Showing posts with label Hurricane Florence. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Hurricane Florence. Show all posts

Monday, 17 September 2018

Why so many people don’t ‘just leave’ when a major hurricane hits

It has nothing to do with being lazy or negligent.

Diane Berberian was so inundated with calls from well-meaning friends and family inviting her to seek shelter from Hurricane Irma with them that she shut off her phone on Tuesday evening.

Despite the grave warnings, the 59-year-old Florida native isn’t going anywhere. It’s far too expensive for the St. Petersburg resident to leave. A flight out of nearby Tampa to Philadelphia, where Berberian has family, would cost her over $1,000, she said. (She noted that she has booked last-minute tickets to Philly in the past that cost as little as $200.)

Berberian is visually impaired, so she doesn’t drive. Even if she did, gas stations across the state are running low on gas. Berberian lives alone and doesn’t have relatives in the area, but she does have friends who will help her get to a shelter, should the need arise.

“I’ve been through this,” Berberian told HuffPost of her past experiences with hurricanes. “I have respect for weather, so I wouldn’t do anything foolish.”

Berberian is hardly alone when it comes to people being unable to escape a hurricane, even one as threatening as Irma.

St. Petersburg resident Diane Berberian won’t be leaving before the storm hits.
She can’t drive and planes are too expensive.

The “extremely dangerous” Category 5 storm has already left at least 13 people dead in the Caribbean and is expected to hit Florida by the weekend. But its path remains uncertain. Florida Gov. Rick Scott declared a state of emergency on Monday and mandatory evacuations have been implemented for the Florida Keys and parts of Miami-Dade County.

Officials in Pinellas County  ― where Berberian lives ― announced on Thursday that they’re evacuating the coastal areas and mobile homes.

“This hurricane will be remembered as one of the greats for generations,” Brian McNoldy, senior hurricane researcher at the University of Miami, told HuffPost.

Historic storm or not, many Floridians have no choice but to stay put when the winds rise.

A man sleeps on the roof of his porch in Biloxi, Mississippi, on Sept. 1, 2005, after Hurricane Katrina destroyed his home.
Those who don’t evacuate before huge storms are often criticized for “choosing” to stay behind. A 2010 study from Northwestern found that the majority of observers looked favorably on Hurricane Katrina victims who had evacuated, calling them “hardworking and self-reliant.” Those who didn’t leave were described as “lazy, negligent and stubborn.”

Such harsh judgments didn’t match the reality of the situation.

Fourteen percent of the people who remained in New Orleans during Hurricane Katrina had a physical disability. Fifty-five percent of them didn’t have access to a car or another way to leave. And 68 percent didn’t have either money in the bank or a useable credit card, Pacific Standard Magazine reported in 2015.

Sometimes, trying to leave can be as risky as sheltering in place.

Travel logistics were a deciding factor last month when Texas officials didn’t order residents to depart before Hurricane Harvey barreled through. At the time, they thought the risks associated with a mass evacuation outweighed those posed by the storm itself, the Los Angeles Times reported.

And they had reason for their fears: In 2005, when Hurricane Rita slammed southeast Texas, at least 60 of the 118 storm-related deaths were connected to the evacuation, according to a report from the Texas House of Representatives. There were cases of heat stroke, fights on the crowded roads and other dangers, the Times noted.

“You literally cannot put 6.5 million [people] on the road,” Houston Mayor Sylvester Turner said as Harvey’s rains were flooding his city. “If you think the situation right now is bad — you give an order to evacuate, you are creating a nightmare.”

Martha Velazquez stands on the road in stalled traffic in eastern Houston as people try to evacuate in advance of Hurricane Rita on Sept. 22, 2005.
For Floridians with access to cars and gas, trying to drive away from the storm is not clearly any safer. Mass evacuations in the face of Irma could cause miles-long gridlock in the state’s long, narrow peninsula, CNN reported.

Flying out is not an easy answer, either. Many flights scheduled for Friday and later have been canceled. Last-minute tickets out of the state were running as high as $3,000, the Miami Herald reported.

A number of airlines have said they aren’t price gouging, which is illegal following a declared state of emergency. American Airlines told the Herald that it hasn’t changed its fare structures and it has added capacity to help affected residents. JetBlue even capped its direct fares out of Florida at $99, but those tickets sold out quickly.

Buses are generally one of the cheaper options. A one-way ticket from Miami to South Carolina costs about $180. But for people who are destitute, even that is out of reach.

People wait in line to purchase plywood at Home Depot in Miami as they prepare for Hurricane Irma on Sept. 6, 2017.
For those who have the money and the physical ability to leave, there’s still the question of where to go and where to stay. Unlike Berberian, not everybody has friends and family ready to shelter them for some unknown period of time.

Camillus House, a Miami-based nonprofit that supports homeless people, has been preparing all week for those who have nowhere else to go during the storm. It currently serves about 1,100 people and is preparing to house an additional 100. The group is reaching out to people on the streets, stocking up on supplies, and seeking out additional volunteers who can help fill sandbags and make sandwiches.

For the city’s most underserved demographics, nonprofits like Camillus House could be their only refuge.

“For folks who are homeless, they’re stuck. They’re not moving because they don’t have a means of getting out of here,” Sam Gil, vice president of marketing and communications at Camillus House, told HuffPost. “For people who are poor or homeless, it’s very, very difficult.”

(Source: HuffPo)

Sunday, 16 September 2018

Don’t pay attention to the hurricane category

The wind-based metric doesn’t fully capture what’s most dangerous about storms like Florence, writes Robinson Meyer in The Atlantic. Read on: 

On Wednesday, Hurricane Florence weakened to a Category 3 storm, and then again to a Category 2. Simultaneously, meteorologists warned that Florence looked even more dangerous than it did before.

How can a storm weaken and also look more life-threatening?

The answer lies in the “hurricane category” system, and how it can distort the most important information about a tropical cyclone.

As a storm bears down on the coast, just about everyone—except, perhaps, veteran meteorologists—tends to fixate on its category. Most people know that the bigger the category, the scarier and more notable a storm.

2015's Hurricane Patricia, one of the strongest tropical cyclones ever recorded, shows where the "category" system breaks down.NOAA
That rule of thumb has the benefit of being true: It was legitimately worrying when, earlier this week, Hurricane Florence seemed like it might become the first Category 5 storm to strike the East Coast north of Florida. Only 33 Category 5 storms have ever been observed in the Atlantic Ocean, and as President Donald Trump exclaimed last year: “I never even knew a Category 5 existed.”

But this rule can also guide families to ruin, especially if they make a survival decision on the basis of category. A family might decide to ignore an evacuation order since it’s survived a Category 4 storm before. But a storm can be scary and notable without having a high category. That’s because only one trait determines a storm’s categorial intensity: its maximum sustained wind speed.

The “category” system—officially known as the Saffir-Simpson Hurricane Wind Scale—is a very simple scheme: The faster a hurricane’s maximum sustained winds, the higher its category. If scientists record winds anywhere in the hurricane between 111 and 129 miles an hour, the storm is Category 3. As soon as they detect 130-mile-an-hour winds, it becomes Category 4.

The scale’s inventors—Herbert Saffir, an engineer, and Robert Simpson, a meteorologist—hoped their scale would measure a storm’s total destruction potential when they developed it in 1971. But their system omits a tremendous amount of information about a storm’s ferocity.

“They took only into account the maximum sustained wind speed,” which is concentrated in a small part of the storm, says Rosimar Ríos-Berríos, a research meteorologist at the National Center for Atmospheric Research. “This doesn’t tell us anything about the storm’s size, or how far from the center the strong winds are located. And it doesn’t tell us anything about rainfall and other hazards.”

She continued: “The problem with [the Saffir-Simpson scale] is that not all hurricanes are the same. We can have two hurricanes with the same category, but one may be smaller and one may be large. Even though they are the same intensity, the impacts may be greater for a large system because the strong winds extend over a large area.”

The category also only loosely describes the most severe hazard of a hurricane: storm surge, which is responsible for half of all hurricane-related deaths in the United States. “The leading cause of fatalities due to tropical cyclones is not the wind, but the water,” Ríos-Berríos said.

Nevertheless, a hurricane’s sustained winds inform the entire way that meteorologists talk about a storm. A hurricane whose peak winds blow a little faster has “strengthened.” If winds lag a bit, then the hurricane has “weakened” or “been downgraded.” This is in fact exactly what happened to Hurricane Florence on Wednesday afternoon. The storm weakened slightly through the day: Its most ferocious winds blew at only 120 miles an hour, not the 130 miles an hour they had achieved earlier this week. This 10-mile-an-hour change was enough to downgrade it from Category 4 to Category 3.

But the size of the storm had actually expanded, wrote Stacy Stewart, a senior hurricane specialist at the National Hurricane Center:

While the hurricane hasn’t strengthened in terms of peak winds, the inner-core and outer wind fields have continued to expand, resulting in an increase the cyclone’s total energy, which will create a significant storm surge event.

In other words, the hurricane looks like it will have worse storm surge now, even though it is officially “weaker” than it was on Tuesday. Hurricane Florence was also predicted to take a meandering, dangerous track that will strafe against the coast of North and South Carolina on Wednesday—another new and scary aspect of its forecast.

There’s one more problem with the Saffir-Simpson scale: You literally can’t have a hurricane stronger than Category 5. Every storm with peak winds above 157 miles an hour is ruled as such.


Sometimes it seems like there should be a Category 6. In 2015, Hurricane Patricia had wind speeds of 215 miles an hour, but it is categorized identically to 2016’s Hurricane Matthew, which had wind speeds of 160 miles an hour. “With climate change, the oceans are going to warm up and hurricanes are likely to intensify,” says Lakshmi Kantha, a professor of earth science at the University of Colorado at Boulder. “Calling them Category 5 is no longer acceptable, then. You have to bump it up so you can go beyond 5.”

There are candidates to replace the Saffir-Simpson scale. Researchers at the National Center for Atmospheric Research have proposed a “Cyclone Damage Potential Index,” which takes into account maximum surface winds, the radius of hurricane-force winds, and how quickly the hurricane moves along its track.

Kantha has suggested a similar system in which hurricanes are categorized through a combination of their peak winds and the radius of their hurricane-force winds. Florence’s peak sustained winds are 120 miles an hour, and its hurricane-force winds extend to 70 miles, he told me. This would make the hurricane Category 2.6 in his reading, he said.

“Florence, however, will go over the warm Gulf Stream before hitting [the] Carolinas, and she is moving slow enough to draw upon the enormous heat content of the Gulf Stream just before hitting the coast,” he added. “So she might intensify very rapidly, and so these indices may go up just before landfall.”

At least these problems aren’t limited to meteorology. Seismologists use the moment-magnitude scale, or Richter scale, to rank the intensity of earthquakes. But a famous 2000 article by a U.S. Geological Survey scientist starts with the following declaration: “I hate the Richter scale.”

Florence might dump 10 trillion gallons of rain on North Carolina

People often use the word trillions when they're overexaggerating something. This is no exaggeration.

North Carolina may get 10 trillion gallons of rain over the next week from Hurricane Florence. This eye-popping prediction comes from meteorologist Ryan Maue of weathermodels.com. Maue calculated the number from the seven-day rainfall forecast put out Wednesday by the National Weather Service Ocean Prediction Center.
So just how much rain is 10 trillion gallons? Well, we crunched the numbers and figured out that's enough to fill 15 million Olympic-sized swimming pools.


Or it's enough water for you to take about 581.4 billion showers.

The scary-looking map that Maue tweeted out with his startling stat covers North Carolina with all bright reds and deep purples, showing the insane amount of rain predicted for the state.

(Source: CNN)

Saturday, 15 September 2018

Hurricane Florence flood victims turn to social media for rescue

Government and civilian rescuers are working to get trapped people to safety in New Bern, North Carolina.

Some residents of the riverfront city of New Bern, North Carolina, who didn’t evacuate ahead of Hurricane Florence were awaiting rescue early Friday, trapped at their homes by the storm’s wind and heavy rains.

About 150 people were waiting to be rescued, the city tweeted. Watercraft manned by two out-of-state Federal Emergency Management Agency teams, the city fire department, and the volunteer Cajun Navy were assisting in moving stranded people to safety.


CrowdSource Rescue, a Twitter account devoted to making sure people reach safety, coordinated with civilian responders and tweeted updates for those who were trapped. The group’s website allows people to file a ticket detailing their location and the help they need.

Those trapped by the storm also used Twitter to send out their locations to rescuers.

“We’ve planned for this,” New Bern Mayor Dana Outlaw said. “We knew it was coming, and we’re working very hard to keep our citizens safe. We were able to evacuate quite a few; some did not go.”

Resident Peggy Perry, who awaited rescue, told CNN that her house flooded up to her waist “in a matter of seconds.”

“And we’re stuck in the attic. There’s four of us,” she said. “We’ve been up here for like three or four hours. There’s a little window here that we might have to break up (to get out).”

Hundreds of thousands were without power as of early Friday as the slow-moving storm began lashing the coastal area. As much as three feet of rain and “catastrophic” flooding were expected.

(Source: HuffPo)

Hurricane Florence is the latest setback to struggling flood insurance program

Hurricane Florence is poised to bring flooding and destruction to thousands of homes in the Carolinas and Virginia, and another blow to the federal program meant to insure homeowners and businesses against flood damage.

Most private insurance policies don't protect against damage from floods caused by rain, overflowing rivers or storm surge. For that damage, the National Flood Insurance Program, which is run by FEMA, provides most of the coverage.


The cost of claims is supposed to be covered by the premiums paid by policyholders. But attempts by Congress to raise premiums enough to cover actual damages caused an outcry from those living in flood zones. That prompted Congress to back off plans to raise rates and place limits how much premiums can be increased. And that only added to massive losses in the program.

Last year with hurricanes Harvey, Irma and Maria, the program paid out $8.7 billion to policyholders, the third highest total in the program's history.

The payments would have pushed the program's finances past its borrowing limits, but Congress forgave $16 billion the program owed the federal government to allow it to pay out the claims. The move received virtually no press coverage, despite the price tag.

"It's damn near impossible for the program not to lose money," said Craig Fugate, the head of FEMA during the Obama administration. "It's been what everybody hopes for but the reality is since you only have mandatory purchases if you live in a [flood zone], you're insuring the highest risk with the least amount of premiums."


Fugate said there should be more attention given to the losses in the program, including last year's debt forgiveness.

"They wrote off $16 billion and no one raised an eyebrow," he said. "That $16 billion could have gone to Pell grants, cancer research, helping to treat veterans."

Hurricane Florence, which is forecast to dump huge amounts of rain as it moves inland, is only going to put new pressure on the already strapped program.

There are 444,000 flood insurance policies in North Carolina, South Carolina and Virginia, the three states expected to take the brunt of the storm. They have a total of $115 billion in flood insurance coverage between them.

Only a fraction of those policies will file claims after the storm, but even if the flood insurance program pays out 5% of the policies' limits, that comes to nearly $6 billion. And $6 billion in claims would be more than the program paid out over the four years between 2013 and 2016.

Claims reaching $6 billion are a real possibility said Chuck Watson, an analyst with the disaster research group Enki Research.

He said the storm surge alone could prompt between $2 billion to $3 billion in claims, since the homes in coastal communities are more likely to have policies in place. An additional $2 billion to $3 billion in claims could come from inland flooding caused by rain and rising rivers.

Watson cautioned it could cost the program far more than that, depending on how the storm develops.
"Flood losses are predictable if we know what the rain fall is," said Watson. "The question is how long Florence will be around, will it stall, and how much inland rain we will get."

Homeowners with federally-backed mortgages who live in areas judged to be at risk of flooding are required to have flood insurance as a condition of their closing on the loan. But coverage is relatively rare for those who live outside those areas, even though many homes outside of those zones sustain flood damage.

Watson and Fugate both say part of the problem is that current premiums don't accurately reflect the risks, and even encourage people to build in areas susceptible to flooding. If Congress doesn't want to hit existing homeowners with huge premium increases that make their homes unaffordable, it could at least prohibit policies on new construction in the flood zones, Fugate said.

Watson said that the flood maps need to be adjusted to more accurately reflect the risk of flooding, which would force more people to get policies and help increase premium revenue for the program. Many of the homes that sustain flood damage every year lie outside of designated flood zones, which causes massive uninsured losses. Flood damage from this storm could easily be double what is covered by existing flood policies.

"The flood zone delineations are just wrong," said Watson. "But communities don't like expansion flood zone, because it makes development more expensive and difficult. So the flood zones really don't reflect the risk."

(Source: CNN)

Friday, 14 September 2018

Hurricane Florence: North Carolina fears possible environmental disaster

Waste from hog manure pits, coal ash dumps and other industrial sites could wash into homes and contaminate drinking water

Hurricane Florence could cause an environmental disaster in North Carolina, where waste from hog manure pits, coal ash dumps and other industrial sites could wash into homes and threaten drinking water supplies.

Preparations are also being made at half a dozen nuclear power plants that stand in the path of the 500-mile-wide hurricane, which is barreling toward the US east coast, expected to make landfall Thursday night. More than 1.4 million residents across North and South Carolina have been ordered to evacuate.

“Preparations to protect life and property should be rushed to completion,” the National Hurricane Center warned Wednesday morning.

Donald Trump has declared that his administration was “absolutely, totally prepared” to deal with the storm, despite warnings from the National Weather Service that Florence “will likely be the storm of a lifetime for portions of the Carolina coast”.

The president insisted on Wednesday that – despite widespread criticism – his government had done an “under-appreciated great job” handling Hurricane Maria last year in Puerto Rico, which killed nearly 3,000 people.

Georgia on Wednesday joined North and South Carolina and Virginia in declaring a state of emergency ahead of the storm making landfall.

In North Carolina, computer models predict more than 3ft of rain in the eastern part of the state – and fears were exacerbated by the many environmental hazards lying in the path of the storm.

There are 16 nuclear reactors in North Carolina, South Carolina and Virginia, the states expected to suffer the most damage from Florence.

Duke Energy, which runs reactors at six sites, has said operators would begin shutting down nuclear plants at least two hours before hurricane-force winds arrive.

Brunswick nuclear plant, located south of Wilmington near the mouth of the Cape Fear river, was identified in 2014 by Huffpost and Weather.com as one of the nuclear facilities most at risk from rising sea levels and resulting floods.

Workers board up shops in preparation for Hurricane Florence in Wrightsville Beach, North Carolina, on 11 September. Photograph: Mark Wilson/Getty Images
The Brunswick plant’s two reactors are of the same design as those in Fukushima, Japan, that exploded and leaked radiation following a 2011 earthquake and tsunami. Following that disaster, federal regulators required all US nuclear plants to perform upgrades to better withstand earthquakes and flooding.

Duke Energy did not respond to requests for information about specific changes made at Brunswick, other than to say emergency generators and pumps will remove stormwater at the plant if it floods. The company issued assurances this week that it is ready for Florence, which is predicted to pack winds of up to 140 miles per hour and a 13ft storm surge.

“They were safe then. They are even safer now,” said Kathryn Green, a Duke spokeswoman, referring to the post-Fukushima improvements. “We have backups for backups for backups.”

The area in the path of the storm in eastern North Carolina is a fertile low-lying plain veined by brackish rivers with a propensity for escaping their banks. Longtime locals don’t have to strain their imaginations to foresee what rain at the level predicted from Florence can do. It’s happened before.

In September 1999, Hurricane Floyd came ashore near Cape Fear as a category 2 storm that dumped about 2ft of water on a region already soaked days earlier by Hurricane Dennis. The result was the worst natural disaster in state history, a flood that killed dozens of people and left whole towns underwater, with residents stranded on rooftops.

The bloated carcasses of hundreds of thousands of hogs, chickens and other drowned livestock bobbed in a nose-stinging soup of fecal matter, pesticides, fertilizer and gasoline so toxic that fish flopped helplessly on the surface to escape it. Rescue workers smeared Vick’s VapoRub under their noses to try to numb their senses against the stench.

Florence is forecast to make landfall in the same region as a much stronger storm.

“This one is pretty scary,” said Jamie Kruse, director of the Center for Natural Hazards Research at East Carolina University. “The environmental impacts will be from concentrated animal feeding operations and coal ash pits. Until the system gets flushed out, there’s going to be a lot of junk in the water.”

North Carolina has roughly 2,100 industrial-scale pork farms containing more than 9 million hogs typically housed in long metal sheds with grated floors designed to allow the animals’ urine and feces to fall through and flow into nearby open-air pits containing millions of gallons of untreated sewage.

During Floyd, dozens of these lagoons either breached or were inundated by flood waters, spilling the contents. State taxpayers ended up buying out and closing 43 farms located in floodplains.

To prepare for Florence, the North Carolina Pork Council says its members have pumped down lagoon levels to absorb at least 2ft of rain. Low-lying farms have been moving their hogs to higher ground.

Murphy Family Farms employees float dead pigs down a flooded road near Beulaville, North Carolina, on 24 September 1999, following Hurricane Floyd. Photograph: Alan Marler/AP
The Environmental Protection Agency said Tuesday that it would be monitoring nine toxic waste cleanup sites near the Carolinas coast for potential flooding. More than a dozen such Superfund sites in and around Houston flooded last year in the aftermath of Hurricane Harvey, with spills of potentially hazardous materials reported at two.

Also of concern are more than two dozen massive coal ash pits operated by Duke Energy. The gray ash that remains after coal is burned contains potentially harmful amounts of mercury, arsenic and lead.

Since power plants need vast amounts of water to generate steam, their unlined waste pits are located along lakes and rivers. Some of the pits were inundated during past storms, including during Floyd and Hurricane Matthew in 2016.

After a 2014 spill at a Duke plant that coated 70 miles of the Dan River in toxic gray sludge, state regulators forced the Charlotte-based company to begin phasing out its coal ash pits by 2029. Because that work was already underway, wastewater levels inside the ash ponds have been falling, Duke Energy spokesman Bill Norton said Tuesday.

“We’re more prepared than ever,” said Norton, adding that crews will be monitoring water levels at the pits throughout the storm.

(Source: The Guardian)