Showing posts with label sister. Show all posts
Showing posts with label sister. Show all posts

Sunday, 22 September 2019

The identical twins who lost their identities to an NHS error

How an administrative mistake left two sisters with the same NHS number – depriving them of vital healthcare and trapping them in a bureaucratic maze with no exit

Ten years ago, identical twins Adah and Anah Bermudez were both in dire need of medical help – but neither could get a doctor to see them.

Adah claims she was attacked at her home in Harrow, northwest London, and needed treatment for the injuries she had reportedly suffered to her right arm and shoulder.

Twelve miles away, in Barnet, Anah was succumbing to a breakdown, and was in desperate need of mental health support.

But their GPs refused to give them appointments, explaining that they had been “struck off” because they had registered elsewhere – at each other’s doctor’s surgeries.

It was the first time that what is believed to have been a simple administration error made when they were born had come to light that was to have a devastating impact on both their lives.

Somehow, both sisters, now 37, had been assigned the same NHS number – something that should be impossible, but once it had happened they found themselves trapped in a bureaucratic maze with no exits.
Anah (left) was assigned the same NHS number as her sister Adah – despite repeated attempts to raise the issue, the problem still haunts them today ( Supplied )

Every time they tried to explain the problem to the authorities, they were ignored.

“I said to them, I’ve got a twin sister. But they didn’t listen,” says Adah, who now lives in Mill Hill with her daughter, 12, and one-year-old son.

“They just said I couldn’t have an appointment. So if I had a problem, I started looking up how I could help myself. I would google treatments.”

Anah, who suffers with severe depression and borderline personality disorder, was meanwhile experiencing acute side effects as a result of not being able to get her medication.

“When I got really sick it was very bad. I was vomiting; I was shaking; I was sweating. It was like coming off methadone or something,” she remembers.

“I was outside the doctors crying but nobody would give me the medication. They said no because you’re not registered here, you’re registered somewhere else.

“They said I had been taken off their system and registered somewhere else: where Adah lives.”

The women sometimes managed to find ways around it. Adah would go to a walk-in clinic, but this meant long waits. Anah resorted to re-registering with the GP each time she needed an appointment – a cumbersome task that still left her without medication for days.

“I’d have to fill in the form and give it to them, and then I’d have to wait 48 hours until I could see a doctor or a nurse. That happened more than six times when I desperately needed it,” says Anah.

“It had a big impact on me. It’s been very stressful. Sometimes I’d think am I going crazy? Is it just me? I’d start doubting myself. It would mess everything up in my head.”

Things got worse when NHS staff reportedly started issuing them each other’s medication.

Adah says she was told to go on anti-depressants that had been prescribed to her sister. She refused, which in turn led to medical professionals assuming that she was failing to heed their advice.

“They were always questioning why I wasn’t on my medication. When I was pregnant in hospital, they were asking me why I came off my medication,” she says.

“I’m being questioned all the time. The way they look at you. It’s just horrible.”

Anah says letters meant for her regarding therapy appointments were sent to Adah instead, which led to authorities to penalise her for missing them.

“I was treated like it’s my fault,” she says.

They tried to resolve the issue. Adah says she spent hours trying to call numerous NHS helplines.

“All they would say is: ‘I can see the problem Ms Bermudez, but it’s private and confidential’,” she says. “Some of the phone calls weren’t free, so my bill was really high. I tried and tried but then gave up. I just didn’t bother going to the doctor anymore.”

And the problem continues to haunt the Bermudez twins today.

Last month, Adah phone the NHS 111 helpline due to bleeding following her baby’s birth, and was told they held no record of her on the system, but two for her sister.

“There’s always a mess-up somewhere. People don’t realise how much your identity in the database affects you. It’s completely broken me down.”

Anah is still suffering from the effects of routinely not receiving her medication when she needed it. She blames the mix-up for her poor mental health today, which she says often leaves her unable to leave the house.

“If I was given the right treatment and medication I don’t think I would be this sick today,” she says.

“If there wasn’t such a mix-up, I think I would’ve realised that I really do have a problem, I would have got the help that I needed, and realised that I really do need to deal with it properly. I can’t believe how the system has failed.”

When contacted by The Independent, a spokesperson for NHS Digital said they could not talk about individual cases, but said that “from time to time errors unfortunately occur”.

“These are most likely to happen where two patients have the same or very similar demographic information, particularly surname, date of birth and address,” they said.

“When a problem with patient records is reported to us, normally by a GP practice or other care provider organisation, a dedicated team investigates promptly to identify and rectify any issues with the records on the national systems for which we are responsible.

“We also work with other NHS organisations to notify them of actions we have taken so that they can check and correct their own records.”

(Source: Independent)

Wednesday, 24 October 2018

Are siblings more important than parents?

How brothers and sisters shape who we are

We don’t choose our siblings the way we choose our partners and friends. Of course, we don’t choose our parents either, but they usually make that up to us by sustaining us on the way to adulthood. Brothers and sisters are just sort of there. And yet, when it comes to our development, they can be more influential than parents. This holds whether they are older and cool, or younger and frustrating; whether we follow in their footsteps, or run screaming in the other direction.

Part of siblings’ sway has to do with their sheer presence. Eighty-two percent of kids live with a sibling [1] (a greater share than live with a father), and about 75 percent of 70-year-olds have a living sibling. [2] For those of us who have brothers or sisters, our relationships with them will likely be the longest of our life.

Whether these relationships make our life better or worse is a more complicated question. On the upside, positive interactions with siblings during adolescence foster empathy, prosocial behavior, and academic achievement. [1] This effect can be complicated by a full house, however. Kids with more siblings (a larger “sibship,” to use the industry term) do worse in school [3]—although the universality of this finding has been challenged by studies of Mormons [4] and the entire population of Norway. [5]

When a sibling relationship is bad, however, it can be really bad—as in messing-up-your-life bad. Tense sibling relationships make people more likely to use substances and to be depressed and anxious in adolescence. [1] Moreover, sibling bullying makes a kid more likely to engage in self-harm as a teen [6] and to become psychotic by age 18. [7]

Whether a person models herself after her siblings or tries to distinguish herself has particularly important consequences. One study found that siblings who felt positively about each other tended to achieve similar education levels, while those who spent unequal time with their dad and perceived unequal parental treatment had diverging educational fortunes. [8] Not that divergence is necessarily bad: Research suggests that as siblings’ relationships with their parents grow more different over time, their relationship with each other may become warmer. [9] And emulating your sibling can be a mistake, depending on what she’s up to: Girls are more likely to get pregnant in their teens and teenagers are more likely to engage in risky behavior if an older sibling did so first. [1] Younger siblings also may have sex earlier than older ones (partly because their big brothers and sisters introduce them to more experienced potential partners). [10]
CHRISTOPHER DELORENZO

One way or another, sibling influence is lasting. A study of more than 1 million Swedes found that one’s risk of dying of a heart attack spikes after a sibling dies of one, due not only to shared DNA but also to the stress of losing such a key figure. [11] Which makes sense: Most of us are different people than we’d have been if our brothers or sisters were never born. Siblings seem like they’re just there only until they aren’t.

The Studies:
[1] McHale et al., “Sibling Relationships and Influences in Childhood and Adolescence” (Journal of Marriage and Family, Oct. 2012)

[2] Richard A. Settersten Jr., ”Social Relationships in the New Demographic Regime” (Advances in Life Course Research, 2007)

[3] Steelman et al., “Reconsidering the Effects of Sibling Configuration” (Annual Review of Sociology, 2002)

[4] Douglas B. Downey, “Number of Siblings and Intellectual Development” (American Psychologist, June/July 2001)

[5] Black et al., “The More the Merrier?” (Quarterly Journal of Economics, May 2005)

[6] Bowes et al., “Sibling Bullying and the Risk of Depression, Anxiety, and Self-Harm” (Pediatrics, Sept. 2014)

[7] Dantchev et al., “Sibling Bullying in Middle Childhood and Psychotic Disorder at 18 Years” (Psychological Medicine, Oct. 2018)

[8] Sun et al., “Sibling Experiences in Middle Childhood Predict Sibling Differences in College Graduation” (Child Development, forthcoming)

[9] Feinberg et al., “Sibling Differentiation” (Child Development, Sept./Oct. 2003)

[10] Rodgers et al., “Sibling Differences in Adolescent Sexual Behavior” (Journal of Marriage and Family, Feb. 1992)

[11] Rostila et al., “Mortality From Myocardial Infarction After the Death of a Sibling” (Journal of the American Heart Association, Feb. 2013)

(Source: The Atlantic)

Sunday, 26 August 2018

How love and loyalty bound siblings in mythology

If marriage binds spouses, Raksha Bandhan ties brothers and sisters. And mythology has numerous stories about such sibling love and loyalty but each telling a different tale.

One of the most unusual and unique relationship is the one that between Krishna and Draupadi. Once, to stanch the bleeding finger of Krishna, Draupadi promptly tore the end of her sari and tied the strip around his wounded finger as a dressing. The debt of this bond Krishna was to fulfil later, when he came to Draupadi’s rescue during her worst time – the vastraharan, where she was stripped of shame and dignity to be saved by a seamless sari. Krishna kept his promise that he would be a holy presence in her life, protecting her forever – saving her from the humiliation of being disrobed by making her sari endless and by punishing the perpetrators with death in the battle of Kurukshetra. The significance is of course, layered. Avatar means a form which descends upon and Krishna’s presence and interference is seen more as an all-pervasive consciousness actuated upon anyone in the royal Sabha, including Vidura and others in protest against the disrobing of Draupadi by Dushasana. Krishna descends into those with Dharma in their mind and conduct and thus saves a woman from humiliation.

Krishna kept his promise that he would be a holy presence in her life, protecting her forever.
In the war between the devas and the asuras, Indra – the king of gods was once defeated and disgraced by the powerful King Bali. Sachi, Indra’s wife sought the help of Vishnu, who gave her a bracelet made of cotton, which she tied as the holy thread around Indra’s wrist. Blessed with her prayers and good wishes, Indra defeated Bali and recovered his celestial kingdom of Amaravati. Interestingly, this story is a precursor of the rakhi in ancient India were the holy thread is an amulet, used by women as talisman to guard men going to war, and not restricted to sibling relationships.

SOME FAMOUS BROTHER-SISTER IN MYTHOLOGY
Krishna -Draupadi
Ram- Shanta
Ravana-Surpanakaha
Shakuni-Gandhari
Krishna-Shubhadra-Balaram
 Kamsa-Devki

Another thread has the same King Bali where after Vishnu won the three worlds from him, Bali requested Vishnu to stay at his opulent palace. Vishnu agreed. But Lakshmi wishing to return home to Vaikuntha and neither approving the stay at the palace nor the budding new friendship between her husband and Bali, goes to Bali and ties a rakhi on his wrist. As a sister would request a brother, she voices her wish to go back home with her husband.  Bali accepts his sister’s wish and the couple return to Vaikuntha.

One legend goes that a busy Yama, the god of Death, had not visited his twin sister Yamuna for twelve long years. A dispirited Yamuna complains to Ganga who goes to Yama to remind him of his brotherly duty. Yama eventually visits his sister who welcomes him with a grand feast and a small request that he visit her more often.  Yama agrees and to be able to see her frequently, he makes his sister immortal by making her the perennial river Yamuna which flows all the year round.

The moral behind this story is of course that one needs to have Santoshi (satisfaction) after all the Shubha Labha (good fortune).
A much later added story is that of Ganesha, who though a father of two sons, Shubha and Labha, wished for a daughter as did the two boys who missed having a sister to tie them a rakhi. Ganesha creates a daughter Santoshi from the divine flames his two wives, Riddhi and Siddhi. The moral behind this story is of course that one needs to have Santoshi (satisfaction) after all the Shubha Labha (good fortune).

(Source: She the People TV)

Wednesday, 22 March 2017

Kerala man kills brother-in-law, elopes with sister-in-law and abandons kids

It can be called a nightmare in adult hands. No enemy should do what these Kerala guys did. Having extra-marital affair is nothing new. I have even seen women/men having affairs with their own brothers/sisters-in-law. But killing and abandoning kids for the so-called love and lust?! Nah. Had the woman who eloped with her brother-in-law realised that she could also have the same fate as her husband, maybe she would have thought twice before shaming her family. I'm sure the story f the two Kerala children, published on the TNM, will break your heart:

For 45 days, six-year-old Aryan never let go of his four-year-old sister Amritha’s hand.  It was this act of love that eventually helped the Kerala police trace the two children and bring them back to the state.

In the last week of January, the two children were abandoned on a Mumbai-bound train by a relative following their mother’s death in Kannur district. They were brought back to Kerala on Sunday by a police team headed by Sub Inspector Anshad of Iritty in Kannur.

How the ordeal began
Until 2015 the children lived in Tumakuru in Karnataka with their parents. Their father Ravi was, however, allegedly killed by their uncle (mother’s younger sister’s husband) Manjunatha in 2015.

Later Manjunatha and the children’s mother Shobha eloped in Iritty and started living together with the kids. Police said that the couple had frequent fights over Manjunatha wanting to return to his wife in Tumaakuru.

Tragedy then struck on January 22 this year. During one of their fights, Manjunatha allegedly strangled Shobha, who fell unconscious. “He thought she was dead, so he threw her into a well. She was not actually dead, but she died due to drowning after being thrown into the well. Initially everyone thought it was a suicide. But police continued to investigate the case,” Iritty station house officer Sudheer told The News Minute.

Manjunatha then took the children to Bengaluru on January 29, where he abandoned them on a Mumbai-bound train. He then returned to Iritty.

During the course of the police investigation, they discovered that Manjunatha had allegedly murdered Shobha.  It was then during the questioning that he revealed that he had abandoned the children on the train to Mumbai.


The rescue
“We shared the children’s photographs with the Mumbai police and contacted them through Childline. When an officer from Ernakulam visited Mumbai recently for some other case, a Mumbai police officer informed him that the children, who resembled those in the photograph, were taken to the Child Welfare Committee. The Mumbai officer also said the children had been found on a train,” Sudheer said.

Last week, a police team from Kerala was sent to locate the siblings.

“We were not sure whether the information was correct and had no idea how to find them in a city like Mumbai. But surprisingly it was them. The elder brother never let go of his little sister’s hands. If they had gotten separated in Mumbai, it would have been a big task for the police to find them. They stayed together on the train all through the two-day journey. Later, some policemen found them in Mumbai and handed them over to CWC there,” Sub Inspector Anshad, who headed the team to Mumbai, said.

The officer said that the children were happy to return to Kerala. He said that the siblings remained silent all through their return journey. “When we asked something, they cried, but otherwise they were quiet and did not speak much,” he said.

Now the children are under the custody of Kannur Childline. Their father’s sister is reportedly willing to take care of the children.

“They have to submit some documents to take the children with them, so the documentation is getting ready. We will also make sure that the children are not abandoned again, as they will not be able to go through the trauma once again,” Sudheer said.

Wednesday, 22 February 2017

Psychology suggests that when someone calls you the wrong name, it’s because they love you

This is one hilarious report I came across. Never knew that if a person misnames you, it's because he loves you! Does that mean if a man calls his second wife using the name of his first wife, he loves her? Ok, how about a woman addressing her presnt guy as her ex-love?! Confusing right?

My hubby once called my son by his brother's name and we had a fight. Recently, again he addressed me like how he addresses his mom and we had a small tiff over that. But an article on Quartz suggests that when someone calls you the wrong name, it’s because they love you. Read it to know it:

Many of us have been called the wrong name by a parent, have confused the names of our closest friends, or, most cringingly, called our new beau by the name of an ex. It’s such a common awkward moment between loved ones that it has become an entertainment trope: Ross calls Emily the wrong name at the altar in a memorable episode of the classic sitcom Friends. In The Goonies, Brand is called his brother Mikey’s name by their mother. The mistake even happens in Harry Potter, with Sirius calling Harry by his father’s name, James.

But while social etiquette dictates we correctly identity the individuals closest to us, errors occur more frequently than we would like. Most people can recall at least one cringe-worthy moment when you wish you could rewind the clock. However, anecdotes are not data. As psychology researchers, we set out to answer a simple question: Why do we so often accidentally call the people we know by the wrong name?

The phenomenon of a person inadvertently calling someone familiar by the wrong name is known as misnaming. In our study (paywall) published last October in the journal Memory and Cognition, we asked over 1,700 people whether they had ever been misnamed or if they had ever committed a misnaming. We then asked what names were incorrectly used and the relationship between the people—or animals—involved. Our results confirmed that these errors are common and committed by people of all ages. (Moreover, misnaming does not appear to be an indicator of aging or of the cognitive decline typically associated with Alzheimer’s disease.)

The most common misnaming reported was a parent, usually the mother, using the wrong sibling’s name. Less common misnaming incidents included children being called the family pet’s name by their parents. Why might this occur? Our results suggest it is not due to people looking alike, nor is it primarily driven by the similarity of the names involved (e.g. calling Mark “Mike”). Misnaming typically occurs within a social group: When family members misname other family members, the incorrect names they most often use are names of other people within the family. The same pattern is observed among friends: Friends usually misname each other using the incorrect name of another friend.

We store information about a person in a mental semantic network that contains information about other related people, places, and things. When we try to remember something, units in our semantic network are activated; when enough units relevant to a concept are activated, the information reaches a threshold, and we remember it. Through a process called “spreading activation,” other information related to a concept may also be activated—this may lead to errors if incorrect information reaches a threshold and is remembered, such as the name of a loved one.

In this mind map, a mother likely associates her children with one another. When attempting to retrieve the name of her son, she is more likely to inadvertently select the name of her daughter than the name of a colleague due to the close connections between her children’s names in her semantic network. In other words, your mom calls you by your sibling’s name because she loves both of you, and associates you with one another.

Perhaps the most surprising finding of our survey was that family members sometimes use their dog’s name, but not any other type of pet’s name, when misnaming family members. This was not because the participants who reported this type of misnaming happen to have owned more dogs: They owned approximately the same number of cats as dogs. One interpretation of this finding is that dogs are a central part of pet-owning families; the family dog is likely stored in the same semantic network as other family members, which suggests that we consider dogs a part of the family, but not cats.
As pack animals, dogs may be more integrated into family units than other domesticated animals.

Humans often form unique attachments to dogs, and they are also likely to orally communicate with them. This unique attachment, coupled with the fact that dogs are more responsive to their own names, may explain why humans are more likely to be inadvertently called the name of the family dog rather than the name of other family pets.

So, the next time you call someone you love the wrong name, don’t fret: It’s just a sign that you are lucky enough to have multiple loved ones to keep track of.

Friday, 20 January 2017

Breaking the bro code

The bro-code within our families and friends’ circles thrives on mutual encouragement, complicit silence and, at best, looking the other way.

When gender based violence erupts on our TV screens, as it did recently with instances of molestation in Bengaluru, we react in shock. What does it say about a society where such acts have become routine? The shell of silence surrounding sexual violence needs to be shattered. As a first step towards a more honest conversation, we bring you “Talking Gender”, a series of articles on the fundamental problems of the collective mindset on gender.

No one teaches us the bro code, boys learn by themselves as they become men. And it isn’t about only the silly Barney Stinson type rules (although there is some nauseating stuff in there), but the more dangerous ones, which actively destroy the lives of people around us from other genders.

The documentary The Bro Code: How contemporary culture creates sexist men talks about how popular culture – films, sports, TV shows and commercials - objectifies and sexualizes women, systematically encouraging men to internalize our gender prejudices and normalize sexual violence.

But there is also the bro-code within our families and friends’ circles, which thrives on mutual encouragement, complicit silence and, at best, looking the other way.

From public policy to public outrage, as has been seen in the aftermath of the December 16 Delhi gangrape case, the battle against gender violence has been discussed in the context of our public spaces. But nearly not enough attention has been brought to how we choose to speak about gender violence within the confines of our homes and work-places, especially as men.

When a bunch of boys hang out together, feminism is most definitely a punchbag. Ideas of gender equality are linked to being a ‘pussy’. Gender violence is not a crime.

It starts small. Girls are considered weak and they are bullied from a position of assumed male power. ‘Girly’ things are sniggered over.

As teenagers, we don’t always immediately take to violence. It begins with the objectification and sexualisation of girls around puberty. We joke about the girls being objects of pursuit, and that alone. It is fun to mess with girls. It is ok to ‘screw around’ and ‘dump a chick’. If you are not playing the game, you are not a ‘man’ – and then ensues the bullying in the name of other genders and sexual identities.

There is the ‘Brode of Silence’ – never tattle on the other guy, because hey, the conquest of the girl is important, not her feelings, or her safety.

The guy could be a known delinquent, and yet, the girl will have to get hurt and figure it out herself, the guys will never hint at it. This starts at teenage and goes all the way to marriage, when his fiancée would ask us if he is really a nice guy, and we would tell her that he is, even if we knew he isn’t, because hey, we are bros.

Gaslighting is employed without a thought, and we give each other ideas for that. We bitch about girls as a sport, feeding into each other’s insecurities.

Rape is a reality, and we simply gloss over it. Beneath all tales of college conquests are horrific stories of physical abuse and torture. We crack some random rape jokes. Later at a party, she gets drunk and passes out. What stops us from ‘having some fun’ and then talk about it the next day, as no one else bats an eyelid and some even crack up to the ‘joke’? Why would any of us question it? After all, we are bros. Unless, of course, the woman is our mother or sister. We split them up like territories, create byelaws in the bro-code.

We never question Men’s Rights Activists, because the poor guy might be stuck with a bitch, right?

That friend who treats his wife or girlfriend as his property, is only ‘protecting’ her. She does not need agency, what she needs is protection. We, the bros, will protect her.

For every man in our patriarchal set up, the first step towards any semblance of gender equality is to first realize our own privilege. The next step is to speak about it to our friends and family, and very few of us get there.

By allowing every rape joke to go on unaddressed, by laughing and hitting high-fives for every ‘conquest’, we have enabled one person to get one stop closer to being an abusive, entitled male.

By walking away when a friend is slapping another girl, by lying to her that he is a ‘good guy’ when know he isn’t, we destroy one life.

The vehicle of gender violence is the complicity among men, and only when that is broken can we truly hope for dignity for other genders. Let’s tell him, that if he cannot respect women and treat them as equals, he cannot be our friend.

(Source: Newsminute)