Showing posts with label frozen embryo. Show all posts
Showing posts with label frozen embryo. Show all posts

Monday, 27 January 2020

‘She said she’d be babysitting our embryo’: What’s it like to carry a child for a friend?

Surrogacy between friends can be life-changing. The people who have done it talk emotions, legal hurdles – and WhatsApp birthing groups

In a flat in north-east London, Abi is cradling her best friend’s baby. At 15 weeks old, the little boy is smiling up at her, testing out his first sounds. His mother, Rachel, prepares his bottle while Abi rocks him, showing all the love she would to any of her friends’ children. The only difference is that Abi gave birth to him.

Abi and Rachel, both 35, met on their first day at university in Birmingham in 2003 and rarely left one another’s side. At 16, Rachel had been diagnosed with MRKH, a congenital condition meaning her uterus was undeveloped. 

Although she produced eggs, she would never be able to carry children, something she kept to herself. “I’d tell people I didn’t want kids but deep down I was insanely jealous,” says Rachel, who works as an events producer in London. “I wanted them so badly but assumed I’d never have my own, so I learned to live with it.”

After meeting her boyfriend, Sam, at a warehouse party on the eve of 2014, she avoided the “family” chat for two years before confiding in him. “We continued our relationship knowing kids may or may not happen,” she says.

A weekend stay at Abi’s home, in November 2017, bringing together five friends, their partners and kids, presented an opportunity to open up to them, too. Abi, a mother to three boys, remembers: “My partner, Rich, was cooking a curry, the kids were asleep and we were sitting around the kitchen table. Everyone spilled something personal. When Rachel told us about her condition, I knew, in my gut, that I would help her to have a child.”

Rachel and Sam had explored IVF, surrogacy and adoption, but had dismissed using agencies, which can be vastly oversubscribed, with waits of up to two years to find a match. “It felt too impersonal; too life-changing somehow,” she says. Her younger sister had yet to start her own family; had she already had children, Rachel might have asked her to be a surrogate.

Abi and Rich, meanwhile, “spent Christmas contemplating what being a surrogate would mean for everyone. We had been so lucky, yet one of the people I love most hadn’t,” she says. “I hate this phrase but it was a no-brainer.”

She called Rachel in the new year and told her to sit down before offering to carry her baby. Rachel remembers: “She said it would be like ‘babysitting’ our embryo and that term stuck. She’d made up her mind, and that blew me away. I hadn’t told my friends expecting one of them to be the answer. When Abi offered, it felt, for the first time, as if having a child was a very real possibility.”

***

In the UK, the number of children born by surrogate is up to 10 times higher than it was a decade ago, according to the Law Commission, which recently consulted on modernising the process to better support parents, surrogate and child. While US states such as California have commercialised the arrangement, with surrogates earning well in excess of $50,000 (£38,300), it is illegal to pay someone for acting as a surrogate in the UK, meaning the process relies on the altruism of strangers recruited through an agency, or loved ones. It is not routinely available on the NHS, and the private medical costs are typically up to £16,000. “Known” surrogacy – between friends or relatives – is still rare: at Care, the UK’s largest private fertility group, they accounted for 10% of more than 100 surrogacy cycles at their clinics last year.
‘I could hardly believe it was real’: Rachel (right) with her baby, for whom Abi was the surrogate mother. Photograph: Silvana Trevale/The Guardian

Surrogacy is a delicate arrangement with high stakes. Pregnancy and childbirth can be gruelling, and present health risks, while the unknown territory of handing over a baby you have carried – or parenting the child you have not – presents added fears over bonding or changes of heart, albeit rare.
When there is an existing friendship at the arrangement’s heart, the stakes can feel higher still, for both the surrogate carrying a longed-for child and parents asking such as sacrifice of someone they care for, typically with a family themselves to consider. (Medics and lawyers advise against surrogacy until women have completed their own families, citing concerns about reproductive health and fears that it would be harder for them to give up the baby.) Not surprisingly, the friendships that underpin these arrangements are life-changing.

Abi, Rachel and Sam embarked on medical appointments at a London fertility clinic. The friends were invited for counselling and asked to consider everything from how they would feel if Abi backed out, to how she would feel if she gave birth to a girl, after three sons. They set up a WhatsApp group. “We left Rich off that,” Abi says. “I’ll talk about body parts and womb washing till the cows come home but he saw his role as keeping things normal – remaining practical and pragmatic in a hyper-emotional situation.” They told their families, including Abi’s boys – four, three and nine months at the time. “We always talked about ‘Rachel and Sam’s baby’. We said, ‘Rachel’s womb doesn’t work but Mummy’s does, so we’re going to look after a baby for them.’”

In hindsight, living miles apart was good. If we were round the corner I’d have been posting steak through her letterbox

After initially being refused any NHS fertility treatment that would lead to surrogacy, Rachel successfully lobbied her local commissioning group for a single round of IVF, in May 2018, allowing her eggs to be extracted for fertilisation by Sam’s sperm, creating a viable embryo. It would later be placed in Abi’s uterus at a private clinic, using money Rachel’s parents had saved for her wedding. “Surrogacy is still seen as something you do if you’ve got money rather than through biological need,” Rachel says.

Abi was given oestrogen and progesterone, and the embryo was transferred, via catheter, in a simple, minutes-long procedure, on 2 October. “From that moment, it was out of my control,” Rachel says. “I felt like I was holding my breath.”

When Abi took a pregnancy test, at 7am on a Saturday morning nearly a fortnight later, Rachel and Sam were in bed, on the end of the phone. “When she sent through a picture of the positive test, we were in total shock; it was extremely emotional. We didn’t know how to get on with our day other than staring at that picture.” They remained in daily contact and Rachel travelled the 150 miles to Abi’s home for midwife appointments and scans, as well as attending antenatal classes, along with Rich. “In hindsight, the distance was a good thing,” Rachel says. “If we were round the corner, I’d have been posting steak through her letterbox.”

They had to consider how to announce the pregnancy. Rachel would say: “We’re expecting a baby, but I’m not pregnant. My friend is carrying our baby.” Abi, who works in public engagement at the BBC, recalls: “Everyone’s mouths dropped at work. My mum asked, ‘Why you?’ But they all thought it was amazing.”

When it came to maternity leave, Abi was entitled to a year, but took six weeks, while Rachel was entitled to a year’s adoption leave. Outdated surrogacy laws require that Abi’s name is on the birth certificate alongside Sam’s; had Abi and Rich been married, he would have been named as the father. They also recognise Abi as the mother until Rachel obtains the court order granting her legal parental status. Seven months on, she is still waiting. “The fact that on paper he’s still not my son is upsetting,” she says, “but I can’t dwell on it. It’s a process, so we treat it that way.”

Many surrogacy pairings put an agreement in place. Although not legally binding – it is illegal for solicitors to negotiate one – it helps mitigate against concerns over all aspects of the pregnancy, from supplements to who first holds the baby. Rachel and Abi decided against it. “If Abi had changed her mind on anything, we all would have,” Rachel says.

Surrogates can receive reasonable expenses, such as extra food, travel, childcare or housekeeping costs, and Rachel and Sam gave Abi a cash card. “It’s the trickiest part because no expenses can repay her,” Rachel says. “She was militant about not asking for too much, but I wanted her to have a meal on us because she had our son with her.”

The baby was born on 8 June 2019. Rachel and Sam drove Abi to the hospital and witnessed the birth. “I could hardly believe it was real,” says Rachel, who fainted as he was delivered into her arms. The couple spent the first two nights after his birth in hospital, down the corridor from Abi.

“Rich was working late and arrived to find us all in the room together and the baby just minutes old,” Abi says. “He stayed for the placenta delivery, had some tea and toast and went home to be there for our boys in the morning. I don’t think the scale of what we’ve done will hit us for a long time. I’m relieved at how normal it feels when I see the baby. Rachel was so generous with her trust in me.”

Rachel adds: “Abi put herself mentally and physically through the most selfless act for me, to make us a family. She gave up a huge part of her life during those months to change ours for ever. I couldn’t handle what I was putting her through at times but she’d always say: ‘You’re not putting me through this, I’ve chosen to do it.’ If I ever asked why, she would say: ‘Well, I can’t think why not.’”

***

As fertility medicine has advanced and different family units evolved, surrogacy has emerged as a more familiar route to parenthood, but demand far outweighs the number of women willing or able to volunteer, and the British legal system is playing catchup. London-based family lawyer Joanna Kay, who has advised on surrogacy for more than a decade, says: “The landscape of what a family looks like has changed beyond recognition, but the laws are from the mid-80s. Without a court order, intended parents can’t make decisions about their child’s medical care or education; there can be problems with passports and inheritance. I don’t think anyone would argue against the need for reform.

“In most cases, everyone knows what they’re signing up for and is happy to honour their agreement. On rare occasions things go wrong and the courts are asked to intervene. There have been a handful of cases where the surrogate didn’t want to hand over the baby or the intended parent didn’t want it.”

Other relationships between parents and surrogates have been deep and enduring. Kim Cotton, who became Britain’s first surrogate in 1985, went on to help her friend Linda, who was unable to carry children because of complications associated with a miscarriage; Cotton gave birth to twins in 1991. “The family moved to New Zealand when the twins were teenagers but I still track their lives, mostly through Facebook now,” says Cotton, who is 63, and the founder of the Cots surrogacy agency. “Christmases and birthdays are still special and the twins and I always send messages to mark them. My friendship with Linda remains the kind where you are for ever aware of that person and can pick up with them anytime, even if you don’t speak often.”

***

Yet even longed-for pregnancies don’t always run smoothly. After Laura was made infertile five years ago, at 28, by treatment for stage two cervical cancer, her best friend Kerrie represented her only hope of becoming a biological mother. Last year, Kerrie offered to carry Laura’s fertilised eggs, frozen before she began intensive chemo and radiotherapy five years ago.
They had been friends since childhood and shared everything, Laura says, over a cup of tea at Kerrie’s home in Lancashire. “Relationships, breakups, marriages, my illness; she cries with me and laughs with me,” she says.

In 2014, Laura, a nursery manager, and her now-husband Grant were about to start IVF for problems unconnected to her own fertility when a routine smear test detected cancerous cells. “They talked about a hysterectomy,” she remembers. “Knowing my illness would take away my chance of having children was what broke me, not the cancer.” By this point in the story, both women are in tears. “As we left the hospital, I told Grant to leave me,” Laura adds. He didn’t. And while a hysterectomy was ruled out, Laura spent Christmas and New Year’s Eve undergoing treatment, with Kerrie by her side. She had delayed it by one month, so her eggs could be extracted and later used to try for a child via surrogate.

In April 2015, a scan revealed the tumour had gone. When Grant and Laura married in Cyprus in 2016, Kerrie was a bridesmaid. “When I was ill, a few friends had offered to be a surrogate,” Laura says. “And when we finally came round to thinking about it, two years ago, it was Grant who said: ‘It has to be Kerrie.’”

Kerrie, 33 and a hairdresser, had a similar conversation with her husband, Danny. “At the clinic, he told us he knew when Laura became ill that I would do it one day. I’d had two good pregnancies and it would only be nine months of my life to improve hers for ever. I focused on seeing them with a child.”

Although it was NHS-funded IVF that had led to the discovery of Laura’s cancer, when surrogacy became her only option, the funding was withdrawn. 

“I didn’t let it go without a fight,” she says. “Ultimately they were taking it away because I had cancer. The NHS saved my life; to then dictate that life isn’t fair.”

In the end Laura’s family paid for her treatment. “They would have helped me with a house deposit but I said, no, give me a baby, please.” The surrogacy was delayed when Kerrie unexpectedly became pregnant with her third child in 2018, but in October 2019 Laura’s eggs were thawed. Eight had been fertilised – but only one looked viable for transfer and pregnancy. It was placed in Kerrie’s womb on 7 October. The women held hands as they sat on the clinic’s bed. “When they told us there was only one chance, I couldn’t look at Laura,” Kerrie says. “She can read my thoughts. I wanted to stay positive for her but the pressure was huge.”

I’d been carrying her most treasured possession. We were numb. We drove home in silence

On 23 October, two clear lines showed on the pregnancy stick, but Kerrie tested and retested, with Laura by her side, to be sure. Both women were ecstatic. However, on 1 November Kerrie started bleeding. A miscarriage, at five weeks, was confirmed two days later at hospital.
She gave me my only chance of being a biological mum,’ says Laura (left) of Kerrie. Photograph: Shaw & Shaw/The Guardian

“It hit me like a ton of bricks,” Kerrie says. “I’d been carrying her most treasured possession. We were numb. We drove home in silence. My priority was being strong for her but I was broken. We went from speaking all day, every day, to nothing for 48 hours. I’d type a message asking, ‘Are you OK?’ then delete it. When we eventually sat down together, we cried our hearts out. I felt responsible but I knew I’d done everything I could.”

Laura is still coming to terms with her grief. “I was uncontrollable, heartbroken. We each had our own grieving to do; it wasn’t that we didn’t want to speak, we just didn’t have the words and didn’t want to add to each other’s pain.”

Kerrie has offered to be a surrogate again, with a donor egg, but Laura says she couldn’t put her friend through it. She has also thought about adoption but needs time to heal before giving it serious consideration.
“I don’t think anybody realises how difficult the process is,” she says. “Kerrie gave me my only chance of being a biological mum. I didn’t know I could love her any more than I already did.”

***

Despite the spike in surrogacies over the past decade – and a rise in profile following the examples of celebrities Kim Kardashian, Elton John, Sarah Jessica Parker and Tom Daley – just 302 (0.4%) of 75,425 fertility treatment cycles recorded by UK watchdog the Human Fertilisation & Embryology Authority (HFEA) in 2017 were surrogacies. But it has become a viable route for gay men who want to start a family. At Care, two-thirds of surrogacies in 2018/19 were for men in same-sex relationships, an option aided by the HFEA’s 2011 decision to offer £750 compensation to egg donors, triggering more women to help others on their parenthood journeys. This, says consultant gynaecologist David Polson, “opened up the options for same-sex couples to seek out a surrogate and become parents”. Advances in freezing fertilised eggs have also made it more likely that a thawed embryo will be suitable for transfer to another woman’s womb.

In Kent, Kevin, 45, a chief marketing officer, and Spencer, 30, a solicitor, are getting their six-month-old son ready for bed when the other half of “Sawyer’s birthing squad” (the name they gave their pregnancy WhatsApp group) arrives: surrogate Leanne, 36, and her sister Rachael, 33, Sawyer’s egg donor. “There’s not many teams like us out there,” says Leanne, grabbing a bedtime cuddle.

Spencer and Kevin have been together 10 years and married in 2015. “I told Kevin on our first date that I needed to be a dad,” Spencer says. “The biological connection was important to us. We wanted to be involved from the start.” They explored agencies but the networking aspect turned them off. “It was like speed dating. There were more couples than surrogates. It felt hard to be your true self.” They spoke to relatives and asked close friends but none provided an obvious solution. So, despite reservations, they turned to an agency and invested five months getting to know a potential surrogate, only to be let down by an early morning text weeks before treatment was due to start.

The one thing they did have was an egg donor. (Medics typically discourage having the same woman perform both functions, to offset concerns around the possibility of bonding too strongly with the baby.) Spencer and Rachael, a credit controller, had become friends two years earlier after meeting on an IVF forum on Facebook. Rachael, then pregnant with her third child, was exploring egg donation, and Spencer wanted to know more about surrogacy. They lived nearby and began meeting up, forming a close friendship that involved weekends together, takeaways, dinners and days out. Spencer and Kevin became unofficial uncles to Rachael’s youngest son and joined in family celebrations, which is how they grew close to Leanne, a mental health support worker who had three sons of her own.

Leanne remembers: “Kevin and Spencer were lovely, and I’d seen how close they all were and how badly the boys wanted to be parents. When Rachael told me their surrogate had let them down, I instinctively offered.”

The group drew up a 12-page “intention agreement”, detailing expenses, medical tests, pregnancy supplements and protection – including life and critical illness insurance – for Leanne’s children in the event that anything went wrong. Kevin and Spencer spent £25,000: £6,000 for the cost of Rachael’s egg donation; £6,500 on medical appointments, screening tests (for all four), medication and scans; £2,500 to transfer their embryo to Leanne’s womb; and £10,000 on surrogate expenses. On pregnancy test day, they sat around Leanne’s kitchen table together, dipping the stick in a cup she’d wee’d in.

“This was the next best thing to carrying the baby ourselves,” Spencer says. “We were so involved. Friendship-first gave us trust and openness.” The expectant dads attended scans, sent hampers each trimester – the first contained ginger biscuits and tea for morning sickness – and downloaded an app that allowed them to read bedtime stories for Leanne to play to her belly. 

When her waters broke three months early, at 28 weeks, the responsibility weighed heavily for all. Leanne says, “You don’t want to let anything go wrong. Decisions about what happened next were theirs to make. I felt guilty.” The men felt responsible, too. “Leanne has three children; she had to go home perfect at the end of this,” Spencer says.

Some nurses called Leanne ‘Mum’ which none of us wanted. It felt antiquated
‘There’s not many teams like us out there’: Rachael (left), egg donor, and her sister Leanne (right), surrogate for Kevin (left) and Spencer. Photograph: Silvana Trevale/The Guardian

Leanne was monitored as an outpatient until labour started a month later. When Sawyer arrived, at 2.36am on 6 April, eight weeks premature and weighing 5lb, all four were in the room, Rachael as birthing partner. Sawyer spent 16 days in neonatal intensive care. His fathers stayed by his side but the now familiar outdated legalities meant Leanne had to return for his discharge.

Even once they have left hospital, it is common for surrogates to be contacted by health professionals seeking consent for newborn checks, despite parents being present. Kevin remembers: “Before the birth, our consultant emailed ahead to enforce our right to be there. Some nurses called Leanne ‘Mum’ which none of us wanted. It felt antiquated. I think it’s sexuality and gender more than surrogacy. It took us being by his side for 16 days to prove ourselves, and it shouldn’t be that way.”

After the birth, Leanne was flooded with emotion: “Your body doesn’t know you’re a surrogate; he was premature and my natural instinct was to know he was all right. I talked a lot with Rachael to be sure what I was feeling was OK. The openness and honesty between me and the boys was vital. Once home, I was back to being Leanne again.”

She expressed and froze milk for Sawyer for two weeks before returning to work. Going home from hospital, Kevin and Spencer stopped at her house, “to give her boys the first cuddle,” Spencer says. “They’d been through a lot, too.”

When the friends share their story with others, it is the egg donation that tends to generate the most interest, Kevin says, but for Rachael it represented nothing more than a tiny piece of DNA. “It’s that black and white for me,” she says. “My own children are the ones I’ve created with my husband. The way Kevin and Spencer look at Sawyer is the exact reason I wanted to do this.”

They see each other often and last month shared a Christmas outing and an early New Year’s Eve celebration before Sawyer’s bedtime. “I want our son to know who the two most incredible women on the planet are,” Kevin says. 

“They’ll for ever have that bond with him. The more love he has, the better.”

Back in north-east London, Rachel and Abi echo the sentiment. As the baby goes down for his nap, the friends leaf through a photo book of their pregnancy, created for their children. “I can’t wait for my son to know how many people brought him into the world,” Rachel says. “It’s the biggest act of kindness imaginable; I can never thank her enough.”

Abi smiles. “But you don’t need to thank me,” she says, “because it just feels entirely normal. We were going to be friends for the rest of our lives anyway; it’s just cemented our bond.”


(Source: The Guardian)

Saturday, 27 July 2019

Single women are paying thousands to freeze their eggs – but at what cost?

One cycle means paying up to £8,000 and the birth rate is just 18%. Despite this, women are increasingly choosing this route

Growing numbers of women are choosing to freeze their eggs because they haven’t found the right partner yet – but with the odds of conception so low, is it a waste of money?

Egg freezing is a method of preserving a woman’s fertility so she can try to have children at a later date. It involves collecting her eggs, freezing them and thawing them later so they can be used in treatment. .

Caroline Watson* was in her late 30s and had been single for three years when she started to seriously consider freezing her eggs. “The clock was ticking and I wanted to buy myself some time as I didn’t expect to meet anyone soon to have a child with,” says Watson, a lawyer who lives in London. Aged 39, she froze her eggs, a process that involves a course of injections to stimulate the ovaries to produce eggs that can be extracted and placed in cryogenic storage. She put the £5,000 cost on her credit card.

Five years later and still single, Watson took out a £25,000 personal loan to pay for IVF with a sperm donor in the US, which involved investing in a further egg cycle and embryos transfer. Sadly, it didn’t result in a successful pregnancy. Now, a year later, Watson is still pinning her hopes – and investing substantial amounts of money – on becoming a mother. “I’m 45 and considering using an egg donor with my last sperm ampoule.”

But for now, given the emotional strain, she’s pressing pause. “I need a break as it’s very stressful,” she says.

Watson’s pursuit of motherhood is far from uncommon. An increasing number of single women are choosing to freeze their eggs and, rather than the reason being that they have focused on their career rather than relationships, as some parts of the media have portrayed it, many are doing so because they have not met the person they would like to have children with.

In 2016, 46% of women who froze their eggs did so without a partner, according to the Human Fertilisation & Embryology Authority (HFEA), the UK’s independent regulator for fertility treatment and human embryo research. Meanwhile, more than three-quarters (77%) of women who froze their eggs with The London Women’s Clinic between 2012 and 2016 were single.

“The request for egg freezing for what we call elective or social reasons has taken off,” says Nick Macklon, medical director at the London Women’s Clinic and professor of obstetrics and gynaecology at the University of Copenhagen. “We have seen a demand for egg freezing among single women with a focus on big cities, so it seems to be commonly linked to [living in] an urban competitive environment.

“There’s also a big change not just in attitude and feelings of ‘we don’t need a partner to design our own future’, but also with technology, which means there’s a chance of having a child in a way that we couldn’t a long time ago.”
 Frozen eggs can only be stored for 10 years, unless there is a medical issue. Photograph: Getty Images/Science Photo Library RF

 I felt I was losing my last chance to be a mother. Freezing my eggs seemed like a way of keeping my options open
But as Watson’s credit card and loan show, the process is costly. The average price of one complete egg-freezing cycle, including storage and use of eggs in future treatments, is £7,000 to £8,000, according to the HFEA (egg freezing is only funded by the NHS in cases where, for example, the individual is undergoing treatment for cancer).

However, despite the hefty charges, research from Imperial College London and Chelsea and Westminster hospital shows that the chances of conceiving with the frozen eggs is relatively small. Their statistics show that the proportion of frozen eggs that leads to a live birth among women under 36 is 8.2% – falling to 3.3% for women aged 36 to 39. According to the HFEA, the current birth rate for women trying to conceive from their own frozen eggs is 18%.

“The ideal time to freeze eggs would be about 30-31 – not just for medical reasons, but also social reasons,” says Macklon, pointing out that egg storage only lasts for 10 years unless there is a medical issue.

Despite the high costs and low success rates, many women such as Watson are prepared to get into debt to preserve their fertility.

When Sarah Thompson’s* relationship suddenly ended at 40, she started to panic that she may never have children. “Being a mother was something I felt innately built for,” says Thompson, now 44 and living in Devon. “However, this was not something I wanted to do on my own or to drive into a relationship for solely that gain. I hoped there was time for this to be done the traditional way: being with someone you love.”

But with evidence indicating that egg quality decreases with age, two years later she decided to freeze her eggs. “This was such a big decision for me – not so much on an emotional level, but more on a financial one,” Thompson says. “I had a good job but didn’t earn enough to rent, save for a deposit [for a property] and freeze my eggs. I had no parental or partner financial support, so I had to do it on my own.”

A month later, she put the £7,000 cost of freezing her eggs on two credit cards. “I’m not really a credit card user, but I thought ‘my eggs can’t wait’,” says Thompson, who produced seven eggs, which are now in storage. “My chances were really low. They were straight with me. They told me I have a one in 10 chance [of falling pregnant with those eggs].”

But despite this, she says she has no regrets, adding that she has since met someone with whom she might try to have a baby in the near future.

It was a year after a long-term relationship had ended when Alice Mann*, then 36, decided to freeze her eggs. “As well as mourning the loss of the relationship, I also felt I was losing my last chance to be a mother,” says the author of the Egged On blog. “Freezing my eggs seemed like a way of pressing pause or keeping my options open.”

 It’s a bit like building work– you need to allow for additional costs and spend all you can for success

She says she researched fertility clinics and “was sceptical of those that charged hundreds for an open morning or tried to sell me three-for-two packages”. She eventually plumped for one with a free open morning and 10-minute consultation with the medical director. Over the past five years, the marketing consultant has spent around £50,000 on three cycles of egg freezing, trying to conceive using her frozen eggs and a further three rounds of IVF, all of which have been unsuccessful.

Fortunately for Mann, who lives in London, it hasn’t been a strain financially. “I’m boring and sensible, and I have a good job that pays a decent wage, so I’d been able to save money over the preceding years,” says Mann, now 41.

“In other years that might have gone towards redoing my bathroom or my kitchen, and I guess long term I was saving up to buy a property overseas. But over the last few years those savings have gone towards egg freezing, IVF and associated costs.

“I’m very lucky – I know it’s not an inconsiderable amount of money, but I don’t feel I’ve had to deprive myself of anything to pay for it.”

However, while one door has possibly closed, another has opened. She is now in a relationship with a man she met a year ago. “He’s wonderful and open to having children, so who knows what will happen next?”

Some other women I speak to say they are saving up to preserve their fertility. Gemma Ellis*, a product manager who lives in London, is on the cusp of freezing her eggs. “I’m 35 and in my head that is the cut-off point to freeze my eggs – at 37 it won’t be money as well spent.”

She says that over the past few years she has put away between £300 and £500 a month into a separate account. “I have saved up £10,000, which I was able to do without noticing too much as I had got a new job with a higher salary.”

Anyone opting for egg freezing is advised to ask the clinic they are considering for a breakdown of all the costs before they go ahead with the procedure.

Thompson says she was left frustrated after the clinic she used wasn’t clear about the price. “They said it would cost a certain amount ... they didn’t say that every consultation would be £250 each time. That particular clinic could have been clearer with the breakdown of the costs.”

Similarly, Watson warns that the costs can spiral given the lack of transparency about it.

“Clinics don’t give a good idea of cost as it depends on your drugs and procedures, and your reaction,” she says. “It’s a bit like building work– you need to allow for additional costs and spend all you can for success.”

* Names have been changed

What the experts say
Dr Jane Stewart, chair of the British Fertility Society, advises women to undertake thorough research before forking out substantial sums.

“There’s no guarantee of success and natural fertility still carries a high cumulative pregnancy rate for women who are otherwise fertile,” she says. “Don’t be scared by the fertility statistics – many women conceive in their late 30s and 40s if they don’t have a separate fertility problem, but it can take longer – and for some may not happen. Understanding that helps to make other decisions.”

Egg storage, she says, is an option in the right circumstances, but is not a guarantee and, indeed, may not be needed. Plus, it’s a big investment.

Aileen Feeney, chief executive of the charity Fertility Network, says that as the optimum time, biologically speaking, for a woman to freeze her eggs is before fertility begins to fall at the age of 28, it would like to see the storage limit for egg freezing for non-medical reasons extended beyond the “arbitrary” 10-year limit.

She adds: “This would give women greater flexibility on when to use their frozen eggs. But egg freezing should not be considered a fertility insurance policy, as this does not guarantee success. For example, the fertility of future partners have to be taken into consideration, the eggs may not survive and frozen-egg birth rates are low. Clinics must be transparent on these factors when their patient is considering freezing their eggs, so they are able to make an informed choice as to whether egg freezing is the right decision for them.”

(Source: The Guardian)

Thursday, 11 July 2019

Top fertility doctors got woman pregnant with someone else’s babies, lawsuit alleges

Couple forced to return babies to natural parents after tests confirmed they were not related

A US fertility clinic that brags to be the “mecca of reproductive medicine” got a woman pregnant with someone else’s babies, a lawsuit alleges.

A New York couple of Asian ethnicity, whom the court documents only refer to with their initials to avoid “embarrassment and humiliation”, paid the California-based CHA Fertility Centre tens of thousands of dollars to have children – but then wound up giving birth to non-Asian babies.

Adding insult to injury, the couple even had to relinquish custody to their natural parents after tests confirmed the babies were not genetically related to them.

The incident started to unfold in January 2018, when they decided to travel to California after struggling to have children, the New York Post first reported.
Higher rates of maternal deaths and stillbirths among black mothers are 'tip of the iceberg', experts say ( Getty Images )
They eventually underwent treatment to prepare for In Vitro Fertilisation (IVF) with CHA Fertility, which describes itself as one of the world’s “premier fertility treatment networks” and claims to have “fulfilled the dreams of tens of thousands of aspiring parents from Southern California and beyond in over 22 countries.”

During IVF, an egg is removed from the woman’s ovaries and fertilised with sperm in a laboratory, according to the NHS.

In all, the couple alleges they spent some $100,000 on doctor fees, medication, lab expenses and travel costs.

The couple decided to have two female embryos implanted in August 2018.

But months later, sonograms started signalling that something wasn’t right – they showed the wife was carrying twin boys, not girls.

CHA Fertility allegedly dismissed the results, saying the sonogram was inaccurate.

When the babies were born, it became apparent that they weren’t of Asian descent. DNA tests then revealed that the two boys were not even genetically related to the parents.

The couple was eventually also forced to give custody of the children to their natural parents.

The couple doesn’t know what happened to their actual embryos that were supposed to be used.

They accuse CHA Fertility, its doctors and related companies of medical malpractice, intentionally inflicting emotional distress and other allegations.

CHA Fertility has been contacted for comment.

(Source: The Independent)

Monday, 27 May 2019

IVF couples could be able to choose the ‘smartest’ embryo

US scientist says it will be possible to rank embryos by ‘potential IQ’ within 10 years

Couples undergoing IVF treatment could be given the option to pick the “smartest” embryo within the next 10 years, a leading US scientist has predicted.

Stephen Hsu, senior vice president for research at Michigan State University, said scientific advances mean it will soon be feasible to reliably rank embryos according to potential IQ, posing profound ethical questions for society about whether or not the technology should be adopted.

Hsu’s company, Genomic Prediction, already offers a test aimed at screening out embryos with abnormally low IQ to couples being treated at fertility clinics in the US.

“Accurate IQ predictors will be possible, if not the next five years, the next 10 years certainly,” Hsu told the Guardian. “I predict certain countries will adopt them.”

Genomic Prediction’s tests are not currently available in the UK, but the company is planning to submit an application to the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority by the end of the year, initially to offer a test for risk of type 1 diabetes.

 Embryo selection for IVF. A US scientist says it will soon be feasible to select by IQ. Photograph: Getty Images/Science Photo Library-Zephyr

The prospect of a new generation of genetically selected babies has prompted concerns about unintended medical consequences and the potential for deepening existing social inequalities. The science underpinning the claim that intelligence can be meaningfully predicted by genetic tests is also contentious.

Peter Donnelly, a professor of statistical science at the University of Oxford and CEO of Genomics Plc, said any such IQ predictions should be treated with “huge caution”, adding: “I have grave misgivings about it on ethical grounds. I think it’s a really bad idea.”

Since the 1990s, couples undergoing IVF have been able to screen their embryos for mutations in single genes that cause serious diseases such as cystic fibrosis, as well as conditions like Down’s syndrome, caused by chromosome abnormalities.

Many other traits, including height, physical appearance, intelligence and disease susceptibility, are known to be partly heritable. But because the genetic component is spread thinly over hundreds or even thousands of DNA regions, it has previously been impossible to screen for these traits.

In the past decade, as vast genetic databases have been established, this picture has changed. Through analysing many genes, each making a tiny contribution, it has been possible to calculate what are called polygenic risk scores, which give a person’s likelihood of getting a particular disease or having a certain trait.

Genomic Prediction is the first company to take embryo screening into this grey area of risk forecasting, offering to alert couples if an embryo has an “outlier” score for risk of cancers, diabetes, heart disease, dwarfism or low IQ.

Prediction for IQ is not good enough to give a reliable ranking, but Hsu said that knowing an embryo has a low score could still be desirable.

“Maybe the bottom 1% embryo will grow up to be a great person … even be a scientist, but the odds are against it,” he said. “I honestly feel if we can calculate that score and find a real negative outlier there’s an ethical responsibility for us to report that.”

The company projects that once high-quality genetic and academic achievement data from a million individuals becomes available, expected to be within five to 10 years, it will be able to predict IQ to within about 10 points.

Hsu is reticent about whether screening for high intelligence would be ethically justified, saying: “Let me just decline to answer that at the moment.”

In some countries, such as Singapore, there is likely to be a high level of public acceptance and demand for such tests, he suggested. “I think the overwhelming majority would say yes, absolutely, parents should be allowed to do that,” he said. “Before you write your piece, you might just want to think that a billion people on the other side of the world might have a different view.”

Whether such tests will become available in the UK would depend on approval from the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority (HFEA).

“If the HFEA decides that it’s not right for the UK, I will respect that,” Hsu said, but predicted that “rich people from the UK will fly to Singapore” if they are unable to get the tests locally.

Some in the UK take the view that prospective parents have a right to access such tests. “I don’t think people should be deprived of that knowledge,” said Prof Simon Fishel, the founder of Care Fertility.

Fishel questioned whether there is any ethical difference between picking an embryo ranked highest for IQ or sending a child to a private school. “What’s wrong with ranking an embryo if you can rank a child?” he said. “I think there are plenty of people who’d choose embryo Oxford [rather] than embryo A-level failure.”

In practice, though, couples often have only a few embryos to choose from. Some may face a dilemma when left with just one embryo if it has been deemed less than ideal from a genetic perspective. And there are concerns about unintended consequences. For instance, there is some evidence linking higher polygenic scores for academic ability to higher likelihood of autism.

“If you analysed genetics of managing directors of companies and tried to reproduce that, I don’t think you’d necessarily have a happy generation of people,” said Pete Mills, assistant director of the Nuffield Council on Bioethics. “In pursuing one thing you might take yourself down a path to somewhere that you don’t want to be.”

There are also significant uncertainties about what polygenic scores for intelligence are actually measuring and whether they would be meaningful when applied to genetically related embryos.

“Risk scores for IQ are very hard to interpret and hard to transfer between different countries and different ethnic groups,” said Donnelly. “They’ll be capturing a lot of stuff that isn’t just fundamental biology, maybe genetic markers correlated with ethnicity or where people live.”

“Any kind of implantation choice based on polygenic risk scores is inappropriate, and for intelligence completely inappropriate,” he added.

The technology is controversial, but that does not mean it will not gain acceptance in the future, Hsu said, drawing parallels with the reaction to IVF in its early days.

“The IVF pioneers … were called monsters, Frankenstein doctors; it was predicted that these babies would have health problems,” he said. “I am actually reassured by that. IVF is completely normalised now. Everyone who is pointing their finger at [Genomic Prediction] now should go back and read those articles.”

(Source: The Guardian)

Wednesday, 17 October 2018

The great frozen embryo debate

It’s been 40 years since the first successful IVF birth. Now an estimated one million embryos are on ice in the U.S., but who gets to decide whether these “maybe babies” are human life, a clump of cells, or something in between?

t took less than five minutes to place the embryo in my uterus. Wearing a paper gown and cap, I was led by a nurse to a surgical suite, where I placed my legs in stirrups. I assumed the position, and a second nurse confirmed my identity while someone else inserted a catheter through my cervix. Then a doctor—and this is the term he used—"squirted" a roughly 0.1 millimeter ­bundle of cells into me. After six months of infertility treatment, I was prepared to have some emotional reaction, but it felt more like I was being prepared for a covert science experiment than a much-hoped-for pregnancy.

Then came the photo. As I was wheeled out of the operating room, someone handed me a heavily magnified shot of the embryo printed on glossy paper. I let out the kind of unruly laugh that has no place in a hospital. The seriousness of the moment had been punctured by the arrival of what felt like a souvenir, the kind shilled by amusement parks after a ride on their tallest roller coaster. Visually, it wasn’t much to see: a gray, scaly moon blown up to the size of an Oreo. Still, it was my Oreo moon. I put the picture in the corner of my bedroom mirror and gazed at it while my husband gave me the nightly progesterone shot to help my “maybe baby” survive the precious days after in vitro fertilization. A few weeks later, after I miscarried, I tucked the photo in a drawer where I knew it would get lost but not destroyed.

Four months passed, and it was time to do it all over again. Hair in cap, legs in stirrups, squirt. Afterward I tossed the photo of embryo number two in with the post-op paperwork, uninterested in contemplating its potential. Today I have all the evidence I need in the form of a sturdy one-year-old boy named Levi. But Levi’s very first photo? Yeah, I don’t know where that went.

These are some ambivalent feelings, I know. But the five- day-old embryos often used in IVF can do this to a person. They’re tiny, smaller than a grain of sand, and they give rise to some big emotions and bigger questions. What, really, was I holding a picture of? A person? A speck on a page? A chemistry experiment that could be destined to fail? Forty years after IVF became an option, we’re only beginning to figure that out. “Medically, we know what an embryo is. But what kind of moral and legal status does it have? There isn’t much agreement about that,” says Lisa Campo-Engelstein, Ph.D., an associate professor of bioethics at Albany Medical College in New York, who writes about reproductive ethics. “Are they persons, property, or something in between?”

Even with all the controversy, more and more are using frozen embryos to help build their families: IVF rates continue to rise and cases of donation went from 621 cycles in 2004 to 1,179 cycles in 2014.

And what if your own answer to that question changes? Or your partner disagrees? Ruth Whippman, a 44-year-old author based in northern California, conceived her second son, Zeph, through IVF. At first she rarely thought about the four extra embryos she and her husband kept in the freezer following his birth. But then, about a year later, Whippman found herself sentimentalizing her frozen embryos, or “frosties,” as they’re sometimes referred to on infertility discussion boards.

There are currently an estimated one million frosties in the United States, a source of both hope and stress for potential parents around the country. Research shows that figuring out what to do with unused embryos is a difficult and contentious process: A University of California, San Francisco, study found that one third of people keep their embryos on ice because they are unable to decide what to do with them. Sometimes this is the result of ambivalence; other times it’s because of a disagreement between a couple. “It crept up on me that their genetic material had already been set—whether they had curly hair, were male or female,” Whippman says of her own embryos. “It felt like, These are my kids, and they are in the freezer. As if they didn’t have their coat on and were cold.”

Her husband, Neil, a software product manager, felt little connection to what he calls his “AmEx points,” a reference to the monthly $45 storage fees they paid with their credit card. (Even if clients stop paying those fees, few facilities will dispose of them out of fear of getting sued down the line.)
While Whippman always thought about having three kids, it was the existence of the extra embryos that turned this hazy longing into an undeniable need. She and Neil decided to give their embryos a shot. Two were deemed viable to try, and the second one stuck. Now they are parents to three sons, two of whom were fertilized at the same time—fraternal twins born four years apart. Whippman describes herself as “100 percent pro-choice” and sees no conflict between her feelings about her embryos and a woman’s right to abort them. “These are my emotions for me to deal with about my embryos. That is what choice means,” she says. “The embryos meant totally different things to me and to my husband. To him, they were as close to nothing as you can possibly get. To me, they were as close to everything as you can possibly get.”

Whippman is describing what Campo-Engelstein calls a relational model for embryos, which means their moral status can be defined only by the person or people who created them (or received them through a donation). In this thinking, the embryo doesn’t intrinsically have a moral status. It’s not a little person. It’s also not not a little person. “Embryos are valuable because people value them, not because of their innate worth,” Campo-Engelstein says.

While a “you do you” approach may work in our personal lives, it can be tricky legally. Take, for example, the recent accidental destruction of thousands of frozen eggs and embryos at fertility clinics in San Francisco and Cleveland. There are currently more than 60 pending lawsuits seeking compensation. “How do we explain that loss in legal terms? Some people see them as frozen children; other people see them as bunches of cells,” Campo-Engelstein says. “There’s such a huge spectrum of views that it can be hard to even begin the conversation.” (Of course, this question—When does life begin?—is one people have grappled with for centuries.)

What to do with leftover embryos complicates decisions about whether or not to use frozen embryos at all as well as how to pick among them. For instance, the Internet raged when Chrissy Teigen announced that she and husband John Legend had chosen to transfer a female embryo in 2015 (now their daughter, Luna). Critics were uncomfortable with the couple selecting an embryo based on sex; some saw it as evidence that IVF was paving the way for “designer” babies. (It is not currently possible to single out an embryo for traits like high intelligence, eye color, or a calm demeanor.)

Like a rising number of IVF patients, Teigen and Legend had their embryos tested for chromosomal abnormalities before transferring them. During this process, the sex is revealed, and some patients choose to learn that information. As Teigen saw it, the idea that she should not interfere with fate was ridiculous. By doing IVF, necessary because of the couple’s struggle with infertility, she had already intervened with nature’s plan. On Twitter, she asked, “What is that difference though? I’ve already created embryos with a doctor. Only after must it be random?” Two years later Teigen and Legend used their remaining embryo to become pregnant with their son, Miles.

The Internet raged when Chrissy Teigen announced she and John Legend had chosen to transfer a female embryo in 2015. Critics were uncomfortable with the couple selecting an embryo based on sex; some saw it as evidence that IVF was paving the way for “designer” babies.

The backlash Teigen experienced may be due in part to the mixed messages Americans receive about embryos. Right now, if you have embryos to freeze, you have control over what happens to them next, and there are no laws governing how long you can keep them on ice. On the other hand, the Dickey-Wicker Amendment, signed into law by President Clinton in 1996, bans federal funding for research involving human embryos. The bill’s authors, then representatives Jay Dickey (R–Ark.) and Roger Wicker ­(R–Miss.), opposed such research because of their belief that an embryo is, in fact, a life.

This ban has handicapped infertility research, says ­Barbara Collura, president and CEO of Resolve: The National Infertility Association, a nonprofit advocacy organization. With few exceptions, doctors and scientists working on embryo-related projects are not eligible to apply for the nearly $30 billion worth of grant money from the National Institutes of Health and must rely on funding from other sources. “The fact is, we know more about a mouse embryo than a human embryo,” Collura says. “The embryo is the holy grail, and researchers have their hands tied.”

But even with all the controversy, more and more are using frozen embryos to help build their families: IVF rates continue to rise, and cases of donation went from 621 cycles in 2004 to 1,179 cycles in 2014, according to the Society for Assisted Reproductive Technology. These donations can take place through fertility clinics, embryo banks, or personal connections forged in person or online. As with all embryo-related matters, the experience varies dramatically.

Consider Tina and Benjamin Gibson of Knoxville, Tennessee. Because of Benjamin’s cystic fibrosis, the couple wasn’t able to have biological children and had long been considering creating a ­family through adoption. Then one night Tina’s dad heard about embryo donation on the news and rushed to tell them about it. After some research and deliberation, Tina, a 27-year-old schoolteacher, and Benjamin, a 34-year-old information technologist, decided to give it a shot.

They reached out to a nonprofit in Knoxville, the National Embryo Donation Center. After a few medical tests, the Gibsons were able to choose embryos from the NEDC’s large database of donor profiles. When they went in for their embryo transfer in March 2017, they learned that the donated embryo they were about to use was 24 years old. About a year later, they became the proud parents of the ­longest-known frozen embryo to result in a successful birth. “While we have never had our own biological kids, I can’t imagine feeling any different,” Tina says of Emma. “The connection comes when you make your decision to commit your life to another human.”




The Gibsons were happy to talk about their experience, which was covered in national outlets like CNN and The Atlantic. “When we first thought of embryo adoption, it seemed very strange and unfamiliar. We did a lot of praying and soul-searching about it,” Tina says. Eventually they came to the conclusion that embryo donation is consistent with their anti­abortion outlook. “We really believe this was saving a life. For us, an embryo is a life.”

Many religious Christians share the Gibsons’ belief that life begins at conception, whether it happens in or outside of the womb. IVF patients with these views often try to use or donate all their extra embryos. Another less common option is to have what is known as a compassionate transfer, in which doctors place an embryo in a woman’s womb during a point in her cycle when it’s unlikely to survive.

Others see an embryo more as a rough blueprint for a baby than a baby itself. After Ona Brazwell had received treatment for a rare ovarian cancer, it didn’t look as though the then nearly 40-year-old engineer from Maine would be able to get pregnant. When artificial insemination and IVF with her own egg and donated sperm failed, she found embryo donations.

Brazwell opted for an open donation, as opposed to an anonymous one. That way her potential future children could “know their roots,” she says. She hit dead end after dead end and was in “a dark place” when she saw a post on a surrogacy discussion board: “Seeking Christian Couple for Anonymous Donation.” Brazwell wasn’t Christian, in a relationship, or in pursuit of an anonymous donation. She wrote the couple anyway, and eventually they agreed to an open donation. Today she has twins born from the embryos, a son and a daughter. The children see their embryo donors, whom they call “auntie” and “uncle,” at least once a year.

Since giving birth to her children, Brazwell has been looking into epigenetics, or how certain genes can switch on and off. This happens during pregnancy, when a mother’s mental health, nutrition, and hormones can affect a child’s long-term development. “There’s all sorts of research out there showing that stuff is happening in the womb,” she says. Over the years Brazwell has observed shared physical similarities with her kids—“My daughter looks just like me as a child,” she says—the fact they gestated inside of her makes them, in ways scientists are only beginning to comprehend, also physically hers.

Unlike Brazwell’s or the Gibsons’ donors, I wasn’t willing to recycle my extra embryos. After the miscarriage and Levi, we still had two left over. We don’t want more children, but I also can’t imagine them being born to someone else. Would he have my smile? Would she have my husband’s animated brow? I’d always be looking. (My husband feels otherwise.)

It’s been a year since we sent in the paperwork informing our clinic that we would like our embryos to be used for research in the lab. By now there’s a good chance that our frosties have helped to train an incoming embryologist, or to test a new freezing technique. When friends and family raise eyebrows at this decision, I explain that it costs $1,200 a year to keep an embryo on ice at our clinic, an amount that would better serve our sons’ college funds. But it isn’t just about money. The decision was also borne of a desire to free myself of those nagging what-ifs—What if we implanted those embryos? What if they turned into children? What if I am a terrible person because I don’t want to give them a chance?—and focus on the what is.

There are still days when those questions torment me. But most of the time, when I think about those embryos, I think about what they already brought me: my second child, a child who wasn’t going to come into the world the old-­fashioned way. Levi is where my embryos story ends. And it’s my story to tell.

(Source: Glamour)

Thursday, 4 January 2018

Creating human beings from skin cells

Stem cell research is one of my absolute favorite topics. This amazing field does not only reveal to us how our bodies function and develop, but also holds promising future applications that could help us treat severe diseases, which would not be treated otherwise. However, stem cell research can do more than just treat diseases. In this article, I will highlight the latest scientific breakthroughs to show you how we can turn a simple skin cell into a fully-grown genetically-engineered human being all thanks to the power of stem cells and genetic engineering.

DESPERATE TIMES CALL FOR DESPERATE MEASURES
The field of stem cell research began in 1981 with the discovery of the embryonic stem cells by Martin Evans at Cardiff University, UK. In 1998, stem cells research became a hot topic in the mainstream media after scientists isolated human embryonic stem cells and grew them in the lab for the first time. Due to this breakthrough, stem cell research faced a lot of resistance from the general public. It raised questions about life, consciousness and human rights. At what point does one consider life to begin? If an embryo can develop into an individual, is it justifiable to destroy it or even use it for scientific research? This led the U.S. government to limit the federal funding of research on human embryonic stem cells because these embryos were destroyed in the process.
News headlines from 2001
In the late 1990s, human embryos for stem cell research were either obtained from elective abortions or donated by couples undergoing treatment for infertility In-Vitro Fertilization (IVF). This sparked a lot of controversy among anti-abortion activists who believed that human embryos should be off limits.

Scientists began to look for other ways to create stem cells in order to overcome the ethical concerns and make everyone happy. They were confident about the therapeutic applications of stem cells, so they were determined to keep this field going despite all the restrictions.

ENDLESS SUPPLY OF STEM CELLS
In 2006, Japanese scientist Shinya Yamanaka managed to create embryonic-like cells from adult (mature) cells. This breakthrough was a game changer because it meant that embryos from abortions and IVF will no longer be needed to create stem cells. Instead, we can turn any adult cells into stem cells. By feeding these adult cells a small set of transcription factors (proteins) or reprogramming them genetically, it was possible to revert them to a pluripotent state. A pluripotent state means that these new cells can potentially produce any cell or tissue the body needs to repair itself. This type of cells came to be known as induced pluripotent stem cells (iPSCs or iPS).

This revolutionary technique allowed scientists to turn any cell in the body into induced pluripotent stem cells (iPS) with simple reprogramming techniques. The iPS cells could then be reprogrammed to become certain types of cells in the body. Credit: Genetic Science Learning Center
Time went by and scientists continued to discover new ways to gain full control of stem cells and turn them into any cell in the body. Thanks to the new methods of creating stem cells and the advocacy of their therapeutic applications, the general public began to understand the importance of this field. Because iPS cells are derived from different types of cells in the body, some people felt that genetic reprogramming is more ethical than creating embryonic stem cells from embryos or eggs. In 2009, the U.S. government lifted the 2001 restrictions on the federal funding for human embryonic stem cell research.

THE BEGINNING OF A NEW REVOLUTION
In 2012, researchers announced that they had treated blindness with the help of human embryonic stem cells. Two patients with eye degeneration had their vision improved in the four months after they received implants of retinal pigment epithelial cells made from human embryonic stem cells. That was the tip of the iceberg of what stem cells could offer. More therapeutic applications followed and new treatments were devised for different diseases including – but not limited to – joint injuries, heart disease, spinal cord injury, diabetes, Alzheimer’s disease, kidney disease, brain tumors, and other types of cancer. Just as scientists predicted, stem cell therapy does indeed work! And right now it is becoming a standard procedure to treat different diseases in countries across Europe and Asia.

As soon as the general public, including media, witnessed the wonders of stem cell therapy, they became more supportive to the field.
ADULT VS. EMBRYONIC STEM CELLS
It is very important to understand the difference between adult stem cells and embryonic stem cells. Stem cells are divided into two types in terms of their development potential. Embryonic stem cells are generally more flexible and versatile than adult stem cells. In other words, embryonic stem cells can develop into almost every type of cell in the human body while adult stem cells can give rise to a limited number of cell types. So, embryonic stem cells are the great deal here! If we can create them in the lab, that would change everything forever! Why this is important will come later.

In 2013, scientists converted human skin cells into embryonic stem cells for the first time! The researchers used a cloning technique called Somatic Cell Nuclear Transfer (SCNT), which involves transplanting the nucleus of one cell, containing an individual’s DNA, into an egg cell that has had its genetic material removed. The unfertilized egg cell then develops and eventually produces stem cells. This was a giant leap! But there was one problem: there is an egg involved in the process. We want to avoid using eggs for stem cell research to keep everyone happy and to avoid the controversy.

Later on scientists used a technique called Somatic Cell Nuclear Transfer (SCNT) to create embryonic stem cells, which can develop into almost every type of cell in the human body.  Credit: Genetic Science Learning Center
TURNING SKIN CELLS INTO EGG CELLS AND SPERMS
In 2016, researchers converted mouse skin cells into viable, fertile, mature eggs for the first time! These same eggs were fertilized to create seemingly healthy pups. In order to achieve this, the researchers converted skin cells first into embryonic stem cells, then programmed these cells to become egg cells. This brings me back to the importance of embryonic stem cells. They have more potential and they can give rise to almost any cell type, including egg cells.

Although researchers hope their breakthrough could help us eradicate infertility and allow couples to become the true biological fathers of their babies, there is actually more to it! Instead of extracting eggs from females to create stem cells, this meant we could create unlimited supply of eggs from as many skin cells as possible.

Scientists converted skin cells into egg cells and then used them to create functional embryos, which then developed and gave rise to 6 healthy pups. Credit: Orie Hikabe et al.

But egg cells alone are not enough. We still need sperms. Although males have unlimited supply which they’re prepared to donate for science, it’s best to stay away from all the controversy and keep looking for alternatives. In 2016, scientists created functional sperms from embryonic stem cells. The sperms were then used to fertilize mouse egg cells before implanting the embryos into female mice. The resulting mice appeared healthy and normal, and went on to produce new healthy generations.

Scientists converted embryonic stem cells into functional sperms, then used them to create healthy pups which went on to produce new healthy generation. Credit: Quan Zhou et al.
There is just one limitation here: they directly used embryonic stem cells instead of using skin cells, but that’s okay. In 2016, researchers managed to convert human skin cells into sperms. The skin cells were reprogrammed with the help of a cocktail of genes. Within a month the skin cells were transformed to become a germ cell, which can develop into either a sperm or an egg depending on what you feed them. Their promising study shows that we could actually create functional sperms from skin cells, which can be used to fertilize egg cells.

ARTIFICIAL EMBRYOS FROM STEM CELLS
If you thought sperms and egg cells must make contact to create an embryo, then you probably haven’t heard of the extraordinary breakthrough that was made at the University of Cambridge earlier this year. The researchers were able to create  artificial embryos using two types of stem cells: the embryonic stem cells and extra-embryonic trophoblast stem cells. The extra-embryonic trophoblast stem cells are normally found in the placenta. The mice embryos were created by placing the two types of stem cells onto a specially-designed 3D scaffold. Four and a half days later, the cells on the scaffold began to form what looked like a natural mouse embryo. If such embryos could ever function as much as natural ones, it would be possible to create unlimited supply human embryos from scratch without the need for sperms and eggs. The same embryos could eventually be used to grow human beings with a completely new process.

An artificially created three-dimensional model of a mouse embryo at 96 hours, left, and then an embryo cultured in a test tube for 48 hours from the blastocyst stage, right. The red colour denotes the embryo-like structure while the blue shows extra-embryonic material that would form the placenta. Credit: Sarah Ellys Harrison et al.
CRISPR AND STEM CELL RESEARCH JOIN FORCES
Existing research showed us that turning skin cells into functional embryos that could be used to create full organism is not so complicated after all. But these embryos will still have the same problems that every other ordinary embryo has: they’re susceptible to genetic diseases, they could mutate and eventually experience serious health problems after birth. They may also give rise to ordinary human beings. We’re looking for something more! Something extraordinary! Luckily, this problem is solvable thanks to the power of genetic engineering.

In China you can genetically engineer human embryos if you follow certain guidelines. The rules and regulations there are not as strict as in Europe and the U.S. (see the map below), which is why some scientists migrate to China to take advantage of this situation. Chinese researchers engineer human embryos with the help of CRISPR-cas9, a revolutionary technique that can edit the genome of any cell with a high precision and accuracy.

In 2015, Chinese researchers announced that they had modified a gene linked to a blood disease in human embryos. This was the first time we learned about editing human embryos using CRISPR-cas9. Well, at least the one that was announced. And in 2017, another team in China reported introducing HIV-resistance mutation into human embryos. 4 out of 26 embryos were successfully modified, which proves that editing human embryos might actually work! It could eventually help us fix genetic disorders before a baby is born.

It’s not just in China, it’s actually becoming acceptable in other countries too. Earlier in 2016, the UK granted a group of scientists a permission to edit human embryos. And recently in the U.S., scientists reported the first ever U.S.-based successful attempt at engineering human embryos. They used CRISPR-cas9 to correct a gene mutation that causes a heart condition called hypertrophic cardiomyopathy, and it was a resounding success!

This map shows the legal restrictions on editing human embryos in different countries across the globe. Some countries allow editing human embryos if you follow certain guidelines while some others have ambiguous rules. Source: Araki and Ishii, Reproductive Biology and Endocrinology, 2014.
With all these amazing breakthroughs that we continue to learn about, it shouldn’t take too long before we master the science of re-engineering human embryos. And when that happens, the same techniques could be applied to embryos that have been created from human skin cells. In other words, we will manage to turn human skin cells into fully grown genetically engineered human beings with incredible capabilities beyond our imagination. The common term for them is “designer babies” because they have been customized or “redesigned” to possess certain genetic traits that have been precisely controlled before their birth.

GENETICALLY ENGINEERED HUMAN BEINGS
So, why exactly would we want to genetically engineer the human body? Simple answer: to overcome the limitations of nature and accelerate the new stage of human evolution, one that is controlled by our species itself. We could enhance our intelligence, become more resistant to diseases and provide our bodies new capabilities to counter the challenging environmental problems. Imagine having the absolute power to fully control what your baby would look before his or her birth! And that is just the tip of the iceberg!

Let’s take a simple case of something rather more astonishing. Tardigrades (or water bears) are tiny creatures renowned for their ability to withstand extreme conditions such as space radiation, extreme pressure (six times the pressure of water in the deepest point of the ocean, the Mariana trench). In addition to surviving in the vacuum of space, these creatures can turn themselves into glass to survive complete dehydration. Scientists discovered that these organisms produce a protein that protects them against damaging X-rays. They identified the gene responsible for synthesizing this protein and introduced it to humans cells. The results were incredible! Human cells became more resistant to X-rays and can now suppress X-ray induced damage by about 40%. If we could integrate this ability to a fully grown human being, we would overcome the danger of space radiation and travel to the farthest regions of the cosmos with minimal risks.

By entering a state known as ‘cryptobiosis’, tardigrades become nearly impossible to kill. Credit: Eye of Science
It seems that we will eventually be able to create human beings who combine the best genetic traits of other species. Earlier this year, scientists created the first human-pig hybrid embryos. They called them interspecies chimeras. Researchers hope that these chimeras would eventually allow growing human organs in other animal species before transplanting into those who need them. We have to take into consideration, though, that these interspecies chimeras will someday prove to be useful in creating humans with capabilities beyond what nature intended, and these capabilities will come from other species.

This pig embryo was injected with human cells during its early stage of development and grew to be four weeks old. The success demonstrates a step towards human organs in large animals. Credit: Jun Wu et al.
WHY EMBRYOS?
If we are very serious about making humans more intelligent, why don’t we do it now? If we can create genetically engineered humans who can survive climate change, why don’t we do it on the existing 7.5 billion people? Spoiler alert: it doesn’t work that way.

There is a huge difference between engineering an embryo and engineering an adult human being. Genetic engineering works best on embryos because the number of cells is so low that you can edit all of them with minimal efforts. However, adult humans already have trillions of cells (37.2 trillion cells), editing all of them at once with our current technologies is near impossible. And it probably won’t be achievable for many decades to come.

In addition to that, editing embryos is also better and far more efficient because genetic information can pass through generations. If you genetically engineer an embryo to become someone intelligent, the intelligence will pass from generation to generation. Assuming that you did this to an adult, which is impossible, the intelligence would remain with that particular individual and will die as soon as s/he dies. That’s why we should work with embryos because any genetic traits introduced here will affect the entire species for a very long term.

THE ARTIFICIAL WOMB
There is no doubt that creating functional developing human embryos from skin cells is indeed possible. But let’s take this one step further. Would it ever be possible to implant such embryos into an artificial support system that could replace the mother’s uterus? In other words, allowing the embryo to develop into a full human being without the need for a mother? Let’s find out.

There is a special field for this called ectogenesis where researchers attempt to replicate the exact conditions inside the uterus with the hope of allowing human embryos to develop in similar but completely artificial environments! And the concept isn’t really new. The growth pod where the embryo will develop is called the Artificial Womb, and it was first patented by Emanuel M. Greenberg back in 1955.

The first concept of the artificial womb was designed and patented by
Emanuel M. Greenberg back in 1955.
In terms of design, the artificial womb consists of two main sections: nutrient supply chamber and waste disposal chamber. The nutrient supply chamber is filled with artificial amniotic fluid, which normally surrounds the fetus inside the mother’s uterus. It is needed to sustain the unborn fetus inside the womb. The device is also equipped with a container that provides the fetus with a constant stream of pure oxygenated blood until the moment of birth. The womb provides the ideal temperature for the fetus to develop and grow. Special pumps maintain the circulation of warm water to achieve a constant body temperature. All of this sounds exciting, but would it ever work?

In 1990s, researchers at Tokyo University’s medical department tested the artificial womb to see if it works. They removed a goat fetus from its mother by Caesarean section after 120 days’ gestation, about three-quarters of the way to its full term. Then they placed it in a rubber womb filled with artificial amniotic fluid, and the little guy was delivered 17 days later. You can see footage of the experiment below.


And earlier this year, researchers at the Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia (CHOP) repeated the same experiment with a modified version of the old design of the artificial womb. They placed a premature lamb fetus inside the womb and kept it in the womb for four weeks. After four weeks, the lamb started to grow a wool coat, gained weight, and even opened its eyes. They successfully conducted this experiment on eight lamb fetuses and the results were promising. You can see the footage below.


The artificial womb is mainly designed to help premature babies to continue their development inside an artificial environment that simulates the mother’s uterus. And that’s great! But there is a big difference between placing a premature baby and an embryo in the artificial womb. So far researchers demonstrated success of using the artificial womb to host premature fetuses, what about embryos?

In 2016, researchers managed to keep lab-grown human embryos alive and active beyond the stage when they would naturally implant in a mother’s womb. The developing embryos were intact for 13 days. On day 14, the embryos were destroyed because the rules generally don’t permit growing human embryos for scientific research beyond that stage. Keeping lab-grown embryos alive outside the uterus is the first step towards finding a way to implant them in an artificial womb. So, we will just need one final factor: an artificial support system. Something that can hold the embryo in place. Guess what? It has already been done.

In 2002, researchers built mini artificial wombs that allow embryos to attach themselves and continue to develop. The prototypes were made out of cells extracted from the endometrium, the lining of the womb. These cells were grown into layers that were then used to coat scaffolds of biodegradable material. The scaffolds were modeled into shapes mirroring the interior of the uterus. The experimental embryos successfully attached themselves to the walls of these laboratory wombs and began to grow. However, the experiments were terminated 5 days later due to ethical concerns and “to comply with the In-Vitro Fertilization (IVF) regulations.” Considering that this was done 15 years ago, the same cells that were extracted from the lining of the womb could be recreated now from stem cells with our current technology. This will ensure unlimited supply of such cells to build as many artificial support systems as possible. These mini artificial wombs could be scaled up and integrated into the main growth pod where the fetus will develop; allowing embryos – instead of just premature babies, to take advantage of the system.

A modern design of the artificial womb. Credit: 2070: Edge of Science
A NEW WAY TO CREATE HUMANS
Everything looks great so far. So, let’s put everything together and devise a new procedure to create human babies. First, you start by extracting skin cells from a single human. Age, sex and gender don’t matter. We just want the skin cell. The skin cell will then be cultured in the lab to obtain maximum number of cells. Then we use genetic reprogramming to turn skin cells into embryonic stem cells. Now we have two options:

Option 1: The embryonic stem cells will be divided into two groups. One group will be converted into sperms while the other group will be converted into egg cells. The sperms will be used to fertilize the egg cells to create viable embryos. We screen for the healthiest embryos before moving to the next step. Once we choose healthy embryos, we use CRISPR-cas9 to upgrade their genome and design them according to our own will. We remove the genes that are responsible for diseases and introduce genes that are responsible for good traits. After engineering the embryos, we screen them once again to ensure only a healthy embryo will be chosen. The healthiest embryo will then be implanted directly into the artificial womb. We keep it alive and active until a fully grown human being is ready to be reborn.

Option 2: The embryonic stem cells that were created from skin cells will be converted directly into embryos. The embryos will then be engineered using CRISPR-cas9 and from there we continue the same procedure as in option 1.

A summary of the procedure.
As you can see, every single step of this procedure has already been achieved. The remaining question is, when are we going to test this on humans? It is possible that it had already been tested but we don’t know about the results yet. It’s just a matter of time.

WE CAN DO IT, BUT SHOULD WE?
If you are now in your mid 50s, you will live long enough to see the world’s first synthetic human being come into existence. Creating customized humans will eventually become as normal as the way we look into babies born using IVF procedures. Yes, it will face a huge resistance in the beginning, so did IVF. And where is IVF now? Anyone can do it as long as they can afford it. But the question is, should we really do this? I will answer this question in part 2 of this article series. The second article will go beyond the ethical concerns to discuss whether or not we should do this.

There are around 35 billion skin cells in your body. The fact that these cells could be converted into human beings is really scary! But as long as we have ethical concerns with such techniques, it’s still a while before this procedure becomes normal and widely accepted by most people. And one last thing, the first synthetic human being would probably be born in China where embryonic stem cell research is flourishing thanks to minimal legislative restrictions.

2070: EDGE OF SCIENCE
Earlier this year, I announced a TV show called “2070: Edge of Science“. The project is a collaboration with ZDF Digital, a media production company affiliated with ZDF, the public-service television broadcaster in Germany. In episode one the show will reveal everything discussed in this article using state-of-the-art visual effects to bring you the best experience of what the future would look like. The show will also have more to offer as it will continue to bring the latest breakthroughs and technologies from the world of tomorrow, and all based on scientific research that has been going on for decades. We are currently working on the pilot episode, which will be released online in the near future. We also launched an official website and a few posters to promote the show. You can see them below.



REFERENCES:

  1. Hansen, T., The Nobel Prize in physiology or medicine 2007. Scandinavian journal of immunology, 2007. 66(6): p. 603-603.
  2. Jones, P.B., Funding of human stem cell research by the United States. Electronic Journal of Biotechnology, 2000. 3(1): p. 15-20.
  3. Takahashi, K. and S. Yamanaka, Induction of pluripotent stem cells from mouse embryonic and adult fibroblast cultures by defined factors. cell, 2006. 126(4): p. 663-676.
  4. Holden, C., A first step in relaxing restrictions on stem cell research. Science, 2009. 323(5920): p. 1412-1413.
  5. Schwartz, S.D., et al., Embryonic stem cell trials for macular degeneration: a preliminary report. The Lancet, 2012. 379(9817): p. 713-720.
  6. Stuckey, D.W., et al., Engineering toxin‐resistant therapeutic stem cells to treat brain tumors. Stem cells, 2015. 33(2): p. 589-600.
  7. Uth, K. and D. Trifonov, Stem cell application for osteoarthritis in the knee joint: A minireview. World journal of stem cells, 2014. 6(5): p. 629.
  8. Mozid, A.M., et al., Stem cell therapy for heart diseases. British medical bulletin, 2011. 98(1): p. 143-159.
  9. Vawda, R., J. Wilcox, and M. Fehlings, Current stem cell treatments for spinal cord injury. Indian journal of orthopaedics, 2012. 46(1): p. 10.
  10. ME Abdel-Salam, O., Stem cell therapy for Alzheimer’s disease. CNS & Neurological Disorders-Drug Targets (Formerly Current Drug Targets-CNS & Neurological Disorders), 2011. 10(4): p. 459-485.
  11. Pino, C.J. and H.D. Humes, Stem cell technology for the treatment of acute and chronic renal failure. Translational Research, 2010. 156(3): p. 161-168.
  12. Hikabe, O., et al., Reconstitution in vitro of the entire cycle of the mouse female germ line. Nature, 2016. 539(7628): p. 299-303.
  13. Zhou, Q., et al., Complete meiosis from embryonic stem cell-derived germ cells in vitro. Cell Stem Cell, 2016. 18(3): p. 330-340.
  14. Harrison, S.E., et al., Assembly of embryonic and extraembryonic stem cells to mimic embryogenesis in vitro. Science, 2017. 356(6334): p. eaal1810.
  15. Araki, M. and T. Ishii, International regulatory landscape and integration of corrective genome editing into in vitro fertilization. Reproductive biology and endocrinology, 2014. 12(1): p. 108.
  16. Liang, P., et al., CRISPR/Cas9-mediated gene editing in human tripronuclear zygotes. Protein & cell, 2015. 6(5): p. 363-372.
  17. Kang, X., et al., Introducing precise genetic modifications into human 3PN embryos by CRISPR/Cas-mediated genome editing. Journal of assisted reproduction and genetics, 2016. 33(5): p. 581-588.
  18. Callaway, E., UK scientists gain licence to edit genes in human embryos. 2016.
  19. Ma, H., et al., Correction of a pathogenic gene mutation in human embryos. Nature, 2017. 548(7668): p. 413-419.
  20. Jönsson, K.I., et al., Tardigrades survive exposure to space in low Earth orbit. Current biology, 2008. 18(17): p. R729-R731.
  21. Boothby, T.C., et al., Tardigrades use intrinsically disordered proteins to survive desiccation. Molecular Cell, 2017. 65(6): p. 975-984. e5.
  22. Hashimoto, T., et al., Extremotolerant tardigrade genome and improved radiotolerance of human cultured cells by tardigrade-unique protein. Nature communications, 2016. 7: p. 12808.
  23. Wu, J., et al., Interspecies chimerism with mammalian pluripotent stem cells. Cell, 2017. 168(3): p. 473-486. e15.
  24. Bianconi, E., et al., An estimation of the number of cells in the human body. Annals of human biology, 2013. 40(6): p. 463-471.
  25. Artificial uterus. 1955, Google Patents.
  26. Partridge, E.A., et al., An extra-uterine system to physiologically support the extreme premature lamb. Nature communications, 2017. 8.
  27. Aach, J., et al., Addressing the ethical issues raised by synthetic human entities with embryo-like features. Elife, 2017. 6: p. e20674.
  28. Bulletti, C., et al., The artificial womb. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 2011. 1221(1): p. 124-128.

(Source: Daily Accord)