Showing posts with label embryologist. Show all posts
Showing posts with label embryologist. Show all posts

Wednesday, 17 October 2018

The great frozen embryo debate

It’s been 40 years since the first successful IVF birth. Now an estimated one million embryos are on ice in the U.S., but who gets to decide whether these “maybe babies” are human life, a clump of cells, or something in between?

t took less than five minutes to place the embryo in my uterus. Wearing a paper gown and cap, I was led by a nurse to a surgical suite, where I placed my legs in stirrups. I assumed the position, and a second nurse confirmed my identity while someone else inserted a catheter through my cervix. Then a doctor—and this is the term he used—"squirted" a roughly 0.1 millimeter ­bundle of cells into me. After six months of infertility treatment, I was prepared to have some emotional reaction, but it felt more like I was being prepared for a covert science experiment than a much-hoped-for pregnancy.

Then came the photo. As I was wheeled out of the operating room, someone handed me a heavily magnified shot of the embryo printed on glossy paper. I let out the kind of unruly laugh that has no place in a hospital. The seriousness of the moment had been punctured by the arrival of what felt like a souvenir, the kind shilled by amusement parks after a ride on their tallest roller coaster. Visually, it wasn’t much to see: a gray, scaly moon blown up to the size of an Oreo. Still, it was my Oreo moon. I put the picture in the corner of my bedroom mirror and gazed at it while my husband gave me the nightly progesterone shot to help my “maybe baby” survive the precious days after in vitro fertilization. A few weeks later, after I miscarried, I tucked the photo in a drawer where I knew it would get lost but not destroyed.

Four months passed, and it was time to do it all over again. Hair in cap, legs in stirrups, squirt. Afterward I tossed the photo of embryo number two in with the post-op paperwork, uninterested in contemplating its potential. Today I have all the evidence I need in the form of a sturdy one-year-old boy named Levi. But Levi’s very first photo? Yeah, I don’t know where that went.

These are some ambivalent feelings, I know. But the five- day-old embryos often used in IVF can do this to a person. They’re tiny, smaller than a grain of sand, and they give rise to some big emotions and bigger questions. What, really, was I holding a picture of? A person? A speck on a page? A chemistry experiment that could be destined to fail? Forty years after IVF became an option, we’re only beginning to figure that out. “Medically, we know what an embryo is. But what kind of moral and legal status does it have? There isn’t much agreement about that,” says Lisa Campo-Engelstein, Ph.D., an associate professor of bioethics at Albany Medical College in New York, who writes about reproductive ethics. “Are they persons, property, or something in between?”

Even with all the controversy, more and more are using frozen embryos to help build their families: IVF rates continue to rise and cases of donation went from 621 cycles in 2004 to 1,179 cycles in 2014.

And what if your own answer to that question changes? Or your partner disagrees? Ruth Whippman, a 44-year-old author based in northern California, conceived her second son, Zeph, through IVF. At first she rarely thought about the four extra embryos she and her husband kept in the freezer following his birth. But then, about a year later, Whippman found herself sentimentalizing her frozen embryos, or “frosties,” as they’re sometimes referred to on infertility discussion boards.

There are currently an estimated one million frosties in the United States, a source of both hope and stress for potential parents around the country. Research shows that figuring out what to do with unused embryos is a difficult and contentious process: A University of California, San Francisco, study found that one third of people keep their embryos on ice because they are unable to decide what to do with them. Sometimes this is the result of ambivalence; other times it’s because of a disagreement between a couple. “It crept up on me that their genetic material had already been set—whether they had curly hair, were male or female,” Whippman says of her own embryos. “It felt like, These are my kids, and they are in the freezer. As if they didn’t have their coat on and were cold.”

Her husband, Neil, a software product manager, felt little connection to what he calls his “AmEx points,” a reference to the monthly $45 storage fees they paid with their credit card. (Even if clients stop paying those fees, few facilities will dispose of them out of fear of getting sued down the line.)
While Whippman always thought about having three kids, it was the existence of the extra embryos that turned this hazy longing into an undeniable need. She and Neil decided to give their embryos a shot. Two were deemed viable to try, and the second one stuck. Now they are parents to three sons, two of whom were fertilized at the same time—fraternal twins born four years apart. Whippman describes herself as “100 percent pro-choice” and sees no conflict between her feelings about her embryos and a woman’s right to abort them. “These are my emotions for me to deal with about my embryos. That is what choice means,” she says. “The embryos meant totally different things to me and to my husband. To him, they were as close to nothing as you can possibly get. To me, they were as close to everything as you can possibly get.”

Whippman is describing what Campo-Engelstein calls a relational model for embryos, which means their moral status can be defined only by the person or people who created them (or received them through a donation). In this thinking, the embryo doesn’t intrinsically have a moral status. It’s not a little person. It’s also not not a little person. “Embryos are valuable because people value them, not because of their innate worth,” Campo-Engelstein says.

While a “you do you” approach may work in our personal lives, it can be tricky legally. Take, for example, the recent accidental destruction of thousands of frozen eggs and embryos at fertility clinics in San Francisco and Cleveland. There are currently more than 60 pending lawsuits seeking compensation. “How do we explain that loss in legal terms? Some people see them as frozen children; other people see them as bunches of cells,” Campo-Engelstein says. “There’s such a huge spectrum of views that it can be hard to even begin the conversation.” (Of course, this question—When does life begin?—is one people have grappled with for centuries.)

What to do with leftover embryos complicates decisions about whether or not to use frozen embryos at all as well as how to pick among them. For instance, the Internet raged when Chrissy Teigen announced that she and husband John Legend had chosen to transfer a female embryo in 2015 (now their daughter, Luna). Critics were uncomfortable with the couple selecting an embryo based on sex; some saw it as evidence that IVF was paving the way for “designer” babies. (It is not currently possible to single out an embryo for traits like high intelligence, eye color, or a calm demeanor.)

Like a rising number of IVF patients, Teigen and Legend had their embryos tested for chromosomal abnormalities before transferring them. During this process, the sex is revealed, and some patients choose to learn that information. As Teigen saw it, the idea that she should not interfere with fate was ridiculous. By doing IVF, necessary because of the couple’s struggle with infertility, she had already intervened with nature’s plan. On Twitter, she asked, “What is that difference though? I’ve already created embryos with a doctor. Only after must it be random?” Two years later Teigen and Legend used their remaining embryo to become pregnant with their son, Miles.

The Internet raged when Chrissy Teigen announced she and John Legend had chosen to transfer a female embryo in 2015. Critics were uncomfortable with the couple selecting an embryo based on sex; some saw it as evidence that IVF was paving the way for “designer” babies.

The backlash Teigen experienced may be due in part to the mixed messages Americans receive about embryos. Right now, if you have embryos to freeze, you have control over what happens to them next, and there are no laws governing how long you can keep them on ice. On the other hand, the Dickey-Wicker Amendment, signed into law by President Clinton in 1996, bans federal funding for research involving human embryos. The bill’s authors, then representatives Jay Dickey (R–Ark.) and Roger Wicker ­(R–Miss.), opposed such research because of their belief that an embryo is, in fact, a life.

This ban has handicapped infertility research, says ­Barbara Collura, president and CEO of Resolve: The National Infertility Association, a nonprofit advocacy organization. With few exceptions, doctors and scientists working on embryo-related projects are not eligible to apply for the nearly $30 billion worth of grant money from the National Institutes of Health and must rely on funding from other sources. “The fact is, we know more about a mouse embryo than a human embryo,” Collura says. “The embryo is the holy grail, and researchers have their hands tied.”

But even with all the controversy, more and more are using frozen embryos to help build their families: IVF rates continue to rise, and cases of donation went from 621 cycles in 2004 to 1,179 cycles in 2014, according to the Society for Assisted Reproductive Technology. These donations can take place through fertility clinics, embryo banks, or personal connections forged in person or online. As with all embryo-related matters, the experience varies dramatically.

Consider Tina and Benjamin Gibson of Knoxville, Tennessee. Because of Benjamin’s cystic fibrosis, the couple wasn’t able to have biological children and had long been considering creating a ­family through adoption. Then one night Tina’s dad heard about embryo donation on the news and rushed to tell them about it. After some research and deliberation, Tina, a 27-year-old schoolteacher, and Benjamin, a 34-year-old information technologist, decided to give it a shot.

They reached out to a nonprofit in Knoxville, the National Embryo Donation Center. After a few medical tests, the Gibsons were able to choose embryos from the NEDC’s large database of donor profiles. When they went in for their embryo transfer in March 2017, they learned that the donated embryo they were about to use was 24 years old. About a year later, they became the proud parents of the ­longest-known frozen embryo to result in a successful birth. “While we have never had our own biological kids, I can’t imagine feeling any different,” Tina says of Emma. “The connection comes when you make your decision to commit your life to another human.”




The Gibsons were happy to talk about their experience, which was covered in national outlets like CNN and The Atlantic. “When we first thought of embryo adoption, it seemed very strange and unfamiliar. We did a lot of praying and soul-searching about it,” Tina says. Eventually they came to the conclusion that embryo donation is consistent with their anti­abortion outlook. “We really believe this was saving a life. For us, an embryo is a life.”

Many religious Christians share the Gibsons’ belief that life begins at conception, whether it happens in or outside of the womb. IVF patients with these views often try to use or donate all their extra embryos. Another less common option is to have what is known as a compassionate transfer, in which doctors place an embryo in a woman’s womb during a point in her cycle when it’s unlikely to survive.

Others see an embryo more as a rough blueprint for a baby than a baby itself. After Ona Brazwell had received treatment for a rare ovarian cancer, it didn’t look as though the then nearly 40-year-old engineer from Maine would be able to get pregnant. When artificial insemination and IVF with her own egg and donated sperm failed, she found embryo donations.

Brazwell opted for an open donation, as opposed to an anonymous one. That way her potential future children could “know their roots,” she says. She hit dead end after dead end and was in “a dark place” when she saw a post on a surrogacy discussion board: “Seeking Christian Couple for Anonymous Donation.” Brazwell wasn’t Christian, in a relationship, or in pursuit of an anonymous donation. She wrote the couple anyway, and eventually they agreed to an open donation. Today she has twins born from the embryos, a son and a daughter. The children see their embryo donors, whom they call “auntie” and “uncle,” at least once a year.

Since giving birth to her children, Brazwell has been looking into epigenetics, or how certain genes can switch on and off. This happens during pregnancy, when a mother’s mental health, nutrition, and hormones can affect a child’s long-term development. “There’s all sorts of research out there showing that stuff is happening in the womb,” she says. Over the years Brazwell has observed shared physical similarities with her kids—“My daughter looks just like me as a child,” she says—the fact they gestated inside of her makes them, in ways scientists are only beginning to comprehend, also physically hers.

Unlike Brazwell’s or the Gibsons’ donors, I wasn’t willing to recycle my extra embryos. After the miscarriage and Levi, we still had two left over. We don’t want more children, but I also can’t imagine them being born to someone else. Would he have my smile? Would she have my husband’s animated brow? I’d always be looking. (My husband feels otherwise.)

It’s been a year since we sent in the paperwork informing our clinic that we would like our embryos to be used for research in the lab. By now there’s a good chance that our frosties have helped to train an incoming embryologist, or to test a new freezing technique. When friends and family raise eyebrows at this decision, I explain that it costs $1,200 a year to keep an embryo on ice at our clinic, an amount that would better serve our sons’ college funds. But it isn’t just about money. The decision was also borne of a desire to free myself of those nagging what-ifs—What if we implanted those embryos? What if they turned into children? What if I am a terrible person because I don’t want to give them a chance?—and focus on the what is.

There are still days when those questions torment me. But most of the time, when I think about those embryos, I think about what they already brought me: my second child, a child who wasn’t going to come into the world the old-­fashioned way. Levi is where my embryos story ends. And it’s my story to tell.

(Source: Glamour)

Thursday, 4 January 2018

Creating human beings from skin cells

Stem cell research is one of my absolute favorite topics. This amazing field does not only reveal to us how our bodies function and develop, but also holds promising future applications that could help us treat severe diseases, which would not be treated otherwise. However, stem cell research can do more than just treat diseases. In this article, I will highlight the latest scientific breakthroughs to show you how we can turn a simple skin cell into a fully-grown genetically-engineered human being all thanks to the power of stem cells and genetic engineering.

DESPERATE TIMES CALL FOR DESPERATE MEASURES
The field of stem cell research began in 1981 with the discovery of the embryonic stem cells by Martin Evans at Cardiff University, UK. In 1998, stem cells research became a hot topic in the mainstream media after scientists isolated human embryonic stem cells and grew them in the lab for the first time. Due to this breakthrough, stem cell research faced a lot of resistance from the general public. It raised questions about life, consciousness and human rights. At what point does one consider life to begin? If an embryo can develop into an individual, is it justifiable to destroy it or even use it for scientific research? This led the U.S. government to limit the federal funding of research on human embryonic stem cells because these embryos were destroyed in the process.
News headlines from 2001
In the late 1990s, human embryos for stem cell research were either obtained from elective abortions or donated by couples undergoing treatment for infertility In-Vitro Fertilization (IVF). This sparked a lot of controversy among anti-abortion activists who believed that human embryos should be off limits.

Scientists began to look for other ways to create stem cells in order to overcome the ethical concerns and make everyone happy. They were confident about the therapeutic applications of stem cells, so they were determined to keep this field going despite all the restrictions.

ENDLESS SUPPLY OF STEM CELLS
In 2006, Japanese scientist Shinya Yamanaka managed to create embryonic-like cells from adult (mature) cells. This breakthrough was a game changer because it meant that embryos from abortions and IVF will no longer be needed to create stem cells. Instead, we can turn any adult cells into stem cells. By feeding these adult cells a small set of transcription factors (proteins) or reprogramming them genetically, it was possible to revert them to a pluripotent state. A pluripotent state means that these new cells can potentially produce any cell or tissue the body needs to repair itself. This type of cells came to be known as induced pluripotent stem cells (iPSCs or iPS).

This revolutionary technique allowed scientists to turn any cell in the body into induced pluripotent stem cells (iPS) with simple reprogramming techniques. The iPS cells could then be reprogrammed to become certain types of cells in the body. Credit: Genetic Science Learning Center
Time went by and scientists continued to discover new ways to gain full control of stem cells and turn them into any cell in the body. Thanks to the new methods of creating stem cells and the advocacy of their therapeutic applications, the general public began to understand the importance of this field. Because iPS cells are derived from different types of cells in the body, some people felt that genetic reprogramming is more ethical than creating embryonic stem cells from embryos or eggs. In 2009, the U.S. government lifted the 2001 restrictions on the federal funding for human embryonic stem cell research.

THE BEGINNING OF A NEW REVOLUTION
In 2012, researchers announced that they had treated blindness with the help of human embryonic stem cells. Two patients with eye degeneration had their vision improved in the four months after they received implants of retinal pigment epithelial cells made from human embryonic stem cells. That was the tip of the iceberg of what stem cells could offer. More therapeutic applications followed and new treatments were devised for different diseases including – but not limited to – joint injuries, heart disease, spinal cord injury, diabetes, Alzheimer’s disease, kidney disease, brain tumors, and other types of cancer. Just as scientists predicted, stem cell therapy does indeed work! And right now it is becoming a standard procedure to treat different diseases in countries across Europe and Asia.

As soon as the general public, including media, witnessed the wonders of stem cell therapy, they became more supportive to the field.
ADULT VS. EMBRYONIC STEM CELLS
It is very important to understand the difference between adult stem cells and embryonic stem cells. Stem cells are divided into two types in terms of their development potential. Embryonic stem cells are generally more flexible and versatile than adult stem cells. In other words, embryonic stem cells can develop into almost every type of cell in the human body while adult stem cells can give rise to a limited number of cell types. So, embryonic stem cells are the great deal here! If we can create them in the lab, that would change everything forever! Why this is important will come later.

In 2013, scientists converted human skin cells into embryonic stem cells for the first time! The researchers used a cloning technique called Somatic Cell Nuclear Transfer (SCNT), which involves transplanting the nucleus of one cell, containing an individual’s DNA, into an egg cell that has had its genetic material removed. The unfertilized egg cell then develops and eventually produces stem cells. This was a giant leap! But there was one problem: there is an egg involved in the process. We want to avoid using eggs for stem cell research to keep everyone happy and to avoid the controversy.

Later on scientists used a technique called Somatic Cell Nuclear Transfer (SCNT) to create embryonic stem cells, which can develop into almost every type of cell in the human body.  Credit: Genetic Science Learning Center
TURNING SKIN CELLS INTO EGG CELLS AND SPERMS
In 2016, researchers converted mouse skin cells into viable, fertile, mature eggs for the first time! These same eggs were fertilized to create seemingly healthy pups. In order to achieve this, the researchers converted skin cells first into embryonic stem cells, then programmed these cells to become egg cells. This brings me back to the importance of embryonic stem cells. They have more potential and they can give rise to almost any cell type, including egg cells.

Although researchers hope their breakthrough could help us eradicate infertility and allow couples to become the true biological fathers of their babies, there is actually more to it! Instead of extracting eggs from females to create stem cells, this meant we could create unlimited supply of eggs from as many skin cells as possible.

Scientists converted skin cells into egg cells and then used them to create functional embryos, which then developed and gave rise to 6 healthy pups. Credit: Orie Hikabe et al.

But egg cells alone are not enough. We still need sperms. Although males have unlimited supply which they’re prepared to donate for science, it’s best to stay away from all the controversy and keep looking for alternatives. In 2016, scientists created functional sperms from embryonic stem cells. The sperms were then used to fertilize mouse egg cells before implanting the embryos into female mice. The resulting mice appeared healthy and normal, and went on to produce new healthy generations.

Scientists converted embryonic stem cells into functional sperms, then used them to create healthy pups which went on to produce new healthy generation. Credit: Quan Zhou et al.
There is just one limitation here: they directly used embryonic stem cells instead of using skin cells, but that’s okay. In 2016, researchers managed to convert human skin cells into sperms. The skin cells were reprogrammed with the help of a cocktail of genes. Within a month the skin cells were transformed to become a germ cell, which can develop into either a sperm or an egg depending on what you feed them. Their promising study shows that we could actually create functional sperms from skin cells, which can be used to fertilize egg cells.

ARTIFICIAL EMBRYOS FROM STEM CELLS
If you thought sperms and egg cells must make contact to create an embryo, then you probably haven’t heard of the extraordinary breakthrough that was made at the University of Cambridge earlier this year. The researchers were able to create  artificial embryos using two types of stem cells: the embryonic stem cells and extra-embryonic trophoblast stem cells. The extra-embryonic trophoblast stem cells are normally found in the placenta. The mice embryos were created by placing the two types of stem cells onto a specially-designed 3D scaffold. Four and a half days later, the cells on the scaffold began to form what looked like a natural mouse embryo. If such embryos could ever function as much as natural ones, it would be possible to create unlimited supply human embryos from scratch without the need for sperms and eggs. The same embryos could eventually be used to grow human beings with a completely new process.

An artificially created three-dimensional model of a mouse embryo at 96 hours, left, and then an embryo cultured in a test tube for 48 hours from the blastocyst stage, right. The red colour denotes the embryo-like structure while the blue shows extra-embryonic material that would form the placenta. Credit: Sarah Ellys Harrison et al.
CRISPR AND STEM CELL RESEARCH JOIN FORCES
Existing research showed us that turning skin cells into functional embryos that could be used to create full organism is not so complicated after all. But these embryos will still have the same problems that every other ordinary embryo has: they’re susceptible to genetic diseases, they could mutate and eventually experience serious health problems after birth. They may also give rise to ordinary human beings. We’re looking for something more! Something extraordinary! Luckily, this problem is solvable thanks to the power of genetic engineering.

In China you can genetically engineer human embryos if you follow certain guidelines. The rules and regulations there are not as strict as in Europe and the U.S. (see the map below), which is why some scientists migrate to China to take advantage of this situation. Chinese researchers engineer human embryos with the help of CRISPR-cas9, a revolutionary technique that can edit the genome of any cell with a high precision and accuracy.

In 2015, Chinese researchers announced that they had modified a gene linked to a blood disease in human embryos. This was the first time we learned about editing human embryos using CRISPR-cas9. Well, at least the one that was announced. And in 2017, another team in China reported introducing HIV-resistance mutation into human embryos. 4 out of 26 embryos were successfully modified, which proves that editing human embryos might actually work! It could eventually help us fix genetic disorders before a baby is born.

It’s not just in China, it’s actually becoming acceptable in other countries too. Earlier in 2016, the UK granted a group of scientists a permission to edit human embryos. And recently in the U.S., scientists reported the first ever U.S.-based successful attempt at engineering human embryos. They used CRISPR-cas9 to correct a gene mutation that causes a heart condition called hypertrophic cardiomyopathy, and it was a resounding success!

This map shows the legal restrictions on editing human embryos in different countries across the globe. Some countries allow editing human embryos if you follow certain guidelines while some others have ambiguous rules. Source: Araki and Ishii, Reproductive Biology and Endocrinology, 2014.
With all these amazing breakthroughs that we continue to learn about, it shouldn’t take too long before we master the science of re-engineering human embryos. And when that happens, the same techniques could be applied to embryos that have been created from human skin cells. In other words, we will manage to turn human skin cells into fully grown genetically engineered human beings with incredible capabilities beyond our imagination. The common term for them is “designer babies” because they have been customized or “redesigned” to possess certain genetic traits that have been precisely controlled before their birth.

GENETICALLY ENGINEERED HUMAN BEINGS
So, why exactly would we want to genetically engineer the human body? Simple answer: to overcome the limitations of nature and accelerate the new stage of human evolution, one that is controlled by our species itself. We could enhance our intelligence, become more resistant to diseases and provide our bodies new capabilities to counter the challenging environmental problems. Imagine having the absolute power to fully control what your baby would look before his or her birth! And that is just the tip of the iceberg!

Let’s take a simple case of something rather more astonishing. Tardigrades (or water bears) are tiny creatures renowned for their ability to withstand extreme conditions such as space radiation, extreme pressure (six times the pressure of water in the deepest point of the ocean, the Mariana trench). In addition to surviving in the vacuum of space, these creatures can turn themselves into glass to survive complete dehydration. Scientists discovered that these organisms produce a protein that protects them against damaging X-rays. They identified the gene responsible for synthesizing this protein and introduced it to humans cells. The results were incredible! Human cells became more resistant to X-rays and can now suppress X-ray induced damage by about 40%. If we could integrate this ability to a fully grown human being, we would overcome the danger of space radiation and travel to the farthest regions of the cosmos with minimal risks.

By entering a state known as ‘cryptobiosis’, tardigrades become nearly impossible to kill. Credit: Eye of Science
It seems that we will eventually be able to create human beings who combine the best genetic traits of other species. Earlier this year, scientists created the first human-pig hybrid embryos. They called them interspecies chimeras. Researchers hope that these chimeras would eventually allow growing human organs in other animal species before transplanting into those who need them. We have to take into consideration, though, that these interspecies chimeras will someday prove to be useful in creating humans with capabilities beyond what nature intended, and these capabilities will come from other species.

This pig embryo was injected with human cells during its early stage of development and grew to be four weeks old. The success demonstrates a step towards human organs in large animals. Credit: Jun Wu et al.
WHY EMBRYOS?
If we are very serious about making humans more intelligent, why don’t we do it now? If we can create genetically engineered humans who can survive climate change, why don’t we do it on the existing 7.5 billion people? Spoiler alert: it doesn’t work that way.

There is a huge difference between engineering an embryo and engineering an adult human being. Genetic engineering works best on embryos because the number of cells is so low that you can edit all of them with minimal efforts. However, adult humans already have trillions of cells (37.2 trillion cells), editing all of them at once with our current technologies is near impossible. And it probably won’t be achievable for many decades to come.

In addition to that, editing embryos is also better and far more efficient because genetic information can pass through generations. If you genetically engineer an embryo to become someone intelligent, the intelligence will pass from generation to generation. Assuming that you did this to an adult, which is impossible, the intelligence would remain with that particular individual and will die as soon as s/he dies. That’s why we should work with embryos because any genetic traits introduced here will affect the entire species for a very long term.

THE ARTIFICIAL WOMB
There is no doubt that creating functional developing human embryos from skin cells is indeed possible. But let’s take this one step further. Would it ever be possible to implant such embryos into an artificial support system that could replace the mother’s uterus? In other words, allowing the embryo to develop into a full human being without the need for a mother? Let’s find out.

There is a special field for this called ectogenesis where researchers attempt to replicate the exact conditions inside the uterus with the hope of allowing human embryos to develop in similar but completely artificial environments! And the concept isn’t really new. The growth pod where the embryo will develop is called the Artificial Womb, and it was first patented by Emanuel M. Greenberg back in 1955.

The first concept of the artificial womb was designed and patented by
Emanuel M. Greenberg back in 1955.
In terms of design, the artificial womb consists of two main sections: nutrient supply chamber and waste disposal chamber. The nutrient supply chamber is filled with artificial amniotic fluid, which normally surrounds the fetus inside the mother’s uterus. It is needed to sustain the unborn fetus inside the womb. The device is also equipped with a container that provides the fetus with a constant stream of pure oxygenated blood until the moment of birth. The womb provides the ideal temperature for the fetus to develop and grow. Special pumps maintain the circulation of warm water to achieve a constant body temperature. All of this sounds exciting, but would it ever work?

In 1990s, researchers at Tokyo University’s medical department tested the artificial womb to see if it works. They removed a goat fetus from its mother by Caesarean section after 120 days’ gestation, about three-quarters of the way to its full term. Then they placed it in a rubber womb filled with artificial amniotic fluid, and the little guy was delivered 17 days later. You can see footage of the experiment below.


And earlier this year, researchers at the Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia (CHOP) repeated the same experiment with a modified version of the old design of the artificial womb. They placed a premature lamb fetus inside the womb and kept it in the womb for four weeks. After four weeks, the lamb started to grow a wool coat, gained weight, and even opened its eyes. They successfully conducted this experiment on eight lamb fetuses and the results were promising. You can see the footage below.


The artificial womb is mainly designed to help premature babies to continue their development inside an artificial environment that simulates the mother’s uterus. And that’s great! But there is a big difference between placing a premature baby and an embryo in the artificial womb. So far researchers demonstrated success of using the artificial womb to host premature fetuses, what about embryos?

In 2016, researchers managed to keep lab-grown human embryos alive and active beyond the stage when they would naturally implant in a mother’s womb. The developing embryos were intact for 13 days. On day 14, the embryos were destroyed because the rules generally don’t permit growing human embryos for scientific research beyond that stage. Keeping lab-grown embryos alive outside the uterus is the first step towards finding a way to implant them in an artificial womb. So, we will just need one final factor: an artificial support system. Something that can hold the embryo in place. Guess what? It has already been done.

In 2002, researchers built mini artificial wombs that allow embryos to attach themselves and continue to develop. The prototypes were made out of cells extracted from the endometrium, the lining of the womb. These cells were grown into layers that were then used to coat scaffolds of biodegradable material. The scaffolds were modeled into shapes mirroring the interior of the uterus. The experimental embryos successfully attached themselves to the walls of these laboratory wombs and began to grow. However, the experiments were terminated 5 days later due to ethical concerns and “to comply with the In-Vitro Fertilization (IVF) regulations.” Considering that this was done 15 years ago, the same cells that were extracted from the lining of the womb could be recreated now from stem cells with our current technology. This will ensure unlimited supply of such cells to build as many artificial support systems as possible. These mini artificial wombs could be scaled up and integrated into the main growth pod where the fetus will develop; allowing embryos – instead of just premature babies, to take advantage of the system.

A modern design of the artificial womb. Credit: 2070: Edge of Science
A NEW WAY TO CREATE HUMANS
Everything looks great so far. So, let’s put everything together and devise a new procedure to create human babies. First, you start by extracting skin cells from a single human. Age, sex and gender don’t matter. We just want the skin cell. The skin cell will then be cultured in the lab to obtain maximum number of cells. Then we use genetic reprogramming to turn skin cells into embryonic stem cells. Now we have two options:

Option 1: The embryonic stem cells will be divided into two groups. One group will be converted into sperms while the other group will be converted into egg cells. The sperms will be used to fertilize the egg cells to create viable embryos. We screen for the healthiest embryos before moving to the next step. Once we choose healthy embryos, we use CRISPR-cas9 to upgrade their genome and design them according to our own will. We remove the genes that are responsible for diseases and introduce genes that are responsible for good traits. After engineering the embryos, we screen them once again to ensure only a healthy embryo will be chosen. The healthiest embryo will then be implanted directly into the artificial womb. We keep it alive and active until a fully grown human being is ready to be reborn.

Option 2: The embryonic stem cells that were created from skin cells will be converted directly into embryos. The embryos will then be engineered using CRISPR-cas9 and from there we continue the same procedure as in option 1.

A summary of the procedure.
As you can see, every single step of this procedure has already been achieved. The remaining question is, when are we going to test this on humans? It is possible that it had already been tested but we don’t know about the results yet. It’s just a matter of time.

WE CAN DO IT, BUT SHOULD WE?
If you are now in your mid 50s, you will live long enough to see the world’s first synthetic human being come into existence. Creating customized humans will eventually become as normal as the way we look into babies born using IVF procedures. Yes, it will face a huge resistance in the beginning, so did IVF. And where is IVF now? Anyone can do it as long as they can afford it. But the question is, should we really do this? I will answer this question in part 2 of this article series. The second article will go beyond the ethical concerns to discuss whether or not we should do this.

There are around 35 billion skin cells in your body. The fact that these cells could be converted into human beings is really scary! But as long as we have ethical concerns with such techniques, it’s still a while before this procedure becomes normal and widely accepted by most people. And one last thing, the first synthetic human being would probably be born in China where embryonic stem cell research is flourishing thanks to minimal legislative restrictions.

2070: EDGE OF SCIENCE
Earlier this year, I announced a TV show called “2070: Edge of Science“. The project is a collaboration with ZDF Digital, a media production company affiliated with ZDF, the public-service television broadcaster in Germany. In episode one the show will reveal everything discussed in this article using state-of-the-art visual effects to bring you the best experience of what the future would look like. The show will also have more to offer as it will continue to bring the latest breakthroughs and technologies from the world of tomorrow, and all based on scientific research that has been going on for decades. We are currently working on the pilot episode, which will be released online in the near future. We also launched an official website and a few posters to promote the show. You can see them below.



REFERENCES:

  1. Hansen, T., The Nobel Prize in physiology or medicine 2007. Scandinavian journal of immunology, 2007. 66(6): p. 603-603.
  2. Jones, P.B., Funding of human stem cell research by the United States. Electronic Journal of Biotechnology, 2000. 3(1): p. 15-20.
  3. Takahashi, K. and S. Yamanaka, Induction of pluripotent stem cells from mouse embryonic and adult fibroblast cultures by defined factors. cell, 2006. 126(4): p. 663-676.
  4. Holden, C., A first step in relaxing restrictions on stem cell research. Science, 2009. 323(5920): p. 1412-1413.
  5. Schwartz, S.D., et al., Embryonic stem cell trials for macular degeneration: a preliminary report. The Lancet, 2012. 379(9817): p. 713-720.
  6. Stuckey, D.W., et al., Engineering toxin‐resistant therapeutic stem cells to treat brain tumors. Stem cells, 2015. 33(2): p. 589-600.
  7. Uth, K. and D. Trifonov, Stem cell application for osteoarthritis in the knee joint: A minireview. World journal of stem cells, 2014. 6(5): p. 629.
  8. Mozid, A.M., et al., Stem cell therapy for heart diseases. British medical bulletin, 2011. 98(1): p. 143-159.
  9. Vawda, R., J. Wilcox, and M. Fehlings, Current stem cell treatments for spinal cord injury. Indian journal of orthopaedics, 2012. 46(1): p. 10.
  10. ME Abdel-Salam, O., Stem cell therapy for Alzheimer’s disease. CNS & Neurological Disorders-Drug Targets (Formerly Current Drug Targets-CNS & Neurological Disorders), 2011. 10(4): p. 459-485.
  11. Pino, C.J. and H.D. Humes, Stem cell technology for the treatment of acute and chronic renal failure. Translational Research, 2010. 156(3): p. 161-168.
  12. Hikabe, O., et al., Reconstitution in vitro of the entire cycle of the mouse female germ line. Nature, 2016. 539(7628): p. 299-303.
  13. Zhou, Q., et al., Complete meiosis from embryonic stem cell-derived germ cells in vitro. Cell Stem Cell, 2016. 18(3): p. 330-340.
  14. Harrison, S.E., et al., Assembly of embryonic and extraembryonic stem cells to mimic embryogenesis in vitro. Science, 2017. 356(6334): p. eaal1810.
  15. Araki, M. and T. Ishii, International regulatory landscape and integration of corrective genome editing into in vitro fertilization. Reproductive biology and endocrinology, 2014. 12(1): p. 108.
  16. Liang, P., et al., CRISPR/Cas9-mediated gene editing in human tripronuclear zygotes. Protein & cell, 2015. 6(5): p. 363-372.
  17. Kang, X., et al., Introducing precise genetic modifications into human 3PN embryos by CRISPR/Cas-mediated genome editing. Journal of assisted reproduction and genetics, 2016. 33(5): p. 581-588.
  18. Callaway, E., UK scientists gain licence to edit genes in human embryos. 2016.
  19. Ma, H., et al., Correction of a pathogenic gene mutation in human embryos. Nature, 2017. 548(7668): p. 413-419.
  20. Jönsson, K.I., et al., Tardigrades survive exposure to space in low Earth orbit. Current biology, 2008. 18(17): p. R729-R731.
  21. Boothby, T.C., et al., Tardigrades use intrinsically disordered proteins to survive desiccation. Molecular Cell, 2017. 65(6): p. 975-984. e5.
  22. Hashimoto, T., et al., Extremotolerant tardigrade genome and improved radiotolerance of human cultured cells by tardigrade-unique protein. Nature communications, 2016. 7: p. 12808.
  23. Wu, J., et al., Interspecies chimerism with mammalian pluripotent stem cells. Cell, 2017. 168(3): p. 473-486. e15.
  24. Bianconi, E., et al., An estimation of the number of cells in the human body. Annals of human biology, 2013. 40(6): p. 463-471.
  25. Artificial uterus. 1955, Google Patents.
  26. Partridge, E.A., et al., An extra-uterine system to physiologically support the extreme premature lamb. Nature communications, 2017. 8.
  27. Aach, J., et al., Addressing the ethical issues raised by synthetic human entities with embryo-like features. Elife, 2017. 6: p. e20674.
  28. Bulletti, C., et al., The artificial womb. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 2011. 1221(1): p. 124-128.

(Source: Daily Accord)

Sunday, 22 October 2017

The leftover embryo crisis

It's a difficult reproductive question faced by hundreds of thousands of people and pretty much nobody is talking about it. Elissa Strauss writes on Elle about the million frozen embryos in the US, the two that are hers, and why nearly everyone has so much trouble figuring out what to do with them. Read on: 

There are an estimated one million frozen embryos in the United States right now. If you're somebody who believes life begins at conception, you might see a potential tragedy. If you’re somebody who has long been struggling with infertility, you might wish that someone, somewhere, would send one your way. If you’re a clinic or storage facility, you might see a logistical struggle. And if you’re a former patient of IVF to whom one or more of those embryos belong, you might see indecision, an unyielding maybe that you can avoid dealing with for the not insignificant cost of approximately $750 per year.

Two of those million some embryos are mine, the byproduct of a successful course of treatment that resulted in the birth of a healthy child earlier this year. They’re currently residing in New York City, bundles of 120 cells suspended in cryoprotectant locked in a freezer set to negative 196 degrees celsius on the Upper East Side. We’re 3000 miles in our new home of Oakland CA, two parents, two kids, one dog. This was the plan, the dream even. Here we are.

What should we do with our two leftover embryos? The options, which include using them to try to have another child, donating them to research or another couple, or destroying them, are clear. Choosing one is not. Much of this struggle lies not so much in my indecisiveness, but my resentment about having to make this decision at all. Following a year of infertility treatments and another ten months of a highly monitored pregnancy, I’d prefer to retreat back to the illusion that creating life is more a matter of fate than human will. My son, the fullness of his thighs, the urgency of his coohs and cahs, affords me this fantasy. My embryos do not. Alive, but not quite, us, but not quite, they came into being by way a series of measured calculations designed to work as corrective to fate. Now we have to decide what’s next.

We are not unique in our ambivalence. A series of research projects led by Robert Nachtigall, a OB-Gyn at UC San Francisco, found that embryo disposition, the official term for getting rid of excess embryos, is rarely easy. A 2005 study called the decision “a significant and frequently unresolved issue for couples with stored frozen embryos,” one complicated by “their deeply personal conceptualizations of their embryos” which “contributes to their ambivalence, uncertainty, and difficulty in reaching a decision.” Another study found that “the majority of embryo-holding families choose to postpone ultimate decision-making about their embryos.” Some do this because they aren’t sure they are done having children, others because of an inability to make a decision, whether because of ambivalence or disagreement, and others because they lack the information and support to make a decision.

“This is one of the unintended consequences of IVF that doesn’t get a lot of attention,” said Barbara Collura, President and CEO of RESOLVE: The National Infertility Association. “But this is a huge challenge, and there is frankly not enough being done to help.”

Most reproductive health clinics, along with the patients they serve, operate with tunnel vision. They want to get you pregnant. When you are going through IVF, they require patients to sign a consent form about the fate of their potential extra embryos should a couple get divorced or someone dies. That tends to be it. Rarely does somebody sit you down and say, “you might end this process with excess embryos and here’s what you might do with them.” Even more rarely does somebody tell you that it might be hard. If they did, you might only laugh at the suggestion of such excessive fortune.

Outside the walls of the clinic it’s not much different. A byproduct of the ongoing fight for reproductive rights has been the self-censorship of stories that don’t follow the logic of either side of the debate. Regrets and mixed feelings about abortions, miscarriages and embryos can easily be interpreted as sympathy towards, or fodder for, the anti-abortion movement. So we hold back from talking about the messy middle in which embryos exist for many of us, compelled to contemplate their meaning and worth all on our own.

IF I DONATED MY EMBRYOS, I WORRIED I’D SPEND MY LIFE LOOKING FOR WHAT I STILL CONSIDERED MY CHILD.

The embryo disposition question surfaced about one month after my IVF baby was born. Having never received information about my options from my infertility clinic, I went searching for them on the internet. Google quickly directed me to RESOLVE’s website, where there is a list of seven options former IVF patients can choose from. Immediately, I ruled out four.

The easiest to dismiss was donating them to be used by someone else. This would involve giving the embryos to a clinic, or directly to a couple or individual who could implant it and, should it lead to a live birth, raise it. In order to create an embryo without any of their biological material, an infertile couple might have to pay for donor sperm and a donor egg, and then pay for a clinic to combine them and then transfer one or more resulting embryos to the womb, all of which can easily cost tens of thousands of dollars. While it is against the law to sell biological material, clinics are allowed to charge for the time and effort that goes into making sperm and eggs. Embryos, on the other hand, are generally a byproduct of a process done for another purpose and therefore can’t be assigned any monetary value. The cost of using a donated embryo includes only legal fees and the cost of transferring the embryo to the womb, which adds up to around $5000.

I could never donate my embryos because I’d be certain that I’d spend the rest of my life looking for what I would still consider my child. Most couples dealing with the disposition question feel the same. According to research done by Nachtigall and others, only a small number of couples—just 6% in one study—decide to donate their embryos.

However, some working in the industry say they see an uptick in couples being interested in donating their excess embryos, and a host of start-ups have arrived to help facilitate the process. One of these is Embryo Options, a new company that works with clinics to guide their patients through the whole embryo storage and disposition process, including donation. “We are like Match.com between embryo donors and recipients,” said co-founder Jim Knowles.

I WON’T OPT FOR THE SIMPLER, CHEAPER OPTION OF EMBRYO DESTRUCTION.

Knowles and his partner Andy Gairani said they started Embryo Options because they saw people trying to donate embryos by way of Facebook and determined they could use some help. Unlike many of the Christian groups helping facilitate embryo donation, or “adoption” as they often call it, Knowles and Gairani don’t put any moral premium on donation. “We just want to make sure [embryo disposition] is an educational process, and that there are tools out there to help place these embryos with recipients who want them.”

The rise in interest could be in part the effect of a federal program that spent tens of millions of dollars to raise awareness of embryo donation, or “snowflake adoption.” This began during the Bush administration, designed to protect what he considered “our society’s most vulnerable members,” and continued through the Obama years.

Even with the recent uptick, embryo donation as a large-scale answer to the excess embryo question has many skeptics. Arthur Caplan, a professor of bioethics at New York University, says he doesn’t believe that this will ever take off. “This is a completely ideological, moralistically driven solution. Meanwhile the fate of all these frozen embryos lies in the hands of utility companies.”

“Most people won’t feel comfortable with this,” he continued. “Could you ever feel comfortable with this?” “Never,” I replied.


Another non-option for me is the compassionate transfer, a procedure which involves placing the embryo in a woman during a time of her cycle when it has little chance of surviving. Before I went through IVF I neatly filed this away in the slightly ridiculous yet forgivable category. I considered it a waste of resources, financial and medical, and a product of the kind of knotty logic that often emerges when religious ethics butt heads with reproductive medicine.

Now that I’m on the other side of this process, I’ve become more sensitive to its appeal. Here’s a ritual, almost pagan in its mix of physicality and near absurdity, that might help women navigate through the liminality of frozen embryo possession. There’s a poetic cyclicality to having the cells reabsorbed into the mother’s body; a sense that the science experiment is over everything is back where it should be.

I won’t do that, nor will I opt for the simpler, cheaper option of embryo destruction in which they are thawed and discarded in the lab, or destroyed in a disposal ceremony of my own devising, because embryos are useful. They can be donated to research, either to be used in the lab or, less commonly, for stem cell research project. When choosing this option, I cut off any chance my embryos have to become life, but I guarantee that they will contribute to life; a fitting end to their confounding alive-but-not-life status. Studies show this feeling is common.

When I first heard of the research option, I imagined that meant that our embryos would head off to a stem cell lab, where they might play a crucial role in curing Alzheimer's or the creation of new organs for transplants. This scenario, I’ve since learned, is highly unlikely. Most embryos donated to research are destined for a less heroic and headline grabbing fate: they are used to help the infertility clinic maintain quality control. They might be used to train a young embryologist, or ensure that a new equipment is up to par. This is still contributing to life—that embryologist might gain skills that help her help other couples have babies—but it’s not what I had imagined.

According to Susan Fisher, the director of the Human Embryonic Stem Cell Program at University of California, San Francisco, this is largely because of federal laws limiting stem cell research. “The bar is so high to be able to do this work. You must work in non-federal lab, with non-federal equipment and non-federal fund,” she said. “This is such a shame to me, because people want them used for greater good, but there are all kinds of obstacles.”


While Obama undid some of the the second Bush’s restrictions, the field is still largely underfunded. Today, most research is done on stem cells created from adults, which are less politically controversial, but also, according to Fisher, less effective. “Embryonic stem cells are still what we would call the gold standard” and would provide far more insights into how our bodies work. “If we take the 30,000 feet perspective, we know nothing about human development. And the reason for this because, for a very long time, the United States government has not supported this work. In many ways they have prevented this work,” she said.

There isn’t a central organization where patients can go look for studies looking for embryos, no single entity that can walk them through research projects and facilitate donation. Doing it on one’s own is possible, but it’s a cumbersome process that requires an in-depth knowledge about how academic institutions work as well as a deep well of patience to wade through all the red tape. Individuals might also be responsible for setting up the transfer of their embryo, which can be complicated in and of itself. The infertility clinic that we used allows us to donate our embryos to stem cell research, but I was told that they embryos with such a designation often sit in the freezer for a long time. Hang in there long enough, she explained, and there’s a decent chance they will be be destroyed.

There is another option here, the one that all choices must ultimately be measured against. We could use the embryo to try to have a child. Ruling this out should be easy. We don’t want another child. But our present selves and future selves are rarely the same people and what’s obvious today might be a source of regret later on. What do I owe to person I will become in the next half decade? Some days I think the answer is clear: as much opportunity as I can give her and her family. Other days, most days, I think differently. Betting on change is foolish. It will cost our family many thousands of dollars, and, worse, serve as invitation for self-examination, even self-scrutiny, over the years about what kind of person doesn’t want more children. Especially when they are already in the works.

Finally there’s the last choice, the popular choice, the no-choice choice, of storing them for some undetermined amount of time. I understand its appeal and might consider it if I wasn’t constitutionally incapable of taking this path. This is because I’m an overly decisive type, the sort who moves swiftly and confidently through matters large and small and rarely second guesses herself afterward, occasionally to a fault. I do this in part because I’m terrible at avoidance, and lack the facility to redirect big questions, or tiny embryos, to the dark corners of mind where they can hibernate until I’m ready. I think of those maybe babies, and all that went into making them, and long for closure.

According to Dr. Nachtigall the no-choice choice is the most common one, and accounts for around two-thirds the people he has studied. “In order for couples to engage with disposition decision, they must first undergo a shift in conceptualization of embryos [away from potential children]. This shift is required before they can let them go. I don’t think it is easy,” he said.

____

Making a decision about embryos is complicated largely because we lack consensus on what they actually are. Bioethicists struggle to define them, trying to find a middle-ground between human tissue and a child. “Even if you don’t believe they are a person, they have moral status. You can’t minimize that; the genetic connection makes it really challenging to do so,” said Lisa Campo-Engelstein, an associate professor at the Alden March Bioethics Institute at Albany Medical College.

She believes one solution to the excess embryo question is for clinics to stop making so many embryos in the first place. They could instead freeze eggs and sperm and create embryos as needed, a process that is far less likely to create lower live birth rates than it would have in the past. This would avoid psychological strife on behalf of the possessors of embryos as well as prevent the number of excess embryos in the country from continuing to grow.

Another way to reduce the number of embryos sitting in freezers would be to have laws limiting how long they can be frozen for, which exist in other countries. In the United Kingdom, for example, most regions only allow individuals or couples to store embryos for ten years. In addition to the obvious effect of reducing the embryo glut, this legal framework might also change the way we think about embryos. If it becomes the norm to dispose of them at some point, then people might become more comfortable with letting go of them—at any point. It would also give the clinic the permission to destroy abandoned embryos after a certain predetermined period of time. As it stands now, most clinics never destroy embryos, even if storage fees haven’t been paid for years, out of fear that they might be sued should their patients or clients return years later and demand them.

“There has to be some endpoint,” Campo-Engelstein said. “I heard about a couple who was planning on bequeathing their embryos to their children. There should be safeguards in place.”

NYU’s Caplan has another suggestion for tweaking how we view embryos: change their name. He prefers calling those that have yet to enter the womb “pre-embryos,” a term some of in the reproductive medicine field have already adopted. “Clinics are responsible [for some of the confusion surrounding embryos] because they treat them like babies,” Caplan said. “There is a lot of politics, and even a little business, in what you call an embryo in a dish or tank.” In this largely for-profit field, the closer you get to promising someone a baby, the more likely your patients will opt for more, and more expensive, treatments.

When Caplan said “pre-embryo,” my mind quickly pivoted away from burden and towards relief. I’d always seen them as potential life, as opposed to life, and bristled at infertility discussion groups where they are lovingly named “embies,” and often attached to a gender descriptor. But this semantic tweak further emphases their potentiality, and detracts from any cuddly associations. When I think of my potential embryos, or the other million potential embryos, I see them less as a burden, or potential scientific plot, and more as a byproduct of a medical procedure. So much easier to say goodbye.

The law offers little in the way of clarity as to the status of embryos. Most lawyers and judges frame them as property, but “deserving of special respect for their potential to become a person,” as one much referenced court case put it. “You treat it respectfully, but it’s not a person. It doesn’t have all the rights of a person,” said Margaret E. Swain, the director of the American Academy of Assisted Reproductive Technology Attorneys.

But this definition is not federal law. Different states have different rules on the legal standing of embryos, mostly regarding what can be done to them while they are alive and whether or not their fate should be determined by a contract or what’s in the best interest of their parents. One state, Louisiana, gives embryos judicial standing, which is the reason why Sofia Vergara’s ex-fiancée Nick Loeb, headed east to file a lawsuit on behalf of their embryos in an attempt to use them. (A federal judge in Louisiana ultimately dismissed the case because neither parent lived there, nor were the embryos created there.)

About the closest we have ever gotten to a federal definition of embryos is when President Obama was sued by Mary Scott Doe, a “frozen embryo symbolizing all existing frozen embryos,” after lifting part of the ban on stem cell research 2009. A federal appeals court ruled against little Mary, claiming that the case had no standing because embryos are an “amorphous” class and nobody could prove any actual harm.

Politically speaking, the few attempts to articulate what embryos are have mostly happened in the context of the pro-life movement. There was the aforementioned program to encourage embryo donations, which was bereft of any information on other disposition options. Also, efforts to make IVF widely available to wounded veterans have been stymied by those on the right who don’t want to be a party to the creation of excess embryos that might later be destroyed.

Overall, however, the anti-abortion movement has largely stayed away from this issue. One rarely sees protests outside IVF clinics, or laws limiting the number of eggs that can be fertilized. Most reproductive advocates believe this is because of the bad optics. These embryos are for family-building, for creating life; the narratives fueling the anti-abortion movement claiming carelessness and disdain for life don’t work here. However, should personhood laws ever pass, the informal armistice could very well end.

____

My husband and I are lucky. The excess embryo question can create a lot of friction between couples, but we’re generally in agreement. Still, this agreement does not reflect an equal sharing of the burden of making this decision. He is also a journalist. He did not decide to research and write a 3500 plus word article on embryo disposition.

The whys are fairly obvious. Most of the physical labor involved in creating those embryos was on me, as would be the act of gestating them. Most of the emotional labor of family planning is on me, because I’m a woman and long ago the world decided women need to worry about such things. He didn’t cast judgement on all my ruminating. He was never an active participant in it either. He wanted to hear where I landed, and when I told him he was in swift agreement.

According to Jake Anderson, co-founder of the Fertility IQ, a website that offers data on doctors, clinic, and treatments in the field of reproductive medicine, women and men tend to approach the embryo disposition question differently.

“We often see a breakdown along gender lines among heterosexual couples. The guy often thinks ‘we got what we wanted, let’s call it a day.’ And the woman thinks that she never wants to revisit the whole process of going through IVF, so she would rather hold onto them,” he said. “This can be a meaningful pain point.”

We decided that we want to put this all behind us. We are going to donate our embryos to stem cell research, but request that if they aren’t used in a couple of years, then they should be donated to the reproductive lab. We concluded that should our tides shift and we decide we want to have another kid, we will try to have another kid. Even if that means going through IVF. That might not work, but so might not these two embryos we are saying goodbye to, or just about anything and everything else we do in a lifetime. We will be submitting ourselves to chance, which will, in turn, allow us to better commit to who we are now. To the children in front of us, to all the life we’ve already created.

Sunday, 9 July 2017

5 things embryologist wants you to know about IVF procedure

As couples navigate through their fertility journey, some arrive at the diagnosis of infertility and need to attempt pregnancy using in vitro fertilization (IVF). This generally starts with meeting with their physician and beginning the first steps of the process that include preparation, stimulation, and monitoring with their clinicians and nurses. In the background is the functioning of the IVF laboratory, where what is actually occurring can be a bit of a mystery to most, especially early in the process.

The scientist who combines the sperm and egg and helps the resulting embryos to grow in a controlled environment is called an embryologist. Access to the laboratory or embryologists in most clinics is limited. It is often not until a failed attempt or cycle that a patient would receive embryology observations, but often times the information is communicated or presented by the clinician. This is often because although embryology insights can be very diagnostic, they are best interpreted by a clinician since they are best educated to correlate those insights with specific patient demographics.

So even if we are behind the scenes, embryologists are still a large part of your IVF journey. Keep in mind that each patient/partner combination is so different, but here are a few insights from an embryologist's perspective that every patient should know before they arrive to a fertility clinic.


1. Every Embryo is Different
Every egg, sperm and the resulting combination of the two are different. That makes every attempt at IVF using different gametes a different experience. When the average infertility patient comes into the clinic, they might imagine a grocery store where they open a container of a dozen eggs and each one looks perfect or the same. This is not the case with human eggs.

From the embryologist’s eyes, each egg looks different, but we can’t see the DNA with a microscope to select the “good” eggs. Each egg is aspirated from a different follicle. Vaginal ultrasounds can predict or indicate how many follicles are growing and what the measuring sizes are each day when medications are delivered into the body at standardized doses. Understand that all the follicles vary in size during the process and some can measure at 14mm while others might be 19mm. The follicular measurements can correlate to healthy follicular environments, chemical communication, and egg health, in a way that we still do not fully understand.

There is a range of ideal follicular size, but that ideal is different for each human (just like body temperature). Not every egg is meant to make a baby, just like not every sperm will fertilize an egg. If you factor in the same variables, you can see that every embryo is very different. Why some eggs do not fertilize, some embryos do not grow or turn into blastulae, why some don't freeze well or survive the thaw, are just indicators that there is probably something flawed about them we don’t understand yet.

2. Embryologists Can't Repair Eggs
Women are born with all of the eggs they will have throughout their life. Embryologists will care and nurture your gametes, but cannot repair or make an embryo better by culturing it in the laboratory. Eggs are made when the female is in utero around 18-20 weeks gestation. Therefore, eggs are the same age as the woman’s biological age. The notion that you could drink juice and make your eggs “better” is a falsehood. There is evidence that the follicular environment and the health of the gamete provider during the stimulation process can affect outcome. In addition, having a normal body mass index (BMI), not smoking, limiting alcohol consumption and avoiding narcotics all have been proven beneficial to the success of IVF.

On the other hand, most men make sperm daily and on average are only 3 months old. Their daily health and choices can affect an ejaculate 60 to 90 days later. Having your clinician tune up you and your partner’s health a few months before your attempt might give you and your partner time to get your emotional, physical and financial health in order to optimize your attempt. Watch out for gimics on the internet or advice about how all supplements or lifestyle changes can improve your fertility, save those questions for your medical provider. We want what is best for you and do not want you to compromise your success because of some bad advice you got from an internet forum.

3. Everyone’s IVF Journey and Outcome Are Different
In this process, it is not uncommon to seek comfort and support by reaching out and comparing yourself to others. It can feel reassuring when a person’s story is similar to your own and ended with family expansion. It is important to keep in mind that everyone's IVF journey and outcomes are different. Because of this, contrasting and comparing your experience to the experiences of others may not truly be as beneficial as it may seem on the surface. Undergoing IVF is emotional and painful and this is why I encourage patients to reach out to professionals, fertility coaches, or counselors if they find the stress overwhelming or their relationship challenged. Ultimately, choosing someone you trust to confide in is the key.

There are many ways to start or expand a family. The decision to change paths can be affected by physical, emotional, financial, religious and familial factors. The decision to change paths can be extremely challenging and can trigger a grief process. Some examples of changes that might trigger emotional distress include moving on to donor gametes (eggs or sperm), choosing adoption instead of having a biological child, or deciding to be a childless couple or single person. Choices like these are decisions that are processed differently for every person. You and your partner may be affected or process these changes differently, but try to remember their path and place is just as valid as yours. Communication is key during this period of time.

4. There Are No Magic Numbers That Will Guarantee Success
As clinicians, we get many calls from patients upset that they did not have the same outcome as another patient or what they expected. This can stem from a semen analysis results to the number of eggs retrieved during an IVF cycle or egg aspiration. You are you. You clinician will give you indicators if your result is unexpected or clinically significant. The internet and online forums are filled with number of eggs retrieved, embryos created, and embryo grading scores. Keep in mind that there are no magic numbers that indicate success. Embryo culture is process designed for an embryologist to gather information about each individual embryo’s growth pattern and quality in order to effectively evaluate embryos for implantation potential. We pick the best you have. There are no indicators that can guarantee 100% success. I have seen patients have beautiful grade A embryos not get pregnant and embryos that were grade C make beautiful twins.

Every clinic has a different system that they grade embryos in their clinic. Asking the clinic to explain their grading system to you will help your personal understanding and allow you to speak the same technical language level. The embryo grading system was created to predict implantation potential and create a system to designate embryos in a group or cohort. That being said, if you only produce grade C embryos and experience failure in your first attempt, that information may help your clinician (and therefore you and your partner) recommend if your physical, emotional, or financial investment in another attempt may be better invested in donor gametes or an alternative path for family expansion.

5. Your Embryologist Wants The Best for You
There is no magic pill, juice or protocol that we didn't tell you about. If we had something we thought would make the process successful for you, we would have told you in the beginning. As we gather information about your journey and you and your partner’s responses we may alter your clinical treatment, but we are always doing our best with the information we have. Embryologists are scientists who are very collaborative. We are unique in the fact that most of us share our trade secrets via publication and meetings. This field is growing and expanding and we are developing new insights at a rapid pace. I really enjoy working in a field where we share our successes and failures because we know that you, the patient, might benefit. We may be a bunch of “lab geeks” but we are inspired to help build families and that is why we choose to work in this field.

What happens in the IVF lab is technical and in some ways mysterious because there is no true recipe for success. Know that your IVF journey is unique and that while it is always good to be informed, don't mistake contrasting and comparing your experience against the experiences of others as reliable information. The goal of IVF is one healthy baby, and your embryologist is part of the team trying to make this happen.

(Source: FertilitySmarts)