Showing posts with label Alice in Wonderland. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Alice in Wonderland. Show all posts

Monday, 22 January 2018

Psychological and neurological disorders experienced by characters in Alice in Wonderland

Most reputable doctors tend to refrain from diagnosing people they’ve never met or examined. Unfortunately, this circumspection doesn't obtain as often among lay folk. When we lob uninformed diagnoses at other people, we may do those with genuine mental health issues a serious disservice. But what about fictional characters? Can we ascribe mental illnesses to the surreal menagerie, say, in Lewis Carroll’s Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland? It’s almost impossible not to, given the overt themes of madness in the story.

Carroll himself, it seems, drew many of his depictions directly from the treatment of mental disorders in 19th century England, many of which were linked to “extremely poor working conditions,” notes Franziska Kohlt at The Conversation. During the industrial revolution, “populations in so-called ‘pauper lunatic asylums’ for the working class skyrocketed.” Carroll’s uncle, Robert Wilfred Skeffington Lutwidge, happened to be an officer of the Lunacy Commission, which supervised such institutions, and his work offers “stunning insights into the madness in Alice.”

Yet we should be careful. Like the supposed drug references in Alice, some of the lay diagnoses now applied to Alice’s characters may be a little far-fetched. Do we really see diagnosable PTSD or Tourette’s? Anxiety Disorder and Narcissistic Personality Disorder? These conditions hadn’t been categorized in Carroll’s day, though their symptoms are nothing new. And yet, experts have long looked to his nonsense fable for its depictions of abnormal psychology. One British psychiatrist didn’t just diagnose Alice, he named a condition after her.

In 1955, Dr. John Todd coined the term Alice in Wonderland Syndrome (AIWS) to describe a rare condition in which—write researchers in the Journal of Pediatric Neurosciences—“the sizes of body parts or sizes of external objects are perceived incorrectly.” Among other illnesses, Alice in Wonderland Syndrome may be linked to migraines, which Carroll himself reportedly suffered.

We might justifiably assume the Mad Hatter has mercury poisoning, but what other disorders might the text plausibly present? Holly Barker, doctoral candidate in clinical neuroscience at King’s College London, has used her scholarly expertise to identify and describe in detail two other conditions she thinks are evident in Alice.

Depersonalization:
“At several points in the story,” writes Barker, “Alice questions her own identity and feels ‘different’ in some way from when she first awoke.” Seeing in these descriptions the symptoms of Depersonalization Disorder (DPD), Barker describes the condition and its location in the brain.

This disorder encompasses a wide range of symptoms, including feelings of not belonging in one’s own body, a lack of ownership of thoughts and memories, that movements are initiated without conscious intention and a numbing of emotions. Patients often comment that they feel as though they are not really there in the present moment, likening the experience to dreaming or watching a movie. These symptoms occur in the absence of psychosis, and patients are usually aware of the absurdity of their situation. DPD is often a feature of migraine or epileptic auras and is sometimes experienced momentarily by healthy individuals, in response to stress, tiredness or drug use.

Also highly associated with childhood abuse and trauma, the condition “acts as a sort of defense mechanism, allowing an individual to become disconnected from adverse life events.” Perhaps there is PTSD in Carroll’s text after all, since an estimated 51% of DPD patients also meet those criteria.

Prosopagnosia:
This condition is characterized by “the selective inability to recognize faces.” Though it can be hereditary, prosopagnosia can also result from stroke or head trauma. Fittingly, the character supposedly affected by it is none other than Humpty-Dumpty, who tells Alice “I shouldn’t know you again if we did meet.”

“Your face is the same as everybody else has – the two eyes, so-” (marking their places in the air with his thumb) “nose in the middle, mouth under. It’s always the same. Now if you had two eyes on the same side of the nose, for instance – or the mouth at the top – that would be some help.”

This “precise description” of prosopagnosia shows how individuals with the condition rely on particularly “discriminating features to tell people apart," since they are unable to distinguish family members and close friends from total strangers.

Scholars know that Carroll’s text contains within it several abstract and seemingly absurd mathematical concepts, such as imaginary numbers and projective geometry. The informed work of researchers like Kohit and Barker shows that Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland might also present a complex 19th century understanding of mental illness and neurological disorders, conveyed in a superficially silly way, but possibly informed by serious research and observation. Read Barker’s article in full here to learn more about the conditions she diagnoses.

(Source: Open Culture)

Monday, 14 August 2017

Photos of Alice Lidell – The girl who was the inspiration for “Alice in the Wonderland”

Alice in Wonderland is one of the most influential books ever written. Adored by both children and adults, it tells the story of a bored little girl named Alice and her journey to an imaginary parallel world, filled with unreal and very amusing human-like creatures. Being one of the most notable pieces of the genre known as “nonsense literature”, the book has made a huge impact on the movie industry,  pop culture and on literature itself.

Written in 1856, this phantasmagorical novel is the creation of Charles Lutwidge Dodgson.

Mr. Dodgson was an English mathematician, photographer, logician, deacon and finally a writer. Born on 27 January 1832, in Daresbury, Cheshire, England, he was a gifted child, showing his intellect in his early years. Dodgson was reading books at the age of 7 and received his first education at home. Later, Charles studied at the Richmond Grammar School. He had lots of health problems in his youth, and the various diseases took their toll. As a very young child, Charles suffered from illness, became deaf in one ear, was stuttering, and had a weak and problematic chest for his entire life. Still, his mind was brilliant, and a big part of his incredible imagination was, in fact, another one of his diseases. He suffered from a rare neurological disorder, which twisted reality, caused hallucinations and made him see things bigger or smaller than they were. Knowing this, it’s easy to assume his ability to imagine and write down the fascinating volume that is Alice in Wonderland.

Alice Liddell and ferns: this was published as a miniature on the last page of the original
Alice’s Adventures Underground (1861).
Signature of Alice Pleasance Hargreaves née Liddell (1852–1933).

Charles Lutwidge Dodgson wrote the novel under the pen name Lewis Carroll, and the entire world knows him by this name. Three years before the book was published, on 4 July 1862, Charles was on a boat trip up the Thames River, accompanied by Reverend Robinson Duckworth and three little girls by the names of Alice, Edith, and Lorina Liddell.

The writer, the three little sisters, and the Reverend were traveling from Oxford to Godstow for a picnic. As Mr. Duckworth was rowing the boat, the ten years old, Alice asked Charles Dodgson to tell them a story. Dodgson began narrating, revealing the story of a little girl named Alice, who fell down a rabbit hole and traveled into a fantasy world. The girls loved the story, and little Alice asked Charles to write the story down for her. As promised, a few months later, he became Lewis Carroll and did what was asked by Miss Liddell.

Alice Liddell (right) with sisters c. 1859 (photo by Lewis Carroll)
Alice Hargreaves in 1932, at the age of 80.
On 26 November 1864, Charles gave Alice Liddell a manuscript called Alice’s Adventures Under Ground, which contained the original illustrations done by him. A year later, on 26 November 1865, the novel was officially published. The book was an instant success. Lewis Carroll soon became a well-known name around the world. Queen Victoria herself was such a big fan of the book that she ordered Charles to dedicate the next book to her.

The writer later presented his mathematical book called “An Elementary Treatise on Determinants, With Their Application to Simultaneous Linear Equations and Algebraic Equations” to the Queen, and it’s hard to believe that her Majesty was amused with this, as she had had something quite different in mind.

The grave of Alice Hargreaves in the graveyard of the church of St Michael and All Angels, Lyndhurst.
Carroll later wrote another book with the Alice character, named Through the Looking-Glass and What Alice Found There. The book was published in 1871. It was five years before that, in 1886, the original manuscript given to Alice Liddell was published, and in 1890, the writer published a shortened version of the book, with more illustrations, for children not older than five years.

Charles Dodgson died on 14 January 1898. He published at least 15 books before he died, but none of them reached the fame and popularity of Alice in Wonderland.

He was a friend of the Liddell family for a long time, as the father of the three girls, Henry, was the dean of Christ Church in Oxford. Charles befriended the Liddells in 1855, first becoming friends with the eldest of the Liddell children, Harry. He often took the kids to picnics, where he told them fantastic stories and used them as subjects for his hobby as a photographer. He spent time with all the children, but his favorite, however, was Alice Liddell. The friendship suddenly ended in June 1863, for unknown reasons. Some biographers worryingly speculate that Charles had inappropriate and romantic feelings towards Alice and wanted to marry the 11-year-old. Others claim that Alice’s older sister Lorina was in love with Charles, so he stopped the relations with the family. However, this topic will remain a mystery because the pages of Charles’ diary from this period are missing and his photos were burned.

Edith Liddell (William Blake Richmond, ca 1864).
Alice was the fourth child in the Liddell family. She was born on 4 May 1852. At the age of 10, she served as an inspiration for the book Alice in Wonderland. She had nine siblings and was regularly accompanied by her two sisters, Edith and Lorina. The three took a trip to Europe when Alice was a young woman.

Alice got married to Reginald Hargreaves, an English cricket player when she was 28 years old. The wedding ceremony was held at Westminster Abbey on 15 September 1880. The couple had three sons: Alan, Leopold, and Caryl. The first two died as soldiers in World War I, but Caryl managed to survive the war and establish his own family. Reginald Hargreaves died in 1926, leaving Alice alone in their house. The maintenance cost for the property was too much for the lone widow, so Alice was forced to sell her copy of Alice’s Adventures Under Ground, a gift from Lewis Carroll himself.

The piece achieved a price of £15,400, four times more than predicted by the Sotheby’s auction house. Later, the book was purchased by the American businessman Eldridge R. Johnson. The book was displayed at Columbia University, and Alice was invited to the presentation where another interesting story happened. The 80-years- old Alice met Peter, who along with his brothers was the inspiration for another famous book: Peter Pan, written by J. M. Barrie. Her book was finally purchased by a consortium of American bibliophiles and given back to the people of Britain as an award for their bravery in World War II. Today, the manuscript is located in the second largest library in the world, the British Library in London. Alice died on 16 November 1934, at the age of 82. Her remains rest in a graveyard in St. Michael and All Angels Church in Lyndhurst, Hampshire.

Alice Liddell at the age of 20, photographed by Julia Margaret Cameron
Another story of interest from Alice’s life is that supposedly, the son of Queen Victoria, Prince Leopold, fell in love with young Alice while he was spending time at Christ Church College in Oxford, where Alice lived.

Although these speculations are not proven, it is certain that Leopold gave the name ‘Alice’ to his daughter, and acted as a godfather to Alice’s second son, Leopold, who he named after himself. Some say that the name of the third son Caryl is inspired by the name of Lewis Carroll, but Alice herself denied this rumor.

Alice and Lorina Liddell as Chinamen.
Even though the Alice in the book and Alice Liddell look differently, it is quite certain that Charles Dodgson had Miss Liddell on his mind while creating his character.

Several movies were made after the book, and it became forbidden in China in 1931, on the grounds that “animals should not use human language”. Until now, the book has been sold in more than 100 million copies.

(Source: The Vintage News)