita Vedanta), Vedanta Deshika (super-commentary on Ramanujacharya’s commentary), Shridhara Swami (following Advaita Vedanta with a strong flavor of Bhakti) and Madhusudana Saraswati (Advaita Vedanta with a strong flavor of Bhakti).

Around the beginning of the 13th cent. AD, Sant Jnaneshvara of Maharashtra wrote a beautiful verse commentary on the Gita in an olden form of the Marathi language. In our own times, Mahatma Gandhi wrote an explanation on the Gita. The longest commentary on the Gita is perhaps the one in Marathi by Vāmana Pandit (~17th cent.) and it has approximately 70,000 verses.

Literally hundreds of translations and beautiful commentaries on the Gita in English, Hindi and many other languages have appeared since 1750 AD. Because of its importance in Hinduism, every important Hindu thinker and philosopher feels the need to write a commentary on this scripture from his or her own perspective, or as a self-study exercise.

The two largest publishers and distributors of the Bhagavad Gita in the world are: ISKCON (International Society for Krishna Consciousness) founded by Srila Prabhupāda Bhaktivedānta; and the Geeta Press of Gorakhpur (India). Just as many hotel rooms in the United States has a copy of the Bible, there is an ongoing effort by ISKCON to place copies of the Gita in hotel rooms as well.

8. The Other Gitas of Bhagavān Krishna
There are more than 30 Hindu scriptures titled as ‘Gita’. But of these, only five are attributed to Krishna:

The Bhagavad Gita (“Song of the Lord”) in the Mahābhārata, Book VI (Bheeshma Parva) in 18 chapters.

The Kāma Gita (“The Gita of Desire”) in the Mahābhārata, Book XIV (Āshvamedhika Parva) in 3 chapters, revealed to Emperor Yudhishthira. It teaches us that it is not sufficient to win the battles of this world. More important and difficult is winning the battle in our mind between evil and good, and between sorrow and cheerfulness. Through a story, it emphasizes that we can win external battles only if we win the war of minds (ours as well as those of others). This short Gita can be considered as an elaboration of Bhagavad Gita’s verses 1.1 to 2.11.

The Anu Gita (“The Follow Up Gita”) in the Mahābhārata, Book XIV (Āshvamedhika Parva) in 36 chapters, revealed to Arjuna. This Gita has more than 1000 verses, and comprises of several short dialogues and stories that Krishna recollects for the sake of Arjuna after the war is over, at the latter’s request. The Anu Gita elaborates much more on themes that are ignored or are covered in lesser detail in the Bhagavad Gita, like the path and philosophy of meditation (Dhyāna Yoga), the wisdom of Sāmkhya (Jnāna), the duties of different stages of our life etc. However, Krishna does say to Arjuna in the beginning of Anu Gita that the Bhagavad Gita in itself is sufficient to take us to Brahman (the Supreme Being).

The Uddhava Gita (“Gita revealed to Uddhava”) is a much later scripture that is a part of Bhāgavata Purāṇa, Book XI. It was revealed by Krishna just before he was leaving the earth finally to return to the abode of Vishnu, to his friend and cousin Uddhava. This Gita explains Yoga, Bhakti, ethical principles, characteristics of a Sādhu, vegetarianism, etc., in great elaboration. Moreover, it also emphasizes that we should try to see the commonalities between different viewpoints expressed in the Vedic tradition, because Rishis often say the same thing in different ways. It has more than 1000 verses in 24 chapters. Another name of this scripture is the Hamsa Gita (“Song of the Swan”) because the swan symbolically stands for purity, and the ability to distinguish between the good and the bad. And it is literally the ‘Swan Song’ (last discourse) of Krishna.

The Uttara Gita (“The Latter Gita”) in three chapters contains a lot of details on various Yogic disciplines and also emphasizes that the caste of a person depends not on his birth but on his character. This Gita has a commentary on it by Gaudapādāchārya, who was the Guru of the Guru of Shankaracharya. Some scholars consider this Gita as well as the commentary to be spurious because it is not quoted by any Hindu scholar in the past. This Gita claims to belong to the Mahabharata. But so far, no manuscript of the Mahabharata is seen to contain it. Therefore, it is unclear as to who wrote it but regardless, it seems to be an ancient work.

If we want to read only one of the above Gitas, it should be the Bhagavad Gita. If a second one, then perhaps the Uddhava Gita. And thereafter, the Anu Gita and the Kāma Gita (which is quite short), and finally the Uttara Gita, to understand the philosophy of Krishna. Collectively, they are approximately 3000 verses. However, as emphasized in the Anu Gita itself, the Bhagavad Gita is itself sufficient to take us to Brahman.

9. The Different Versions of the Bhagavad Gita:
The standard text of the Bhagavad Gita has exactly 700 verses. This is the text that was used by Shankaracharya for his commentary in the 7th CE, and his is the oldest commentary available today.
Several manuscripts add a single verse by Arjuna at the beginning of chapter 13, bring the number to 701.

Then, manuscripts found in Kashmir have an additional 15 or so verses and half verses, that are also included in the commentaries of Kashmirian scholars like Abhinavagupta (950 – 1020 CE) or even earlier in the commentary of Bhaskara (7th – 8th?). However, these extra verses do not really add anything new to the teachings of the Gita.

The exact wording of the verses of the Gita also varies a bit here and there in different manuscripts. This is in fact true for all ancient scriptures of the world (except for the Vedas). But again, these textual variations do not really amount to much and are not significant in any way.

A modern version (from 20th published from Gondal in Gujarat) claims to have 745 verses. Its authenticity has been challenged. And again, these 45 extra verses do not add anything new to the message of the Gita.

Another modern version (again, from the 20th, published by the Suddha Dharma Mandala) has another version in 745 verses, and unlike all the other versions, it divides the scripture into 26 instead of into 18 chapters. This text is not accepted by any scholar as being genuine.

Therefore, for our purposes, we will largely stick to the text of 700 verses that was followed by Shankaracharya. In the standard version of 700 verses, 574 are spoken by Lord Krishna, 84 by Arjuna, 41 by Sanjaya and 1 by King Dhritarashtra. Most scholars prefer to follow this text.

The Gita has 18 chapters which have different titles. However, different commentators and different manuscripts either sometimes omit these titles or give different titles for the same chapter. This is taken to mean that the addition of titles to these chapters took place at a later time, and that the chapters did not have names originally. Moreover, these titles often do not necessarily reflect the actual contents of these chapters faithfully.

There are two types of meters in the Gita: The Anushtubh (642 verses) and the Trishtubh (58 verses).

10. The Bhagavad Gita and the Number ‘18’
The Gita is a part of the Mahābhārata that has 18 books. The Gita too has 18 chapters.

The Gita was recited at the beginning of a war that lasted 18 days.

In chapter 1 of the Gita, Sanjaya enumerates exactly 18 warriors in the side of the Pāṇdavas, who won the war.

In Hindu Dharma, there are 18 major Smritis (codes of Dharma); 18 major Purāṇas (narratives about Devas), 18 minor Purāṇas (ibid.).

Why is the number 18 found so frequently in Hindu Dharma?
It is the ‘numerical value’ of ‘Jai’ or victory of Dharma over Adharma.

The number ‘1’ denotes Bhagavān, and ‘8’ denotes the 8 root materials (Prakritis) from the Hindu tradition from which this Universe is made.

There are several other reasons why ‘18’ and ‘108’, ‘1008’ are holy in Hindu Dharma but a detailed discussion of the same is beyond the present scope.

11. The Bhagavad Gita: A Summary
 Arjuna said to Lord Krishna:

Overcome by faint-heartedness (a sinking feeling), confused about my duty (Dharma), I ask you: Please tell me that which is truly better for me. I am your student. Please teach me, who has taken refuge in you. Gita 2.7

The Blessed Lord Krishna replied:

[BRAHMAN IS THE SUPREME BEING]

I am the final Destination (Goal), the Provider, the Master of all, the Witness of everything, the Abode (in which the whole universe resides), worth seeking shelter of, and the Friend of all. And I am the origin and the Dissolution, the Foundation of everything, the Resting Place and the immortal cause of everything. Gita 9.18

[OUR TRUE NATURE IS DIVINE]

An eternal portion of My own Self becomes the soul of creatures in the world of living things. It attracts the five senses and the mind as the sixth (which lords over these senses) – all these six are comprised of non-living matter. Gita 15.7

[SEE THE DIVINE IN ALL CREATURES]

The wise see the same (Brahman) with an equal eye, in a learned and humble brāhmaṇa, in a cow, in an elephant, in a dog, and even in a dog eater (outcast). Gita 5.18

[WE ARE THE ETERNAL ATMA, NOT THIS PERISHABLE BODY]

The soul is never born and it does not ever die. The soul is not something that exists at one time and then vanishes the next. The soul is not something that did not exist at one time and then took birth and came into being subsequently. It is unchanging, eternal and primeval and it is not destroyed when the body is destroyed. Gita 2.20

Weapons cannot cleave the soul, fire cannot burn it. Water does not wet (or drown) it not does wind dry it. Gita 2.23

[DOCTRINE OF REBIRTH – WE NEVER DIE]


Just as a human casts off worn out clothing and puts on new, the soul too casts off old bodies and enters into new ones. Gita 2.22

Just as the soul dwelling in the body passes through childhood, youth and old age; in a similar manner, it travels from one body to another. Therefore, the wise do not get deluded over these changes. Gita 2.13

When the soul enters a body, it becomes the master of that body. And when it leaves the body (at death), it takes the mind and senses along with it, just as the wind takes fragrances from their sources (the flowers). Gita 15.8

[BHAGAVAN IS IMPARTIAL]

All beings are equal in my eyes. There is none especially hateful to me, nor one who is especially dear to me. But all those who worship me with devotion are in Me, and so am I in them. Gita 9.29

[THERE IS HOPE FOR EVERYONE]

Even if a person of the vilest conduct starts worshipping me with single-minded devotion, he too must be counted amongst the good, because he has resolved well. Gita 9.30

[GOD SAVES ANYONE WHO APPROACHES HIM]

Whosoever takes refuge in me, even if they are lowly born (due to the sins of their previous lives), and be they women, or Vaishyas or Shudras – they will all attain the Highest Goal. Gita 9.32

[TRUE DEVOTION IS MORE IMPORTANT THAN EXTERNALS]

Whosoever offers to Me with devotion a leaf, a flower, a fruit or even water – that offering of love, of the pure of heart I accept eagerly. Gita 9.26

[MANY WAYS TO REACH GOD – FREEDOM OF WORSHIP]

In whatsoever way men approach Me, even so do I bless them. For whichever path that men make take in worship, they will all come to Me. Gita 4.11

[WHO IS ESPECIALLY DEAR TO BHAGAVAN?]


In My view, that Yogi is the best who puts himself in the place of others at all times, and seeing his own identity with them, he is able to experience their pain and pleasure. Gita 6.32

He who has no hatred for any living being, who is friendly and also compassionate instead, who is free of the feeling of ‘I’ and ‘mine’, even minded in pleasure and pain and ever forgiving and forbearing. Gita 12.13

He who is alike to enemy and friend, also to good or bad reputation; He who is the same in pleasure or pain, in heat or cold and who is free from all attachments. Gita 12.18

He who considers insult and praise alike, who is silent (restrained in speech), content with whatever comes his way (through his own effort), has no abode (i.e., is not tied to home or family) and is firm in mind and full of devotion – that man is extremely dear to me. Gita 12.19

[LIVING ETHICALLY AND SPIRITUALLY]

Absence of fear, purity of mind, steadfastness in the path of meditation, Charity, control over one’s sense organs, performance of Vedic sacrifices, study of Holy Scriptures, austerity and straightforwardness… Gita 16.1


Ahimsa, truthfulness, absence of anger, renunciation, peacefulness, absence of backbiting or crookedness, compassion towards all creatures, absence of covetousness, gentleness, modesty (decency), absence of fickleness (or immaturity)…. Gita 16.2

Vigor and energy, forgiveness, fortitude, cleanliness, absence of hatred and no exaggerated self-opinion – These belong to the One who is born to achieve Divine Wealth, O Bhārata. Gita 16.3

Ostentation, arrogance, excessive pride and a tendency to demand respect, anger, harshness and indeed ignorance – these are the endowments of him who is born with the demoniac wealth. Gita 16.4

[LAW OF KARMA, FREEDOM IS OUR TRUE DESTINY]

Divine wealth leads to Freedom, whereas the demoniac wealth results in bondage. Do not grieve, because you are born naturally with the divine wealth (and therefore destined for freedom). Gita 16.5

[CONTROL YOUR WANTS TO ATTAIN PEACE AND HAPPINESS]

He attains peace into whom all desires enter as waters enters the ocean, which filled from all sides, remains unmoved; but not to him who wants to have (more and more) desires. Gita 2.70

[PRACTICE MODERATION IN ALL THINGS]

Meditation (Yoga) becomes the destroyer of sorrow for him whose food (eating habits) and recreation are temperate, whose efforts and activities are controlled, and whose sleep and waking are regulated. Gita 6.17

[ENGAGE WITH GOOD, DISENGAGE FROM EVIL]

Arjuna, without doubt, the mind is difficult to discipline because it is restless. But it can be restrained through constant engagement in good things (abhyāsa) and constant detachment from bad things (vairāgya). Gita 6.35

[SCRIPTURAL TEACHINGS SHOULD BE OUR GUIDE IN OUR ACTIONS]

Let scripture be the means by which you determine what should be done and what should not be done. After knowing the commands of the scripture, it is your obligation to perform your duties while you live in this world. Gita 16.24

[GOD SETS AN EXAMPLE THROUGH DIVINE INCARNATIONS]

Whenever there is a decline of Dharma and ascendancy of Adharma, I bring Myself into being, i.e., I assume a physical body. Gita 4.7

To protect the virtuous, destroy the evil doers and to re-establish the rule of Dharma, I come into being in every age. Gita 4.8

[WE TOO SHOULD SET AN EXAMPLE FOR OTHERS]

Whatsoever a great man does, the same is done by others. Whatever standard he sets, the world follows. Gita 3.21

[DO YOUR DUTY WITH A HIGHER PURPOSE]


The unlearned performs their duties from attachment to their work. Therefore, the wise and learned too should perform their duties, but without any attachment and only with the desire to promote harmony and welfare in the world. Gita 3.25

[BE STRONG, BELIEVE IN SELF-HELP]

Let a man lift himself by himself; because we alone are our own friend and we are also our own enemy. Gita 6.5

[DO YOUR DUTY SELFLESSLY, WITHOUT EXPECTING REWARDS]

You have control over doing your duty alone, and never on the fruit of your actions. Therefore, do not live or do your duty that is merely motivated by fruits of your actions. And do not let yourself get drawn into the path of non-action. Gita 2.47

[TAKE PRIDE IN WHATEVER YOU DO]

One should not give up the work suited to one’s nature, though it may be defective, for all enterprises are clouded by defects, just as fire is covered with smoke. Gita 18.48

[ALL WORK IS IMPORTANT]

One’s duty, even if devoid of merit, is better than the duty of another, well done. Doing action ordained by one’s own nature, one does not incur any sin. Gita 18.47

[CORRECT MENTAL ATTITUDE IN DOING OUR DUTY]

Steadfast in Yoga, and abandoning attachments, perform your actions and duties. Face all accomplishments and failures with an even mind, because yoga means evenness of mind. Gita 2.48


[WHEN WORK BECOMES WORSHIP]

(For a person who is immersed in spirituality) The act of offering is Brahman. The offering itself is Brahman. By Brahman is it offered into the fire, which is Brahman too. He who realizes Brahman while performing all actions, indeed reaches Brahman. Gita 4.24

[WE ARE INSTRUMENTS OF GOD]

The Lord resides in the hearts of all beings, causing them to revolve (i.e., go about their tasks) through his Māyā as if they were mounted on a machine. Gita 18.61

[GOD’S PROMISE TO US]

Abandoning completely all duties (i.e., dedicating them to Me), seek refuge in Me alone. I will liberate you from all evil, therefore do not grieve. Gita 18.66

[SPREAD THE GOOD WORD]

He who teaches this most exalted and supreme secret – this scripture (Gita) to My devotees, while having the highest devotion to Me, will come to Me alone – let there be no doubt about this. Gita 18.68

Arjuna said:

O Lord! You are Imperishable, the Supreme Being that we should seek to know. You are the ultimate shelter of the entire universe. You are the relentless protector of eternal Dharma. I believe that You are that Being Who has existed since eternity. Gita 11.18

By Your grace, my delusion is gone; and I have gained recognition of who I am and what is my duty. I now stand firm with my doubts dispelled and will do as You say. Gita 18.73

Thursday, 21 September 2017

No, Krishna was not a negligent father

If a father has only one son and that son became a bad guy due to neglect, that father may be questioned for his bad parenting and neglect, writes Jijith Nadumuri Ravi on Indiafacts. Read on: 

This is a Rebuttal to Devdutt Pattanaik’s article published in Economic Times and subsequently in his website Devdutt.com titled ‘Children of the Great’ published in the category of applied-mythology and in the sub-category meant for leadership & business audience, which makes its content deserving a rebuttal and critical analysis, based on original sources, as it portrayed Krishna as a bad example for fatherhood. Though this article was published on 7th August 2015, its impact is now far and wide. Spin-offs from this article is found circulating in social-media and WhatsApp groups. It was republished 15 or more times, such as in Speaking Tree and recently (30th August 2016) in the School of Inspirational Leadership.

The basic premise of Devdutt Pattanaik’s (DP’s) article is this: Samba (also rendered as Samva), the son of Krishna, is a spoiled child. Samba was spoiled, because Krishna didn’t give attention to him, as he was busy in his work of advising the Pandavas and completely immersed in the politics of Kurukshetra. In other words, Samba was the product of his workaholic father Krishna’s neglect. He then compares Krishna to the modern-day fathers, who work 24×7 or spend most of their time on internet and smart phones, creating neglected and spoilt children like Samba! Thus, in the eyes of DP, Krishna is a bad father, who neglected his son and turned him into a spoilt adult of bad manners and bad character. He then advices today’s fathers not to be like this workaholic Krishna.

Let us examine how much valid DPs premises are.

If a father has only one son and that son became a bad guy due to neglect, that father may be questioned for his bad parenting and neglect. If he has two or three sons and one became bad, still he can be questioned. Krishna had many sons, who became highly accomplished and gained name and fame like Pradyumna and Charudeshna. Hence, if one of them, Samva, became a bad person, then the father Krishna cannot be blamed. DPs argument falls flat there itself. But, let us dig deeper.

Krishna praises Samba as a great warrior
In Mahabharata, we get to see that despite the bad manners, Samba was a good warrior, a quality his father Krishna had appreciated, which means DP’s charge that Krishna neglected Samba is untrue.

Krishna with his political allies and kin, viz. the Pandavas. Painting & Illustration – by Jijith Nadumuri Ravi
In Sabha Parva, Chapter 14, for example, Krishna says to Yudhisthira: In our race, O king, there are full eighteen thousand brothers and cousins. Ahuka has had a hundred sons, each of whom is almost like a god in prowess, Charudeshna with his brother Chakradeva, Satyaki, myself, Baladeva-the son of Rohini, and my son Samva who is equal unto me in battle, these seven, O king, are Atirathas.

Krishna seated in the court (Maya-Sabha) of emperor Yudhishthira. Painting & Illustration – by Jijith Nadumuri Ravi
Then again in Vana Parva, Chapter 16, Krishna is showering all praise to Samba for his valiant fight against the Salwa king, who attacked Dvaraka, when Krishna was away at Indraprastha, to attend the Rajasuya Yajna of emperor Yudhisthira.

Here we see Krishna proudly telling Yudhisthira about the valor of his son Samba: “Beholding the army of Salwa, Charudeshna, Samva, and Pradyumna sailed out to attack it. Samva taking up his bows attacked Kshemavriddhi, the commander of Salwa’s forces and his chief counsellor too. The son of Jambavati (Samva) began to shower arrows continuously like Indra showering rain! Kshemavriddhi, bore that shower of arrows, immovable as the Himavat. The Salwa Commander then discharged at Samva a volley of shafts. Samva showered on his adversary’s car a thousand arrows. Then pierced by the shafts of Samva, the commander of the hostile host, left the field by the help of his fleet-steed!

“When the wicked general of Salwa had left the field, a mighty Daitya called Vegavat rushed at my son! The heroic Samva bore that onset of Vegavat, keeping his ground. Whirling a quickly-going mace, he hurled it at Vegavat. Struck with that mace, Vegavat fell down on the ground, like a weather-beaten and faded lord of the forest of decayed roots! Slaying him thus with a mace, my son entered within that mighty host and began to fight with all.”

Here, what we are witness is a father Krishna, feeling great pride in the battle-prowess of his son Samba. Any thought of Samba being a neglected child is washed away by this incidence found vividly in the Mahabharata.

We also learn from the chapter 118 of Vana Parva of Mahabharata that when Yudhishthira with his brothers reached Dvaraka in their pilgrimage, during their 12 yearlong exile, Samba was there with Krishna and Balarama to welcome him: “Yudhisthira cordially met Balarama, Krishna, Samva the son of Krishna, the grandson of Sini and other Vrishnis, and paid honor to them in a suitable form.”

Krishna’s cousin Satyaki has this to say about Samba: “Let Samva chastise, by the force of his arms, Dussasana; let him destroy Dussasana, his charioteer and his car. In the field of battle, when the son of Jamvavati becomes irresistible in fight, there is nothing which can withstand his force. By him was killed in fight Asvachakra. Who is there that would be able to go forward to the car of Samva, who is great in fight, when mounted on a car? As a mortal coming under the clutches of death can never escape; so who is there that once coming under his clutches in the field of battle, is able to return with his life?”

Samba follows father Krishna in his Kurukshetra politics
If DP had cared to look at Virata Parva and Udyoga Parva of Mahabharata, he would have known that Samba was not averse to Krishna’s political activities. Samba was present with his father at the Virata’s court, where Krishna and the Pandavas formulated their war-strategies to prepare for the upcoming Kurukshetra War.

Mahabharata, Virata Parva, Chapter 72: After the kings had come there from different parts of the country, there came Vasudeva decked in floral garlands, Halayudha, Kritavarman the son of Hridika, Yuyudhana the son of Satyaka, Anadhristi, Akrura, Samva and Nisatha.

Mahabharata, Udyoga Parva, Chapter 1: Side by side with the king of the Matsya sat Krishna, Yudhishthira, all the sons of king Drupada, Bhima, Arjuna, the two sons of Madri, Pradyumna, and Samva both valiant in battle and Abhimanyu with Virata’s sons.

Mahabharata, Udyoga Parva, Chapter 158: Beholding that a very destructive battle was about to take place, there came into the Pandava encampment, Halayudha, accompanied by Akrura, Gada, Samva, Uddhava, Rukmini’s son Pradyumna, Ahuka’s sons, Charudeshna, and others.

Mahabharata, Drona Parva, Chapter 11: Here Dhritarashta, the king of Hastinapura tells to his minister Sanjaya:- “Gada, Samva, Pradyumna, Viduratha, Charudeshna and other mighty Vrishni heroes, accomplished in smiting, will take up their position in the Pandava host, when summoned by Krishna.”

Mahabharata, Ashvamedha Parva, Chapter 66: Accompanied by Subhadra, Yuyudhana, Charudeshna, Samva, Gada, Kritavarman, Sarana, Nisatha and Unmukha, Krishna came with Balarama as the head to attend king Yudhisthira’s Ashvamedha Yajna.

Doesn’t all of this make it more than clear that Samba was very much part of Krishna’s political life and shared the burden of his work, unlike what DP wants to portray in his articles and essays?

Samba was a son born to Krishna by Shiva’s blessing
A few chapters in the Anushasana Parva of Mahabharata are dedicated to Krishna’s explanation to Yudhishthira detailing how he went to worship the great god Shiva and obtained a son by the blessing of Shiva. That son was Samba!

Krishna to Yudhisthira: “Hear you, how I obtained a sight, so difficult to obtain, of that great god, for the sake of Samva.”

Krishna’s wife Jambavati wanted a son from him, who is equal to Pradyumna, Krishna’s elder son born of his first wife Rukmini. Krishna, then, set forth to meet Shiva who grants him the desired boon.

The spouse of Shiva tells this to Krishna: – “The puissant Mahadeva has granted thee, a son who shall be named Samva.”

Here we see that Samba was the son whom Krishna got as a blessing of Mahadeva, after performing prolonged penances. It is unlikely that such a son will be neglected by his father. It is always better to dig deep into the original sources, than believing the agenda driven opinions of a single mythologist like DP.

As per Mahabharata Samva’s complexion is white
A crucial information found in the Anushasana Parva of Mahabharata is that Samba was pale-complexioned, while Krishna was dark hued. Hence, Samba did not resemble his father in appearance, which means anyone can easily distinguish between Krishna and Samva. Krishna’s elder son Pradyumna, on the other hand, is mentioned as looking exactly like Krishna and Pradyumna is not portrayed as a spoilt son anywhere. This is also repeated in Harivamsha, Vishnu Purana and Bhagavata.

The above description is in conflict with the later description found in some sun-temple folklore, ‘Sthala-purana’ and ‘Aitihya’. According to this, Samba looked exactly like Krishna in appearance. Taking advantage of this, Samva impersonated his father Krishna and some of Krishna’s younger wives got infatuated towards him. One wife Nandini pretended herself as Samba’s wife and embraced him. Knowing this, Krishna cursed Samba to be inflicted with leprosy and his wives to be kidnapped by Abhira robbers after his death. All of this has found its way into Padma Purana, Bhavishya Purana, Varaha Purana and Samba Purana. (Samba Purana one of the Saura Upa-puranas, dedicated to the sun and sun-temples). Samva’s affliction is variously described in these diverse narratives as leprosy, skin lesions on his face or some other skin disease, so that Krishna’s wives can recognize him as different from Krishna.

DP is basing his assumptions fully upon this, without mentioning about the conflicting information in the Mahabharata, for reasons known only to him.

The rest of the narrative is more vividly described in the Samba Purana as per which Samba got cured by worshipping sun-god (Surya). For this, he constructed a temple in Mitra-vana on the banks of Chandrabhaga (Chenab) river upon the advice of sage Kakata. Samba prayed to sun-god there for 12 years. This is identified as the Sun Temple at Multan (Kashyapapura). Tradition holds that Samba constructed it. As per Konark tradition in Odisha, he was cured at Konark temple. Samba Dashami is celebrated on the 10th day of the Shukla Paksha of Pausha Masa in Odisha in memory of Samba getting cured by the sun-god. Mothers pray to Surya for the health of their children on this occasion.

Other narratives of Samba
For those enthusiasts who want to dig deep into the Puranic and Aitihasic narratives, the story of Samba’s abduction of Duryodhana’s daughter leading to war between the Kauravas and Yadavas is mentioned in the 5th book of Vishnu Purana in chapter 35.

Samba carries off the daughter of Duryodhana, but is taken prisoner. Balarama comes to Hastinapura, and demands his liberation. Duryodhana does not oblige. A wrathful Balarama dragged Hastinapura using his plough and threatened to throw it into river Ganga. Only then, Duryodhana releases the couple. This story is not without a geological and historical significance. River Ganga has changed its course due to tectonic activities often flooding Hastinapura and causing tremors and cracks in the city’s dwellings and streets. The relative distance of Hastinapura from Ganga varied in the course of history due to this and a future Kuru king Nichakra abandoned the city and re-established his rule at Kausambi.

The most famous narrative of Samva for which Mahabharata has dedicated an entire Parva, viz. the Musala Parva is about his role in the destruction of Dvaraka. The prankster Samba, disguised himself as a pregnant woman, calling himself the wife of Vabhru. He then insulted a group of sages Narada, Visvamitra and Kanva among them. They were visiting Dvaraka to meet Krishna. Samba in the guise of the pregnant woman jokingly asked them to predict if he will beget a boy or a girl. The sages uttered a curse that Samba will deliver an iron bolt (Musala) and it will become the cause of the destruction of Dvaraka and his entire family. This narrative is also detailed in the 5th book of Vishnu Purana in chapter 37 and also in Harivamsha and Bhagavata Purana.

None of these traditional texts accuse Samba as the sole cause of the destruction of Dvaraka. Rather, he was described as a medium through which Karmic forces acted, causing an end to the glory of the great island city of Dvaraka, for everything that has a beginning, there is an end. This is hinted in the idea that Samba was born to Krishna as a boon of Shiva, the lord of time and final dissolution. Destruction of Dvaraka was also described as an effect of Gandhari’s curse, who mistook Krishna to be the root cause of the Kurukshetra war in which all her 100 sons died, unable to accept that the Adharmic conduct of her own sons was its root cause. Dvaraka’s fateful end was further strengthened by the curse of the ascetics upon Samba.

Destruction of Dvaraka is an example of how excessive wealth (Artha) in a society, when not supported by Dharma can degrade it to anarchy, immorality and finally to destruction. The balance of the Purusharthas viz. Dharma, Artha, Kama and Moksha is essential for a healthy society. When Dharma declines, the society weakens, despite its Artha (wealth and affluence).

Political polarization also was another cause for the destruction of Dvaraka, as the Yadava war-heroes, who participated in the Kurukshetra-war, fighting each other from the side of Pandavas and Kauravas started an internal strife among themselves in Dvaraka, before the city was finally flooded by the sea.

For those, who are curious to know, how many sons Krishna had, the total number of Krishna’s sons as per Vishnu Purana is 180,000 from 16108 wives  – which sure is an exaggerated figure, as it counts, as his wife, every woman rescued by him directly or indirectly from the patriarchal societies.

Conclusion
By examining all the traditional sources, we see that Samba was not a son spoilt due to the neglect of a workaholic father Krishna. Though DPs critique of today’s workaholic, internet-addicted, smart-phone-wielding men and women, for neglecting their children is much valid, he chose an incorrect example from Indian tradition to illustrate his point.

We learn that Samba was a son Krishna got as a blessing of Mahadeva, after prolonged penances. We have seen that Krishna held Samba in high esteem as a great warrior and praised him profusely among the company of his political allies and kin viz. the Pandavas. We learn that Samba was very much an active participant of Krishna’s politics and that he accompanied his father Krishna in many of his political campaigns and gatherings.

This leaves DP’s assertions regarding Krishna utterly baseless. Dharmic tradition hails Krishna as a Karma Yogi. His life philosophy of ‘nishkama-karma’ i.e. doing one’s work by relinquishing doer-ship and avoiding the urge to enjoy the fruits of one’s work all by oneself rather than leaving it to the society at large – is a remarkable guiding light even today.

Calling a Karma Yogi as a workaholic and presenting it in front of a leadership and business audience – is it not a mischievous, tacit attack on Karma Yoga and the Dharmic tradition?