President 'still in the process of clearing his virus’, argues respiratory scientist, as another aide tests positive
Donald Trump is likely shedding airborne coronavirus particles each time he breathes, an expert in respiratory sciences has said, as the US president continues to recover from his diagnosis last week.
The 74-year-old president, who remained out-of-sight on Tuesday, was discharged having spent as little as three nights at the Walter Reed Medical Centre outside Washington D.C. on Monday.
That followed his coronavirus diagnosis on Thursday night, which his doctors admitted had caused two drops in the president’s oxygen levels over the weekend.
And whilst his physician, Sean Conley, reported that the president had “no symptoms” on Monday, it was still not clear whether Mr Trump was still Covid-19 positive – and therefore potentially spreading his infection to White House staff at present.
Studies carried-out on coronavirus patients have so far shown that they typically continue to shed airborne virus particles for up to 10 days from their first symptoms, according to Dr Julian Tang, honorary associate professor in respiratory sciences at the University of Leicester.
Dr Tang argued that the president was likely still shedding virus particles if he was diagnosed on Friday morning.
“If he was PCR (polymerase chain reaction) positive on Friday with more symptoms developing on Saturday last week, he is likely still infectious and shedding airborne virus each time he breathes,” said the professor.
The president has been widely criticised for ripping off his mask while appearing on the Truman balcony upon his return to the White House on Monday, a stunt described as being reminiscent of Mussolini.
“We expect most acute Covid-19 cases to be shedding live virus for up to 10 days post-symptom onset,” he added, pointing to the body’s production of antibodies around 10 to 15 days after initial symptoms," Dr Tang added.
“So, although he has apparently recovered to some extent from his acute Covid-19 phase, he is still in the process of clearing his virus,” Dr Tang said.
As that news broke, CNN’s medical analyst and cardiologist, Dr Jonathan Reiner, suggested that Mr Trump was the White House’s so-called coronavirus “superspreader”.
"I think POTUS was infected with coronavirus for at least a week before he was admitted to the hospital ... I think he's the superspreader,” argued Dr Reiner. “And I think the reason the White House will not have the CDC do a formal check ... is they're concerned patient zero might be POTUS."
CNN reported on Tuesday that the White House is refusing the offer of contact tracing assistance from the Centers for Disease Control, amid speculation surrounding the extent of the administration's attempts to isolate potentially infected individuals.
Mr Trump is expected to continue recovering for at least another week from the White House, with less than four weeks to go until election day.
Trump canceled travel to Florida for a planned campaign event. The severity of Covid-19 cases varies widely and it was not clear whether the president felt ill.
The diagnosis left the next steps in the presidential campaign in doubt and led to a scramble for testing on Capitol Hill, where elected officials have been planning confirmation hearings for supreme court nominee Amy Coney Barrett.
If Trump becomes too ill to lead the country, the vice-president, Mike Pence, could be placed in charge under a constitutional provision. Pence and his wife tested negative on Friday, a spokesperson announced.
The Democratic nominee, Joe Biden, released a statement of support: “Jill and I send our thoughts to President Trump and First Lady Melania Trump for a swift recovery. We will continue to pray for the health and safety of the president and his family.” Biden was reportedly due to take a Covid-19 test shortly.
Hicks had flown with the president on Air Force One earlier on Wednesday and accompanied him to the first presidential debate on Tuesday in Cleveland, Ohio.
The CDC guidelines for people who have tested positive state that they should inform all close contacts.
Pence attended a White House coronavirus taskforce briefing with Trump on Monday. Pence did not attend the presidential debate.
Hicks is not the only White House staffer to have contracted the virus. Katie Miller, press secretary to the vice-president, who is married to Trump’s adviser Stephen Miller, has recovered from Covid-19. One of Trump’s personal valets also tested positive for coronavirus, in May.
Donald and Melania Trump at the airport in Cleveland, Ohio, on Tuesday. The president and first lady have both tested positive for Covid-19. Photograph: Carlos BarrĂa/Reuters
What we don’t know
How long the virus has been circulating in the White House. Close aides to Trump told Bloomberg he seemed ill as early as Wednesday. According to the World Health Organization, it takes five or six days on average from when someone is infected until symptoms show, but it can take 14 days. It appears Hicks began to feel ill on Wednesday.
If any of the people Trump came close to in the last week, including Biden at Tuesday’s debate, have become infected. Trump also attended a rally in Minnesota on Wednesday and a fundraiser at his New Jersey golf club on Thursday, the latter after Hicks had begun to show symptoms.
The language barrier fell away Monday when Emperor Naruhito and Empress Masako greeted U.S. President Donald Trump and first lady Melania Trump in English at the Imperial Palace, in what could be a taste of things to come for the most internationally minded imperial couple in Japan’s history.
Trump became the first world leader to meet with the emperor since he ascended the throne and the Reiwa Era began on May 1. Monday also marked the imperial couple’s first ever meeting with Trump.
The emperor and empress greeted the president and first lady with warm smiles upon their arrival at the palace. The party shook hands and then continued inside, where the imperial couple introduced their guests to other members of the imperial family. Prime Minister Shinzo Abe and his wife, Akie Abe, were also in attendance.
Emperor Naruhito chats with U.S. President Donald Trump as Empress Masako speaks with first lady Melania Trump — both without the help of interpreters — at the Imperial Palace in Tokyo on Monday. | POOL / VIA KYODO
Afterward, the imperial couple met with the president and first lady for further discussion. In the past, such meetings have been used to discuss the state of each nation.
The emperor is a graduate of Oxford University with experience traveling in Europe, and the empress, a graduate of Harvard, is a former diplomat and a polyglot fluent in English and French. The arrival of a multilingual imperial couple is seen by observers as representing a decisive shift in the Japanese monarchy and its relationship with other nations.
On Monday, the emperor and empress acted as translators for Trump and the first lady as they spoke to a seemingly endless line of politicians, ambassadors and other guests. Professional interpreters — who were presumably hired for the occasion — could only watch while the imperial couple handled themselves with poise while navigating countless introductions and interactions throughout the affair.
Trump’s meeting with the imperial couple was followed by a summit with Abe. In the evening, a banquet at the Imperial Palace was set to be attended by roughly 170 guests including members of the imperial family and several Cabinet ministers, among others. (Source: JT)
A recent public appearance has reignited internet rumours that the White House occasionally employs a body double to stand in for the first lady.
Donald and Melania Trump visited the town of Opelika in Alabama on Friday 8 March to survey the damage done to the state by a recent tornado, a natural disaster in which 23 people lost their lives.
The president and first lady spent time signing Bibles and paying their respects to local people at a makeshift relief centre on what was a deeply sombre occasion, expressing their support for residents and handing out supplies.
But one picture of Mrs Trump, stood holding hands with her husband before a row of white crosses outside the Providence Baptist Church, struck some observers as very odd indeed.
The woman in the press shot, taken by Nicholas Kamm of AFP, just didn't look like Melania.
"So everyone has just accepted that they use a fake melania sometimes", one Twitter user asked.
"It's crazy to me that every news organization isn't working full time on the Melania stunt double story," wrote another.
President Trump has since hit out at the story on Twitter after the Fox and Friends breakfast show devoted a segment to it, accusing the media of photoshopping the original. "They are only getting more deranged with time!" he fumed.
The Fake News photoshopped pictures of Melania, then propelled conspiracy theories that it’s actually not her by my side in Alabama and other places. They are only getting more deranged with time!
The suspicion the White House routinely uses a body double in place of the real Mrs Trump, an old security ploy once used to safeguard dictators like Joseph Stalin and Saddam Hussein, is not new.
According to Snopes, it was first pitched on Facebook by actress Andrea Wagner Barton and on Twitter by Joe Vargas (founder and CEO of CBD Dispensary, a Las Vegas-based retailer of hemp syrup) on 18 October 2017, both posting videos of the first lady stood mute and nodding beside her husband:
This is not Melania. To think they would go this far & try & make us think its her on TV is mind blowing. Makes me wonder what else is a lie pic.twitter.com/JhPVmXdGit
President Trump rather hurriedly referring to, "My wife Melania, she's right here", certainly roused suspicion and an accompanying picture tweeted by Vargas appeared to show a completely different woman, with broader nostrils and a flatter chin, those distinctive eyes concealed behind huge Jackie Kennedy sunglasses.
The suggestion that the Trumps were employing a body double took Twitter by storm, with the perennially-paranoid keen to promote it as the latest evidence of sinister government deception, rarely stopping to ask what interest the state might have in concealing the real Melania.
The hysteria eventually forced a denial from East Wing communications director Stephanie Grisham, who told CNN: "Once again, we find ourselves consumed with a ridiculous non-story when we could be talking about the work the first lady is doing on behalf of children, including the opioid crisis that is gripping our nation."
In other words, the White House turned the story to its advantage, using the "ridiculous non-story" as further evidence in support of President Trump's "fake news" narrative, used to attack and discredit media outlets hostile to his agenda.
The trope returned in July 2018 when a windswept Melania was seen descending the steps of Air Force One as she and her husband arrived in Brussels for a Nato summit.
A popular theory about the Melania doppleganger is that a Secret Service agent assigned to protect her periodically takes her place at affairs of state.
One Twitter user noticed over the weekend that the first lady and her bodyguard even wear the same ring on their left hands, only adding to the intrigue.
Too weird for words. Are Melania and #FakeMelania even wearing the same ring? Do secret service agents generally wear such elaborate rings on the job? pic.twitter.com/Hm784nsBNn
"The United States Secret Service doesn't use body doubles," former agent Jonathan Wackrow categorically told CNN in response to the first incident in 2017.
"Mrs Trump's lead agent is a woman... and she happens to look a little like her, but physically, she is much shorter," he said.
The desire to believe Melania Trump might wish to duck out of official engagements springs from the popular assumption she dislikes her public duties and is a reluctant first lady.
Or even hates her husband so much she can't stand to be around him.
While Melania has said little about the president's alleged extramarital affairs with porn star Stormy Daniels and Playboy model Karen McDougal, her habits of batting away the President's hand and walking well behind him have been noted.
The Huffington Post even tasked a body language expert to assess the behaviour two years ago, Jacqueline Whitmore concluding the patterns "could be perceived as a sign of disrespect".
Her initial decision to stay in New York rather than join her husband in Washington after his inauguration, apparently to shield their then 10-year-old son Barron from the media spotlight, was regarded as highly suspect.
As was her disappearance from public view in May 2018 while she recovered from a kidney operation, which forced her to tweet reassuring her followers she is alive and well.
I see the media is working overtime speculating where I am & what I'm doing. Rest assured, I'm here at the @WhiteHouse w my family, feeling great, & working hard on behalf of children & the American people!
If Melania Trump really does loathe her role so much she'd rather hire an imposter than be on public view - as indicated by her notorious "I really don't care, do u?" army coat - it is, to an extent, understandable.
Her White House Christmas decorations are routinely derided as "scary" and her anti-bullying agenda is either undermined by her husband overtly bullying his rivals on the world stage or picked apart for rehashing old Obama-era pamphlets with a new cover.
French first lady Brigitte Macron described Melania as "very fun" behind closed doors when they met last year but observed she is subject to so much criticism "she can't even open a window" without being criticised.
Why not let someone else take the flack once in a while?
US President Donald Trump and First Lady Melania Trump have made an unannounced Christmas visit to US troops in Iraq.
They travelled there "late on Christmas night" to thank troops for "their service, their success and their sacrifice", the White House said.
Mr Trump said the US had no plans to pull out of Iraq.
The trip came days after Defence Secretary Jim Mattis quit over divisions about strategy in the region.
The US still has some 5,000 troops in Iraq to support the government in its fight against what remains of the Islamic State (IS) group.
However, a planned meeting between Mr Trump and Iraqi Prime Minister Adel Abdul Mahdi was cancelled. Mr Mahdi's office said it was because of disagreements on how to conduct the meeting.
A phone call between the two leaders was held instead and the White House said Mr Mahdi had accepted an invitation to visit Washington.
What happened during Trump's visit?
Mr Trump, his wife and National Security Adviser John Bolton travelled on Air Force One to al-Asad airbase, west of the capital Baghdad, to meet military personnel in the base's restaurant.
It was his first visit to the region.
During the visit he got a standing ovation from troops as he entered a dining hall and walked around greeting them, posing for selfies and signing autographs.
He said the reason for the visit was to personally thank them for helping to defeat IS, adding: "Two years ago when I became president they were a very dominant group, today they're not so dominant any more. Great job."
.@FLOTUS Melania and I were honored to visit our incredible troops at Al Asad Air Base in Iraq. GOD BLESS THE U.S.A.! pic.twitter.com/rDlhITDvm1
Mr Trump had planned to spend Christmas at his private golf club in Florida, but stayed behind in Washington because of the current partial government shutdown.
The visit to Iraq lasted about three hours. On the flight back, the president's plane refuelled at Ramstein Air Base in Germany and Mr Trump used the brief stopover to meet troops stationed there. He posed for pictures and shook hands with some of the hundreds of soldiers who lined up inside a hangar.
President Donald Trump signed "Make America Great Again" hats during his visit to Ramstein Air Base, Germany
What did Trump say in Iraq?
"We're no longer the suckers, folks," he told American service personnel. "We're respected again as a nation."
Mr Trump said the US could use Iraq as a forward base if "we wanted to do something in Syria", Reuters news agency reports.
He defended his decision to withdraw US troops from Syria during the visit, saying: "A lot of people are going to come around to my way of thinking.
"I made it clear from the beginning that our mission in Syria was to strip Isis [another name for IS] of its military strongholds.
"Eight years ago, we went there for three months and we never left. Now, we're doing it right and we're going to finish it off."
President Trump and his wife met military personnel at the al-Asad airbase, west of Baghdad
Mr Trump also spoke of his conversations with Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan which are believed to have influenced his decision to pull US forces out of Syria.
"I will tell you that I've had some very good talks with President Erdogan who wants to knock them (IS) out also and he'll do it. And others will do it too," Mr Trump said.
"We are in their region. They should be sharing the burden of costs and they're not."
He said there would be no delays in the withdrawal and added that the US "cannot continue to be the policeman of the world".
President Trump told service personnel he wanted thank them for their work
"It's not fair when the burden is all on us, the United States," he said.
"We don't want to be taken advantage of any more by countries that use us and use our incredible military to protect them. They don't pay for it, and they're going to have to."
The president also said that security considerations had prevented him from visiting US troops in the region several weeks ago.
Why is withdrawing from Syria controversial?
Mr Trump announced the decision to pull US troops out of Syria last week.
However, important allies including senior Republicans and foreign powers have disputed the claim that IS is defeated in Syria and say the US withdrawal could lead to a resurgence.
In his resignation letter, General Mattis said he did not share Mr Trump's views.
One of the top US diplomats in the fight against IS, Brett McGurk, also resigned early. He reportedly described Mr Trump's decision as a "reversal of policy" that "left our coalition partners confused and our fighting partners bewildered".
A Kurdish-led alliance, the Syria Democratic Forces (SDF), has also warned that IS could recover.
US troops have helped rid much of Syria's north-east of the jihadist group, but pockets of fighters remain.
She said she’s too busy being a mother and first lady to fret about cheating accusations.
First lady Melania Trump said she doesn’t waste time wondering about reports of President Donald Trump’s infidelities.
“I’m a mother and a first lady, and I have much more important things to think about and to do,” she told ABC in an interview taped last week, new snippets of which aired Friday. “It is not concern and focus of mine.”
Media attention from a stream of women who have accused the president of sexual misconduct or extramarital affairs isn’t pleasant, the first lady added, dismissing the claims as “gossip.”
“Yes, we are fine,” she said of her marriage. “It’s what media speculate, and it’s gossip. It’s not always correct stuff. I’m very strong, and I know what my priorities are.”
EXCLUSIVE: First lady Melania Trump brushes aside allegations of her husband’s infidelity.
“I’m a mother and a first lady, and I have much more important things to think about and to do,” she tells @ABC. https://t.co/VILtmVBA2E pic.twitter.com/MSLsRksVu8
— ABC News (@ABC) October 12, 2018
The first lady, who has mostly been reserved during her time in the White House, revealed in the interview series that she doesn’t hesitate to offer her husband advice and opinions on political matters. She said she made known her distrust of some in the administration who no longer hold their positions, for example.
She also referred to herself as “the most bullied person in the world” because of what people say about her.
Among the high-profile accusations against Donald Trump is former porn star Stormy Daniels’ claim they had an affair a few months after the birth of Barron Trump.
Daniels, whose real name is Stephanie Clifford, said she was silenced in the weeks before the 2016 election. Trump’s former lawyer, Michael Cohen, said Trump directed him to pay the actress $130,000 to sign a non-disclosure agreement. Her tell-all book, Full Disclosure, was published last month.
Melania Trump, in an interview that aired on Friday, offered an assessment of being first lady: “This won’t last forever.”
Trump gave a rare insight into her White House life during an interview on ABC’s “20/20,” taped during her visit last week to Africa, in which she addressed an array of topics, including the #MeToo movement, her husband’s alleged infidelities and her efforts to rein in her husband’s notorious Twitter habits.
“I don’t agree always with what he posts,” she said of President Trump’s use of the social media platform.
In the interview, Melania Trump also took on one of her own biggest controversies — the jacket she wore to visit the U.S.-Mexico border, where migrant children were being separated from their families under the Trump administration’s policies, that read “I really don’t care, do u?” That message was “for the left-wing media” and other critics, she said, echoing her husband’s explanation of the jarring sartorial choice.
The network had been teasing the Friday night interview, the only one that the first lady has sat for since her husband was elected, by releasing snippets throughout the week.
Melania Trump considers herself “one of the most bullied people in the world.” She revealed that there are people working in the White House that she doesn’t trust. She said women accusing men of sexual assault needed to show “really hard evidence.”
And she said allegations of her husband’s infidelity were “not a concern and focus of mine.” On the state of her marriage? “Yes, we are fine.”
Which might not sound like a woman baring her soul — but for the normally tight-lipped first lady, who publicly sticks to short, teleprompter remarks, such statements were something close to revealing.
In the 20 months of her husband’s presidency, Melania Trump has said little publicly about the news of the day, scandals swirling around her husband’s administration or about policy issues. When she has spoken in front of cameras, it has almost always been scripted, invariably brief and carefully crafted to avoid controversy.
Her silence had led some of her husband’s critics to project their own ideas on her or to imagine that she might not be fully on board with President Trump’s divisive administration. People read volumes into the smallest gestures: her swatting the president’s hand away was seen as a rejection of him (“Melania Trump Hates Her Husband and She’s Becoming Our Spirit Animal,” read a headline on the Root). And whenever cameras capture an unhappy expression, it’s immediately tagged with a #FreeMelania hashtag.
“Democrats want to imagine that she’s the resistance inside the White House, and that’s just not the case,” said Kate Andersen Brower, the author of “First Women: The Grace and Power of America’s Modern First Ladies.” “She’s showing that there’s much less daylight between her and President Trump on issues than people might think.”
Although Melania Trump has shown flashes of independence from her husband — for example, by taking up cyberbullying as a plank of her platform, despite her husband’s belittling comments on Twitter, or her visit to the border to witness people impacted by her husband’s policies — her answers to questions from ABC’s Tom Llamas indicate that behind her reticence to engage in public life is a resolute embrace of President Trump’s worldview.
“I believe in the policies that my husband put together,” she said when asked about his immigration policies. “Because I believe we need to be very vigilant who is coming to the country.”
Even Melania Trump’s claim that she might be the “most bullied person in the world” has the distinct ring of the superlative-loving president.
Democratic strategist Karen Finney said Melania Trump’s defense of her husband in the wake of the “Access Hollywood” tape in which he was heard making derogatory comments about women (Melania Trump dismissed it as “boy talk”) had long ago signaled that the first lady was willing to step into the public eye when her husband needs defending. “That told us a lot about the role she was going to play,” Finney said. “She’s not above the fray. She’s concerned about what’s going on and how it’s being perceived.”
Republican strategist Ron Bonjean says that although Melania Trump might be operating from the Team Trump script, her words can have a different effect than her husband’s. “She may be saying the same thing as the president, but she’s saying it a different way,” he said. “She’s not approaching the issues the way Donald Trump does, which is designed to be in your face and overwhelming — and she’s not tweeting about it. She has a soft touch.”
It’s unlikely that Melania Trump will ever “mom dance” with Jimmy Fallon like Michelle Obama or jokingly refer to herself as a “Desperate Housewife,” as Laura Bush did during a White House correspondents’ dinner comedy routine. But might her recent willingness to speak up signal a new era of approachability?
A new CNN poll finds that the first lady remains more popular than her husband — 54 percent hold a favorable opinion of her, compared with 41 percent for the president — making her a potentially powerful surrogate for her husband’s administration.
“She’s coming into her own as first lady,” Bonjean said. “Many people see her as a very glamorous, but they don’t know anything about her. This is definitely an effort to paint a picture of who Melania Trump is as a person and to start to define her — her personality and her thoughts on the issues.”
But others are loath to forecast much about anyone in the orbit of the famously unpredictable administration.
“Logically, you could see that this might be the beginning of a new approach to being first lady where she is more accessible,” Brower said. “But with the Trumps, who knows? (Source: WP)
First lady Melania Trump said victims who make accusations of sexual misconduct "need to have really hard evidence" in a recently taped interview, echoing a statement she made in October 2016 amid allegations against her husband.
"If you accuse (someone) of something, show the evidence," Trump said in a sit-down interview with ABC News that took place in Kenya last week during her first major solo trip to Africa.
Trump also said she supports women, but she echoed her husband, President Donald Trump, adding that men need to be supported, too.
"I support the women and they need to be heard," said Trump. "We need to support them and, you know, also men, not just women."
She added that women who come forward as victims should be prepared to back up their claims.
"I do stand with women, but we need to show the evidence. You cannot just say to somebody, 'I was sexually assaulted,' or, 'You did that to me,' because sometimes the media goes too far, and the way they portray some stories it's, it's not correct, it's not right," said Trump.
During the 2016 presidential campaign, at least 13 women accused Donald Trump of misbehavior ranging from sexual harassment to sexual assault. They came forward in the wake of a 2005 "Access Hollywood" tape that was released in October 2016 in which he is caught saying on a hot mic: "And when you're a star, they let you do it. You can do anything. ... Grab them by the p***y. You can do anything."
The White House -- through press secretary Sarah Sanders and others -- has dismissed all the allegations against him as old news that was litigated during the campaign.
Melania Trump told CNN's Anderson Cooper in October 2016: "Every assault should be taken care of in a court of law. And to accuse, no matter who it is, a man or a woman, without evidence is damaging and unfair."
"This was all organized from the opposition. And with the details ... did they ever check the background of these women? They don't have any facts," she had said.
The President has also voiced suspicion about the year-old #MeToo movement, complaining that allegations made decades later can ruin a man's life. He has questioned why women wait so long to come forward if they are telling the truth. He also has expressed concern for men in this #MeToo moment.
During an impromptu briefing with press traveling with her in Egypt last week, Trump would not say if she believed Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh's accuser, Christine Blasey-Ford.
"I will move on that and I think that all the victims they need -- we need to help all the victims no matter what kind of abuse they had, but I am against any kind of abuse or violence," she said.
Melania Trump is an enigmatic character: a modern-day Mona Lisa, you might say. As one of the world’s most famous woman, her every action and facial expression is picked over by the media – and yet she remains a total mystery.
What can it be like to have a string of glamorous women claiming to have had sex with your husband in 2006 just after you had given birth to your only son? To have visited your apartment in his company? To have gone to a hotel room where he met them in a bathrobe? I can’t imagine it’s pleasant, even if you already knew some of the details. Even if your husband had a well-documented fondness for the female form, those sorts of allegations must be horrible to hear.
Now Melania has gingerly put her toe into the spotlight, giving a revealing interview to ABC News (her first for over a year) in which she claims she “could be the most bullied person in the world”, and, when pressed if that was true, she reiterated that she believed she was indeed “one of them, if you really see what people are saying about me”.
In the past, Melania has claimed she has a “thick skin” and could handle uncomplimentary remarks – but now, something has changed. She says she has been “chronically harassed” and no longer bothers to check Twitter.
There has been a constant stream of snotty attacks about her appearance (speculation about cosmetic surgery, for instance), her choice of designer clothing and her body language around the president. When she swatted away his hand in public, it made headline news. Comedians routinely joke about the fact they sleep in separate beds, and recently, the former porn star Stormy Daniels told the world about the size of the Trump manhood, describing their sexual encounter in embarrassing details and claiming it was “a total disappointment”.
Is it OK for one famous woman (Daniels, in this case) to bully another by default? Melania is guilty of no crime as far as I know, other than a few fashion faux pas – that jacket with the slogan “I don’t really care, do u?” she wore to visit the Mexican border was a dodgy choice, but who can say they’ve never put on the wrong frock for a big occasion? Melania is always courteous to everyone she encounters, never less than professional in the role she was projected into when her husband (to her great discomfort) was elected to the highest office in the land.
I hope she has a secret exit strategy when his term of office is over and has planned a quiet life out of the spotlight. Maybe even another husband, one who would not be quite so patronising.
Melania’s claim that she’s the most bullied person the world is not altogether without merit – she’s clearly bossed about to within an inch of her life by White House staff, who run around like headless chickens trying to please Trump while at the same time defusing and toning down his most dangerous initiatives. According to New York magazine, Trump has repeatedly tried to fire his chief of staff John Kelly, but Kelly “just ignores him”. Bob Woodward’s new book Fear: Trump in the White House reveals what a chaotic, toxic place it is, with claims that staffers secretly go into the president’s office and remove paperwork off his desk so he can’t action it.
Yesterday the world was granted an astonishing insight into how business is conducted under Trump, when the rapper and megalomaniac Kanye West was filmed bursting into a 10-minute monologue in the Oval Office, ostensibly at a lunch to discuss gang violence and manufacturing jobs in his home town of Chicago.
West started mouthing off and swearing while Trump just sat there, not sure how to respond. One giant ego out-trumping another. In this febrile environment – one where her husband rises early and goes to bed late, glued to the TV news, tweeting a torrent of bombastic abuse directed at anyone who dares question his judgement – is it surprising that Melania should feel under siege?
Contrast her predicament with that of Brigitte Macron, wife of the French president, who has insisted she continues her daily walks around Paris, even if she has to be accompanied by bodyguards. Brigitte’s husband might be increasingly unpopular, but the former teacher is a huge hit, the most popular first lady in years. Poor Melania is a modern prisoner, serving out a sentence in a high-security unit, every step of her day under surveillance.
Melania is clearly no pushover – she has occasionally spoken out to support causes or people her husband doesn’t agree with. Recently, she stuck up for basketball star LeBron James after her husband had described him as “the dumbest man on television”. She has launched a campaign called “Be Best” focusing on cyberbullying – not a comfortable fit with her husband’s volatile behaviour. She’s revealed that some charities have refused to support her because of her husband’s policies. Surely that’s another form of punishment for crimes she’s not guilty of.
As for #MeToo, Melania says that women who claim they have been assaulted deserve to be heard, but they must provide “really hard evidence” to support their claims.
Melania says she gives the president her honest opinions – and then he does what he wants to do. You could read anything into that statement: resignation, weariness, or inner strength. As usual with Melania, it’s annoyingly opaque. The first lady is not the most bullied person in the world, but she is getting a raw deal from liberals and other women. She deserves better.
A gossipy study of the Trump clan reveals little of note besides their obsession with keeping up appearances
When Melania Knauss, a Slovenian-born model, married Donald Trump in Palm Beach at 7pm on 22 January 2005, all was right with the world – at least in the eyes of the groom. At his wedding to wife No 2, Marla Maples, in 1993, only a load of B-listers had turned up. “It’s just like I was afraid of,” the radio star Howard Stern would tell a reporter. “I’m the biggest name here.” Now, though, Trump looked around and saw among those gathered at the Episcopal church of Bethesda-by-the-Sea not only Billy Joel, Barbara Walters and Simon Cowell, but also, infamously, Hillary and Bill Clinton. No wonder that once the vows had been exchanged he was moved enthusiastically to kiss his new wife three times in a row (the doomed Maples had received only a peck on the cheek).
Trump and his family set great store by appearances. Look beyond the surface of things, however, and whatever the occasion, you’ll find so wide a selection of cheap metaphors for the wobbly way their universe operates, you’re truly spoilt for choice. Shortly after midnight, at Trump’s Mar-a-Lago estate, the happy couple cut into their cake: a 70in, seven-tiered gold and white sponge, adorned with 2,000 sugar flowers. Weighing in at more than 90kg, by rights it should have fed the hundreds of guests with perfect ease. Only there was a problem. This mammoth confection was held together by a web of hidden wires, an intricate structure that made it all but impossible to slice. The crowd had to be fed specially baked back-up cakes. The real thing was only eaten later, once the party was over, by the staff.
Their lives, being all riches and no rags, afford neither reporter nor reader even the slightest change of tone or pace
Eric, Barron, Melania, Donald, Ivanka and Donald Trump Jr at the Celebrity Apprentice final at Trump Tower, New York, February 2015. Photograph: Jim Spellman/WireImage
Emily Jane Fox’s Born Trump: Inside America’s First Family fairly bulges with scenes like this; thick and fast they come, five or six to the page. If everything in Trump Land is flashy, super-abundant and wholly exorbitant, it’s also superficial, shoddy and almost entirely mean-spirited. At first, to put it mildly, this is queasy-making. When Trump flies in to Slovenia to meet Melania’s parents, a trip that lasts in total only a few hours – “I was there about 15 minutes…. I landed, said: hi Mom, hi Dad. Bye!” – you think all over again: my God, how ghastly he is. After a while, though, a certain numbness sets in. The news that Jared Kushner proposed to Ivanka Trump with a ring from her own jewellery collection barely raises an eyebrow. The fact that Donald Jr agreed to ask his wife, Vanessa, to marry him in front of a load of television cameras in a New Jersey shopping mall, in order to bag a discount on a $100,000 emerald-cut diamond, strikes you as so predictable as to be almost unworthy of comment.
This, I think, is one of the major problems involved in writing about the Trumps – and all the more so for a writer such as Fox, whose breathless prose is neither quietly angry nor laced with irony (a reporter at Vanity Fair, she is much given to the kind of glossy magazine talk that has her writing sentences such as: “They [Eric Trump and his wife-to-be, Lara] hired both a wedding planner and an event designer who worked with the couple to strike a balance between what Eric described as ‘formal and fun’ with elegance mixed in.”) Their lives, being all riches and no rags, afford neither reporter nor reader even the slightest change of tone or pace.
But there are other difficulties, too. For one, the Trumps have for decades lived out their lives in public, mainstays both of the New York Post’s Page Six and of reality TV, and thanks to this, Fox’s text often reads like nothing so much as an elaborate cuts job. For another, and this is perhaps the more important fact should you unaccountably be thinking of buying this book (I’ve read it so that you don’t have to), the Kennedys they are not. How unutterably stupid-seeming they are, and how unspeakably tedious reading about them is. From Fox, we learn, for instance, that Donald Jr’s nickname at university was Diaper Don, on account of the fact that in his frat boy days, he was inclined to wet the bed when drunk. His young brother Eric, meanwhile, was known by some school friends as Choad, a term that denotes a penis that is wider than it is long (good to know!). Ivanka, the oldest of Trump’s three children by his first wife, Ivana, used to try and make herself seem a touch more interesting than her brothers, and perhaps a little more classy, too. “My friends always joke that I’m going to marry a 90-year-old Pulitzer prize-winner,” she told a (baffled?) interviewer when she was still a single girl. But then she went and married poor little rich boy Kushner, whom even she once described as “a mutant”. What was on their wedding list? (Yes, they really had one.) Answer: 75 items from Williams-Sonoma, Crate & Barrel and Tiffany’s, among them some spatulas, a rolling pin and a Bundt cake pan.
Advertisement
Fox’s book is a gossipy family study; by design, it touches on politics hardly at all. Still, from her brief account of the transition, we learn that Trump wanted nothing to do with the team working on it (“bad karma”, he called the idea of his involvement, using a term he presumably picked up from Marla, who horrified him by giving birth to their daughter, Tiffany, surrounded by candles, with a Native American “nurturer” on hand to provide massage and prayers). Also, that on election night, it wasn’t only Melania who was seemingly traumatised. Asked for a kiss by her vice-president-elect husband, Mrs Pence – the poor creature whom we now know to call Mother – could only snap: “Mike, you got what you wanted.”
What does Fox make of the fact that Trump immediately tasked his son-in-law Kushner with achieving peace in the Middle East? Her analysis is bold. “Years of political know-how and understanding of an issue so complex that it has eluded seasoned diplomats for decades isn’t like conjunctivitis,” she writes. “It doesn’t rub off on shared pillows, nor is it picked up in conversations with a father’s friends over Shabbat dinner.” And having laid this matter thus to rest, she returns swiftly to the important stuff: Ivanka’s brief stint as a model and Jared’s Common Project sneakers; Tiffany’s tragically brief pop career and Eric’s excessive fondness for sauces; Donald Jr’s predilection for shooting prairie dogs in Montana and Donald Snr’s passion for the film Zulu. All in all, it fairly makes you weep, though whether from boredom or because no fewer than three of these people are now installed in the White House, it’s sometimes hard to say.
Melania Trump returned to the White House on Saturday from a weeklong hospitalization after treatment for a kidney condition, a lengthy stay that raised questions about whether the first lady’s condition may have been more complicated than initially revealed.
Her spokeswoman, Stephanie Grisham, has declined to release additional details, citing Trump’s right to privacy.
Donald Trump heralded his wife’s arrival home with a tweet in which her name was spelled incorrectly.
“Great to have our incredible First Lady back home in the White House,” Trump wrote. “Melanie is feeling and doing really well. Thank you for all of your prayers and best wishes!”
The tweet was quickly superseded with another that spelled the first lady’s name correctly.
In a statement on Saturday morning, Grisham said: “The first lady returned home to the White House this morning. She is resting comfortably and remains in high spirits. Our office has received thousands of calls and emails wishing Mrs Trump well, and we thank everyone who has taken the time to reach out.”
The first lady had been at Walter Reed National Military Medical Center near Washington since Monday, when she underwent an embolization procedure to treat an unspecified kidney condition the White House described as benign. Word of the hospitalization came as a surprise because there was no indication in numerous public appearances in recent weeks that Trump had been ailing.
First ladies are under no obligation to make their medical histories public. Grisham said on Monday that the procedure was “successful”, there were no complications and that Trump would probably remain hospitalized for “the duration of the week”.
Melania Trump arrives to announce her “Be Best” children’s initiative in the Rose Garden of the White House. Photograph: Jim Watson/AFP/Getty Images
Mrs Trump has a medical team that is comfortable with her care, which is all that matters
Stephanie Grisham
The president tweeted on Tuesday that his wife would be released in “2 or 3” days, but Thursday and Friday passed without word from the White House. Donald Trump visited during the first three days of her hospitalization but he did not make the trip on Thursday or Friday, leading some to wonder if the first lady had been released.
The first lady, 48, said on Wednesday on Twitter she was “feeling great” and looking forward to going home, but gave no indication of when. On Friday, she tweeted about the school shooting at a Houston-area high school but did not update her followers on her medical situation.
Urologists with no personal knowledge of Trump’s condition said the most likely explanation is a kind of noncancerous kidney tumor called an angiomyolipoma. They are not common but tend to occur in middle-aged women and can cause problematic bleeding if they become large enough, said Dr Keith Kowalczyk of MedStar Georgetown University Hospital.
Doctors often treat the condition by cutting off the blood supply so the growth shrinks, added Dr Lambros Stamatakis of MedStar Washington Hospital Center. Doctors do that with an embolization, meaning a catheter is snaked into the blood vessels of the kidney to find the right one and block it.
Most of the time, these tumors are found when people undergo medical scans for another reason but sometimes people have pain or other symptoms, Kowalczyk said. Embolization patients often go home the same day or the next.
Grisham characterized speculation about the first lady as “uninformed”. “Mrs Trump has a medical team that is comfortable with her care, which is all that matters,” she said. “Her recovery and privacy are paramount and I will have no further comment beyond this.”
Donald and Melania Trump's remarkably separate daily routines begin with him getting up around 5:30 a.m., watching cable news shows and tweeting.
The First Lady wakes in her own bedroom a bit later, according to two close friends of the Trumps. She then readies their 12-year-old son for school, including checking to make sure his homework is in his backpack.
Amid the noise and churn of the Trump administration - most recently about how the president paid money to silence Stormy Daniels - Melania Trump has settled into a quieter routine, often apart from the president, raising their son and carving out a place for herself in a most untraditional White House.
The First Lady has not directly addressed the affairs that Daniels and another woman, Karen McDougal, said they had with her husband. But she has noticeably begun to raise her profile, independent from the president's, and she called a news conference in the White House Rose Garden on Monday, a public appearance that would have been almost unthinkable just a few months ago.
"Her focus all along has been children and this launch is meant to formalise what her role will be for the next three to seven years," said Stephanie Grisham, Melania's spokeswoman. She said the First Lady will devote the rest of the Trump presidency to the issues children face today and their well-being.
In recent weeks, the First Lady has been at the centre of more high-profile events than during the entire previous year - including attending the funeral of former first lady Barbara Bush solo.
Political marriages tend to be more complicated than most, but it's striking that the Trumps make so little effort to project a more united front. Although both are keenly aware of the power of visual images, some of their memorable moments together are awkward: Melania swatting his hand away on a tarmac, and several times caught on camera seeming to resist his outreach.
"She is a dignified, private person, and she'll deal with her personal life in private and it's no one's business," said Stephanie Winston Wolkoff, a longtime friend of Melania's. "They are not that couple that holds hands just because; she is old-world European and it's not who she is."
It is unusual to see a candid shot of the president enjoying an unplanned moment with his wife, or even with Barron, the first young son in the White House since John F. Kennedy Jr. in the early 1960s.
The Trumps are often apart even during their free time, according to several people who know the couple's schedules. At Mar-a-Lago on holidays and weekends, the president golfs or dines with politicians, business executives and media personalities on the patio, while Melania is often nowhere to be seen. According to several current and former aides, the president and first lady often do not eat together in the White House either.
"They spend very little to no time together," said one longtime friend of the president.
Grisham said the president and Melania do spend time with each other. "Aside from the president's solo trips, the family spends most evenings together." She also played down the headlines about Trump's alleged affairs and said Melania "is focused on being a mom. She's focused on being a wife, and she's focused on her role as first lady. And that's it. The rest is just noise."
A senior West Wing official, when asked about the couple's separate schedules and bedrooms, declined to comment, saying it wasn't official business.
Melania grants few interviews and declined to speak for this article, but during the campaign she told The Washington Post that she and her husband are "very independent," adding, "We give ourselves and each other space."
According to several people who know the couple, that space appears to have grown wider under the White House roof - especially since Daniels, a porn star whose real name is Stephanie Clifford, as well as Karen McDougal, a Playboy model, publicly talked about their alleged affairs with Trump during his marriage to Melania. Daniels was paid $130,000 during the campaign by a Trump attorney to stop talking about the affair.
Last week, Mr Trump tweeted that he repaid the attorney to "stop the false and extortionist accusations made by her about an affair." Rudy Giuliani, one of Trump's lawyers, told NBC News that payment was made "to prevent personal embarrassment and heartache to [Trump's] wife."
Another awkward exchange happened April 26 with Mr Trump calling into "Fox & Friends," announcing that it was Melania's birthday, and then suddenly talking about Daniels. Asked on the same TV show what he had got Melania for her birthday, he paused: "Maybe, I didn't get her so much. I got her a beautiful card, you know I'm very busy to be running out looking for presents."
According to several White House staff members, Melania has erected a de facto wall between the East Wing, where she is renovating her office and enjoying growing popularity, and the West Wing, where her husband and Ivanka Trump, her eldest stepdaughter, have offices.
While she goes to the West Wing for official duties, she does not walk down the hall, pop her head in and see how the president's day is going.
"She seldom sets foot in the West Wing," said one person with first-hand knowledge.
Yet, many political analysts believe that Trump will need Melania at his side if he wants to win again in 2020.
The Trumps have broken the traditional mould of a presidential family from the moment he was sworn in. While Melania stood beside the president at the Capitol, his two ex-wives, Ivana Trump and Marla Maples, sat in the crowd.
Trump is the only president to be married three times. Melania is 48, and the president is 71.
Rather than move into the White House with her husband, Melania stayed in New York for six months to allow Barron to finish his school year there. That delay initially put Melania at a disadvantage, according to a friend who said the rhythm of the White House had already been established, and left her out of the mix. Some staff positions from the first lady's office were diverted to the West Wing - including to support Ivanka, who is a presidential adviser, according to a person close to the first lady.
Ivanka, 36, and Melania, both former models, do not have a close relationship and are very different from one another, several people who know them both said. Grisham said it was not only wrong to say Melania was not close to her stepdaughter but "hurtful."
Noticeably, Melania's presence is growing as Ivanka's fades.
Last year, an official White House statement described Ivanka as holding an "unprecedented role for a first daughter" and she has at times taken on the duties of a First Lady. Ivanka acts as the president's policy adviser, has travelled the globe as her father's surrogate, and sat down with world leaders at the White House. But recently her public profile has been reduced.
First Ladies often have had considerable influence, as an informal adviser to the president and the person closest to him. They have been the hidden hand in policy decisions and hiring and firings. And, they can command attention for causes. Most recently, Laura Bush established the National Book Festival and used her foreign trips to focus concern on HIV/AIDS, and Michelle Obama promoted girls' education globally and started a movement here to get children exercising and eating healthier.
Melania's staff is unusually small; with 10 people, it is about half the size of Michelle Obama's at its peak.
Melania has borrowed books from the White House Historical Association to study the first lady's role and plans to outline on Monday a new initiative about children.
Several polls have shown that as she becomes more visible, her popularity is rising. In many ways the image she projects is the least like Mr Trump's of all the Trumps.
The president organises big rallies; Melania often holds meetings with just a few people. Her husband rails against family-based "chain migration"; she is from Slovenia and now her parents, also immigrants, have become legal resident here, too.
The president mocks political enemies on Twitter with his derogatory nicknames such as "Cryin' Chuck Schumer" or "Cheatin' Obama"; Melania calls cyberbullying an "evil" and organised a White House conference to try to stop it.
Melania has complained that she doesn't deserve the mean comments she has read about herself online. She has been heard saying that she knows her husband has contributed to the combative nature of today's online chatter, and one associate said she has persisted with her anti-cyberbullying efforts despite White House advice that she pick any other issue to champion.
In March, Melania invited top executives from Twitter, Facebook and other tech companies, along with non-profits working on Internet safety, to the White House to hold a meeting on the issue.
"I am well aware that people are sceptical of me discussing this topic," she told the group. "I have been criticised for my commitment to tackling this issue, and I know that will continue. But it will not stop me for doing what I know is right," she said in opening remarks. "We have to find a better way to talk to each other, to disagree with each other, to respect each other."
Stephen Balkam, the founder and CEO of the Family Online Safety Institute, was seated at a table with the First Lady. "It was a pretty remarkable opening," he said. "I was pleased that she addressed the elephant in the room."
Melania has not always been willing to go in a different direction from her husband. In 2011, when Mr Trump was one of the leading "birthers" challenging the validity of President Barack Obama's birth certificate and U.S. citizenship, Melania backed him up.
"What's this with the birth certificate obsession? Did he ask to see yours when you met him?" asked TV interviewer Joy Behar.
"Do you want to see President Obama's birth certificate or not?" Melania responded. She also said what Obama had made public to date was "different" from a birth certificate. "It would be very easy if President Obama would just show it," she said.
"It is not only Donald who wants to see it. It's the American people . . . they want to see that."
But as first lady, she has publicly praised Michelle Obama and laughed alongside President Obama, who sat beside her at Barbara Bush's funeral last month in Houston. She also shared the pew with Bill and Hillary Clinton - two favourite targets of her husband's criticism.
Melania received a warm reception from the former presidents and first ladies. Photos of them all together - the Obamas, the Clintons, George W. Bush, Laura Bush and George H.W. Bush - show Melania beaming.
She has also travelled apart from her husband - even when they are going to the same destination. In February, hours after the New Yorker published a story about Trump's alleged affair with McDougal, the Playboy model, Melania did not walk with Trump across the White House's South Lawn to board Marine One.
Both Trumps were heading to Mar-a-Lago for the weekend, but instead of making the very public walk across the White House lawn with her husband to the helicopter, she drove separately to the Maryland military airport to catch Air Force One. Grisham told reporters at the time that given the first lady's schedule, it was just easier for the couple to meet at the plane. When her motorcade pulled up, White House press aides shouted at journalists to get off the plane until she boarded. No photos were allowed of her arrival.
As First Ladies often are, Melania is more popular than her husband. But two friends of the couple say the president, who pays close attention to his poll numbers, also fixates on hers. Her approval rating was 47 percent to his 40 percent in a January CNN poll.
Grisham said Melania takes her role seriously and is careful to coordinate with Sarah Huckabee Sanders, the White House press secretary. "Basically, we're like, 'OK, we'll put this out,' or, 'We'll wait for you.' . . . We don't want to conflict with the president's message of the day, nor do we want him to do that to us."
But, she added, "the 24/7 social media-cable news cycle and a West Wing that's very active . . . perhaps overshadows some of the good work she's doing."
Mr Trump described Melania to supporters in a recent email as his "rock and foundation." "I wouldn't be the man I am today without her by my side," he said. "My BEAUTIFUL, kindhearted and exceptional wife."
"They have an unspoken affinity," said Winston Wolkoff, whose official advisory arrangement in the first lady's office ended earlier this year amid headlines about inauguration spending and the White House's move to end informal contracts.
Another person close to the president said they had heard him call Melania when he travels and "she is someone he relies on and listens to."
Melania has said she sometimes offers advice to her husband - including about his tweets - but that doesn't mean he takes it.
During one dinner in the White House in late 2017, Melania told the president that he should be more concerned about the investigation led by Special Counsel Robert Mueller and that his legal team wasn't protecting him, according to a person who attended the dinner. Trump disagreed, this person said, insisting that the investigation was going to exonerate him and that he had great lawyers. Grisham disputed this account, saying: "Your anonymous sources are wrong." Since that dinner, two of three lawyers have left Mr Trump's Russia team.
Several people in the White House, who like others interviewed for this story did not want to be quoted by name discussing the first couple's relationship, said Melania does not trust some members of her husband's staff. Two people in a position to know said she particularly disliked former chief strategist Steve Bannon and told her husband so, and she was upset about the abrupt dismissal of John McEntee, Mr Trump's young personal assistant. He left over a security clearance issue but is now working on Mr Trump's re-election effort.
Mr Trump insisted on a prenuptial agreement when he married Melania 13 years ago, just as he had with his two previous wives. The terms have never been made public. A person close to Melania noted that the prenuptial was signed before his political career, which forced her to take on a whole new role and one, as a friend said, that is "unpaid."
"Free Melania!" continues to be a popular meme. Late-night TV comedy skits portray her as trapped inside the White House, unhappy.
For months, a persistent rumour has floated around Washington that Melania doesn't really live in the White House and stays in a house with her parents and Barron near his suburban Washington school.
"It's 1,000 percent false. We laugh at it all the time," Mr Grisham said.
"It's an urban legend," said Rickie Niceta Lloyd, the White House social secretary.
Melania is exceedingly close to her parents and her son, Barron, who also speaks Slovenian with his grandparents. When she is out of the public eye, she is often with her family, friends say.
Her office declined to say where her parents live, or even whether they keep a room at the White House, as Michelle Obama's mother did.
Melania does spend a lot of time in the White House, according to people who work there, and has a very good relationship with the permanent household staff of nearly 100 that includes chefs, florists and butlers, and she oversees the residence as well as the state floor.
Friends say she is a perfectionist who oversees the tiniest details of events in which she is involved.
She enjoys putting her personal mark on the historic home and has redesigned the family living quarters. While her husband favours the lavish gold-and-glitz decor of their Trump Tower penthouse, Melania has picked neutral colours.
"It is a very comfortable and calming place to be in," Winston Wolkoff said.
Still, Mr Trump often waves friends up to the residence after holiday parties or social gatherings and gives tours of the Lincoln Bedroom, where he remarks on how tall the former president was while showing off the Gettysburg Address and other features of the home. Melania has, however, told confidantes she wants to keep the residence private.
Although English is not her first language, she is getting more used to public speaking. She has also begun releasing videos of her work.
The latest highly produced video shows her preparing for the recent state dinner for French President Emmanuel Macron and has been viewed by nearly 1.5 million people.
Twenty-two years after first coming to the United States to model, she is now one of the most-photographed women in the world.
Paolo Zampolli, who helped arrange for Melania to work in the U.S. fashion industry and sees her in the White House, said Melania is blossoming.
"It's an incredible story. It's the American Dream," said Zampolli. "She really will become the queen of people's hearts, like Princess Diana was. I think the world will be seeing more of her."
US First Lady Melania Trump has been caught up in another plagiarism row, following the launch of her new online safety for children campaign on Monday.
A booklet put out by Mrs Trump bore a striking resemblance to one published under the Obama administration.
The text and graphics of the "Be Best" booklet were nearly identical to those in the previous edition.
The White House said that Mrs Trump had sought to used her position to "amplify" the text's positive message.
In 2016 Mrs Trump was accused of plagiarising parts of a speech from a 2008 address by Michelle Obama.
After commentators picked up on very close similarities between the two speeches, Meredith McIver, a Trump administration staff member who wrote Mrs Trump's speech, admitted borrowing from Mrs Obama.
Mrs Trump's online safety booklet was initially billed on the initiative's website as being "by First Lady Melania Trump and the Federal Trade Commission".
After similarities to the Obama-era edition were picked up online, the text was revised to describe it as a "Federal Trade Commission booklet, promoted by First Lady Melania Trump".
A White House statement released on Tuesday accused "opposition" media of taking "a day meant to promote kindness and positive efforts on behalf of children, to instead lob baseless accusations towards the First Lady and her new initiatives".
It said that the Be Best initiative was aimed at supporting children and opening dialogue on issues affecting them - including by helping the Federal Trade Commission to promote the booklet - and called on media workers "to attempt to Be Best in their own professions" by focussing on Mrs Trump's programme.
A sample from the two booklets: 2014 on the left, and the Melania Trump version on the right
Launching the "Be Best" initiative at the White House on Monday, Mrs Trump said the aim was to promote healthy living, encourage positive use of social media, and combat opioid abuse.
"As we all know, social media can both positively and negatively affect our children, but too often it is used in negative ways," she said.
Her decision to focus on cyber-bullying has prompted questions about the behaviour of her husband, who frequently uses Twitter to attack and insult his opponents.
The 2014 version, left, and Melania Trump version, right
Mr Trump was widely criticised in 2017 when he used the platform to call TV hosts Mika Brzezinski and Joe Scarborough "low I.Q. Crazy Mika" and "Psycho Joe", and claimed he saw Ms Brzezinski "bleeding badly from a face-lift".
He has also been accused of mocking a disabled reporter.
White House Press Secretary Sarah Sanders was asked ahead of the launch of the initiative whether President Trump believed he bore any responsibility for the need to address cyber-bullying.
"I think the idea that you're trying to blame cyber-bullying on the president is kind of ridiculous," she said.
Asked whether Pres. Trump believes he has any responsibility for need to speak out against cyberbullying, Press Sec. Sanders says, "I think the idea that you're trying to blame cyberbullying on the president is kind of ridiculous." https://t.co/NkJuIoh4fPpic.twitter.com/ggeFzSd7Sg
The French first lady has shared some insight into the life of Melania Trump during her visit to the White House.
Brigitte Macron has called The US first lady “really fun”, but says “she can’t do anything”.
Speaking to Le Monde on the tail end of her three-day state visit to Washington with her husband, French president Emmanuel Macron, she said:
[Melania] cannot do anything. She can’t even open a window at the White House. She can’t go outside. She’s much more constrained than I am. I go out every day in Paris.
The internet has speculated much on the seemingly awkward interactions between the US president and his wife, from the multiple times she appears to have avoided her husband's hands, reports that Donald Trump was too “busy” to get his wife a birthday present, and her increasingly cold behaviour towards her husband (if videos of them together are anything to go by).
However, Macron also insists that the US first lady, who is reportedly fluent in five languages, is “kind, charming, intelligent and very open”, and admits that living in the public sphere can be difficult.
She says:
Everything is interpreted, over-interpreted. She’s someone who has a strong personality but works hard to hide it. She laughs very easily, at everything, but shows it less than I do.