Showing posts with label Rajput. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Rajput. Show all posts

Thursday, 23 November 2017

Padmavati has been a part of Indian theatre & cinema for 111 years, and nobody protested

Since 1906, the Rani Padmini-Alauddin Khalji story has been told and retold multiple times in various forms, without people going up in arms, writes Mahrukh Inayet in The Print. Read on: 

Former Central Board of Film Certification chairman Pahlaj Nihalani, not known for a reasonable approach till recently, has perhaps made the most pertinent comment on the controversy over Sanjay Leela Bhansali’s film Padmavati. He asked: “Why is it that earlier versions of Rani Padmini’s life invited no wrath from any Rajput groups?”

Indeed, many versions of Rani Padmini’s epic story have been part of Indian theatre, film and television for about 111 years, and none invited strictures.

Literature
Bengali poet and playwright Kshirode Prasad Vidyavinode’s play Padmini in 1906 revolved around the same story – Alauddin Khalji capturing the Rana of Chittor using deceit, Rani Padmini managing to rescue her husband, and later, as the battle ensued, all Rajput women including Padmini self-immolated.

Three years later, in 1909, Abanindranath Tagore’s Raj Kahini was published. This children’s literature collection told a similar tale of Padmini-Ratan Singh-Khalji, adding a part where the Rajput king offered to surrender his wife to Alauddin to protect Chittor, but his fellow Rajputs refused the offer.

Cinema
Cinema history is also littered with retellings of the Padmini story. In 1963, Tamil film Chittoor Rani Padmini had actor Vyjayanthimala playing the lead role. Tamil superstar Sivaji Ganesan played Rana Ratan Singh and M.N. Nambiar played Khalji. The film didn’t create any protest before release, nor any buzz at the box office.

A year later came the Hindi version Maharani Padmini, starring Anita Guha as the queen, Jairaj as her husband, and Sajjan as Khalji. The film was a damp squib at the box office, but the songs, featuring Mohammad Rafi, Asha Bhosle, Suman Kalyanpur, and Usha Mangeshkar were hits. This film saw no protests either.


Television
Apart from these two 70 mm versions, the story of Rani Padmini also found its way to the smaller screen. Shyam Benegal’s epic show Bharat Ek Khoj had one episode on Padmini, with Om Puri playing Khilji, Seema Kelkar playing Padmini, and Rajendra Gupta playing Ratan Singh.


In 2009, Sony Entertainment Televsion began broadcasting Chittod ki Rani Padmini Ka Johur, a show directed by National Award-winning art director Nitin Chandrakant Desai, featuring Tejaswani Lonari as Padmini.

The show didn’t complete its six-month run due to low TRPs and high costs. And while it was in the news for its opulent sets and costumes, it never witnessed protests for its historical content or context.


Bhansali’s Padmavati is clearly not the first time the story of Rani Padmini has been the inspiration for a creative piece. Khalji’s infatuation with her has also been used as a significant part of the narrative.

So is the film just an easy target for fringe groups and right-wing elements to force their beliefs on one man’s freedom of expression? History certainly seems to show that.

Monday, 20 November 2017

The many Padmavatis

There is no historical record that she existed — and her story has been reshaped in diverse ways over time, writes Divya Cherian in the Hindu. Read on: 

As the release of Bollywood film Padmavati  draws near, protests against it are reaching a fever pitch. Claiming to speak on behalf of all Rajputs, several political figures have objected to the portrayal of the title character of the film for two reasons — that it is a distortion of history and that it is disrespectful to Queen Padmini (appearing in some texts as Padmavati), who is deeply revered by the Rajput community.

Recent scholarly work on the Padmavat, such as that of Thomas de Bruijn, Shantanu Phukan and especially Ramya Sreenivasan, makes possible an informed engagement with these claims.


The earliest tale
The earliest known composition of the Padmini tale is Sufi poet Malik Muhammad Jayasi’s Padmavat, dating to 1540. This tale is part of a new genre, the Sufi premakhyan (‘love story’), that flowered from the 14th to 16th centuries in North India. Most of these tales feature a hero-king’s quest for union with supreme truth and transcendent beauty — embodied in the texts by a woman of unparalleled physical beauty — and the difficulty of navigating the contradictory pulls of the spiritual and worldly domains.

The Padmavat is perhaps the only one of these texts to be grafted upon a historical event, Delhi Sultan Alauddin Khilji’s siege of Chittor in 1303. Writing more than 200 years after the event, Jayasi’s tale bears little resemblance to surviving historical accounts of the siege and instead appears to draw in details from contemporaneous events and places.

In Jayasi’s composition, a parrot, Hiraman, tells the king of Chittor, Ratansen, of the unequalled beauty of the princess of Sinhal, Padmavati. Hiraman’s description is enough to trigger in Ratansen a desire to attain Padmavati. He leaves behind his wife, Nagmati, becomes a yogi, and heads out, along with his men who also become yogis, on the arduous quest to the faraway Sinhal.

With great difficulty, and only after he is ready to give up his life for the quest, Ratansen is united with Padmavati and marries her. Due to the pulls of his natal home and the suffering of his first wife, he returns to Chittor, bringing Padmavati along with him. While Ratansen works on building peace between Padmavati and Nagmati, a deceitful brahman, expelled from Ratansen’s court, seeks revenge by going to Delhi and informing Khilji of Padmavati’s stunning beauty. Piqued, Khilji decides to march upon Chittor to demand Padmavati. Ratansen refuses to part with her.

With the Sultan’s forces closing in, Ratansen dies of injuries sustained in a fight with a Rajput rival. Padmavati and Nagmati commit sati on Ratansen’s funeral pyre while the remaining Rajput men go into the battlefield to be martyred. When Khilji manages to finally conquer the fortress, all that remains of Padmavati are her ashes. His victory is thus rendered hollow.

Some manuscript copies explain the Sufi import of the tale by referring to Chittor as the body, Ratansen the spirit, Padmini the mind, Hiraman the spiritual guide, and Khilji as illusion (‘maya’). Literary representations of Khilji in a polyvalent text such as the Padmavat and in future iterations of the tale then should not be taken as historical.

The historical Sultan Alauddin Khilji, as we know him from accounts of his time, was a gifted statesman who strengthened the fisc of the Delhi Sultanate, expanded the frontiers of his kingdom, and capably protected North India from the expanding Mongol domain, a feat that many of his contemporaries could not accomplish.

As for Padmavati, there is no historical evidence that there was such a figure in Chittor when it was besieged, or that desire for a woman played any role in Khilji’s interest in conquering the fortress. Padmavati/Padmini, then, is a literary artefact, as is the entire story of love and sacrifice at whose heart she is placed. Any depiction of Padmavati thus cannot be a distortion of history since, in our current state of knowledge, she never existed. Born as a figment of poetic imagination, she is free to be reshaped in the hands of a different creator.


Padmini, recast
And indeed, the Padmavat was told and retold over the centuries and across the land. As historian Ramya Sreenivasan has carefully shown in her book, The Many Lives of a Rajput Queen, in each retelling, the contours of the story and the key characters within it, including Padmini, changed. Starting a few decades after the original composition, the Padmavat was adapted into Persian forms in North India and Gujarat, and Jain literati and bardic groups composed versions of it for Rajasthani courtly elites.

In the 17th century, professional genealogists wove the Guhila house of Ratansen into the genealogy of their patrons, the Sisodia rulers of Mewar. By the 18th century, after the decline of the Mughal empire but before colonial conquest, the tale of Padmini was refashioned in Mewar to demonise Alauddin Khilji, also emphasising his Muslim identity and presenting the clash between the Rajputs of Chittor and the Sultan of Delhi as the resistance of Hindus against an encroaching, ‘impure’ Islam.

In the 19th century, Colonel James Tod, Political Agent in Rajputana of the English East India Company, was guided in his attempt to write the first authoritative history (by contemporary European standards) of the region by the philological, historiographical, and intellectual frameworks of his age, as well as by the political goal of stabilising the region by strengthening the hands of kings against rebellious chiefs.

He selectively chose information from the range of pre-colonial sources at his disposal. He incorporated the courtly Rajasthani Padmini narrative into his early 19th century history of Rajasthan, using it, along with other material, to cast Rajputs as a valiant, pure fighting race of Hindus that resisted Islamic conquest, just as Christians had done in the West.

Bengali intellectuals of the nascent bhadralok were deeply impressed with the figure of the Rajput as presented in his account, not just for his selfless bravery but also for his resistance against a Muslim conqueror. As the earliest imaginings of an Indian nation — and a Hindu nation — began to take shape, Padmini became a token of the self-sacrificing, virtuous, and chaste Hindu woman that was to be at its heart. In this idealised form, her decision to annihilate her own body was celebrated for the preservation of her ‘honour’ (read ‘chastity’) through which was indexed the honour of her husband, her family, her community, and now, her nation.

In her journey from the 16th to the 21st century, Padmavati appears to have become increasingly shackled in the confines of patriarchy. In Rajasthani versions, Padmavati lost her autonomous voice, reduced to a prop on the edges of a scene largely occupied by the king and his courtiers. It was this Rajasthani Padmavati who was celebrated in 19th century bhadralok plays beginning to imagine a Hindu nation and who is today deified as the apotheosis of Rajput, and even Hindu, valour, purity, and sovereignty.

Padmavati has been recast as adhering strictly to codes of conduct applied to elite Rajput women. Allegations of disrespect and inaccuracy being levelled against the film are thus rooted in the expectation, by those familiar only with the Rajput or early Hindu nationalist adaptations, of a silver-screen Padmavati who observes the purdah and does not display any trace of sexuality. The current row over Padmini’s portrayal only underscores that in the long arc of its history, the imagined Hindu nation holds in its heart the dutiful, chaste Hindu woman, who acquiesces to patriarchal controls and only exercises her agency within their bounds.

No exclusive legacy
It is important to bear in mind, as Ms. Sreenivasan has shown, that at the same time that the Rajputs were articulating a new claim upon the Padmavat in the 17th century, other Padmini tales continued to be composed. A Sufi migrant from Bengal to the Arakan court (in today’s Myanmar) composed his own version of the text in Bengali. In the 19th century, there were multiple Urdu adaptations of the tale printed in North India and an opera performed in 1923 in Paris.

There have then been many Padmavats, just as there were many Ramayanas. The tale, and its heroine, are then not the exclusive legacy of any single community. The effort of spokespersons of a single community, one that continues to exercise tremendous sociopolitical power, to freeze the text into a single, authorised version, will rob it of the vitality that has allowed it to thrive over the ages.


Padmavati row: Why Rajput pride could excuse Gowariker but not Bhansali

Padmavati is not the first film to face hurdles for supposedly hurting Rajput sentiments.

The anti-Padmavati movement across the country, spearheaded by the Shri Rajput Karni Sena, has gone out of hand, with members of the organisation issuing death threats to the film's director Sanjay Leela Bhansali. Leading lady Deepika Padukone has not been spared either, with the Shri Rajput Karni Sena branding her as "naachnewali" and threatening to chop off her nose. Deepika has just been provided a special security cover after these threats.

The bone of contention is the alleged demeaning of the honour of Rani Padmini by incorporating a romantic dream sequence between her and Alauddin Khilji. Sanjay Leela Bhansali and the team of Padmavati have been shouting from the rooftops that no such scene was ever a part of the film's script, but it has fallen on deaf ears.

Padmavati is not the first historical film to face roadblocks. In fact, it is not even the first film with uncertainty looming over its release for hurting Rajput sentiments. Before this, there was Ashutosh Gowariker's Jodhaa Akbar.


The Hrithik Roshan and Aishwarya Rai Bachchan-starrer was under fire for supposedly distorting history. Incidentally, it was the Shri Rajput Karni Sena, who took it upon themselves to be the guardians of Rajput culture and honour there as well.

According to the founder of the organisation, Lokendra Singh Kalvi, Akbar had no wife named Jodhaa. He claimed that Jodhaa Bai was actually the wife of Akbar's son Salim, and thus, the Ashutosh Gowariker film was objectionable. Eventually, Jodhaa Akbar did not see the light of day in Rajasthan.

But Padmavati is no Jodhaa Akbar. The protests against Sanjay Leela Bhansali's period drama are not limited to Rajasthan, they have spread across the nation.

So why does Padmavati matter more to the Rajputs than Jodhaa?


Rani Padmini is deified in Rajput culture and her valour has attained legend status, because of her placing 'honour' above life. To the Rajputs, she proved that, as Deepika Padukone says in the trailer of Padmavati, "Rajputi kangan mein utni hi taqat hai, jitni Rajputi talwar mein."

The Padmini Mahal, where Rani Padmini supposedly lived, is regarded as sacrosanct, and temples and shrines have been built in her memory in Rajasthan. Jodhaa Bai, while revered as a historical figure, has no such cultural significance.

The Rajputs' intense emotion for Rani Padmini comes from anger and hurt. To put it from their perspective, she was a dutiful wife to a brave Rajput king. All was well, till she unwittingly became the object of the uncontrolled lust of a barbaric Muslim plunderer.

The Rajput hero of our story (Maharawal Ratan Singh) fights valiantly till his last breath, but is vanquished by the villain (Alauddin Khilji). The heroine refuses to be 'defiled' and instead, goes beyond her call of duty and embraces death by jumping into a burning pyre.

Needless to say, this is a sore point for the Rajputs. Rani Padmini's pride and honour has been further aggrandised to whitewash the defeat at the hands of Alauddin Khilji. Anyone who dares differ from this narrative will not be spared.

Jodhaa Akbar weaves together a tale of romance between a Hindu princess, Jodhaa Bai, and a Muslim emperor, Akbar, and how they achieve communal harmony. It is not a subject that evokes such strong sentiments as Padmavati does.


There, of course, is the divide along religious lines too. With Padmavati, emotions have been spilling over because how dare a filmmaker show the quintessential Rajput woman dancing in front of men in 'less clothing' and a Muslim barbarian dreaming about romancing her?

Jodhaa Bai, on the other hand, might probably have served as one of the first examples of 'love jihad', a concept that saffron fanatics have been trying to peddle for a few years now. In fact, one can't help but wonder if Jodhaa Akbar would have been allowed to release, had it been made today. Because, how dare a filmmaker show a Hindu princess and a Muslim emperor living in marital bliss?

(Source: India Today)

Padmavati row: An open letter from Shurpanakha to men sharpening knives

As noses go Deepika's is a nice nose, don’t you think? Not that it matters to you, you’d cut off any woman’s nose and then promptly get to writing that she looked kakka anyway, what loss her nose? asks Nisha Susan in the Ladies Finger. Read on: 

Can’t a girl get some sleep around here? No? Because every time I get a little shut-eye I hear that metallic grind of you lot sharpening something. And then I know it’s not my nose, but there is some woman’s nose you are after.

This time, I hear it’s Deepika Padukone’s nose. Because she is in that movie about Padmavati, a long-dead woman who a long-dead man may have seen in a mirror. Over the millennia I’ve seen lots of gents running around cutting women’s noses. As you know. For stupid reasons. As also you know. I mean, you got worked up when Padukone said she is appalled that you brothers did things like destroy shops and vandalise a cinema hall in Kota. “Rajputs never raise a hand on women but if need be, we will do to Deepika what Lakshman did to Shurpanakha,” said Karni Sena leader Mahipal Singh Makrana.

Having lived as long as I have, I can never crank up feelings to properly appalled. But attacking that rangoli artist in Surat was quite random, if you don’t mind my saying so. Abhi kya hai ki, I don’t mind if you mind also. The beauty of my post naak-katva scene is that men in battle formation or sulk formation cease to bother you. Now, if only I didn’t wake up each time I hear that grinding I’d be truly zen. But there is that Phantom Nose Syndrome, what to do.

Karni Sena leader threatened to cut off Deepika Padukone’s nose. Photo courtesy: Padmavati Facebook Page
As noses go Padukone’s is a nice nose, don’t you think? Not that it matters to you, you’d cut off any woman’s nose and then promptly get to writing that she looked kakka anyway, what loss her nose? I wasn’t bad-looking, you know. I looked a lot like my mother Kaikesi. But you men were in some post-truth funk, prepared to swear up and down that since I made a move first, I must be desperate with my ugly face, pot-belly and those sharp nails of mine.

My friends called me Meenakshi, if you really want to know. I did have eyes like a fish and I needed those sharp nails in my life. First they married me to someone literally called Dushtabuddhi (I mean, literally) and then Ravana was like: Surprise, sis! He’s no good, I will just kill him. So there I was, a widow, not what you call conventionally beautiful, and stuck in the court of an extra ambitious, too many brains brother.

Back in that moment when I was making my famously #fail move on one brother and the other, I kept wondering which way to go. Soft sell or hard sell. Little bit smoochie and then ask them whether they’d teach my brother a lesson, or pick one of the above. Anyway, it all fell apart and instantly appeared you boys ki famous proclivity. Either you are saying ki you didn’t fight your kidnapper hard enough, naak katva di. Or it is that you came on too hard so I will kaato your naak for you. Basically roaming around grinding your knife ready to cut a nose, any lady’s nose.

What is with men and wanting to cut off women’s noses? Photo courtesy: Women India Blog
Now you gents are after Deepika Padukone’s. Sanjay Leela Bhansali has sworn up and down the country that there is no dream sequence in which Alauddin Khilji and Padmavati will be in the same frame and that it’s all a rumour, but you are like no, no, no. Because you have dreamed that there is a dream, is that it? Over hundreds and hundreds of years, ever since the 13th century, the frisson of the Muslim man glimpsing the Rajput queen is still giving you the shivers, is it? (Achha chalo, I don’t blame you on this front. The Other is Hot, this is the universal truth. Hence my misadventures in the forest and hence, also, that incredible Muharram scene in Raees. Whip me.)

Maybe what you are really afraid of is that this new movie will somehow remind people how daft our textbooks are to continuously claim that Khilji attacked Chittor for Padmavati. That people will start wondering why Chittor collapsed, queen or not. Books written by men, I notice, are not so hot on facts and are really hot on blame.

Now I have lots of books I could quarrel about, especially one written by a man whose name starts with a V and ends with an I, but I’m too old for this. Places to go, things to do, y’know. But I’m going to make an exception for Padmavati, seeing as she is my fellow countrywoman from Sri Lanka, at least in that poet dude Malik Muhamed Jayas’ version. According to Jayas, a talking parrot told Chittor’s king Ratan Sen about Padmavati and so he brought her away from her nice, leafy island happiness to be among folk who were constantly worried about noses. And then Khilji, the mirror, the war, and the end. Now, Jayas probably dreamt up a fictional heroine for whom a hardened invader would change his plans to make the story more relatable, or he just liked writing about beautiful women whose lives end badly, or he liked the adolescent pathos of the it-was-all-for nothing-feeling when Khilji walks into an empty fortress after everyone dies. Who knows.

The existence of my nose is no matter and neither is your point, Mr Makrana.
Photo courtesy: Mahipal Singh Makrana Facebook page
I just want to tell you that back in Lanka, no poet would write about women jumping into fire to kill themselves just in case the men lost a battle. We girls from Lanka like to ensure we don’t lose battles (and if you are murmuring something about Hanuman and fire right now, please don’t, that’s another story). Poor Padmavati, so much peer pressure, she must have been wishing that parrot dead and all mirrors shattered. Instead, into the centuries the parrot talked and the mirror gleamed and she became that simpering inflammable miss.

So no, Padmavati wasn’t real but does it matter? And Jodha Bai of Jodhaa Akbar was not really Akbar’s wife, and that doesn’t matter also. I mean, my nose isn’t real and it doesn’t matter and the dream sequence you brothers are burning things in several states for apparently isn’t real and that doesn’t matter either.

Sanjay Leela Bhansali was attacked on set. Photo courtesy: Sanjay Leela Bhansali Twitter handle
Here you are again, fellows, prepared to go to war for a film you haven’t watched. I hear you are saying that Sanjay Leela Bhansali can’t be trusted because you feel he gave haath last time with his Ram-Leela screening, showing you one version and releasing another. Betrayal makes your knife hand itch and everything your mother told you about filmi types is coming back, isn’t it?

I understand the sab kuch jala do feeling (or to quote you precisely, “jauhar ki jwala hai, bahut kuch jalega. Rok sako to rok lo”), so I won’t give you a laundry list of shattered promises that you might want to be angry about instead. Rationality is so overrated. Instead, Karni Sena brothers, I give you one of those strange English sayings: Don’t cut off your nose to spite your face. Why not meditate on that? Breathe in. Breathe out.


Padmavati row: Karni Sena calls Deepika a 'bazaaru' woman

Shri Rajput Karni Sena founder Lokendra Singh Kalvi called Padmavati actress Deepika Padukone nasty names.

The raging protest over the release of director Sanjay Leela Bhansali's upcoming period film Padmavati reached a new low today with the founder of the Shri Rajput Karni Sena, Lokendra Singh Kalvi going on an abusive rant against the film's leading lady Deepika Padukone calling her a 'bazaaru' woman who dances for money.

Speaking to India Today in Patna, Kalvi said that the Sena has called for a Bharat bandh on December 1, the date on which the controversial film is slated to release.

"Padmavati will not release at any cost. Who is Deepika Padukone? Is she the Prime Minister or President that she is challenging us? Will a 'bazaaru' woman like Deepika tell us now what the Rajputs should do? On 1st we have called for Bharat bandh to protest the film," said Lokendra Singh Kalvi.


He further defended the threat given by a member of the Shri Rajput Karni Sena, Mahipal Singh Makarana, to Deepika Padukone to chop off her nose if the release of the film is not stopped. He said that it was the sentiment which should be looked at rather than the words.

"We should go by the sentiments and not the words being used by a protester against Padmavati. What is the status of Deepika? She is just a woman who dances for money," the Shri Rajput Karni Sena founder said.

Kalvi argued that Ranveer Singh, who plays the role of Alauddin Khilji in Padmavati, chose to do this film in order to do couple of intimate scenes with Deepika Padukone.

"Almost one and a half year back, Ranveer Singh himself said that he would play even a role of a villain to do a few intimate scenes with Deepika Padukone," he said.


(Source: India Today)